About Me

My photo
This blog is the work of an educated civilian, not of an expert in the fields discussed.

Friday, February 17, 2012

Sexual Assault / Health Care ... Tomato/oe

Life has a looking glass quality at times. The Republicans are concerned about "voting fraud" but can't handle (as Rachel Maddow notes) to count votes properly in more than one state. They don't like abortion or threats to religious liberty or wasting money, but a means to save money, further the religious liberty of employees and cut down abortions is a problem. Over at Volokh Conspiracy, we even have talk about how prevention isn't really part of health care, really, it is sort of a "liberal" ideological trick. BTW, talk about judicial activism -- January 1, 2014 is the due date here and court challenges are up already.
So the problem is not just that the woman and her physician (the core relationship protected in Roe) no longer matter at all in deciding whether an abortion is proper. It is that the physician is being commandeered by the state to perform a medically unnecessary procedure upon a woman, despite clear ethical directives to the contrary.
Dahlia Lithwick (via here) is but one person who shows us more situational ethics (and you thought it was some sort of leftist thing). The non-mandated insurance requirement ("mandate" = some people paying more income taxes) is according to some a nefarious "commandeering" of the people, per Paul Clement a means to avoid "upfront" accountability. Yeah, because no one knows what is going on there. Meanwhile, Virginia wants to join the "forced ultrasound" club* and who but the choir knows? A procedure as DL's links note will sometimes require an actual vagina penetration, an amendment to require consent there rejected.

Unwanted "penetration of a woman’s vagina without her consent is sexual assault" (to cite a RH Reality Check story linked). Such a threat to "bodily integrity" was a key aspect cited by Planned Parenthood v. Casey as a reason for the right to choose an abortion. If removal of a bullet or pumping the stomach to expel contraband swallowed is problematic, this should be too. As with other cases, including biased informed consent requirements or religiously slanted funding moves, this problematic above and beyond merely being an undue burden on abortion. The argument is that the medically unnecessary procedure is important for full informed consent, but it is clearly not compelling on that front since it is not common practice or anything.

[Update: informed consent material inserted here.]

I abbreviated that last paragraph for editing purposes but it really should be added that this type of regulation is a direct effect of Casey, particularly when it burdens early abortion choices and is largely about prenatal life. Casey removed the trimester scheme which blocked legislation that was only about the last interest, except in the third trimester and when it didn't directly block abortion choices (funding was seen as not doing this, since poverty is not the government's fault).  Now, you can do that sort of thing, unless there is a substantial burden on abortion.  The ultrasound law adds expense and hardship and should be considered "undue," but it seems to me to be debatable enough that the non-abortion "liberty" concerns must be added to put it over the top.

Casey also shoehorned women's health here though Blackmun and Stevens were wary about some of the material provided given its slanted quality.  Also, as Stevens noted, the fact an interest in potential life might be present does not mean it can trump the woman's interests here. Do we require newly pregnant women to hear about the costs and hardships of pregnancy and children, particularly for certain people, since it might lead them to be upset about carrying it to term later on? Perhaps, pictures of children in foster homes, after their parents couldn't care for them?  Some do (as in marriage and so forth) after all regret their decision and when it comes to teenagers (and probably others), it is particularly important for them to know what is coming.  Spoiler alert: we do not compel that sort of thing; we trust the women. 

Informed consent is not a bad thing, but the below sentiment from Casey should be evenhandedly applied with the full interests of the patient (client) taken into consideration, including other constitutional interests:
It cannot be questioned that psychological well being is a facet of health. Nor can it be doubted that most women considering an abortion would deem the impact on the fetus relevant, if not dispositive, to the decision. In attempting to ensure that a woman apprehend the full consequences of her decision, the State furthers the legitimate purpose of reducing the risk that a woman may elect an abortion, only to discover later, with devastating psychological consequences, that her decision was not fully informed. If the information the State requires to be made available to the woman is truthful and not misleading, the requirement may be permissible.
In the so-called "partial abortion" case, there was a fear that if the procedure was allowed, doctors would (for the sake of the sensitive women) avoid fully informing them of the procedure, so perhaps, it was best just not to have it at all.  This approach is a tad better, though we are not merely talking about "information" (see footnote for a link to the importance of "ethical" use of informed consent)  here, but forced medical procedures on patients.  It is one thing to require abortion providers to offer ultrasounds for those who want them (some find patients appreciate the option, so do so voluntarily) but forcing the issue is different, particularly when probes need to be put in vaginas. The effects on abortion decisions are at best cloudy, so there is (even if we accept them at face value) no compelling need to force the women here. The implication that the main value is to shame women and force them to serve as conduits of a certain ideological / moral viewpoint is rather strong. 


Next month some alleged big threat to individual medical choices (inactively done) will be heard by the Supreme Court. Meanwhile, the right of women with her doctor to make a health choice following her conscience will be continuously invaded by the same side that uses this as a big issue.  Women are not trusted here to make their own choices, adding a choice to have an ultrasound not the point here.  The refusal to accept the amendment requiring consent when a transvaginal (never a good idea to have "vagina" as club against you) was involved underlines the point.  As with the contraceptives situation, trusting the individual is not the rule here.  We yet again await the true libertarians. 

Also, as seen today in NJ, same sex marriage should be left to the legislature, except when it should not, moving past "civil unions" to same sex marriages must for some reason be done by public referendum. After all, if given the chance, wouldn't blacks have done that in the 1960s contra using the legislature to pass civil rights acts?  Unfortunately, I'm not just being snarky -- the governor who vetoed it made that comparison.

---

*  According to the Guttmacher Institute, twenty states have ultrasound laws as of 2/12/12, a "mid-90s" (post-Casey) trend.  Seven states require it though only Texas (two other states in legal limbo) require showing and explaining the image. If performed, nine states say the provider must allow the woman to see the image while five others require such an opportunity even if the physician would not normally perform it.

Since it often is not normal procedure (adding cost and time), particularly for early abortions, this would add costs. A report on informed consent linked by the above notes that it "can add $50–$200 to the cost." Images also might be misleading, which might be a problem at biased crisis pregnancy centers, not there to give full information and not necessarily staffed by those fully trained in prenatal development.  This is why full disclosure upfront, something they repeatedly resist doing, is so important.  Not just when it might promote one viewpoint. 

"Yale Kamisar on the Rise and Fall of Miranda"

See here and reference is made to another scholar's works, including "mourning Miranda." It is a good discussion but Miranda wasn't some be all, end all. It was a start of sorts and continues to be tweaked, in various ways negatively. Aspects still useful.

How I Learned to Drive

I saw this years back when Mary-Louise Parker starred (also saw her on stage in Proof) and it's back out there with Elizabeth Reaser, who I liked in Sweet Land and Puccini for Beginners. Good luck.

Thursday, February 16, 2012

Slings and Arrows

A review of a new stage drama let me to this old Canadian series with some familiar faces, including the lead of Due South and Rachel McAdams about a Canadian theater company. Pretty good so far.

PPACA Taxation

It's a tax folks:
Folks here who are arguing about “honesty” and “dishonesty” in the interpretation of federal statutes, or about the “letter of the law” as opposed to the substance and purpose of the law, or who believe that a “magic word” will make the difference between whether a law imposes a “tax” or a non-tax “penalty,” are obfuscating. They want ACA to be struck down, and don’t much care how it is done.

