About Me

My photo
This blog is the work of an educated civilian, not of an expert in the fields discussed.

Thursday, October 06, 2011

More on al-Awlaki


Another privilege of a citizen of the United States is to demand the care and protection of the Federal government over his life, liberty, and property when on the high seas or within the jurisdiction of a foreign government. Of this there can be no doubt, nor that the right depends upon his character as a citizen of the United States. 
 -- Slaughterhouse Cases (1873)
Thus, the citizenship of Awlaki mattered.

Ron Paul is upping the outrage, raising the "i" word and wondering is the media will be next.  He does realize certain members of the media already has been detained or even killed in the past, right?  Paul is a flawed libertarian hero here given his stance on various things (like letting states outlaw abortion or disallow same sex marriage) and his decision a few years ago to oppose the death penalty across the board adds to the overall deal -- I welcome his efforts, but let's not pretend that there aren't better advocates or that "the left" isn't also criticizing some of the same things.  On the whole, rather President Obama than President Paul, but since he won't win (Paul), go ahead.  Next, maybe the Tea Party can admit the Wall St. protests are what they are supposedly about.  Joe sees the connections.  Admittedly, he does say a lot.  I can relate ... I just ramble on the page. 

Paul says that Awlaki should have received a fair trial, noting even Nazi war criminals received trials.  Thus, maybe it is not just citizenship, since those people at Nuremberg weren't American citizens to my knowledge.  (There were spies etc. that were, but these aren't who I think when "Nazis" come up in this context.)  If he were concerned about giving people trials and not give the President unilateral power here, why did he sign this:
That the President is authorized to use all necessary and appropriate force against those nations, organizations, or persons he determines planned, authorized, committed, or aided the terrorist attacks that occurred on September 11, 2001, or harbored such organizations or persons, in order to prevent any future acts of international terrorism against the United States by such nations, organizations or persons.
"He" doesn't mean "a court."  It suggests something like a process the third link suggests was used:

They said targeting recommendations are drawn up by a committee of mid-level National Security Council and agency officials. Their recommendations are then sent to the panel of NSC "principals," meaning Cabinet secretaries and intelligence unit chiefs, for approval. The panel of principals could have different memberships when considering different operational issues, they said.
Lawyers were involved in the process too -- "rules of engagement" are the norm these days for any use of force, leading me to find "summarily" applied to this process [if properly "due" or not] as misleading as "assassination."  Erwin Chemerinsky noted in a speech that the norm in our constitutional system is that at least two branches of government has to sign off on something.  This was the case here big picture-wise -- authorization was provided by Congress and like usual, specific application was provided by some executive agency.  It is not always the case that another body has to sign off before each specific application is put into place, life, liberty and property at times in the balance.

Some believe that "necessary and appropriate" in this context is different when U.S. citizens are involved.  Citizenship split the Supreme Court in the Hamdi case, Scalia (with Stevens) arguing in dissent that detention rules for "enemy combatants" are different, Souter/Ginsburg believing the same, resting on statutory grounds.  I'm all for that. They didn't win though: O'Connor wrote the plurality, holding that citizens can be detained as enemy combatants (a clear case here -- an armed person on the battlefield -- other cases left open for lower court determination)  if suitable due process is provided.   So, a hearing, but no "trial" or criminal "charges" required as such.

Where the officer has probable cause to believe that the suspect poses a threat of serious physical harm, either to the officer or to others, it is not constitutionally unreasonable to prevent escape by using deadly force.
So says a ruling involving the proper use of deadly force, which baby Alito was involved in behind the scenes.  It is said that some are upset that the Administration is being Bush-like for "secret legal justifications and undisclosed intelligence assessments" like those that were used to kill Awlaki.  To my knowledge, the Administration has been upfront on the basic logic here -- national self-defense as well as the AUMF 2001 authorizes the executive to target Al Qaeda and citizenship does not alter this general principle. The Administration has no obligation to make public "intelligence assessments" used to apply military force, though is obligated to show it to certain people in Congress.  As I referenced in the past, there is also some controversy concerning requirements to inform those with the duty to oversee human rights law of enough information that the force is being used legitimately. 

The Administration denies that some unarmed mere propagandist (see last set of blog comments) was involved here:

U.S. officials contrast intelligence suggesting Awlaki's involvement in specific plots with the activities of Adam Gadahn, an American citizen who became a principal English-language propagandist for the core al Qaeda network formerly led by Osama bin Laden.

While Gadahn appeared in angry videos calling for attacks on the United States, officials said he had not been specifically targeted for capture or killing by U.S. forces because he was regarded as a loudmouth not directly involved in plotting attacks.
The general sentiment of some is: yeah, like we are supposed to trust you.  But, if we are going to authorize military force, some degree of trust is going to be needed.  They are not going to provide their operational logs for perusal or anything.  What about if the targets are citizens, who have a right to governmental protection, even if they are overseas?  If they are somewhere we can reasonably access them, such as reachable farm in Pakistan or something, a "kill order" probably is not appropriate.  The line I would draw would be a case like this where such access is not readily available. The fact the host country assisted (or consented) removes that issue, though if does not provide reasonable assistance in detaining someone who is a threat to our country, see Bin Ladin and Afghanistan, force without local consent is legitimate as well.  

Some wanted us to indict and try him, not satisfied with Yemen doing it.  Curious about that.  The government doesn't have the power to execute people by remote control, so even if he was convicted of a capital offense, actually capturing him alive would seem to be required.  So, that seems to be something of a red herring -- the idea that a few years hence, while the government has evidence that he is continuously plotting to aid and abet violent attacks from his isolated foreign locale in the mean time, after appeals and such are concluded, critics would accept an "assassination" is a dubious proposition.  To be blunt, the logical implication is that we will have to bear with him being  at threat, the means used illegitimate.

And, we probably could -- he was just one man, somewhat fungible. Use of kill orders to target individual members seems to me something of a whack-a-mole game, though special cases like Bin Laden are somewhat unique. So, legal or not, it was not mandatory or anything to kill al-Awlaki.  This influences the calculus when determining the proper due process required.  When they are in harm's way, such as in an enemy base, they assume the risk. If detained, they should be treated as American citizens, various cases setting forth the guidelines there. 

When specifically targeted, something more should be required than if they are in effect collateral damage. Realistically, the targets here often will be living with others that can be targets too, so a slight of hand can be imagined.  The internal process is appreciated but some third party should be involved with citizens are involved. If FISA courts can be in place merely to search, something akin to that should be in place to "seize" in this fashion. The shoot to kill "in the heat of the moment" case cited earlier would not apply in this situation.  And, there seems no reason that they should not be warned.  The inability to capture for trial is one thing.  The idea that the target should be secret is quite another.  Again, he knew what was going on and in effect laughed at the government.

So, to summarize.  I think American citizens, even alleged terrorists living abroad, have the right of protection from their government.  As a general matter,  "flying killing robots" sent to kill them is bad policy.  But, legally, particularly under current law, each branch of government has authorized some use of deadly force against certain citizens. International law also allows this is certain cases, particularly if the host country agrees. Nonetheless, if individual citizens are targeted, they should have some sort of individualized independent review akin to referenced in Hamdi:

the threats to military operations posed by a basic system of independent review are not so weighty as to trump a citizen’s core rights to challenge meaningfully the Government’s case and to be heard by an impartial
adjudicator
If such is required merely for detention, since "death is different" and worthy of more restraints, the very least required should be that here.  Given his status was made public here without the sky falling, I see little call even to have this process done totally in secret though some might be required.  He did not seek out this process and the court that decided the matter brought by his father implied that it was not necessary, so nothing "illegal" as such was done here.  But, such "due process" SHOULD be required, by statutory law (cf. Souter/Ginsburg opinion) in fact.  And, even if the person targeted doesn't want it, such a finding should be required, again akin to a search warrant obtained unless the need is waived.  In this context, that probably is not appropriate.

Ron Paul should work to pass legislation in this respect. Sen. Coons noted during his remarks to Chris Hayes that legislation is needed to add teeth to the overly broad AUMF in place, but if anything the Republicans in the House want to expand executive power too much in the other direction.  Regardless, the concern about killing U.S. citizens is completely acceptable, even if I disagree with certain aspects of its content. 

More Corporate Personhood

In a liability ruling by Justice Brennan: "In addition, by 1871, it was well understood that corporations should be treated as natural persons for virtually all purposes of constitutional and statutory analysis."

Foreign TV

YouTube is providing me new episodes of Doc Martin (UK), reduced charm but still charming enough to watch.  The message board for Being Erica (Canada) provided a link to the first episode of the new season, not due in the US until 2012, though its old home SoapNet is going bye bye.  Still don't see much of a need for a U.S. remake.

Arizona roared ahead and tacked on, forcing a Game 5. Way to go!

Wednesday, October 05, 2011

Cards Force a Game 5

They had a good chance to win last night, but today they actually did win.  So, it's now ace v. ace, this time the Cards' ace (who only went three last time) will have full rest.  Arizona faces elimination in a few.  They are my favorite, Cards just less annoying than the Phils. 

