Today is the last day anything is scheduled at SCOTUS until the end of the month.
We then move into the December Argument Term. A media advisory flags an assault weapon case that promises to have heavy attendance.
Last Friday, the justices granted two cases, including a major Trump asylum case. The case covers the canard that immigrants are "invading" the country.
In 2022, California began requiring private instructors in privately run and privately accredited continuing medical education (CME) courses to discuss how so-called implicit bias affects healthcare outcomes.
The Order List was mostly housekeeping. The three High Federalists (Thomas/Alito with a dissent) would have granted a case with "anti-woke" vibes.
The other relisted case with some comment was a Second Amendment case that received some notice. Thomas dropped a statement that the law probably banned guns in too many public places but was too complicated a "vehicle" (to use the jargon) to warrant review.
Kagan and Alito didn't take part in two cases. Kagan, as usual, explained why. I will cover four executions (unless something changes) later this week.
ETA: I missed it, but Justice Jackson posted the text of her speech criticizing her colleagues' handling of the emergency docket on the speech page.
She posted four speeches over her tenure. No other current justice has done so, except for the end-of-year Chief Justice report.
Other justices have given speeches.
We discuss how, for 19th-century justices, their jury charges while riding circuit and anonymous op-eds were collectively more important than their opinions; the assumption that a federal judicial seat was a short-term political office; and how we can re-envision a more modest Court for the 21st century [etc.]
I agree this is a very good book. It's a great work of scholarship. There is lots of stuff there. It provides insights on the potential for change.
Originalists want us to be tied to the past. That's wrong. But that doesn't mean we cannot learn from history. One problem is that they often provide a confused view of the past.
I was sometimes unsatisfied with how the book summarized its points. For instance, it doesn't really talk much about jury charges. The one that comes to mind is Justice Story and the Dorr's Rebellion.
Okay. So, unlike today, Supreme Court rulings were not accepted as the final word. How about some examples of this principle in action?
For instance, they could have cited a major landmark and shown how, in practice, it has little true authority. Again, citing Luther v. Borden is of limited value. Yes, the whole thing was over by then. So, it would not have mattered much.
I think a good concluding summary in each chapter -- one historical book I read recently had this, and it was very useful -- could have helped. It seems petty to carp, but at times, I did want more information. The last chapter also seemed to be a bit quick. Again, this is carping. It is also because I know a lot of this stuff more than the average person.
One thing that annoys me is that she only references the temporary reduction of size in the 1860s in passing. That is just plain wrong. You can't include everything, but "judicial representation" was a key theme. She kept on showing us maps that broke down the circuits. This was a key moment.
Podcasts and interviews are a good way for authors to highlight themes and flag key points. I can say a lot more. See, e.g., in the comments here ("Bronx").
No comments:
Post a Comment
Thanks for your .02!