The actual provisions of the ACA tell a different story. The provisions relating to the minimum health insurance requirement (commonly, but not accurately, called the mandate) are all geared to income taxes. They provide that, beginning in 2014, non-exempted federal income tax payers who fail to maintain a minimum level of health insurance coverage for themselves or their dependents will owe a penalty for each month in the tax year during which minimum coverage is not maintained. 26 U.S.C.A..5000a. The amount of the penalty will be calculated as a percentage of household income for federal income tax purposes. 26 U.S.C.A.. 5000a(c). The penalty will be reported on the taxpayer’s federal income tax return and assessed and collected by the Internal Revenue Service. 26 U.S.C.A.. 5000a(b)(2) and (g). Individuals who are not required to file federal income tax returns for a given year will be exempt from the penalty. 26 U.S.C.A.. 5000a(e). Looking at these provisions, and analyzing what they actually require, it is clear that the so-called “penalty” operates as a tax; is imposed as a tax; is measured by taxable income; is collected as a tax. And it is an income tax.
Truth doesn't always win out, but it kinda matters all the same.  

It's about religious liberty AND women

The refusal to allow a women student on a panel discussion on "religious liberty" (not absolute) about the contraceptives ruling (what is this Pan Am?) got some pushback about it being about women. Yeah, women whose religious liberty includes choosing birth control.

30 Years On Death Row, Unlimited In The Grave

A person convicted of a heinous murder was executed after thirty years, this post discussing why Florida seems to drag things out.  Justice Breyer has long been on board as being against such a thing.  There is a logic to carrying things out but it seems rather pointless.

Linsanity

Not a basketball fan, but this Lin stuff is fun though even Steve Somers on WFAN, not known for his hard eyed realism, seems to be taking it as a "enjoy it while you can" thing.  Spring Training almost here.  Yes, still care about the NYM. Long term, hope it will be ok.

Wednesday, February 15, 2012

Lovings on a day for Loving

There can be no doubt that restricting the freedom to marry solely because of racial classifications violates the central meaning of the Equal Protection Clause.
HBO, a black history/VD two-fer, had a nice documentary on tonight.  Mildred Loving later supported SSM.

Tuesday, February 14, 2012

Pan Am

Good episode on Sunday though no reference to the JFK assassination. [IMDB  Message Board flags that the episode was aired out of order.] Next week will be the season [series?] finale.

Monday, February 13, 2012

Religion and Public Officials etc.

And Also: A helpful analysis of SOPA.  [More]


There is concern when people of a certain religious faith wish to guide public policy in a direction that matches their beliefs, both on substantive policy grounds and a desire to separate church and state.  It is a bit ironic, but not really, that we ban religious tests for public office (Art. VI and the First Amendment) while religion is such an important part of many who run for office.  The barrier is not to a person promoting a certain religious viewpoint; it is in effect a guarantee that this will be in place for all comers.  This doesn't mean it is always a great policy or that unofficially, the public decides certain faiths are more "proper" than others. 

As noted in McDaniel v. Paty, there once was an effort to promote separation of church and state by preventing ministers (widely defined*) from running for office. This is no longer the policy, the outlier there declared unconstitutional as a violation of the First Amendment (one justice arguing it is a violation of voting rights).  The right to equal access to public office also applies to the general believer, religious freedom based on individual belief, not merely associated with an established faith.  It is left to the voter to decide who is best there.

The ruling was of the pre-Oregon v. Smith era, where equal application of general laws could still be a violation of the First Amendment, the old rule still statutorily protected under RFRA and allowed if state law requires it.  The plurality here noted "free exercise of religion unquestionably encompasses the right to preach, proselyte, and perform other similar religious functions."  This seems obvious to me. "Free exercise" cannot merely be "belief," but surely must entail other basic religious acts like going to services and so forth, though the core stuff often overlaps with speech and association (the "ministerial exemption" tends to involve religious associations having additional freedom of movement) in such a way that an independent right need not be focused upon. 

Still, there seems to be something beyond belief and other First Amendment activities, noting that originally said activities might have been more limited than they are today (e.g., a focus on political assemblies; the Free Exercise Clause would add religious assemblies, leaving open various others that might be banned). Sacraments, for instance, involves meetings, words and acts.  Thus, my concern regarding the ULC Church / marriage officiant controversies that religious freedom is hindered. Special favoritism or burdens on religion, especially certain religions, is particularly problematic.  It also has arisen in the same sex marriage area, if we want to see a real religious freedom burden in place arising from that issue.

So, the proper approach is to accept that a Rick Santorum is allowed to run for office, but to be concerned with the merits of his plan for public policy. Also, "free exercise" involves various things, not just belief. The NY Court of Appeals in fact touched upon this when dealing with the contraceptives coverage issue a few years back (see here and my allusion here), the Supreme Court denying cert. NY took a half-way approach, providing limited heightened scrutiny to protect religious acts even respecting general applicable laws, such as one that might prevent use of ceremonial wine. Nonetheless, since the Church need not distribute contraceptives, non-believers are broadly affected and interests in sexual equality and health care arise etc. on balance made the requirement acceptable.

Anyway, Paty was a rather short oral argument, the state spending about seventeen minutes, might have spent less if a few questions added to his time.

---

* The state ruling defined "priests" this way:
"1: one who performs sacrificial, ritualistic, mediatorial, interpretative, or ministerial functions esp. as an authorized or ordained religious functionary or official minister of a particular religion."; [and] "2. A minister in a non-Christian religion. 3. One whose role is considered comparable to that of a priest."
A question in the oral arguments referenced a possible religion where each member is considered a "minister," another suggesting the Mormons so recognize.  Quakers are specifically singled out in some marriage laws, e.g., since their "self-uniting" marriage ceremony has no officiant given the equal roles in that faith, the discussion there noting a federal court in at least one case suggested there was a federal right involved to equally application of marriage laws in such cases.

Sunday, February 12, 2012

Super PACs



It is a constant refrain that Super PACs are a big factor in this election and that they are the direct result of Citizens United. For instance:

Super PACs are the byproduct of the 2010 Supreme Court decision commonly known as "Citizens United," which granted corporations, unions and individuals the right to donate unlimited funds to outside groups to campaign for or against candidates.
I'm continuously confused here particularly because this discussion often arises when some billionaire (Rachel Maddow suggests each candidate seems to have their "own" or perhaps vice versa) is behind things.  The ruling did not concern individuals providing unlimited funds.  No.  The concern were that it gave too much power to "corporations," yes?  So, why exactly would Citizen United be to blame when Super PACs are not funded by corporations (or perhaps unions)?  Is it that they would not be as problematic without corporate funds?

As with the whole "corporations are people" business, this is seriously confused.  At least, I am.  I checked Wikipedia.  It notes that another case is also involved here, involving SpeechNOW.org, which applied a principle of Citizens United involving the assumed lack of corruption (at least for so-called independent groups, the "so-called" fodder for Colbert et. al.) being a legitimate interest to limit donations.  It is that broader principle, not just the protection of corporations as such, which connects things to Citizens United.  As summarized at the link to that case:
However, the [lower] Court, following the Citizens United holding that independent expenditures do not create actual or apparent quid pro quo corruption, found that applying limits to contributions for independent expenditures would violate the First Amendment rights of SpeechNOW.org and its donors. The Court held that SpeechNOW.org was entitled to accept unlimited contributions from individuals for IE’s, but also stated “...we only decide these questions as applied to contributions to SpeechNOW, an independent expenditure-only group. Our holding does not affect ... limits on direct contributions to candidates.”

The FEC then made rulings pursuant to these principles. This underlines that focusing on "corporations" here is misguided, since broader game is involved. The legal conclusion (the result of not much analysis and not overly convincing as compared to Scalia's more honest "that's how the system works" stance) the corruption is not really a compelling state interest in this context is the real problem with Citizens United.