Food

I would have appreciated this healthy vending machine and I think many others these days would.  I started her book and the radish chapter is interesting.  Farmers markets are charming and the WIC benefit provided is a good touch.  Michelle can tell Lily about it.

"opportunists and obligationists"


[This essay includes a discussion on how language can be used to try to influence judgments, such as "health care" or "persons" in the abortion context. Similarly, I oppose the use of "Obamacare" for various reasons, but regardless, it is simply not a neutral term that does not influence the arguments made.  The term is specifically chosen for that purpose.]

I started to read the Cato Supreme Court Review, including a fairly straightforward discussion of the violent video game case, which disputed the attempt by Justice Thomas to simplify the original understanding of the question. 

On the other hand, the annual lecture series brought forth a discussion of "opportunists and obligationists" -- of the many ways to interpret the Constitution, William Van Alstyne determined there were really only two -- colloquially, those who respect original understanding (you know, like Thomas) and those who make shit up.  They "find" things that they want to keep the Constitution a "living" one.  The latter group don't really want to respect the amendment process, keeping the Constitution up to date by interpretation, particularly if enough people, for long enough (ala Bruce Ackerman's "constitutional moments"), go along. You know, like James Madison:

Waiving the question of the constitutional authority of the Legislature to establish an incorporated bank as being precluded in my judgment by repeated recognitions under varied circumstances of the validity of such an institution in acts of the legislative, executive, and judicial branches of the Government, accompanied by indications, in different modes, of a concurrence of the general will of the nation.

Aside from the New Deal, of course, an example was given respecting the ERA.  This was the proper way to amend the Constitution to protect the equal rights of women.  Instead, largely because people feared the amendment would be abused like this, the Constitution was opportunistically "interpreted" to protect gender equality.  Which isn't in there.  After all, Section 2 of the Fourteenth Amendment allows states to deny women the vote without application of a penalty by Congress that reduces their House delegation.  This must mean sex equality isn't found in the Constitution.  Me, myself, I think the ERA didn't pass because a sizable minority of the country opposed the substantive reach of the amendment, thinking men and women were in fact not equal, including beleving women should have certain protections that men would not have.  This plus a reasonable fear where an honest application of the text would lead would explain things. I am an "opportunist" though.

But, still, he can't be right.  The provision does cover blacks, but the right to vote was dealt with in another amendment. Why? At least two reasons. (1) At the time, many believed "equal protection" was a matter of civil rights, not political rights like voting.  Or, social rights for that matter, which explains why miscegenation laws and segregation was allowed.  (Even Justice Harlan was apparently not opposed to segregation in education in respect to minors.*) Voting rights cases, including before the New Deal, later blurried the lines. (2) The provision is a mild (it was later deemed not self-executable and was never applied) means to address one type of inequality. So, other than the fact that the equal protection provision has no apparent limit that doesn't apply it to women (women had SOME rights in the 1870s that put them in equal stance with men, such as the right to criminal justice protections; the ERA was about expanding its reach), that section doesn't tell you much.  The error, even by a law professor, is forgivable, though the tone makes it harder to do so.

I don't think the amendment process is obsolete though except for certain major moments, it has never been actually the primary driver of constitutional change. A constitutional amendment didn't end segregation. Was this wrong?   There are various provisions, such as be President while not being a natural born citizen, that clearly require an amendment. Others put forth a clear line where there might be some debate, such as the income tax amendment revoking a controversial 5-4 ruling.  In fact, many thought the Bill of Rights itself could be deemed redundant, at least some of them merely declaratory of basic principles (such as the 10th Amendment), there for added force.  The ERA seems to me to fit such latter categories, while the actual path taken, drawing things out over time, was the more ideal approach. 

Constitutional interpretation is hard and always has been and will be open to debate.  The attempt to make a reasonable attempt, which by the way is correct, illegitimate as well as wrong continues to annoy me. I like this series since it provides interesting perspectives and (as recent discussions suggest) leads me to support points of view that might at first blush seem not to match my overall philosophy.  The correct path has a liberal, libertarian and conservative mixture (probably other stuff), so it's good to read some of each.  I don't do in equal measure, but do try.

And, each at times should show a tad more humility about things. 

---

* A 1908 case involving a law that required a corporate charter used for a college to apply in a way that segregates the races upheld the law 7-2.  Justice Harlan dissented, but tossed in this interesting bit: "Of course what I have said has no reference to regulations prescribed for public schools, established at the pleasure of the state and maintained at the public expense."  Given his Plessy dissent, this is a bit curious.  On the other hand, he went along with a law that gave higher penalties to interracial fornication, underlining his views are not 100% modern on the subject.  The fact that seven justices upheld the law that "progressives" in this day in age would deem blatantly unconstitutional is a telling point on how the New Deal was not some evil line in the sand where the Constitution went to die.

The case has other interesting lessons. The ruling upheld a special restriction on corporations, contra to Citizens United, though the current majority noted that result would harm the interests of individuals. But, Harlan in dissent suggested the same -- "private" colleges were harmed here since their discretion to teach as they saw fit, to allow people to associate as they saw fit, were harmed. The majority:

In creating a corporation, a state may withhold powers which may be exercised by and cannot be denied to an individual. It is under no obligation to treat both alike. In granting corporate powers, the legislature may deem that the best interests of the state would be subserved by some restriction, and the corporation may not plead that, in spite of the restriction, it has more or greater powers because the citizen has.
I have spoken about how an infamous 1886 ruling didn't just give corporations all the rights of persons, as the story goes, and this underlines the point.  Here, however, we have a case where privileges for a corporation advance individual rights and the government is misusing its powers, even if the target aren't natural persons.  So, there would at least have to be a middle ground there, corporations (like the NAACP) sometimes having some rights.  Corporate personhood was created for benefit of society and it benefits them if corporate persons have some rights. 

The case also touched upon a familiar principle:

Upon this we remark that, when a state court decides a case upon two grounds, one federal and the other nonfederal, this Court will not disturb the judgment if the nonfederal ground, fairly construed, sustains the decision.

This sounds like the "independent state grounds" doctrine where a state court deciding a question on local law should be respected, the federal question not addressed unnecessarily.  That is, if the case concerns a search and it reasonably (how this is determined is a separate question) can be held to violate the state constitution, the Fourth Amendment issue should not be decided. This would avoid a ruling that would apply to all states, since it would be in effect an advisory opinion.  It would also promote federalism by respecting local courts. 

iCarly -- iLove You

iCarly feels like it "jumped the shark" but still provides fans some enjoyment.  A recent episode is curious though both with its clear kinkiness (Spencer and his former babysitter)  and Carly showing herself (again) as something of a prig for being upset that it is all "unnatural" and stuff.  Really, don't be a pill. 

Tuesday, October 04, 2011

Not Satisfying

Nature of the game, but the Rays and Cards' games are not satisfying because each overall played better, lost anyway.  The Rays game was particularly annoying -- one guy hit three solo home runs.  After he hit two, maybe you should walk him?  Nah.  Was the difference.  4-3.

Diamondbacks Showing Life

Burnett Does The Job

The rain forced the Yanks to rely on a fourth starter, the often unreliable Burnett, but he did the job.  5.2 innings, one run.  This is not really that surprising and felt guarantee by some that he would simply collapse was a bit much.  The Tigers pen is imploding.

Cards Lose

Baseball Update

Tigers did hang on with a gutsy eight inning performance from their ace after pitching an inning on Friday and the Colts did lose. Tampa again didn't quite do it, too bad, since I'd have liked a Game 5. One mistake in the 7th could kill the Cards today. Painful. Shall see.

Cato Supreme Court Review

I did something new this year -- downloaded Cato Supreme Court Review (2010-2011) on to my Kindle. I could have downloaded it to my computer, but this makes it more portable. The series promotes an interpretation of the constitutional law in (to quote the foreword) "a classical Madisonian perspective, grounded in the nation's first principles, liberty and limited government." That's sounds nice, but it's boilerplate. The so-called "living constitutionalism" of Justice Brennan was based on such things, though what was "liberty" and how government was "limited" would be a matter of dispute.

The result is far from "largely unlimited government," particularly given all the times where the limits (hyperbole aside) are well shown. Though, thankfully, not all contributors lay it on so thick, the evil moment for many at Cato is the New Deal. To quote the foreword again: "the social engineering schemes of the Progressives. In time those schemes were 'constitutionalized' by the New Deal Court, not by amendment, as constitutionally required, but by legerdemain." So you claim. Likewise, in any number of ways, rights were more protected after the New Deal, particularly against state action. Strangely this wasn't noted.

Instead, there is a concern that after the New Deal, the Supreme Court only gave "fundamental rights" special protections. The idea there were certain rights "in their nature, fundamental; which belong, of right, to the citizens of all free governments" and warrant special protection from legislative control was however cited a hundred years before in a seminal case. If anything, the post-New Deal Court (putting aside limited spans of time during the "Lochner Era") was more protective of rights, the pre-New Deal Court tending either to be pretty lax or to only concern itself with a limited number of things. The pre-New Deal treatment of the First Amendment underlines the point. It were "progressive" judges that were most protective until the 1930s.

