Various thoughts on current events with an emphasis on politics, legal issues, books, movies and whatever is on my mind. Emails can be sent to almostsanejoe@aol.com; please put "blog comments" in the subject line.
About Me
- Joe
- This blog is the work of an educated civilian, not of an expert in the fields discussed.
Tuesday, August 18, 2009
A Less Offensive Defense of DOMA
The Obama Administration provides a less offensive brief in support of DOMA. But, disagreement on a "policy" ground is not enough. If it is "discriminatory" it is UNCONSTITUTIONAL. The "rule of law" (selectively upheld, see torture) includes the "supreme" law of the land. Its limited defense also provides thin "rational basis," particularly since DOMA did more than uphold the status quo. OTOH, this might not be the strongest lawsuit in the pipe. See, e.g., the one pending in Massachusetts and the Boies/Olson lawsuit.