The fact "corporations" are involved as compared to individuals or other types of business arraignments is not the biggest problem. There are various ways to regulate corporations, but if the basic idea of the corruption or appearance thereof is not allowed, we will have the path taken here.  Personally, I think we can work around the ruling, including with better disclosure rules, public financing and other methods while various problems such as people speaking in apparently nefarious ways in an unbalanced fashion is inherent to the First Amendment. 

Regardless, it is helpful to understand more why the ruling was so important, even though they are not just corporately funded.

More On Prop 8 Case

I have provided my .02 (more like $2) on this case in various Volokh Conspiracy threads, including repeatedly answering "ME," who is not a lawyer, but unlike me, when pressed, doesn't actually say so.  Much heavy lifting in the promotion of bigotry. Who needs the Fray?

Cat Is Getting to Be Too Much of an Airhead

Tone it down Victorious.  Pretty good episode where Beck actually got upset and Tori was right about not rushing to replace the cell phone. 

Whitney Houston

I am a fan of her music but are we really surprised at her death?  Have not heard much about her lately myself other than hints of drug problems.  Good discussion on Chris Hayes about her and public life.  Seems like he went to school (and jumped rope) near me.

Saturday, February 11, 2012

Freedom of Conscience

At the heart of liberty is the right to define one’s own concept of existence, of meaning, of the universe, and of the mystery of human life. Beliefs about these matters could not define the attributes of personhood were they formed under compulsion of the State.

-- Planned Parenthood v. Casey
Some Catholics might feel a need to defend the Catholic Church, even when they personally do not follow its dictates (contra a representative on Chris Hayes this morning, they don't just treat things like birth control like lying -- they think lying is generally bad and don't continuously use it, even in the confessional [birth control pills]). Still, ultimately, personal decision making here is usually most important to them.   The stance of an established church, even their own oftentimes, notwithstanding.

The Universal Life Church "ordains" ministers on demand as long as they are human beings (as far as they know) and the individuals are to use their conscience to determine what is "good."  There are a few limitations here, such as respecting the rights of others, but ultimately the theme is individual conscience. This has been accepted, even in the Deep South, as enough for a "religion" to exist.  A modern day definition to be sure, since "religion" was understood a bit more broadly back in the day where Jefferson and Paine might be deemed "atheists" even though both believed in God and at times even a final judgment of some sort.  A more respected example here would be Unitarian-Universalism, which also welcome a diverse group, including atheists and agnostics, setting forth certain basic rules of equality and equal respect. 

I do not like the term "atheist" because it has a certain close-minded implication that is in part anti-religion. This does not mean the term necessarily implies that, but it tends to oftentimes.  I do not think disbelief in "God" warrants that, particularly since "religion" should be defined broadly (see, e.g., U.S. v. Seeger).  A thing of central importance for me is freedom of conscience, which is inhibited by selective authorization of one or the other side of things that divide conscientious people.  Note, e.g., the founding principles of a secularist student group, strongly supported by an atheist blogger:
The mission of the Secular Student Alliance is to organize, unite, educate, and serve students and student communities that promote the ideals of scientific and critical inquiry, democracy, secularism, and human-based ethics. We envision a future in which nontheistic students are respected voices in public discourse and vital partners in the secular movement's charge against irrationality and dogma.
This movement welcomes a diverse group:
We embrace the common goals and shared aspects of all naturalistic, secular worldviews. Secular Student Alliance affiliates include, but are not limited to, atheists, agnostics, humanists, freethinkers, skeptics, naturalists, brights, Pastafarians, and many others.
Labels can hold people back. Some "freethinkers" or "skeptics" or whatever might belong to some "religious" community of some sort but welcome a secular government and the other ends here.  The bottom line is a respect for freedom of conscience (broadly defined) and opposing those who would inhibit that by setting rules from above that interferes with that.  Such breadth requires some line drawing and compromises.

The contraceptives controversy underlines this -- the individual need not use contraceptives, the religious institutions do not have to distribute them.  These are important values to respect.  But, as part of a wider regulation of health care and employment, they cannot block individual conscience in various respects, particularly when the institution is not purely religious and serves a diverse group, including those not members of the religion. The result threatens individual liberty. Money being fungible, absolutism becomes even less possible, arbitrary line drawing to be avoided, even though the proper line might be somewhat hazy and open to debate/compromise.*

If we were less concerned with individual liberty, including conscientious choices of broad discretion, a different path might be possible. But, we are so concerned.  Particularly given their minority view, the Catholic Church here and some other group in some other context should understand that.

---

* The special treatment of abortion is but one example here.

Update: A lot of the coverage on the contraceptives controversy here is about symbolism and as this discussion noted "recognition" if not respect.  Prop 8 is a form of that -- a means to give the other side something, though unlike here, another group is seriously getting harmed in the process.  Respect of religion, especially in our modern regulatory state, is a big factor to consider.  But, the rule already respected religion. 

Red Dust

A good film portraying a Truth and Reconciliation hearing in South Africa, Hilary Swank (looking great, good role overall) playing a South Africa born lawyer representing someone challenging it. I wonder how this would play if this was used for our torture regime.

Santorum's French Revolution Nightmare?

Contraceptives "Compromise"

Some don't like the um "revision" taken here, seeing it as an "accounting trick." But, money is fungible. If individual tax breaks were in place, wouldn't that be impure too? I'm sure Medicare funds are sometimes used in ways some religions don't like.

Friday, February 10, 2012

Joe's Constitution (Not That One)

Joe's Constitution is a creative website that provides information on the amendments of the Constitution. It should not be confused with a certain two part book by the same name and either way, has no connection to me or this blog. Check it out all the same.

NCIS 200th

Recently charmed by this show, even with its too cool for school vibes. Like L&O, it lasts so long by doing what it does professionally. Comfort food. Latest gave a few "what could have beens" for fans.

Thursday, February 09, 2012

Contraceptives Coverage -- Nothing New

The not new rule has older antecedents involving other religions. Consider this case from 1982 rejecting an Amish tax exemption claim, the law there too a compromise, involving a "comprehensive insurance system" that "binds others" in a commercial area.

Mother and Child

The rather unpleasant (if with reason) characters of this film were too much for me, how it turns out ... well.  Good to see a strong atheist character ("she was created from nothing and will return to nothing, the time in between becoming a journey of will, luck, and desire").

Republican Form of Government & Prop 8



Among some of the dreck commentary on the Prop 8 case has been some good stuff, and Marci Hamilton -- our friendly conservative separation of church and state representative -- uses her forum to focus on the process.  No, not the judicial process:
If ever one might question the wisdom of these western-style direct-democracy systems, it was surely then.  First, the state’s law had been amended through a secret vote of the people, who never had to explain to anyone why they voted the way they had.  (Voters, of course, aren’t up for re-election, and have no obligation to disclose their votes or the reasons that lay behind them.)  Then, when the time came to defend the initiative’s constitutionality under state or federal law, it was not the state or its offices, which are accountable to all the people, but rather the special interest groups, who were in the position to make arguments that could affect not just this case, but also all litigation involving state law.
She argues that there is a strong case to be made, particularly if the Supreme Court has long not take it off the table,  that this is a violation of the Guarantee Clause. This is the little known clause, which was one thing used during the Reconstruction to hold the defeated states in abeyance until they were "republican" enough, that guarantees to "every state in the union" a "republican form of government." Unlike in respect to domestic violence, this is not only upon request. And, the "United States" is involved, which some argue includes the courts independently via judicial review, not just the Congress and the President (and I assume, the courts pursuant to laws and such arising from these actors).  