We are told that the fundamental rights were "defined quite often not as the Framers would have defined them, drawing on the common law, but as reflections of egalitarian aspirations." A core problem here is that a key aspect of "the common law" is that it develops over time, basic principles applied bit by bit to new cases, the law slowly changing in the process. Like a game of telephone, the final result will be quite different in various cases than the opening bid. School segregation is but one instance. And, repeatedly, "rooted in the traditions and conscience of our people as to be ranked as fundamental" -- that is, the common law -- continues to be the test. But, I thought "fundamental" rights aren't supposed to be the "liberty" interests we are supposed to be concerned about?

As the Supreme Court said over a hundred years ago:
The Constitution of the United States was ... made for an undefined and expanding future, and for a people gathered and to be gathered from many nations and of may tongues.... There is nothing in Magna Charta, rightly construed as a broad charter of public right and law, which ought to exclude the best ideas of all systems and of every age, and as it was the characteristic principle of the common law to draw its inspiration from every fountain of justice, we are not to assume that the sources of its supply have been exhausted. On the contrary, we should expect that the new and various experiences of our own situation and system will mould and shape it into new and not less useful forms.
Thus, the "liberty" protected by due process of law, the "limits of those fundamental principles of liberty and justice which lie at the base of all our civil and political institutions" are not fixed by what was done in the past, the specific application of the text a developing process. And, again, it was post-New Deal that the Bill of Rights (though still not the Grand Jury Clause) was applied to the states. So, I can do without a bit of the sanctimonious tone about how "progressives" ruined things. But, the Cato series as a whole was repeatedly interesting, including some liberal voices like Laurence Tribe involved. The collection this time looks good with a few less business type cases that glaze my eyes.

Onward.

[One more thing:
But of equal importance, the implication -- that where there is no power there is a right, whether enumerated or not -- was made explicitly clear by the Ninth Amendment.
If the government lacks the power to do some purely internal thing, such as use a certain file system, it is unclear what "right" (at least of value much worth noting) this offers to others.  Second, "right" implies a moral thing that is protected by God or arising out of the nature of things.  The mere ability to do something because the government cannot stop you doesn't make it a "right," even if it a matter of brunt power.

And, the government has an obligation to secure "rights."  If someone has the ability to do something because the government lacks a certain power, such as to enslave, this does not necessarily make it a positive "right" that the government has an obligation to protect in any fashion.]

Wall St. Protests

I'm not a protest type of guy but as with other things I'm glad others are out there doing it. Mass protests, not always looking very organized (though this one is organized, down to "people's mikes" to repeat things) or specific, repeatedly help force change. The cause/effect might be hazy but history teaches these things matter.

Monday, October 03, 2011

Sunday Today

Claire Danes was good in Homeland as a CIA agent. It's on Showtime, so we see some nudity (and good acting from her and others) though not CD yet. The second episode of Pan Am was a pleasant enough time waster. Both were on Sunday at 10, but saw it on demand.

Sports Update

Romo shined twice, blew it twice, including yesterday. Rays middle relief didn't have it today. Not a good start of game for Verlander. Tampa not scoring vs. Manning's young back-up. More sports to come. [Latest Score: Tigers 3-2; 10-7, Colts, Tampa blowing chance to tie.]

More Sports

My back-up NL team with Arizona collapsing would be the Brewers, so it is appreciated that the Cards are making a game of it vs. the Phils. The Jets made it a game after being down by a lot, gave up another turnover after Halftime and then the game staid as is. Lame.

Sunday, October 02, 2011

Sunday Sports

Detroit/Yanks split the non-aces games. Some more interesting NFL games and Cards made some questionable moves to save the Giants. Meanwhile, Oakland made various stupid moves to help the Pats. Brewers look to get to the next round quick. Jets upcoming.

Further Viewing

Chris Hayes had some interesting stuff, including having a pro-life voice on and yesterday started with a good conversation on the current subject of controversy.  Breyer provided some interesting remarks on the 40th year anniversary of his copyright article.

"Assassination"

[It is somewhat striking that many quote the likes of Glenn Greenwald with approval, people who in part make LEGAL cases the various things Bush and Obama are doing is wrong and when some do the same they are disdainfully said to be using "legalisms."  Not that I merely made a legal case, but when I read "murder" etc., legality does come to mind.  

As to "morally," the law tends to overlap there and I repeatedly note that I'm against the general policy used here, citizen or no citizens.  "Murder" and "political" still has meaning.  Finally, the comment makes dubious assumptions that -- this happens too much -- if the other side made, it would be disdained as well.  This talking past each other happens all too often and it is one of the biggest problems with these types of discussions.] 

I was challenged by my opposition of this word and it's worthwhile to respond:
DocAmazing
Okay, Joe, define "assassination" then.  Back at LG&M, I've got three definitions, taken from politically neutral sources.  All encompass what was done to al-Awlaki. 
My primary concern is that the word is used by some to underline that we are doing something illegal here. Like "murder," implies illegitimacy. The thread referenced suggests that it can be legitimate. I guess, also, war can be hell, simply "murder," and be legal too. As someone at TalkLeft noted:
While using the appropriate word in this case - "assassination" - is intended to shock, and it definitely jars, the REAL issue is what is the battlefield?
But, before I go there, it is suggested that I look at some definitions. Sure. The first definition is "Assassination is a killing of a prominent person for political or ideological reasons." Doesn't work without argument. That is, if you want to dispute that al-Awlaki was killed because he was an operational leader or in some other way a legitimate military target, fine. Say the official story is bogus or can't be trusted. Fine. But, it was not that he was killed for political or ideological reasons ala the CIA helping with the killing of various political leaders. And, this is a decent definition -- it is what I basically think of as "assassination."

A second definition: "Murder committed by a perpetrator without the personal provocation of the victim, who is usually a government official." Okay. Again, doesn't seem to apply, unless you assume various things. If this is a legal killing, as I argue it reasonably can said to be, it isn't "murder." I'm supposed to (per the thread) being trying to "dodge" something here. Quoting me a definition citing "murder" when I'm arguing this is legal, which "murder" is not, doesn't help explain me much there. Now, as I said, as with abortion and the death penalty, you can disagree with the law and call it "murder." But, I'm using it in a legal sense in response to those who those who imply it is not. And, the second part is quite questionable too. There was some "provocation."

Again, I can work with that definition, though the first one is probably better. Third, Wikipedia: An assassination is “to murder (a usually prominent person) by a sudden and/or secret attack, often for political reasons.”[1][2] An additional definition is “the act of deliberately killing someone, especially a public figure, usually for hire or for political reasons.” Again, if you want to call this "murder" go right ahead, some think killing OBL was "murder." But, the argument here is that it is not. This wasn't "for hire" either, nor again, "political," unless the term is stretched to a degree that war itself ("politics by other means") can mean that, which isn't quite how the law uses the word. Since we are annoyed when others stretch words in that sense, I wish to be consistent.

The Wikipedia entry cited includes this:
On the other hand, Georgetown Law Professor Gary Solis, in his 2010 book entitled The Law of Armed Conflict: International Humanitarian Law in War, writes: "Assassinations and targeted killings are very different acts".[31] The use of the term assassination is opposed, as it denotes murder, whereas the terrorists are targeted in self-defense, and thus it is viewed as a killing, but not a crime.[33] Judge Abraham Sofaer, former federal judge for the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, wrote on the subject:

When people call a targeted killing an "assassination," they are attempting to preclude debate on the merits of the action. Assassination is widely defined as murder, and is for that reason prohibited in the United States.... U.S. officials may not kill people merely because their policies are seen as detrimental to our interests.... But killings in self-defense are no more "assassinations" in international affairs than they are murders when undertaken by our police forces against domestic killers. Targeted killings in self-defense have been authoritatively determined by the federal government to fall outside the assassination prohibition.
An executive order was put in place barring "assassination." A CRS Report discussed it (h/t). The report noted:
In general, it appears that an assassination may be viewed as an intentional killing of a targeted individual committed for political purposes.
The idea that comes to mind is the CIA trying to kill Castro, not the reasons summarized in the NYT article cited yesterday. The report goes on:
In time of war, assassination appears to be distinguished in some discussions from cases of lawful killing, because the former is carried out in a “treacherous” manner.10 “Treacherous” is not defined in the Hague Convention IV, but does not appear to be interpreted to foreclose operations in time of war involving the element of surprise.11 However, putting a price on the head of an enemy appears to be regarded by some as an act which would render a resulting killing an assassination, as distinguished from a lawful attack on legitimate military targets, including the enemy chain of command.
I'm quite willing to admit to some debate here and "assassination" can have a colloquial or argumentative (assuming it was illegal, not military related) application, but that is basically where I'm coming from. Since this is not "murder" or "political" (unless the word is stretch severely), the definitions if fine, don't seem to apply. It is illegal to "assassinate" people.

And, even colloquially, I myself would use the word in respect to some political hit, such as the "assassination" of Abraham Lincoln or some opposition leader of the Popular Front, that is a civilian that has protected status as a noncombatant. Killing someone pursuant to his position in an organization Congress and the Supreme Court recognizes we are in armed conflict with for the reasons spelled out in detail yesterday doesn't do it.

