About Me

My photo
This blog is the work of an educated civilian, not of an expert in the fields discussed.

Thursday, November 19, 2026

Four Executions

I will discuss four executions that took place over the last two weeks. Two occurred on November 12; the other two on November 19. 

We had some rather horrible crimes. 

They happened a long time ago. I refer, as usual, to Justice Breyer's dissent to flag why that is problematic.  

James Pavatt (Oklahoma)

Pavatt was executed for murdering his wife's husband in 2001. They worked together to get the insurance money. It's prime television mystery drama material. 

The final appeal alleged that the jury was misled into thinking he acted alone. The Supreme Court did not find this worthy of comment. He claimed innocence, but that is probably "Sure, Jan" material.  

John Rubio (Texas)

Okay. This is just horrible.

He and his common-law wife in 2003 murdered their three children. They thought the children were possessed or something. Money problems also factored in. She pleaded out and got life in prison. He ultimately asked to die. 

His lawyers, understandably, argued he was mentally unstable. I provided his final statement. 

Thomas Mitchell Overton (Florida)


Another Florida execution for a horrible crime that took place a long time ago. The 1990s. 

You want to know the crime? That is, if you support the death penalty and want to play gotcha. It was a rape and murder. The woman was very pregnant. The fetus (baby) did not survive. Her husband was also murdered.  Pretty damn horrible. 

If you believe in the death penalty, that sounds like something you use it for. Well, if it didn't take around thirty years. I don't, and the time lag is an added problem. Florida isn't done for 2026. 

Overton's lawyer provided a final appeal. The petition cited multiple failed challenges made over the years. Horrible crimes do not mean the absence of due process concerns, though I did not go into the weeds.

The challenge focuses on the significant degree of power the governor of Florida has over the final authorization of an execution. It argues the process is too secretive. Also, the governor has asserted a general policy of never commuting a death sentence, which taints the process. 

A different Supreme Court might have more concern about such things. For those who do, check out here.

Reinaldo Dennes (Texas)

Reinaldo Dennes has been on death row for a 1996 deadly robbery scheme that left jeweler Janos Szucs dead, and security guard David Copeland wounded. 

Not quite as horrible as the second or as classic as the first. I am less sure why this, among all the rest, warranted the death penalty. Also, after thirty years, too much time has passed.

The final appeal, given the usual "no comment," involved ineffective counsel claims. The counsel probably could have done a better job. Various things cited might have led to a jury decision of "life" over death. 

It suggests how the death penalty tends to be a twisted form of The Lottery. But it doesn't look like a blatant case. Still. It is a final sign-off to an execution. 

A few more words from someone would be appreciated. 

Monday, November 16, 2026

SCOTUS: Order List

Today is the last day anything is scheduled at SCOTUS until the end of the month. 

We then move into the December Argument Term. A media advisory flags an assault weapon case that promises to have heavy attendance. 

Last Friday, the justices granted two cases, including a major Trump asylum case. The case covers the canard that immigrants are "invading" the country. 

In 2022, California began requiring private instructors in privately run and privately accredited continuing medical education (CME) courses to discuss how so-called implicit bias affects healthcare outcomes. 

The Order List was mostly housekeeping. The three High Federalists (Thomas/Alito with a dissent) would have granted a case with "anti-woke" vibes. 

The other relisted case with some comment was a Second Amendment case that received some notice. Thomas dropped a statement that the law probably banned guns in too many public places but was too complicated a "vehicle" (to use the jargon) to warrant review. 

Kagan and Alito didn't take part in two cases. Kagan, as usual, explained why. I will cover four executions (unless something changes) later this week. 

ETA: I missed it, but Justice Jackson posted the text of her speech criticizing her colleagues' handling of the emergency docket on the speech page. 

She posted four speeches over her tenure. No other current justice has done so, except for the end-of-year Chief Justice report. 

Other justices have given speeches. 


We discuss how, for 19th-century justices, their jury charges while riding circuit and anonymous op-eds were collectively more important than their opinions; the assumption that a federal judicial seat was a short-term political office; and how we can re-envision a more modest Court for the 21st century [etc.]

I agree this is a very good book. It's a great work of scholarship. There is lots of stuff there. It provides insights on the potential for change. 

Originalists want us to be tied to the past. That's wrong. But that doesn't mean we cannot learn from history. One problem is that they often provide a confused view of the past.

I was sometimes unsatisfied with how the book summarized its points. For instance, it doesn't really talk much about jury charges. The one that comes to mind is Justice Story and the Dorr's Rebellion. 

Okay. So, unlike today, Supreme Court rulings were not accepted as the final word. How about some examples of this principle in action? 

For instance, they could have cited a major landmark and shown how, in practice, it has little true authority. Again, citing Luther v. Borden is of limited value. Yes, the whole thing was over by then. So, it would not have mattered much. 