"Republican" doesn't mean direct democracy, but it is quite debatable just where in the middle we should be. I am quite wary of the process in California, partially on republican grounds, and am open to examining using the clause in federal judicial review. Various questions are in fact at least in part Guarantee Clause in nature, such as the "one person, one vote" issue. For the time being, however, the best check on the federal level at the very least should be careful scrutiny when: 
"prejudice against discrete and insular minorities may be a special condition, which tends seriously to curtail the operation of those political processes ordinarily to be relied upon to protect minorities, and which may call for a correspondingly more searching judicial inquiry." 
Some miss the point, but this is the spirit of the Prop 8 opinion, even if it follows Justice Kennedy's Romer lead in  not expressly using heightened scrutiny. Like Justice O'Connor in Lawrence v. Texas, a somewhat stronger flavor of "rationality" is required in such cases. This is even more so when the legislation is not the product of representative democracy with the clashing views and compromises of that system.  Under that rubric, the California legislature would have passed a same sex marriage law, just as Washington State (yay!) just did.  If allow some form of ballot process, and I'm for a more limited process myself that works with the legislature (e.g., the legislature submits certain things to a vote or is required to address a question), the possibility of majority infringement of minority rights can increase.  Judicial review is a proper check. 

Meanwhile, I appreciate this defense of substantive due process. a concept as cited in this speech by one of its proponents, that has had a long history, even in name. 

Tuesday, February 07, 2012

Prop 8 Unconstitutional

This column notes a bill in Washington State to allow same sex marriage "validates marriages that are performed by someone without the authority to solemnize weddings, as long at least one of the parties had a good faith belief that the officiant did, in fact, have such authority."  The law also replaces religious "denomination" with "organization," and religious organization is defined as "not limited to, churches, mosques, synagogues, temples, nondenominational ministries, interdenominational and ecumenical organizations, mission organizations, faith-based social agencies, and other entities whose principal purpose is the study, practice, or advancement of religion."  Religious liberty to the better. 

The march to SSM equality slowly advances.  Meanwhile, so does the Prop 8 case.  Prop 8 was declared unconstitutional via a 2-1 opinion by Judge Reinhardt.  Those in the know will provide a knowing nod, so I kind of wish the other judge wrote the opinion.  The issue of standing is begun about 1/4 of the way and on that, all three agree, following the lead of the California Supreme Court on the matter.  Some hoped they would punt here, but to me, it is something of a sham to have a system as a way to provide the people a means to amend outside the normal process and allow the officials to nullify the result by inaction.  The state court determined state law gave third parties, not just the governor here, the power to defend Prop 8, and that's the ideal path.

The opinion took a Romer v. Evans approach, so it argued, avoiding deciding the fundamental right to marry or to marry equally without sex discrimination as well as not dealing with the question of suspect classification.  This made it specific to California -- only California gave same sex couples the right to marry and then targeted a minority group by depriving them of an existing right without a legitimate reason.  The fact Prop 8 was narrow, more about the (significant) symbolic value of "marriage" and not incidents like tax benefits, only made the indignity more blatant.  [Cf. to this law that harmed a lot more than same sex "marriages."]  For those who wish to move to another state or might some day want federal "marriage" benefits in a post-DOMA world, it might not even be purely symbolic.  Other examples can be imagined. 

The debate was whether Prop 8 "rationally" or "reasonably" advanced some legitimate state interest.  Heightened scrutiny would have made the other case easier, but also would require a more "activist" opinion.  The limited nature of Prop 8 underlines the little value (unlike more restrictive states) to advance parentage by traditional couples.  Same sex couples have the same right to foster, adopt and raise children. Relatedly, removing same sex marriage rights does nothing to really promote -- again taken it as a given as credible -- "responsible procreation." Next, if the state wanted to "precede with caution," a permanent ban was not the way to do it.*  Anyway, the evidence suggests this isn't a credible explanation of its purpose here.  There also is no religious liberty or protect children from being taught about SSM interest promoted here either.  Bare tradition isn't enough, it being good and bad.  Mere disapproval of gays and lesbians is not enough, said disapproval evidenced by the details particular to the Prop 8 experience. Again, this is not a universal decision. 

The dissent agrees with the issue of standing and Judge Walker's ability, even as a gay man in a relationship, to decide the case.  It agrees it is not about the constitutional right to same sex marriage as such, so Baker v. Nelson doesn't control.  It makes a specific decision on scrutiny: rational basis applies. Why?  The Supreme Court never held; yes, it is an open question.  Also, why isn't this a matter of sex discrimination as well as Judge Walker argued?   Yes, Romer v. Evans involved a broader denial of rights, but the stigma as the majority notes is in a way worse given it is the very point to treat same sex couples as less valuable.  Animus is animus, even if the degree is lesser.  Finally, it says the responsible parenthood rationale is reasonably furthered.  It spends much time defending the interest though; it remains rather unclear how -- in the California context -- how removing "marriage" from same sex couples advances it. 

SSM should be treated using heightened scrutiny, but regardless, using Romer v. Evans analysis, the majority opinion works.  My opinion is that the specific problem is that Prop 8 seems so gratuitous, a fact suggested by an "issue brief" cited here. A pre-existing same sex marriage ban, especially in many states that at best provides some rights to same sex couples, is not the same thing.  If this be "rational basis with teeth," particularly given the clear animus present here, so be it. Justice O'Connor in fact suggested as much in her Lawrence concurrence:
When a law exhibits such a desire to harm a politically unpopular group, we have applied a more searching form of rational basis review to strike down such laws under the Equal Protection Clause.
CLS v. Martinez cited her to show that status/conduct is connected and a majority probably would follow this principle too. Thus, I think this analysis sort of misses the point, taking an artificial "law professor" stance on what state and federal courts up to the USSC has done in practice. To blame lower courts when the USSC hasn't been totally aboveboard is bad pool too, especially (by someone who I usually find reasonable, even with his conservative policy views on certain subjects)  if you do so sloppily. The court's logic might if taken to its logical conclusion be taken much further, but it is narrowly applied here.  This is how the law develops, including in the courts.  As with the GPS ruling and Orin Kerr's criticism over at Volokh Conspiracy, it might be a bit messy, but life is messy.**  And, if Kennedy is coy (or is "lying" as suggested by a comment in the last link), some lower court ruling, surely not Reinhardt from the Ninth freaking Circuit doesn't have the clout call him out. 

Judicial restraint without judicial blindness.  To be continued, for sure.

---

* Compare this to Hawaii in the 1990s where the legislature was given the flexibility to allow same sex marriages.  As I note here, this is but one possible difference, underlining each state must be treated on its own.

** I find the analysis by the first three conspirators on this subject rather questionable, especially Prof. Kerr's "gist" that the majority opinion said that Prop 8 didn't actually do anything.  Various law professor types (see the previous link in that paragraph, including a follow-up post)  are simply confused on basic details.  Another "seems" to think that the opinion thinks a state cannot change its constitution to clarify what its supreme court ruled.  No, the issue is that it cannot do this in a way that wrongly burdens a particular group of people.  Why is this so hard?  

Update: Thank you Marty Lederman, but again, why no comments?

This Guy Should Not Be A Role Model

Monday, February 06, 2012

Girls on The Run

One of the talking heads tweeted about taking her daughter to this organization.  Sounds great.

A Win Involves Lots of Things

The safety, e.g., gave them a safety valve and a great catch not only continued the drive but led to a failed challenge that cost the Pats precious time -- with the time, they would have two time outs and a real shot for a winning drive. As is, they came a bit too close.