More Baseball

The Rays' ace got messy though the team made it respectable. More than can be said for other teams (including the completion of Game 1) except for the Diamondbacks, who ended the game in the 7th by pitching to Cecil Fielder.  Some pretty bad (well uneven) baseball.

Saturday, October 01, 2011

More on Reyes

Some are upset that he sat out after his first at bat in his last game to secure a batting title.  It's granted that St. Ted Williams played his final games even with his record at risk.  But, being human is not a mortal sin.  As if those complaining would be saints about it.

More on al-Awlaki

I cannot support the strong denunciation of the killing of Awlaki.

First, I do not think it was an "assassination" and the use of the word bothers me.  Second, and I guess this underlines along with the first that people are talking different languages here, "charges" aren't required before military force is used, even against American citizens. So, harping on that doesn't quite do anything for me.  Third, the argument (however broad) made by the Administration isn't some power to kill anyone, anywhere.  Fourth, all the same, I'm not fine with all of this.

I already quoted an international law blog with centrist Democrat leanings. Another who is no kneejerk supporter of our "war on terror" can be quoted to show the complications involved here:
Admiral Yamamoto was the Commander in Chief of Japan’s Combined Fleet, the prototypical combatant who was targetable at any time by the U.S.  Al-Awlaki was a radical cleric whose targetability depended on whether he assumed a “continuous combat function” in AQAP (in which case he was, like Yamamoto, targetable at any time), or whether he was a civilian who directly participated in hostilities on various occasions (in which case he was targetable only for the duration of his direct participation).  Which is it?  I frankly don’t know — but I do know that determining al-Awlaki’s targetabiity is vastly more legally and factually complicated than whether it was legal to kill an enemy Admiral in a formally-declared war.
This helps the "he should get some sort of court process" side some, but it STILL does not mean he has to be "charged" with a "crime," so quoting the Fifth Amendment simply takes you only so far. That isn't the rule in detaining someone in a mental institution either. The civil and military rules change the rules some. This also brings to mind al-Marri, where capturing someone on domestic soil was argued to be different. As Scott Shane (not Savage) wrote today:
The administration’s legal argument in the case of Mr. Awlaki appeared to have three elements. First, he posed an imminent threat to the lives of Americans, having participated in plots to blow up a Detroit-bound airliner in 2009 and to bomb two cargo planes last year. Second, he was fighting alongside the enemy in the armed conflict with Al Qaeda. And finally, in the chaos of Yemen, there was no feasible way to arrest him.
This might be a bit simplified but it reflects his role as an "operational" member or some such thing of Al Qaeda and outside of our ability to capture him. This doesn't matter to some people (I say this politely) and some will remind people that we really aren't "at war" and can't be against an organization. But, politely, this seems to be like saying abortion is murder -- the 2001 AUMF and international law (though the rules are complex/debatable as applied) authorized military force, which is admittedly not full fledged "war" which brings various other legal results. Ditto the use of "assassination" -- legally, killing legitimate targets (people) is not that. Words have legal meanings and if you are going to not use them, I start to have a visceral reaction.

Awlaki's father brought a federal suit to protect him. Judge Bates, who has shown himself to be a reasonable person on executive power (offering real limits), rejected the suit. He did not rest on state secrets, the Administration saying their reasoning on targeting him was secret. So, those who raise that raise something of a red flag. The article also notes that the ruling was limited, even if one thinks that in practice, it will be open-ended:
But Judge Bates rejected the notion that his ruling granted the executive “unreviewable authority to order the assassination of any American whom he labels an enemy of the state.”

“The court only concludes that it lacks capacity to determine whether a specific individual in hiding overseas, whom the Director of National Intelligence has stated is an ‘operational member’ ” of Al Qaeda’s Yemen branch, “presents such a threat to national security that the United States may authorize the use of lethal force against him,” Judge Bates said.
So, contra to the guest on Rachel Maddow last night, it is unclear if someone can be shot in NJ. That is, it's a much large step than claimed here by the Administration. I would be strongly against that as I said in the al-Marri discussion. Anyway, the fact that criminal process leaves open other process. From today's article:
No public legal process led to Mr. Awlaki’s becoming the first American citizen to be placed on the C.I.A.’s list of Qaeda-linked terrorists to be captured or killed. Officials said that every name added to the list underwent a careful, if secret, legal review. Because of Mr. Awlaki’s citizenship, the decision to add him to the target list was approved by the National Security Council as well.
Some, logically, aren't too impressed. It is a limit, a process though and if he was on the battlefield, the government didn't have to go to court first to "prove" him "guilty." But, the fact that he had a target on his back was known (I'm not sure how). That matters. Judge Bates noted that he himself didn't seem to want to challenge it in court. I think he probably should have the right to do so. If pressed, I think he would lose in the federal circuit, but that is a separate matter. Of course, he could have submitted himself to custody, though probably not in Yemen, since they convicted him in absentia.

I honestly can't feel too sorry for a guy who put himself in harm's way in enemy territory, especially since he was aware of being targeted and didn't seem to care. It simply was not some horrible horrible thing to target him like this. The nature of this conflict justifies addressing the new situation with new rules and safeguards. This includes - if we allow it - some third party (even ex parte) examining the evidence before putting American citizens on kill lists. I cited an article on how some sort of safeguard should be in place for drone use generally. Let's be honest though and note that judges would be loathe to second guess the government here. And, though there was debate (as is often the case on military targets) on the role of Awlaki, the test isn't beyond a reasonable doubt or something. The Administration in fact claims a higher test for detaining "enemy combatants" than some of the DC appeals judges want to use.  Would it be any difference here?  So, the result is likely to be risky. 

So, if I oppose how this went down, it is in effect more ideal than practical. The level of opposition bothers me more than saying that the Administration was wrong. They might have been. It's a close call to me, especially under the rules in place, which matters if we are concerned with the "rule of law," not simply what is right or wrong. Given it was a close call, ideally, I wouldn't have killed the guy. Yeah, I know. Who am I? As to pragmatics, there are various ways to go there:
The death of Anwar al-Awlaki, an American-born cleric linked to al Qaeda's operations in Yemen, is likely to impact American Arabs and Muslims in positive fashion, according to Dr. Hussein Ibish, former communications director for the Arab-American Anti-Discrimination Commitee.
Again, that counsels caution.

Rain Rain Go Away

The Tigers/Yanks series was hit by rain, hurting the Tigers since the game was suspended after their ace could only pitch an inning.  It was okay all day, but of course, they had to play at night.  The weather was supposed to be mild rain. But, still.  Rain might continue.

Friday, September 30, 2011

Yanks, Rangers ... 2-0

Such is the ML start for Matt Moore, the second game as the Game 1 starter in the playoffs.  Rays easily won 9-0.  The Rangers don't do good with rookies (sounds like the Mets), which might be why Wade Davis (with a decent record) didn't start.  Next up, the aces.

DISCLOSE Act

Colbert had his lawyer discuss a striking thing regarding how he could arrange to keep contributors to his PAC secret.  Citizens United doesn't compel this.  Disclosure laws were upheld.  The problem is filibustering a bill that fills the continual gaps found in the law.

American Citizen(s) Killed By Drone

[As I wrote this, reports are out Samir Khan, a sort of Al Qaida propagandist, also an American citizen, was killed in that attack too.  More on the "pro" side at various spots here.]
The Associated Press intelligence correspondent Kimberly Dozier was told by a U.S. government source that al-Awlaki was killed in a joint CIA-Joint Special Operations command (JSOC) operation using drones and jets, an AP colleague said.
Some over the (RIP) Slate Fray were really on Obama for use of drones, even alleging "the left" gave him a pass on it vis-a-vis Bush. It got to be a bit annoying, especially given the death toll in Iraq etc. didn't make it "partisan" to think Bush was worse. Or, that I was an "Obama lover" or "didn't care" about what was going on. Glenn Greenwald's yes brigade has the same sentiment at times. This lack of coverage is curious with all the talk and coverage on blogs, Democracy Now!, Rachel Maddow et. al. Finally, there was some confusion on the difference between the requirements of those under our control (including regarding torture) and those outside of our control, including those actively avoiding it to continue to threaten the U.S., join with our enemies and make retrieval without military force very tricky. 

Drones were used pre-Obama and until now, the last American citizen killed by one was during the Bush years. Yes, drone use greatly increased in the last two years, a strategic choice to target actual terrorists (or those we think are), not a country that didn't invade us, and in a way that put a lot less of Americans in harms' way (or in a more indirect way than being shot at). The result are thousands of people killed, some fraction innocents, though what exactly that means is a matter of debate. This to me is ill advised, but again, cf. Iraq where hundreds of thousands were killed according to the Lancet study, tens of thousands even by Bush's own mouth.

Also, this is important, drone use is not inherently illegal. At least, that is the current understanding of international law. There are problems, especially if the CIA is involved, at least without better safeguards. There is also a question of locale -- it is quite different to use it in areas generally understood to be "war zones" (I use the quotes, since there is real debate over these issues) such as Afghanistan and Pakistan. Drones have an uncomfortable feel to some (killing by remote control), well grounded on some level, but is dropping bombs far above the ground truly different in kind? Howard Zinn and others didn't seem to think so when talking about WWII bombing raids. And, it targeted attacks actually lead to much less loss of life. The cost/benefit of easier warfare is hazy, granted, but the people not killed by better pinpoint accuracy is duly noted.