I think a good concluding summary in each chapter -- one historical book I read recently had this, and it was very useful -- could have helped. It seems petty to carp, but at times, I did want more information. The last chapter also seemed to be a bit quick. Again, this is carping. It is also because I know a lot of this stuff more than the average person. 

One thing that annoys me is that she only references the temporary reduction of size in the 1860s in passing. That is just plain wrong. You can't include everything, but "judicial representation" was a key theme. She kept on showing us maps that broke down the circuits. This was a key moment. 

Podcasts and interviews are a good way for authors to highlight themes and flag key points. I can say a lot more. See, e.g., in the comments here ("Bronx"). 

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Lust or Marriage


I have discussed Showtime's (and, at times, other channels') adult programming (okay; soft porn) before. There is less of it now, but still a few movies, including on-demand. Going back to the 1990s, there used to be a few erotic-themed cable series. I do not know of any on the main channels these days. 

Lust or Marriage is the best of the recent bunch. The AI (I like the AI summary of my Volokh Conspiracy names, including "Joe from the Bronx") summary is amusing:

A daughter becomes concerned her mother is marrying a man she doesn't know.

The Complication: Khloe unexpectedly develops feelings for her mother's soon-to-be husband. 

Meanwhile, Khloe's boyfriend grows suspicious, launches his own investigation, and uncovers a much larger, dangerous game at play.

TBF, that is accurate, but it sounds like a Lifetime movie. It might add that it is soft porn. The photo is of Khloe and her boyfriend and is misleadingly mild.

I've seen the two guys in other films, especially the soon-to-be husband. The women aren't amateurs, but as far as I know, they haven't appeared on Showtime. 

There are three women, including a co-worker (who has a sex scene where she never takes off her glasses, which do not steam up). The mom looks the most slutty, with breasts that appear to have implants, tattoos, and makeup.

The other women are more petite with small breasts. The daughter has a cute laugh, which might be her thing. I doubt she only uses it in this film. IMDB lists, among other things, various lesbian-themed films.

The sex scenes are decent, if not anything that special. The exposition is also credible. I like a film that mixes that in. The acting is also reasonable. The mom and boyfriend have the most thinly expressed skills, but they aren't horrible.

The daughter has sex with both boyfriends, the co-worker has a scene with a friend of the husband-to-be, and the mom has sex with the daughter's boyfriend. The mom and her boyfriend never have sex, which is somewhat disappointing, including dramatically.

Showtime soft porn only shows so much. No penises -- one popped up in a non-sex scene some time ago, and it was surprising. The camera angles often do not show much, relying on audio. 

A bit of pubic hair is visible in a few shots. We do not see penetration. I once found a more explicit cut online of a film where you did see penetration. But, going by what one porn actress said, often they film it without the penetration. 

The glossy -- if that is the right word -- quality of the film provides a certain "magazine" feel to the whole thing. For me, it diminishes my enjoyment of the action. The playful giggle was a fun touch.

If penetration is your thing, you can find that for free on places like PornHub. OTOH, that website has a lot of the same phony-looking material. I know all of this is phony, but there are degrees.

We find out (spoiler!) at the end that the whole thing was a setup so the mom can receive alimony because of the husband's actions. Good touch. Abella Danger was in an "obsession" themed film that ended with a bit of a twist, too. 

(Abella Danger later retired and had a bit of a new career, while going back to school, as a "superfan.") 

Most of the current Paramount+/Showtime "after hours" films are not good. "Bucket Lust," with someone who pops up in this film, is decent. 

This film is an all-around credible effort that almost (almost! tad too much sex!) might be the non-porn film suggested by that AI summary. 

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

RIP Richard Posner

Many accounts will honor Judge Richard Posner. He wrote many good things and inspired many people. He also wrote stuff I disagreed with such as this account of the 9/11 Report. 

That is okay. I appreciate his pragmatic, aboveboard intellectual style. We need more people like him in public service of all kinds.

Monday, November 09, 2026

SCOTUS Watch: Orders

The first Order List for a while was largely a clean-up job. Alito and Kagan (who said why) didn't take part in a case.  

An Easter Egg: the Attorney Discipline section involved Larry Klayman. He's a right-wing activist who founded both Judicial Watch and Freedom Watch. 

Meanwhile, will SCOTUS totally finish off Bivens? Hey, we can all agree Congress has a big role here. Maybe they can address qualified immunity, too. Restrain those blue-leaning types!

ETA: More Shadow Docket Follies. Jackson dissents.

Thursday, November 05, 2026

Some More Executions

November has some executions, including multiple days when more than one is scheduled. 

Perspective should be placed. A relatively "heavy" month still has fewer than ten executions nationwide. This article covers concerns in each of today's scheduled executions. 

Jesse Guardado was convicted of killing Jackie Malone, 75, before stealing money and other items while he was on a crack cocaine binge.