Sunday, February 05, 2012

"A More Perfect Military"



We the people of the United States, in order to form a more perfect union, establish justice, insure domestic tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.
The most recent book on the side panel -- by a vet / law professor -- suggests that treating the military more like everyone else, particularly in respect to constitutional restraints, will "make our military stronger."

She argues that a key problem was a post-Vietnam policy, led by Justice Rehnquist to provide judicial discretion at the "apogee" in military matters.  The irony being in that very case (involving draft of women) that Congress went against military desire (as it did in the FAIR case*), so the discretion often is more political or an ill advised trust of the military hierarchy as shown in the DADT context.  Other times, the military wasn't even the main problem, torture being against traditional military rules and not asking to head combatant status tribunals making decisions as political as they are military in various respects. 

The "otherness" of the military, the problem already growing with the end of the draft, which also leads to a noticeably more conservative (politically speaking) military, is promoted as their due.  Consider the 2000 elections, when oversea "military" votes (in fact, the rules applied to oversea votes generally) were thought to be miscounted.  The author argues in fact, if anything, some unknown numbers of members of the military gamed the system to affect the election by voting late.  But, this one group was given special dispensation, bending the rules because their votes apparently were more important. George III was deemed a tyrant for deigning "to render the Military independent of and superior to the Civil Power."  We are to think it par for the course.

The book is well argued by someone passionate about the subject, but did not really talk enough about the pre-Vietnam period to give a complete sense of how things truly changed.  What of the Japanese Internment Cases where the military received a bit too much discretion?  She even undersold the possible dissent possible in a few cases, including a case that Justice Stewart -- not exactly known to be a passionate dissenter -- singled out to read a strong dissent from the bench. This might be a matter of space, the book coming out to two hundred pages plus notes, but it is a bit problematic.  But, she makes her case of the problems with the current situation either way and it is well worth reading. 

Her three recommendations: (1) excessive judicial deference can undermine the military by denying it an important check (2) military advice should be taken carefully with a grain of salt but  not ignored when correct but politically incorrect and (3) a diverse military must be our goal, a national civil service plan ideal, but if not, some other sort of flexibility (such as short term tours by various types of individuals) must be used for it truly to thrive.

---

* She thinks, the at times snide 8-0 loss (overturning the lower court, no not the Ninth Circuit) notwithstanding, the law schools had a good case, but its strong position was still ill-advised.  Nor would the JAG corps or the military effort as a whole fall apart if the law schools that joined the protest would be allowed to go their own way.  Each could bend a little. 

I agree -- it is better to welcome the recruiters in, voicing opposition to their policy, but trying to change things all the same. A misguided military group amicus brief notwithstanding, the military as a whole realized the "all or nothing" policy was counterproductive, the law schools sentiments not stopping the schools as a whole providing services to the military.  

Another 4Q Comeback

Brady scored 14 points in the middle, but Eli (more easily) came back after his team chipped away.  Brady had about forty more seconds at the end, making it more interesting, but similar result -- 21-17. 

Halftime -- Tiresome

The NYG had the upper hand for much of the 1H, but not enough to actually score much.  Pats finally have a good TD drive.  Giants losing 10-9.  I find this business tiresome.  Giants losing 7-3 last time. 

Women's Health x 2

Taking things at face value is often not the best policy. A leading breast cancer association's decision to defund Planned Parenthood for the allegedly neutral reason of it being under investigation is a case in point. First, we learn the connections to Palin among other red flags.  Then:

An internal Komen memo written by President Elizabeth Thompson and obtained by Jeffrey Goldberg of The Atlantic states that if "an applicant or its affiliates" is under investigation "for financial or administrative improprieties by local, state or federal authorities," then "the applicant will be ineligible to receive a grant." Penn State, the Pennsylvania university that the Hershey center is affiliated with, is currently under investigation by the federal government over the sexual assault scandal involving former assistant coach Jerry Sandusky, who has been indicted on multiple counts of sexual abuse of children. In 2008, the Komen foundation awarded a five-year, $7.5 million grant to the Hershey center to study treatments that could reduce the risk of breast cancer.
This is far from surprising since the fact something or someone is under "investigation" can mean any number of things and even if you just assume guilty until proven innocent, it is hard to apply such a rule to everyone.  Suddenly, you will determine "this is different."  On the other hand, if you are just looking for reasons to target, a ready made "neutral" excuse can be found.  Those looking for an out can find one.
Under President Barack Obama’s health care overhaul law, most employers and insurance plans will have to cover birth control free of charge as preventive care for women. Churches and houses of worship do not have to follow that requirement, but administration officials recently announced that many religious-affiliated institutions such as hospitals, colleges and charities must comply after a year’s phase-in period.


Chris Hayes,* who I'm liking in particular among the many progressive talking heads (btw, Keith seems to be out a lot), talked about this and other issues this morning.  One issue raised was the matter I raised last week concerning new rules regarding birth control, just one of many aspects of that oh so lame (according to some) PPACA law that might help lots of people. Washington Post had a good article on the new policy, providing some important details, including something I don't think Hayes was careful enough to underline -- the exemptions even for the Catholic Church, who was out on the ramparts (statements at mass) railing at the injustice of it all.  The exception:

That rule, however, exempted houses of worship and their employees, as well as other institutions whose primary purpose is to promote religious belief. Churches, synagogues, mosques and other places would not be required to cover contraceptives, it specified. Neither would religious organizations whose purpose is to promote belief, and that primarily employ and serve people of the same creed.
The horror of it all.  I don't know what exactly "promote religious belief" means, but that sounds like even Catholic schools would be covered though that was the big issue in the NYT article I talked about concerning state requirements.  I think abortion is a matter of health care too, but under Hyde and so forth, it is excepted from the rules given strong societal opposition in some quarters.  And, not just at those institutions morally opposed.  The problem with lines was raised on the show and the designed conservative basically admitted he couldn't deny problematic cases can be raised.  A cop-out.  Are Catholics special?  Well, yes, numbers-wise and all.  As Scalia noted:

It may fairly be said that leaving accommodation to the political process will place at a relative disadvantage those religious practices that are not widely engaged in; but that unavoidable consequence of democratic government
The ruling also underlines neutral requirements that might negative affect certain religious institutions (another recent case made an exception for institutional membership decision-making) are allowed.  Just how far are we to go here?  Any number of health requirements might be opposed by any number of religious faiths on some grounds.  These institutions might run institutions that involve many members of other faiths. The article also notes that the regulations don't even go into effect until mid-2013, the employees benefits kicking in at the beginning of 2014. And, "secular enterprises from profit-making companies" will provide "access" to workers at the beginning of 2013. Sounds like the religious organizations are being given some real respectful treatment here. 

One panel member on Hayes show noted this is a reason for health insurance to be separate from employers, which many say is good policy overall.  But,  what about the student on campus whose best health option is the campus health care center?  And, we are a long way from separating health care from employment.  So, we have some sister being real upset that the rules are "telling the church what it has to buy," but such are the breaks -- that is what regulating health care does.  Duly noted you want to deprive even people outside of churches and the like of basic health care here. With government involvement comes strings.
At issue is a provision of the health care law that requires insurance plans to cover preventive care for women free of charge to the employee. Last year, an advisory panel from the respected Institute of Medicine recommended including birth control on the list, partly because it promotes maternal and child health by allowing women to space their pregnancies.
Birth control is but part of a set of proposals the panel -- last year -- set forth that are part of a reasonable approach to health care. And, it is unclear if it is the only possible red flag. There is a mention of HPV testing, though only for those over thirty.  What if that is tweaked to include some option for teenagers? The HPV vaccine was a major controversy for some religious conservatives.  What about "counseling on sexually transmitted infections" -- should that only be allowed for those over eighteen?  Can't encourage sexual activity!  Will screening for domestic violence in some cases violate the man's role over the family? 