In 2001, Congress (yes, even Ron Paul) authorized military force against the forces (including individuals and groups, a controversial bit) that attacked us on 9/11. The open-ended nature of this authorization is troubling, and some clarification should be passed given changing times, but it leads me to be turned off when people claim use of drones against such forces is "assassination," a few even saying killing OBL is one such incident. As if killing General Rommel during WWII via a raid would be such. This aside from if it was a good idea. A strict reading of the law might question it, but it is a type of venial sin at worst. I talked about a speech on this issue here.

The federal courts, up to the Supreme Court, authorized use of military force against American citizens if they are "enemy combatants." This is after all what the Hamdi case was about. But, he was captured on the proverbial battlefield. Thus, when it was reported that Anwar-al-Awlaki, a bi-national, was targeted, his family tried to narrow things -- if an American citizen is involved, at least, the government cannot use military force against them outside of war zones. The family lost on standing issues, though one judge was wary about deciding the question at all. I find the family's claim reasonable, surely as a matter of policy, but the Obama Administration doesn't agree. Al Qaeda forces in Yemen are a legitimate target, even if an American citizen is involved. Such as the one just reportedly killed.

As noted, this apparently (you never know for sure) is only the second such citizen killed by drone in a decade. As with Troy Davis, is it really worth the trouble killing this guy? Going to a good international law blog, it's debatable. The question might be if he was in some "material" way connected to threats to the U.S. in the relevant way. This is an important question in the lower federal courts -- just strong must the connection be for the person to be an "enemy combatant," since you after all are saying you can be authorized to detain or even kill these people. There is confusion here -- some seem to think that they deserve full criminal trial rights. This might be ideal, but that isn't the rule. They are not being tried criminally, but in a military context. Some lower standard, but some standard all the same, is involved. And, when an American citizen is involved, who clearly has the right of protection from our government (see, e.g., The Slaughterhouse Cases), special care should be provided. I don't know if it was adequate done here legally. As policy, killing him was probably a mistake. For me at least.*

I might give a strict meaning to "enemy combatant," and in open-ended conflicts, Congress should not let some authorization of force a decade ago just linger on. It is true that Congress has to re-authorize funding every two years, but it is something of a joke to suggest this is a very serious examination of the legitimacy of the conflict. Still, killing American citizens, or particularly aliens, via on the ground attacks, dropping bombs from planes or by remote control in Afghanistan or Pakistan is "legal," if not a great idea. It is not "assassination" to do this. The means might be a problem, particularly if the means are done so secretly that it is unclear if the proper rules were followed. Once you get pass that, it gets closer. I think the speech referenced in general is reasonable, if too open-ended at some point. Where that point is past my pay grade, though I pretend to be able to say reasonable things about it. The killing here is rather close to the line, at least.

Congress should pass a new authorization or we should stop our roving military force. At the very least, if an American citizen is involved, family members (see the Hamdi case) should have standing to plead their cases. If they did, giving the state of the law in the federal circuit, he very well might have lost. This very well might have been unjust, but giving this guy any grounds of being some kind of martyr isn't grand either.

---

* Rhetoric aside, no one is being "summarily" killed here. There is a process involved in determining who is targeted, and the Obama Administration isn't claiming some open-ended power to kill anyone deemed a threat. So, some drug kingpin can't be killed by drone when criminal process isn't successful. I fully am aware of the limits to such "process" and particularly with American citizens are involved, some court review is appropriate, but as with "assassination," some care should be used when discussing what is going on here. If not, why worry about proportional use of force or anything, since it's all bad?

Summer Vacation

Supremes style. Kagan and Thomas are hanging out? See also, the link on her page to a Q&A at Aspen.

Thursday, September 29, 2011

DADT Case Mooted

The Log Cabin Republicans brought a suit challenging DADT, just declared moot by the Ninth Circuit because the underlining law was overturned. Regarding a claim that benefits might have been lost, "these missed benefits are not legal penalties from past conduct," so an exception pursuant to a previous ruling do not apply. The per curiam underlined what they were doing:
Because Log Cabin has stated its intention to use the district court’s judgment collaterally, we will be clear: It may not. Nor may its members or anyone else. We vacate the district court’s judgment, injunction, opinions, orders, and factual findings—indeed, all of its past rulings—to clear the path completely for any future litigation. Those now-void legal rulings and factual findings have no precedential, preclusive, or binding effect.
This wasn't enough for Judge O’Scannlain, who decided to underline how wrong he thought the district court was to apply Lawrence v. Texas to the military context or suggest some "fundamental right" was protected by that ruling, some broad language of what was at stake (hint: not just sex) notwithstanding. I would add notwithstanding citation of Griswold et. al. that were clearly about fundamental rights. The whole point of the opinion was that the conduct here fit into the general trend, Bowers denying it being simply wrong.

A judge does not "sacrifice the rule of law to find rights they favor" in seeing this. That tired reference to what is actually a difference of opinion based on a honest judgment (to me, also correct) is as recently noted, a pet peeve of mine. The dissent in the 11th Cir. case he cites (the same circuit that struck down the PPACA provision) underlines the point. He also cites a conservative 7th Cir. ruling rejecting a shot in the dark defense of brother/sister incest that similarly went out of its way to diminish Lawrence v. Texas. Again, cf. the concurrence to Muth v. Frank, which reached the same result without the right wing commentary.

What is the wrongful fundamental right at stake here?
Put simply, the substantive due process question raised by Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell was whether a service member possesses a right to serve in the military when he is known to engage in homosexual conduct or when he states that he is a homosexual.
The latter point is free speech, even if it is free speech that arises out of conduct. Nothing novel about protecting that. What if the military tried to silence people talking about their sexuality totally? Unlikely. How does one do that? It would require not talking about spouses or showing any evidence of it to others. The basis of the policy was that there was something special about homosexuals. Lawrence v. Texas (and Romer v. Evans) underlined that homosexuals weren't some special group in this respect. It was not merely something that struck down an "outlier criminal statute." It "resolved by determining whether the petitioners were free as adults to engage in the private conduct in the exercise of their liberty."

The military can have stricter rules and it is true that Lawrence v. Texas (like Heller) was sure to add an advisory section about what is not covered. But, the ruling was clear that homosexual couples were to be treated like "individuals," and that the law "demeans the lives of homosexual persons." The ruling ultimately rested on substantive due process but clearly had an equal protection flavor. This was reaffirmed in a later case that cited O'Connor's equal protection concurrence. As with Romer v. Evans (overbroad animus) and back to Griswold (married couples), basic principles are at stake, not merely narrow results.

Sorry if you do not "favor" this result. DADT was overturned because, as with racial desegregation of the armed forces, the equal protection principles found in the cited cases were deemed applicable to the military. It is gratuitous for some appellate judge to allege that the district court judge voicing the same general spirit was in effect making shit up out of policy preferences. At least. The question was at least debatable. After all, a few judges thought it was the right approach long before Lawrence was decided, even after Bowers. Merely speaking about one's status being not the same thing as conduct.

It surely does not merit the narrow reading of Lawrence provided here, responding to something not quite that "outlier." A case was cited that counseled against broad judicial recognition of rights, but as with Romer not citing Bowers, the dissent criticized the majority not citing Washington v. Glucksberg. If anything, the implication might be that the "fundamental rights" of "intimate and personal choices" made that case not applicable, since (unlike physical assistant suicide) there was nothing novel going on. Just applying old rights equally.

The restrictive approach of the DADT concurrence was "judicial activism" of a questionable sort on the merits. The two other judges might be sending a signal too with the apparently particularly forceful language but if so, they did it with a bit more finesse than trying to restrict Lawrence to the facts or something.

Tampa Again

A thread about the Constitution becomes one about tired abortion arguments.  How old. I didn't really see it, but the final innings of that Rays game was crazy -- Ayala and Logan aren't really scrubs, the guy who hit the tying homer usually is etc. Save some for Texas.

Don't Agree With It All, But Journey Is Worth It (and quick!)

The author is personally conservative but blogs in reasonable fashion and here underlines constitutional interpretation is affected by generational struggles. Interesting sequel.

Supreme Court Watch

A cop killer -- after thirty-three years (I share Breyer's concerns) -- was executed, repeated final appeals rejected by the USSC.  A new drug protocol was used per shortages.

Reminds Me Of A Classic Pic Of Clemens

He threw a bat in the direction of Mike Piazza and the NY Daily News had a great cartoon of him in a bat suit with a lit fuse on his head.

Game 162

Reyes -- after leaving the game after one at bat (a bit chicken, but a venial sin; he bunted ... didn't know Mets could bunt) -- is the first Mets batting champ, after Braun got no hits. Given that result, Reyes could have gone 1 for 3 and still won, but it would have been more risky. The SNY didn't like him coming out -- a rare strong dissent -- including since it might be his last day and they didn't even let him come back on the field one more time to get a full send-off. Reyes had his night the day before -- with two home runs, when he rarely ever hits one. The Mets did win, finishing with two games under last year's totals, but with less expectations. I need to see what off season moves they make; the true proof in the pudding will be in '13.

