About Me

My photo
This blog is the work of an educated civilian, not of an expert in the fields discussed.

Tuesday, March 18, 2008

Gun Case

ScotusBlog and Volokh Conspiracy, see blogroll, are two good resources for today's oral argument in the D.C. gun case. Kennedy's pro-individual rights sentiments and Breyer's desire for some middle ground is a plus for the pro gun rights side; I was not sure how strong Kennedy (and all of the new conservatives) be on that point. Volokh's comment on the justices supporting a practical, not strictly originalist, view of the Second Amendment is on point but a bit ironic given the excessive originalist nature of the lower court opinion. See some of my thoughts here. I have not read/listened to the orals yet.