On the issue of morning after pills, I wavered on the proper rules, particularly in those areas with diverse providers. So, I respect the arguments for religious freedom here, but even in that area, there were problems.  Lest we forget the infamous Lieberman stance on women who were raped easily having the ability to travel after being denial Plan B at the Catholic hospital to which they are first taken.  But, some balance is being used here, including additional time to arrange the best policy for the Fordham University health center type situation. If health care is going to be employer based, there has to be a balance.

The Catholic Church is too entwined with the weeds to claim purity here.  Again, to me, this is a moronic thing to draw the line in the sand for, especially with the special graces provided.

---

* Hayes added some further links to today's show here. This includes a link to the White House blog that warrants an extended citation.  As with ending "Don't Ask Don't Tell," this matter ALONE is a significant reason to be glad Obama is President rather than Mitt Romney, who opposes both. 
  • Churches are exempt from the new rules: Churches and other houses of worship will be exempt from the requirement to offer insurance that covers contraception.
  • No individual health care provider will be forced to prescribe contraception: The President and this Administration have previously and continue to express strong support for existing conscience protections.  For example, no Catholic doctor is forced to write a prescription for contraception. 
  •  No individual will be forced to buy or use contraception: This rule only applies to what insurance companies cover.  Under this policy, women who want contraception will have access to it through their insurance without paying a co-pay or deductible.   But no one will be forced to buy or use contraception.
  • Drugs that cause abortion are not covered by this policy:  Drugs like RU486 are not covered by this policy, and nothing about this policy changes the President’s firm commitment to maintaining strict limitations on Federal funding for abortions. No Federal tax dollars are used for elective abortions.
  • Over half of Americans already live in the 28 States that require insurance companies cover contraception: Several of these States like North Carolina, New York, and California have identical religious employer exemptions.  Some States like Colorado, Georgia and Wisconsin have no exemption at all.
  • Contraception is used by most women: According to a study by the Guttmacher Institute, most women, including 98 percent of Catholic women, have used contraception.
  • Contraception coverage reduces costs: While the monthly cost of contraception for women ranges from $30 to $50, insurers and experts agree that savings more than offset the cost.  The National Business Group on Health estimated that it would cost employers 15 to 17 percent more not to provide contraceptive coverage than to provide such coverage, after accounting for both the direct medical costs of potentially unintended and unhealthy pregnancy and indirect costs such as employee absence and reduced productivity.
Thank you, Cecilia Muñoz, Director of the Domestic Policy Council.

Saturday, February 04, 2012

Anne of the Thousand Days

Church and state with sexual politics mixed in had more bite in the 16th Century. This was a pretty good film with Geneviève Bujold the prime attraction though her sudden love for Henry is rather abrupt. The first half is the best. Film history is always somewhat mixed.

Friday, February 03, 2012

Komen Sorta Backtracks On Planned Parenthood

Guarded optimism for a breast cancer group somewhat stepping back from its decision to stop future funding because of "investigation" by anti-choice forces in Congress. This heckler veto was strongly rejected, protests having some quick results. Ever vigilant.

Thursday, February 02, 2012

Rerun

Not a fan of the Super Bowl rerun, especially when losing to the Pats would be particularly annoying. And, too many people are saying the NYG are a lock, though the betting line disagrees. Bad karma there.

Vaclav Havel on "Democratic values"

Liberty in the constitutional sense must mean more than freedom from unlawful governmental restraint; it must include privacy as well, if it is to be a repository of freedom. The right to be let alone is indeed the beginning of all freedom.

-- Justice Douglas
Justice Goldberg also cited Douglas in another opinion regarding "from experience with the requirements of a free society" being a test to determine if a Ninth Amendment liberty is in question. Justice Harlan also provided a well cited dissent (like Brandeis' Olmstead dissent, now effectively the established view) that included something similar to determine what is "implicit in the concept of ordered liberty." All promoted privacy interests and took the motto that a page of history is helpful in determining what constitutional liberty entails.

Slavery is a way to determine what "liberty" entails as does looking to countries we have determined provide a contrast to our system. Thus, the words of Vaclav Havel are helpful:
Democratic values constitute the foundation of the state.
The freedom of thought, conscience, and religious conviction is guaranteed.
The inviolability of the person and of her privacy is guaranteed.
A person’s dwelling is inviolable. It may not be entered without the permission of the person living there.
Only a law may designate which acts constitute a crime.
Censorship is not permitted.
Everyone who suffers from material need has the right to such assistance as is necessary to ensure her a basic living standard.
Everyone has the right to the protection of her health.
Everyone has the right to education.
Everyone has the right to demand that her human dignity be respected.
"Democratic" is not a partisan label in this context though it arguably could be how things are these days.

Right to Work Coverage

Rachel Maddow last night spent about ten minutes rambling about how she liked a certain radio show and (eventually) how it aired some anti-immigrant legislation satire that included references to voluntarily leaving the country that (eventually) was attached to something Mitt Romney is saying. It was definitely something warranting editing, not just a bit of self-indulgence that is more filler than substance. I find this occurring too often (if not this badly) in segments that already have a limited amount of time to cover the subject matter.

Again and again, I am left annoyed that stuff isn't being covered. For instance, repeatedly, a reader/viewer (fine, this reader/viewer) did not get a real sense of what exactly SOPA does that bothers people. Instead, we get a lot of commentary and political theater (talk about how people opposed SOPA, seeing it as a threat, but I still didn't quite understand why exactly) and general comments. So, Rachel Maddow notes the irony of anti-union legislation being passed in the state that will provide the field for the Super Bowl (remember, sports are unionized) and reports in general about efforts to pass such legislation and opposition to it, but what exactly does the legislation entail? Details!

The issue here is "right-to-work" legislation, a nice bit of framing. A bit of history, including a 1947 federal law that deals with political contributions (sorta relevant these days) which "allowed states to prohibit unions from collecting fees from non-members or making membership mandatory," would be very helpful here. It is particularly important in Indiana since it is a type of swing state, one that "straddles the union and non-union regions of the country, a buffer between the country's unionized northern block and anti-union South and West." Instead of spending ten minutes rambling about Mitt Romney, perhaps a segment could be included to discuss such details, including how unions are harmed when free riders are helped by union efforts that they need not pay for. Shades of the health insurance debate?

And, one claim made is that these laws are economically valuable to the state. True or not? Is the debatable value there superseded by the importance of not weakening unions or perhaps some other factor? It would be helpful if Rachel Maddow and others do more to address these issues, though the link underlines that some are doing the heavy lifting. It is appreciated that RW brings to the forefront various issues that deserve to be out there but necessary context is sometimes lacking. This and the rather predictable nature of the coverage (good sources sometimes surprise you, everything rarely black/white) is a major problem in news commentary today. MSNBC/Current/Democracy Now! all have this problem from my experience. Chris Hayes, helped by having at least one dissenting voice on board, seems to do a somewhat better job at times. Other sources might too.

But, if at times coming at things from different directions (liberal, conservative, allegedly neutral etc.), sources all over are too incomplete.

Clyde

Another family member (not me) gets a cat. They are taking over.

Wednesday, February 01, 2012

Death Comes To Pemberley

P.D. James provides something of a bland account, with only Darcy having much presence, of a mystery in the world of Pride & Prejudice. The two allusions to later novels are amusing but wrong as a matter of dating. Disappointing if okay addition to pseudo-Austen universe.

