We are approaching Thanksgiving and the beginning of the Christmas season. Over the years, I have read and talked about holiday display cases. That is, disputes involving governmental holiday displays.
My sentiment leaned toward a strong separation of church and state. My lowest common denominator principle supported equality and the avoidance of blatant support of certain religions.
I also wanted localities to have some discretion in drawing lines in these areas. That is, there was a floor that they could go further on separatist grounds.
So, I lean toward Stevens dissent here, but at the very least, I would have let them choose that route.
The current Secretary of Agriculture might have fit in with some of the women in this book. Her Wikipedia page focuses on her political life. She is not a newcomer here.Leslie graduated from Glen Rose High School in 1990 and attended Texas A&M University as a pre-law student. By 1994, Leslie had become the student body president of the university, the first female to hold the position in its history.
Secretary Rollins (her married name) has held significant political positions for thirty years. She also joined the first Trump Administration. Rollins served in a leading domestic policy role, working with Kushner, who had a more domestic portfolio. So, she was a logical choice.
A district court recently held that her holiday messages to employees crossed the line. Again, I look at this as a matter of degree. The ruling is from the Ninth Circuit, so there is a reasonable chance it will hold. How the Supreme Court, under its current policies, would rule, I put aside.
FFRF has been on her case. The Trump Administration advances Christian Nationalism. Hegseth is the obvious case study. But he is not a one-off.
We should put this lawsuit in the context of the wider problem. The employees here, contrary to one dismissive comment, did not have "eggshells" instead of a thick spine.
A recent FFRF press release noted her use of religious views in an employee's Veteran's Day message. She included a biblical reference. Some might handwave this.
Following the links, we have more details.
FFRF has previously written to Rollins on April 8 and July 10 of this year regarding a series of official USDA communications and activities that promoted religion. These included an explicitly Christian Easter devotional, a Memorial Day message invoking the Christian promise of eternal salvation, an Independence Day message calling for God’s favor, and USDA-organized prayer and worship services.
Do many people have such religious proselytizing messages at their places of employment? A bit more:
According to the event brief, the purpose of the gathering was to “celebrate faith,” educate employees about faith-based organizations, and launch a recurring quarterly “USDA Prayer and Worship Service.” The event, held during working hours, featured an opening prayer, worship music, “Corporate Prayer & Intercession,” and a “Special Message from the Secretary.” The program states that participants would gather to seek “God’s presence, wisdom, protection, and blessings” for USDA and that the department seeks to ensure employees may “share and celebrate their faith.”
I don't think this is appropriate, especially for a governmental workplace. The lower court opinion notes how the holiday emails assume people had the same religion:
The Secretary’s use of “we,” “us,” and “our,” along with her failure to recognize other religious holidays or acknowledge that other employees may have different beliefs, expresses a culture and environment within the USDA which ostensibly universally conforms with the Secretary’s beliefs.
Any recipient of the Secretary’s email is assumed to subscribe to the same Christian beliefs as the Secretary.
For example, by comparing federal employees to “the very first disciples to encounter our risen Lord in the Upper Room almost two thousand years ago” and calling on those employees to carry out “the mission each of us has been called for” with “Paschal joy,” the Secretary is portraying the agency’s work as a mission to serve her particular Christian views.
[slightly edited]
The reference to "particular Christian views" is important. People might think we are only talking about limited holiday references such as a creche or a bare reference to celebrating the birth of Jesus. More than that is involved.
The title of this blog post references "expressly Christian references." I grew up in a Christian household. We were Catholics, if not very fervent.
I did go to many years (6-12) of Catholic school. (In my case, it was largely since the public school alternatives left something to be desired.)
The strength of some of these messages would bother many Christians. At the very least, we did not openly talk like this even among ourselves.
There is a more evangelical flavor in proclaiming to employees how Jesus came to "free us from our sins and open the door to eternal life."
That sort of thing very well might be said at Mass. Not by employers when talking to their employees. Well, unless the employer was the Catholic Church.
Some might not like her saying things like "May God Bless You." I am not a fan of so-called ceremonial deism that mixes church and state. I do not like "In God We Trust" on coins. That message, however, might count.
This does not:
No matter the very real trials and hardships we face, fear and sin and death do not get the last word. Because on Easter morning, "Hell took a body, and discovered God. It took earth, and encountered Heaven. It took what it saw, and was overcome by what it did not see." Now that is reason to rejoice!
And so, like the very first disciples to encounter our risen Lord in the Upper Room almost two thousand years ago, this Easter let us too be alive with hope, full of Paschal joy, and confident in the mission each of us has been called for.