The Brewers did win, so are the second seed. The Cards won but the Braves blew a save and their wild card chances in the 13th. Who do they think they are with such a collapse? The 2007/8 Mets? The Mets only blew a seven run lead in September, not eight, and not 10.5 in late August. Yeah, don't feel that good -- the Phils are the problem now. And, because their ace closer couldn't do it. The Cards winning helped Arizona, since the Phils will play non-NL East dwelling birds in the first round. The Brewers are tough especially at home but in a short series, the Diamondbacks have a chance, probably a bigger one not facing the aces from Philly. Go Diamondbacks!

Meanwhile, Tampa looked D.O.A. with Price not having it (he had a mediocre year) vs. the Yanks B team, but they came back down 7-0 with six in the 8th and one in the 9th (down to the last strike, since things weren't corny enough) to tie. Then, they went back to not scoring. Meanwhile, the Orioles (though giving up a run on a balk) had another gutsy performance, only losing 3-2 in the 9th, including after dealing with a rain delay. Lousy year, but great start and finish. First, Texas gained the second seed, so its Yanks v. Detroit. Then, Papelbon didn't gut it out. Even with two outs with no one on, up by one. The Red Sox blew the save. And, then the scrubs left (Proctor in his third inning) gave up the winning run and the f-ing Rays -- I didn't believe it would happen a few weeks back -- won it in the 12th!

No Game 163, huh? Go, Tampa!!!!!

Wednesday, September 28, 2011

Slate Fray Ending Soon etc.

And Also: A discussion on a long term (unlawful/racist) practice of getting around the treatment of small time possession of pot in NY as a trivial matter. Another good Body of Proof episode with a good mystery. Caught NCIS repeats. Decent time waster.

When the Slate fray stops being active, perhaps today, it is too bad. It was a good platform to address the material covered as well as discuss it and other matters with other people. Using inferior posting software to comment to individual articles is not quite the same thing. I enjoyed my time at Slate, but will stop reading after the "fray" ends. The actual content isn't that good any more or at least anything that will compel me to come or anything. Political Jack, an alternative some fraysters will use is not what I'm looking for. It is merely a message board. This is fine, but I like responding to specific articles and the overall format used. This even after the "star" system was discontinued. Twice being a "star" poster was nice, though perhaps a violation of my "no titles of nobility" principles.

Blogs continue to provide a means to do what the Slate Fray offered. You have blog posts to respond to and the ability to interact with others. The threading on certain blogs (let's say Daily Kos) even offers a type of "threadjacking" possibility to address other issues. Blog threads in general often don't quite address what the person was talking about. This can be equally interesting and annoying. For instance, here, "Shag" often cites some article he is reading that might interest people. That's generally positive or neutral, if somewhat non-germane. But, Slate fray provided a platform for freestanding posts on issues not connected to the article. Not linked to the article, it would receive less hits, but still it might interest someone. It was a good system. But, not meeting Slate's needs any more.

The blog linked discussed a pledge to support the "whole Constitution." I discuss the matter there, including how "support" doesn't mean you never criticize some provision, nor does it mean agreeing with a specific interpretation. Thinking the 2A only protects state militia does not mean you don't "support" the Second Amendment, even if you are wrong. The same applies to constant talk of people "inventing" stuff, when what is really meant is that you don't agree with their interpretation. One is a debate over interpretation, the other is a matter of bad intentions. It is a tiresome matter that so many do not seem to recognize the difference. And, one side (often, quite vocally, the so-called Tea Party -- which I find a stupid name) saying they are the real slim shady here (obscure reference), that they are the ones who really support the Constitution, when in fact they reasonably can be said to want to change major aspects of regularly accepted understandings of it, is particularly hard to take.

[Sometimes, people are wrong, sometimes too sure of themselves, but there is a lot of stuff to discuss, so that is going to happen.]

But, trusting the bona fides of your opponents is sometimes not popular these days. Nor is polite debate. See, e.g., taking guns to protests or trying to shout down people at town hall meetings. Or, last night on Rachel Maddow, we heard about how Gov. Christie (R-NJ) is seen by some as a savior in the Republican presidency race. Partially, it is a matter of him seen as not just a kneejerk troll. He appointed a Muslim to the courts, after all. RM focused on his attitude -- well he is from NJ (it's okay, I'm from NYC), right?

I personally don't appreciate jerks and he comes off as that sometimes. He ran against some leaving a lot to be denied rich guy last time, so him winning was not quite a slap against the whole Democrat brand. He does (sadly) represent the national Republican brand in that they are unpleasant sorts. To be honest, going beyond his image, Christie is someone who probably is a member of the "adult caucus," which seems lacking on his side. So, he needs a hook to be attractive to the base, and his "take no prisoners" approach (including being nasty to teachers and such) helps. The Koch Brothers also like him, so he has some support from the richer than God class.

Still, I hope Jon Huntsman is the face of the future.

Church and State

First, I welcome (who knew? it's like I'm on Twitter or something) my new follower.  Second, this"prison or church" program was cited in my local paper.  If there are secular alternatives, as I note there, it might work.  Meanwhile, big "ministerial exception" case coming up.

Tuesday, September 27, 2011

Mets Manage To Lose The Game

One out from winning, blew it, and a closer that didn't seem to know how to throw a strike when the Reds finally (what's that? a bunt?  what's a bunt?) went ahead, but the Mets still lost.  I think the season as a whole was okay, but the last few weeks were pretty hard to take.

Game 161

The road to a game 163 continued with a 8-7 win by Boston, a triple play by the Rays, the Cards coming back with five runs and needing more ... and Reyes hitting two home runs.  And, the night continues, in part thanks to Parnell not being able to get a one out save.

J.R. Ackerley



J.R. Ackerley has my first name ("J" is for Joe) but that isn't the only thing that led me to read his books. 

The critically praised (though I didn't quite care for it) animated version of My Dog Tulip led me to check out the book.  The book's open and honest tone, the narrator was something of a curmedegon but far from an all knowing one, was attractive. He was an editor of an English literature magazine so his writing skills are not surprising, though on his own, Ackerley only thrived when providing autobiographical material of various types.  This included a play based on his P.O.W. days, a book about his father (dedicated to Tulip) and the novel recently referenced.  As a young man, after WWI, Ackerley tried to branch out but to his disappointment, failed in the effort.  His works remain critically praised and an intro to one notes, this plus the fact he served as a mentor to other writers left him as a pretty good success.

Ackerley was the son of a "banana king" (the importance of fruits to 20th Century Latin American history has been well documented) and an actress, who he later learned only married when he was an adult. His father also secretly had another family and a past with homosexual overtones.  JA was solidly homosexual though he never truly found that "ideal friend" dreamt about, a couple long term relationships (not without disappointments too) notwithstanding.  This led to years of loneliness and dispair until he obtained a dog via one such relationship, when the person was jailed on a theft charge. He used this for his novel, which is a pretty sad account of a clearly lonely man who is desperate for some recognition of his role in the guy's life -- his parents and wife seems unfairly to dominate him, blocking him out.  Only the dog (here "Evie") is loyal and there (though he's glad) so much as to refuse to share him with anyone else, even his own cousin.

Tulip was an "Alsatian Bitch" ("bitch" is how she is repeatedly described, so the word was not disreputable in that context as it might be now), a telling bit. The introductions to the books and the film commentary all underline the symbolic nature of his relationship with his dog.  Ackerley's ideal friend was a man loyal to him, somewhat feminine (since Ackerley was to be the dominant one in the relationship, including financially, which is the "masculine" role) and beautiful.  The dog here (a type of greyhound looking breed) met those requirements, but there was a sacrifice involved with such a needy breed (even vets and kennel owners spoke of their unruly behavior).  Also, those who wonder why the Tulip book is so concerned with her breeding, well, Ackerley himself sought out an "ideal friend" via many many sexual relationships, sex an imperfect way to meet his needs.  Finding a mate (to "marry" her) would therefore be a way to please her.  Transference involved.

The Tulip film as noted took a few scenes from We Think The World Of You (an ironic title, since he doesn't really think "they" do, if not as strongly as he does for his "ideal friend"), which is fine, since the novel was really a roman à clef.  The author was middle aged when he obtained the dog, the film a bit misleading, the old man a better match to the voice actor than the original.  My Dog Tulip was a slightly altered (how much, I guess, warrants a look at Ackerley's biography by Peter Parker) account as well.  There is one other book that I have yet to read, a narrative of a trip to India in the 1920s as well as some correspondence published after his death. 



This is a graphic novel (it speaks of two others) from the author of The Time Traveler's Wife.  It is a charming adaption of her short story, with an adult twist involved, about a woman who comes upon a bookmobile containing all the stuff she ever read. 

Graphic novels are not just glorified comic books, but a nifty art form in themselves with much potential.  Some serious subjects, including the Holocaust and Israeli fighting in Lebanon underlines the reach as does less serious fare such as Pride and Prejudice in graphic novel form. 