"Thank you so much"

A favorite line of the faux Southern gal on The Closer, Gingrich's daughter ended her appearance on MSNBC last night with a real Southern version. Not sure if she meant it as a "fu" as Brenda Leigh sometimes does. She's from the first wife. Let's draw this thing out!

Pro Bowl

I missed the game, shame, but I finally checked the score -- 100 points, AFC winning by 18. Here I thought the AFC was something of an underdog. Won 4Q. Newbie Newton threw three interceptions.

Tuesday, January 31, 2012

PPACA In Action



My recent birth control discussion is connected to new rules pursuant to the PPACA requiring it to be part of health insurance plans. Another discussion, accepted by two who oppose the "mandate" on policy grounds, provided in depth discussion on the fiction of the "novelty" of the inaction/action distinction.  An opponent again wrongly noted that everyone who resides in the U.S. is covered by the requirement.  The official Maddow blog also flags an account that shows the good things that have occurred thanks to the law:
The health care law (1) is combating fraud and abuse, which in turns saves Americans quite a bit of money; (2) has brought coverage to 2.5 million young adults; (3) is delivering major savings to seniors on prescription drugs; (4) is giving a boost to small businesses through ACA tax credits; (5) has slowed the growth of Medicare spending; (6) has provided new treatment options for cancer patients; and (7) has offered new coverage protections for those with pre-existing conditions.
This is but an incomplete listing of things now in practice, more due to kick in eventually, including the actual "mandate," which even if it was struck down could be replaced before it was due to kick in. An extended debate is possible there, since it is due to begin in 2014, and then only the first installment.  I continue to find those who belittle what was done here because political realities made a better law unlikely at best woefully misguided.  Push all you want, but realize the good that was done too.

Tax season

Tax season begins and NY has a new "mandate" for those who use "software" (a bit vague as to if use of fill-in forms on the state website counts there) and have broadband internet service -- e-filing. The more simpler two page form is also no more.  Tedious business.

Monday, January 30, 2012

"Ruling on Contraception Draws Battle Lines at Catholic Colleges"


The Obama administration relied on the recommendations of the Institute of Medicine, an independent group of doctors and researchers that concluded that birth control is not just a convenience but is medically necessary “to ensure women’s health and well-being.”
-- "Ruling on Contraception Draws Battle Lines at Catholic Colleges"

It is striking that birth control is in 2012 a dividing line. The leading Republican presidential nominees support "personhood amendments" that would declare fertilized eggs "persons" with legal and constitutional rights of unclear breadth.  I have spoken about the absurdity of this, something even voters in Mississippi agreed with, and it is [insert adjective here] that this is a major issue.  The fact that one side realizes that this is not merely a matter of personal choice and is quite different from abortion is appreciated and draws a line in the sand.

The Catholic Church is woefully misguided on this question and many who are deeply observant are well aware of the fact, have been since its tragic decision to reject proposed reforms in the 1960s.  This is not a matter of saying pregnancy is just a "disease" or about not respecting life.  It is about reality and reality is that the perfect can be the enemy of the good, akin to not lying to kidnappers.  
Some Georgetown professors question the wisdom of the university’s current policy. “I wish Catholic institutions would have more open conversation about how bans on birth control can increase abortion rates among students,” said Robin L. West, a law school professor. “Both are contrary to Catholic teaching, but abortion as I understand it is the graver of the sins, and certainly the greater injury to the fetus and the woman.”
The article, however, notes that when the matter was discussed in one forum, a head in the sand approach was followed. I am particularly supportive of the woman who organized a one day clinic after the health clinic at the  law school at Fordham University  would not prescribe her birth control pills.  I like her was "raised a Catholic and was educated at parochial schools," this sort of b.s. not focused upon.  In fact, to the surprise of my mother, a teacher noted that evolution is accepted doctrine. Apples and oranges?  I think not -- their position on birth control is as nefarious as creation science, more so in many ways. 

Fordham University (I passed the college just last night) isn't what many would think of as a Roman Catholic institution, at least one which would be so strict as not to prescribe birth control to law students.  I myself find too many Catholic doctrines misguided, but respect the religion as a whole in various respects too much not to be disappointed that contraceptives is treated like this.  But, the religion has just too many issues with sex and related issues to be surprised really. 

Anyway, harder questions about discrimination laws as applied to teachers and so forth, when students cannot get prescriptions in this fashion, some line has been crossed.  To make THIS a religious freedom issue is misguided in the extreme people.  If you want to follow this counterproductive doctrine, okay, but the Administration is correct.  Contraceptives are a matter of health, not just doctrine.  Cases like this underline the need for some sanity and if leading Republican presidential nominees refuse to be sane on the matter, they should not be taken seriously as credible candidates. Contraceptives should not be a Republican issue.  Serious Republicans realize this. 

As do quite a few serious Catholics.  Even some who would accept to some extent Catholic bigotry (insert nicer word here) on homosexuals draw a line here.  Including many with less children than necessary to draw up a baseball team. 

Saturday, January 28, 2012

What's Wrong With CU?



Citizens United is the new Lochner, a somewhat misused symbol for the times.  A discussion raised an important point (Monica Youn) that I have made myself -- people might not be focusing on the right thing, even if they are on the whole correct (shades of Lochner, sorry David Bernstein*)  to be wary about the whole thing.  Ms Youn opposes the cocksure nature of the opinion ("remiss in performing its duties" if they didn't take the case then and there etc.), particularly on this:

[W]e now conclude that independent expenditures, including those made by corporations, do not give rise to corruption or the appearance of corruption.
That is the money, if I may, quote.  Not only, as noted shortly above that legal conclusion (that pitcher didn't have a perfect game ... it sure looks like he got that 27th out, but the umpire didn't call it, so he officially does not), the "anticorruption interest is not sufficient to displace the speech here in question."  This would be strongly opposed by many, not limited to the majorities in state (the opinion notes twenty-six restricts the expenditures addressed here, using the figure to show the "limited" concern in place) and federal legislatures passing laws with this in mind.  This is so even if -- like many things -- you can't "prove" it in a court of law or such.  But, to not even be there at all?  Really now.

I continuously note, and Ms Youn calls out to Congress et. al. to do what they still can, that the opinion leaves open regulation.  But, as she notes, if it doesn't "give rise to corruption," what is the explanation for banning non-citizens to contribute here, particularly for certain subjects like US-Cuban policy in the upcoming Florida primary?  What is the point of disclosure law anyway if there is no real concern for corruption or its appearance?  It contributes information, sure, but why? It is a "less restrictive alternative," but it is a burden and to some degree limits associational privacy (see Thomas' partial dissent).

Scalia is more blunt and sees it as a necessary evil, just as speech hurts people's feelings and promotes nefarious ideas that has real harm:
It cannot be denied, however, that corporate (like noncorporate) allies will have greater access to the officeholder, and that he will tend to favor the same causes as those who support him (which is usually why they supported him). That is the nature of politics—if not indeed human nature
If this be "corruption," it simply is not the sort that the First Amendment allows to be barred by this method.  By his lights.  We hear of the power of the well off individuals controlling elections, but there is nothing novel about this. Chris Hayes this morning as much as another contributor on the panel I linked to above cited the billionaire (not a corporation) who is a if not the primary reason Newt Gingrich still has funds, but did rich individuals not do the same in the past, if in some different fashion? And, are we actually upset about it here?  People on my side LOVE the fact he is out there railing against Romney, providing an entertaining as well as educational means to challenge the presumptive nominee who otherwise would have much weaker opposition.  We rather a different conduit, but any port in the storm, if the real alternative in nothing much. 