A death opponent focuses on his rehabilitation in prison. He admitted his guilt. His childhood was horrid. Other red flags. 

But I think the first part is the strongest argument. If you have the death penalty, you should repay those who help out. It's an incentive. 

Overall, this sounds like one of those cases where you understand the original sentence, but on balance, the execution is a bad idea. 

The final SCOTUS appeal, the only one for today's executions, was yet another challenge to Florida's lethal injection protocol. I don't begrudge the concern. It surely has some basis. 

But by now, no one is listening, with even the liberals silent. I don't really know why SCOTUS even took so long to hand down its pro forma order. It came down sometime after mid-afternoon today. 

Alabama plans to carry out its third execution of 2026 on Thursday evening, putting Michael Shannon Taylor to death by lethal injection almost 35 years to the day that he beat and murdered an elderly couple in Gadsden.

The twenty-year lag time is a concern. (Breyer, dissenting.) It's better than usual as compared to many recent Florida executions. Thirty-five years definitely crosses the line. 

He went AWOL and sent the message, as Jesse did, that elderly people shouldn't be nice to others. Alabama chose lethal injection because a court of appeals judgment earlier this year ruled that nitrogen gas has not been the expected panacea.

The governor's scheduling of his execution is one of her final acts. Alabama, showing its acceptance of national shame, elected Tommy Tuberville.

Jeffrey Weisheit has been sitting on death row since 2013, when he was convicted and sentenced to death for the 2010 murders of two young children, 8-year-old Alyssa Lynch and her 5-year-old brother, Caleb. The children were trapped and burned alive in their home in Evansville.

Indiana executes fewer people than Alabama and Florida. The crime is truly horrible. I use the modifier because executions occur for various reasons. 

Some arise from facts that are simply horrible to read about. The mindset required to do this brings to mind some movie sociopaths. Keeping up with all these executions is very depressing. 

The immediate concern is Christa Pike's horribly botched execution. I think she should be released into a rest home after thirty years in prison. Her lawyers are going for LWOP, which many deem a long shot. 

JW's lawyers argued that execution by lethal injection is unsafe. The state court was closely divided on the question. No SCOTUS review. 

One final thing. The Supreme Court handled a death penalty-related appeal on Wednesday. After a longer oral argument on Tuesday, this one was less than an hour long. 

One advocate appealed to the victims obtaining justice (a long prison sentence not being enough) when opposing it as frivolous. As noted in the first link, the parents split here. 

The father strongly opposes the execution. Appeals to "what about the victims" only go so far. What should we do here? Reminds me, as I noted in a comment, of a case decades ago (tempus fugit) where two brothers split on the matter. 

A person noted elsewhere, correctly, that victims do not settle the issue. The criminal justice system represents society. The civil justice system deals with personal justice. Nonetheless, people do appeal to such things, and they do so selectively. 

California

The governor commuted all the people on death row to LWOP. The state Supreme Court has to sign off on two-thirds of them. 

Overall, the death penalty is effectively dead in the state at this time. I think it's a good idea that the governor does not have carte blanche pardon power. 

President Biden did not commute every death sentence. An absolutist might be upset. I find it that hard to do so given he did commute thirty-seven, which is a lot more than anyone else. He also, unlike the governor here, acted unilaterally. 

He left three mass murderers and those on military death row (one due to die now in December) to their fates. Trump was also able to transfer a non-death-row prison to state custody, where they were executed for state crimes. 

The move today does not have much practical effect. It is symbolically powerful, especially since so many people are involved. I still don't like LWOP, which in most cases is too long. Anyway, the inmates on death row in California basically have that now. 

Wednesday, November 04, 2026

Some Quick SCOTUS Reactions Regarding Yesterday's Elections

The Supreme Court gave the cold shoulder to a Trump Justice Department ("DOJ" is a bit too generous) request involving claims that noncitizens may be voting in California. A bit of Election Eve News.

The Democratic wave has significant potential in local justice departments with national effects. Partisan lawsuits, red and blue, are a big thing these days. Federalism for the win! Congress also needs to investigate Judge Emil Bove, among other things. 

I agree Alito retiring NOW is unlikely. I'm not sure how much SCOTUS will otherwise respond as positively as Vladeck suggests. If you want to reference 1936, SCOTUS soon upheld many New Deal programs. We had a great shift in constitutional law. What is the idea now? 2026 didn't promise to have too many significant cases anyhow.  

Meanwhile, on Election Day, the Supreme Court had another case on the lengths they have gone in the direction of promoting free exercise over establishment, even in the face of discrimination. 

Mirror of Justice Blog (Catholic Legal Blog) back pre-Obergefell argued "race (and maybe sex) is different" in that area. To answer the "what about racist religions" hypotheticals. 

I disagreed then; I disagree now. 

ETA: New case granted.