Another Gutsy Romo Performance

Monday, September 26, 2011

Baseball Update

Reyes is ahead in the batting race by a hair but overruns the base & helps the Mets lose. Cards lost to the Mets and now Astros in a key moment. And, Rays/Sox tied. Some meaningful baseball left. [Also, Arizona has a shot for second seed, one way to avoid the Phils.]

We Think The World Of You

This is the semi-fictional part of the "Tulip trilogy" that later was made into a movie. A type of beginning. The movie version of My Dog Tulip also takes some material from here. Pretty good but I enjoyed the non-fiction better as a whole. Similar emotional honesty.

Burden on Proof

There is some reasonable dispute over what happened to Troy Anthony Davis, but the burden of proof is on the "pro" side. "Beyond a reasonable" doubt, especially with life at stake is harder to meet even than "pretty sure." One can "give a little" and still win.

Sunday, September 25, 2011

Sunday Quickies

Pretty interesting sports day, including in NY sports, one still ongoing. Even the Mets loss ended a long Phils losing streak (of little note). Pan Am looks possibly interesting, good Drop Dead Diva cliffhanger. [Update: The wrong teams won Sunday night. Boo boo boo!]

Saturday, September 24, 2011

Gee Rights Self

Well, the games are only for pride, but the Mets managed to sweep a doubleheader vs. the Phils after an error aided big inning gave Gee the lead, which he kept. He even laid down a bunt (on the second attempt)! Tampa won too & retain a long shot chance.

Saturday Quickies

Low key, but decent DVD commentary for the t.v. news fluff film Morning Glory. Yet another very good no decision for the Mets knuckleballer/cum philosopher. They won this one. Gee struggling again in nite cap. Hope he can have a better year straight thru in '12.

Death Is Different

[posted in a slightly different form in the Slate fray]

As with torture, there is something archetype related in the opposition here that goes beyond mere numbers. Numbers-wise, even in Texas, a very small number of people are involved here. Even in days of yore, only a fraction of those death penalty eligible (even a smaller subset of murderers) were even given a death sentence, as an Explainer piece notes, even a much smaller number were executed. So, why the noise on both sides?

There is something special about the government executing those in their custody, particularly American citizens, particularly if there is something hinky about how they got there. The concern goes beyond this narrow area, of course, just as DNA testing isn't just concerned with those on death row (e.g., various people were found to be falsely accused of rape). But, the death penalty is specifically symbolic of the dangers of government wrongdoing and the sanctity of life. Even if the people involved are heinous,* we want to ensure a certain level of protection.

To quote:
The penalty of death differs from all other forms of criminal punishment, not in degree, but in kind. It is unique in its total irrevocability. It is unique in its rejection of rehabilitation of the convict as a basic purpose of criminal justice. And it is unique, finally, in its absolute renunciation of all that is embodied in our concept of humanity.
The judgment of society, which is ultimately what guides what "cruel and unusual" means to a large extent (if channeled to some degree, as Dahlia Lithwick noted in a NYT op-ed, by the courts) was expressed by Justice Kennedy, the current "swing" justice:
The rule of evolving standards of decency with specific marks on the way to full progress and mature judgment means that resort to the penalty must be reserved for the worst of crimes and limited in its instances of application. In most cases justice is not better served by terminating the life of the perpetrator rather than confining him and preserving the possibility that he and the system will find ways to allow him to understand the enormity of his offense. Difficulties in administering the penalty to ensure against its arbitrary and capricious application require adherence to a rule reserving its use, at this stage of evolving standards and in cases of crimes against individuals, for crimes that take the life of the victim.
The "limits" here include limiting it to cases where there does not remain some "residual doubt" after sentencing, which repeatedly has shown to be an imperfect process making appellate review and re-examination by executive bodies well justified. I and others think Troy Davis failed this test, putting aside the further belief of some of us that the "peculiar institution" du jour should end.

Meanwhile, many more lives are at risk in ways the government can address. For instance, the thousands of people who die because of the inability to have adequate health insurance, which was addressed in significant part by the PPACA. Those of us that think health care should be a protected right, such as it is for some, see this also as an important life and death issue. As with the many criminal justice issues beyond the death penalty that needs to be addressed better, these are all important issues.

But, death remains different, particularly the death penalty.

---

* A few over at the Slate fray fantasize about getting some personal justice if a family member is involved here, but it is just that. In reality, we have a criminal justice system, one where "an eye for an eye" isn't the philosophy.

Clinchers

Last night was one of various clinchers, including the Diamondbacks (my playoff '11 team)and near clinchers (e.g., Tampa lost again, limping toward elimination, after having a real chance again). Slate fray lives for another week or so. Yeah, a stay from execution.

America Was Great?

“Pan Am” doesn’t say much of anything about the current state of the nation except that our best days are behind us.
Depressing times. This too shall pass. We still have to get through it, not all doing it. Meek's Cutoff looked good, too dull for me.

Friday, September 23, 2011

Blag Hag Gets New Home

And, really, Rush Limbaugh loving? I think that, not the Lutheran part might have been the problem. People do have different religious views, especially if the other isn't an asshole pro-RL. There are other deal breakers than some liberal religion type. But, to each their own.

Mets Spoil Again

After hurting the Braves, the Mets came back from a stupor (with some help) and scored seven runs in the last two innings to stop the Cards from benefiting as much as they could. Still, won't win as many games as '10. A "to be continued" feel. Learn how to bunt!

Thursday, September 22, 2011

Doc Martin

A sorta spin-off of Saving Grace, if with different personality and last name, episodes of this amusing British show can be found online. The latest on Youtube. The leads also were good in other stuff, Louisa in varied cop roles and DM on the rather different William and Mary.

Scalia vs. common law judging

Since courts in each jurisdiction here and many abroad interpret a written Constitution in a way he thinks is "entirely senseless,"  it is quite impressive he is so very wiser than all those people. (/sarcasm)  A bit of confusion in Kelo reporting. Brooke Shields to play her on t.v.

"Mommy, bears don't use toilet paper."

What half-way smart five-year-olds should say to this.

Change in Death Penalty Conversation etc.?

Rachel Maddow, Dahlia Lithwick et. al. had some interesting coverage, but I don't know how much Troy Anthony Davis or the Supreme Court taking a few more capital cases will change things. 

Wednesday, September 21, 2011

Troy Davis Has Been Executed

"legal acrobatics"



Some comments by "Brett" on the constitutional recognition of slavery (and its racial nature) led me to supply my .02.  He was partially right to call out some who don't recognize that the Constitution is somewhat mixed on the subject, the fact it leaves an opening for a lot of wrongdoing not meaning it quite requires such a path.  The subject of the post -- the 3/5 Clause -- underlines the confusion.  The clause does not treat, stereotypes aside, blacks as 3/5ths of a person.  It treats slaves (as James Madison's discussion in F.54 suggests, "other persons" were basically slaves, even if literally others might be included, and the slaves were going to be black, again even though the path is left open for something more) that way in respect to apportionment of House seats and direct taxes.  But, the underlining principle (see Madison) does recognize slavery as legitimate and given the realities of the situation, blacks (even if free) in particular were harmed.

I added a link to my quick comment yesterday about the end of DADT, the link to a discussion on how both political (executive action covered, so not merely legislative) and court action (I guess some might think of this as "political" too; maybe "elective" then) work together to change things in the area of civil rights. This underlines the principle discussed by Pamela Karlan in my Constitution Day post last weekend: the Constitution sets forth basic rules that change over time.  This is one reason why electing Lincoln was so dangerous to certain forces -- true enough he agreed the federal government could not interfere with state power to allow slavery in any number of ways. But, there was enough flexibility there (see the dissents in Dred Scott) to endanger slavery forces all the same.  If slavery was ended, as it was without amendment in a majority of the states (including Maryland and Missouri during the Civil War), slaves wouldn't be "other persons." They would be "persons" with certain basic rights. 

And, even with slavery, a different mind-set could interpret certain provisions a different way.  Imagine if the Fugitive Slave Act was declared partially unconstitutional since "persons" (as alleged fugitives were) did not get proper due process rights. The law, after all, wasn't the only thing that led the Missouri Supreme Court in Dred Scott's case (in a separate lawsuit) to change its rules regarding recognizing that slaves that went into free areas staid free, even if they returned to the slave state of Missouri.  The majority opinion cited the pressures of the day, how free states allegedly violated the comity involved that warranted the old rule.  Electoral politics also led certain people to be elected President, people who then nominated certain people to the Supreme Court though the division of the country into judicial circuits, not by some sort of "one man, one vote" fashion that would have given non-slave areas more coverage, also influenced the breakdown.  And, the very decision of Dred Scott was influenced by party politics, Congress in fact basically welcoming some judicial settlement of the question by easing suits involving slavery in the new Mexican War obtained territories. 

