Balkinization Ends Outside Comments

Over the years, various places allowed me to provide my .02 until comments were cut off.

For years, I took part in the "Slate Fray" until that ended. The movie database IMDB eventually cut off comment threads.  Mirror of Justice and Rewire (current name) had comments once upon a time, both ending it since moderation was not deemed worthwhile.  Comments allowed the former in particular to have a few replies from those somewhat critical of its conservative leaning tone.  The Justia/Verdict essays recently also cut off comments, comments tending to be somewhat trollish. 

Balkinization Blog also provided me a platform though in time the named contributor cut off comments, bothered in particular by disputes involving a trollish person in particular.  Sandy Levinson later repeatedly flagged his annoyance at non-germane comments, including replies to two Trumpy contributors. The two remaining contributors who allowed comments now do not, comments if opened only open to blog contributors. This was finally noted officially after it already occurred.  

I understand why this was done -- as noted by JB, readers (most of whom did not comment) were annoying by the comments becoming flame wars.  Biased I might be, but did think some of the regulars had useful comments. The comments from the two Trumpy types were useful to get a sense of that sort of thing, which led to some strong reactions, including from myself.  But, Sandy Levinson's posts alone were rather strong, so is that really that surprising?  Still, it clearly bothered contributors.

The result is still unfortunate in part because repeatedly the contributors warrant a reply. They often have a speak to the choir type tone (less so various guest contributors) with comments well worthy of criticism. It is well recognized that they have the right to self-expression. Still, comments also provide their own value.  (Sometimes, you get a tired putdown regarding "maybe you should cancel your subscription," or just don't read the stuff, but critics of comments can be answered the same way) 

The guests/at times Marty Lederman with long detailed analysis of certain legal disputes provide the best value.  But, without comments, it is not that worthwhile. For now, it's off my blogroll.