It is equally naive and blind not to recognize that a mere literal reading of the Constitution fails to explain how the courts and the people at large interprets the Constitution.  It is especially true when examining things at the margins and by looking at swing votes, which our system (including in Congress) gives some extra power to at the end of the day.  Such forces are influenced by things like public opinion, personal beliefs (including empathy) and other "soft" factors other than some strict reliance to the law. Our system of law in fact encourages that sort of thing by setting up broad rules ("due process," "beyond a reasonable doubt," "rule of reason") that have a lot of play in the joints. This results in a type of "common law" approach influenced by events, even if statutory rules serve as limiting factors.  It's messy, but realistically that is how things work, even if some angrily reject it (while following it sub silento).  On the SSM issue:

So, the legal acrobatics have already been invented and exercised. The question is whether the public’s comfort level has advanced far enough toward accepting marriage between same-sex couples to embolden the Supreme Court to do its job.
I would question if the "legal acrobatics" is always a bad thing.  The ideal for some is justice, even if the sky will fall. But, life doesn't work that way.  Someone cited to me the idea that we all have inherent rights and accused me of believing we have rights, until the government doesn't recognize them.  Sounds nice, but if the government doesn't recognize them, what good are the rights?  We can imagine "natural rights" that exist but are unenforced.  On some level, that sounds good, but again, only helps the slave so much.  Practice is a bit more messy.  And, the slow change -- at times being a bit coy about the messiness involved -- approach just might be the way to go there.  After all, people can all they want pretend that the Constitution in practice meant the same thing (putting aside amendments) in 1900 and 2000, but that's not how things actually work.

The change -- kinda like evolution -- is slow, if with some major changes mixed in to keep things interesting.

Three Thoughts



Food: One medium sized grapefruit can be used to make a pitcher of grapefruit juice or mixed with wine to make a tasty cooler.  Raw carrots make good snacks.  That water you drain from pasta, especially if you added something (like a few packets of Chinese food flavorings) beforehand, can make tasty soup base.  The pasta tub in the microwave thingie works pretty good.

TV: Body of Proof is back and it started off nicely.  Good character stuff, mystery and the always charming (for t.v./film nerds) familiar guest stars (FNL/True Jackson V.P.) with an inside joke about Desperate Housewives tossed in.

Complaint: Slip-ups that seem so patently obvious.  For instance, having "no doubt," contra one recent book I read, is not necessary before "clear and convincing" is met. There is something else, which actually has "doubt" in its name, where that works better. And, even there, it is not really "no" doubt but no "reasonable" doubt.  Some argue, e.g., that the death penalty should be left open only when even perhaps a higher standard is met, even a "shadow" of a doubt, even if somewhat unreasonable, would disqualify. This from a law professor type.

Also, Justice Douglas did not "speak for the dissenters" in Poe v. Ullman.  It's a pretty important case and easy enough for a person to look up and see he spoke only for himself.  Didn't these people have readers or something to stop such stuff from being in the final copy?   No review for you!

Tuesday, September 20, 2011

Repeal Day


At press conference on the day DADT finally ended, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs Mike Mullen says decision to end the policy was "first and foremost a matter of integrity."
Elections matter. [Courts do too & who picks the judges?]

Slate Fray Ending Soon

I first contributed to the Slate Fray to comment on the Bush v. Gore litigation and then returned in early 2002. It allowed me to comment on articles and submit freestanding stuff, getting feedback. Good as long as it lasted. Don't think much of the new comment system.

Monday, September 19, 2011

Drop Dead Diva

Another average episode, Stacey being the most dramatic bit with her comeuppance coming at the end. The guest stars (yes, that's the guy from the football movie) didn't add too much, especially the judge.

Sunday, September 18, 2011

Jets Still Looked Like The Rams

McCown, who was replaced by rookie Blaine Gabbert early in the fourth quarter after posting a dismal 1.8 quarterback rating.
The actual NY team, Buffalo, had some comeback as well.

Deputy National Security Advisor John Brennan Remarks

Some comments [by a former Obama legal adviser and critic of broad claims of executive power] on recent remarks by Deputy National Security Advisor John Brennan seems a fitting thing to discuss since they address some of my themes and answer some of the strong criticism of Obama from some on the left that to me seems rather skewered, this from someone far from enthused about our use of force. In part, an op-ed is quoted:
It has simply not been more of the same. The CIA’s “black sites”–secret prisons in other countries–are closed. Enhanced interrogation is outlawed. The laws of war have been restored. Guantanamo remains open not because Obama wants it that way, but because Congress has barred the expenditure of funds to bring its prisoners to the United States for trial.

Thus, to pretend that there has been no rejection of what came before–of what defined the “war”–is a mistake. It took court decisions, public opposition, congressional changes, new leaders within the Bush administration, and finally a new president to end the war on terror as we knew it.

And the effort was worth it. Because we got better.

What of criticism of drone attacks, even as a reply to criticism of use of the death penalty? As the analysis shows, the attacks are not open-ended summary use of force:
It’s evident that a principal purpose of this section of the speech concerning the use of force, especially outside the “hot battlefield” of the Af/Pak theater, is to further distance the Administration from the “Global War on Terror” framework that infected U.S. characterizations of our counterterrorism strategy shortly after September 11th. ”[W]e are at war with al-Qa’ida,” emphasizes Brennan–not with all terrorists the world over. (Brennan explains that our “ongoing armed conflict with al-Qa’ida stems from our right—recognized under international law—to self defense. This is not news, or controversial. See, e.g., U.N. Resolution 1373 (Sept. 28, 2001). There is no such self-defense rationale available as a matter of the jus ad bellum with respect to all international terrorist groups.)
The use of this power can be attacked on policy grounds, and in respect to some target areas perhaps legally, but to simply speak of it like we are going around assassinating people willy-nilly is exaggeration on steroids. We also are not merely picking some groups worldwide we don't like and killing them. The group is one that attacked us and membership is worldwide and continues to wish to do us harm, including by military means. The use of force was authorized by Congress (2001 AUMF) and (in various cases) international law. Cf. torture and cruel/inhumane treatment.

Aside from the fact (unlike those in custody) that the people being killed (see, e.g., drone attacks in Pakistan  to see who these people tend to be ... the collateral damage of civilians granted, underlining the problems with any use of military force) don't have some sort of constitutional right of protection. Also:
Of course, there will be contexts, particularly in some of the locations to which Brennan is referring, where capture is infeasible, for various reasons of logistics, technology, diplomacy, the nature of the consent the U.S. has obtained from other nations, etc. But Brennan’s remarks should put to rest the notion–for which I’ve yet to see any good supporting evidence–that the U.S. policy is now to kill persons who it would have apprehended several years ago.
Any "policy" isn't likely to be applied 100% without breach (see comment there on OBL, which is as the reply notes, not exactly the normal case though some harp on it like it was), but this has bite. Too much force, secrecy and so forth continues, but there are shades of gray indeed.

Constitution Day

And Also: I admit to have grown tired of Rachel Maddow, but the news in general tires me out -- it's depressing in repetitive fashion. But, I'm glad Chris Hayes has a new show; his strong "The Nation" voice is appreciated.

A couple quotes from a few years back:
Why study the Constitution? Study the Constitution because it is both the foundation and the guardian of our liberties. Study it also with the knowledge that as strong and enduring as our Constitution has been, it is nevertheless a fragile, almost intangible thing that cannot survive without the dedication and constant support of citizens. The statement of Benjamin Franklin, made in 1787, is still true today. This is a Republic, if we can keep it.

-- Sen. Byrd

On September 17, 1787, the 55 delegates to the Constitutional Convention held their final meeting. Only one item of business occupied the agenda that day, to sign the Constitution of the United States of America.

-- Constitution Day [shifts to next business day, if it falls on a weekend]
I'm not sure if 9/17/87 is the best day to celebrate, since it might be better to be concerned about when it was ratified or officially was put in place (not the same day), but then we celebrate 7/4 based on the potential over the actuality. Guess there is some message there about our culture. Anyway, the day continues to have value, the government (per the Declaration of Independence) established to secure our rights and protect our interests, the Constitution to do so better:
We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.
A reasonable (and sane) reading of the document continues to be important, even as some use it to the public's detriment:
Keeping Faith with the Constitution wades into a long-running debate about how we should interpret our Constitution. This debate is an important part of public policy discussions on everything from judicial nominations to health care reform. For a long time, conservatives have framed this debate by portraying themselves as strict adherents to the text and original understanding of the Constitution, while claiming that liberals and progressives ignore the text and decide cases based on their own values or policy preferences.

That characterization is, of course, a caricature.


-- Pamela Karlan
This is also the traditional time that the Cato Institute releases there book analyzing some of the key rulings of the previous Supreme Court term, though it might take a bit of time to be available on Amazon (I will get it in the beginning of November). And, the first Monday of October is just around the corner as the more chilly weather upon us here suggests as well. Time goes on.

Saturday, September 17, 2011

The Closer

I caught the latest episode and the ending (good guest star turn) has some bite for a person of my sentiments; the bad Mexican cop killed in custody (S4) was particularly problematic. We now have a new show about IA. Episode as a whole was good. Still don't know the mole.

Finding Bliss

I first saw this film via Netflix. [Another good watch there was TiMER] It was on television last night. Again, good film, and darn if she even sounds like Helen Hunt. Denise Richards has a nice role too.

Friday, September 16, 2011

Becoming Jane Austen

I did not read a full length biography during my "Austen" period of late but did not really care for this one. A few too many assumptions, too many family details (done in a tedious way) and a few questionable absences. Stopped reading though admit to it having some charm.