Still, regulation in this area is valid and corruption and the appearance of corruption is a major reason why.  This cannot override First Amendment protections and even the dissent knows as much, supporting limited means, means that do not simply give no protections to "corporations."  The path to the right destination, however, is not to be taken under misguided assumptions on either side.  The majority is correct to respect First Amendment values, even when corporate spending is at stake, but getting there the wrong way still has problems. 

Life is complicated. 

---

* In a new book, promoted at the blog he contributes to -- Volokh Conspiracy (fix the comment issue, please!) -- is promoted by him at times as a means to address stereotypes concerning Lochner v. NY, not some sort of substantive defense of its result.  That is, he puts himself out there as some sort of agnostic on the opinion while just concerned with opposing the stereotype of its opponents then and now. 

This isn't credible given his overall approach, down to the very title of the book: Rehabilitating Lochner: Defending Individual Rights against Progressive Reform.  Fact is, he is a libertarian and shares the overall sentiments of the opinion, though its authors did a lot less at the time for non-economic rights than he would.

The fact the criticism is off doesn't mean it is totally wrong and we should not miss the forest for the trees though if you miss a tree, it can be a problem.  Just ask those who drive into one.  The result is not pretty. 

Jane By Design

This new show about a teenager with a secret life as a Devil Wears Prada like assistant is a bit like a somewhat more mature True Jackson V.P.  It is a pretty good bit of wish fulfillment/teen angst, some pretty nice aspects if the usual bit too pretty boy characters.

The Closer

I am about caught up now, watching the sixth season, seeing the origins of a major subplot from latest one.  Started great with a new building and some amusing material, some familiar faces from current shows popping up along the way. Slips a bit mid-season.

Thursday, January 26, 2012

Twenty Anniversary of Casey Preview



In honor of the 39th anniversary of Roe v. Wade, I listened to some abortion oral arguments, including Roe, Webster and Planned Parenthood v. Casey.  The latter of interesting for various reasons, including the website in question (not SCOTUS itself, which only goes back to last term; why not guys and gals?) includes the opinion announcement, including the Chief Justice reading a summary of his dissent.  Each justice but Thomas (though he asked questions back then) asked questions as well, so we got a bit of everything. 

The strategy of the Planned Parenthood attorney was to defend the strict scrutiny rule, not defend what she could under the somewhat lower protection that would remain from Webster. The appellate court determined the balance of the opinions there was an "undue burden" standard, rightly judging the ultimate ruling down to striking down (with Judge Alito dissenting) a spousal notification rule.  Kenneth Starr was on board to counsel the overturning of Roe and the state to whatever was necessary to uphold the law in its entirety.

The oral argument therefore started with a strange thing -- about seven minutes of the attorney talking about precedent alone, not the specifics of the Casey case itself.  Her strategy, especially with an upcoming election season, was a calculated risk and somewhat reasonable, since after all the law had stuff (waiting period and controversial informed consent) that the Supreme Court struck down already in two rulings less than a decade before.  The "informed" parental consent law was likely to be upheld, given parental consent was upheld with a bypass already, and was 8-1 (Blackmun, the sole justice left who voted against single parent consent laws, noting it was somewhat more intrusive than the ones upheld).  The spousal notification law was likely doomed too, since it had a paternalistic taint. The remaining medical emergency and record-keeping (even Blackmun accepted one of these) also were either of little importance or likely to be upheld.

There was a real chance too of Roe being totally overruled or a low level reasonableness test (which received three votes in Webster, Thomas providing a likely fourth; who knew about Souter?)  be put in place that would allow a slew of regulations.  Starr didn't want to go there, but could only say there would at least have to be a "life" exception.  No justice said as much, but the law at stake in Roe didn't have a rape exception.  Starr also basically bs-ed and said that the lower standard was reasonable since the right in question was novel.  As the ultimate plurality opinion noted, it surely was not -- both as a matter of choice in family life and as a matter of bodily integrity, it fit into a line of cases.  Each case had its own wrinkle, some including third parties, such as educating children or sex lives that are not ultimately limited to the two people in question. 


Rehnquist in dissent noted the difference (not anyone except White would have been a fan of the Griswold line generally) was the potential human life.  I suggest he ask Roman Catholics who oppose barrier birth control about that. And, why is potential human life a game changer given the breadth of the interest, including when cases protected privacy against things such as convicting alleged felons?  Past cases underlined that such questions of private morality could not do the trick, but again, except for White, they weren't a big fan of many of the cases anyways.  As to Scalia's appeal to tradition, various cases upheld the right to do things traditionally deemed illegal, down to purchase of contraceptives. After all, there was a federal law against sending them through the mails in place for years. 

The strategy was problematic because it made it harder to provide a true answer to provisions even under an intermediate test such as "undue burden." Gender discrimination, for instance, is looked upon with disfavor, even though it is not seen as problematic as race or when fundamental rights are at stake.  And, the spousal notification law fell on that ground alone.  As the opinions made clear more than previously, abortion as a whole is a matter of gender equality.  The "informed consent" aspect had First Amendment problems, particularly when applied (as O'Connor noted) to private parties like the women themselves.  It was coerced speech, though -- as the plurality noted -- the rules are looser there when it is a matter of professional regulations, especially if the material in question is "truthful" and not "misleading."

The PP lawyer in summary fashion spoke of the "biased" counselling and the problem of requiring some of it in certain situations (though information on the requirements of father could be omitted for rape victims, though that would require saying you are raped).  For instance, a previous ruling struck down a requirement concerning "the unborn child is a human life from the moment of conception," which is is more ideological than "truthful" per se.  The lower court here noted, however, that the law here* "is not an attempt to prescribe an orthodoxy in matters of opinion, and the information involved is reasonably related to the state's interest in ensuring that women have relevant information before having an abortion."  Justice Stevens noted separately here:
The counseling provisions are similarly infirm. Whenever government commands private citizens to speak or to listen, careful review of the justification for that command is particularly appropriate. In this case, the Pennsylvania statute directs that counselors provide women seeking abortions with information concerning alternatives to abortion, the availability of medical assistance benefits, and the possibility of child support payments. §§ 3205(a)(2)(i) (iii). The statute requires that this information be given to all women seeking abortions, including those for whom such information is clearly useless, such as those who are married, those who have undergone the procedure in the past and are fully aware of the options, and those who are fully convinced that abortion is their only reasonable option. Moreover, the statute requires physicians to inform all of their patients of "the probable gestational age of the unborn child." § 3205(a)(1)(ii). This information is of little decisional value in most cases, because 90% of all abortions are performed during the first trimester [n.7] when fetal age has less relevance than when the fetus nears viability. Nor can the information required by the statute be justified as relevant to any "philosophic" or "social" argument, ante, at 30, either favoring or disfavoring the abortion decision in a particular case. In light of all of these facts, I conclude that the information requirements in § 3205(a)(1)(ii) and §§ 3205(a)(2)(i) (iii) do not serve a useful purpose and thus constitute an unnecessary--and therefore undue--burden on the woman's constitutional liberty to decide to terminate her pregnancy.

It might be a close case here, but are some cases where the "informed consent" rules would be problematic under the First Amendment.  Stevens also thought they were unconstitutional here under an "undue burden" test for the right to choose an abortion.  The waiting period rule also can be challenged on "undue burden" grounds, especially under various fact situations.  Stevens/Blackmun challenged the basic principle, since it presupposed the woman could not choose on her own to decide whether or not to have an abortion without more time.  This was a problem both on due process grounds and the equality principle to the extent it was targeted to women particularly.

The rejoinder would be that something fundamental was at stake -- the potential life -- but an additional problem on the other side is that for many locations, if you have to wait a day, it will be more than a day.  And, it might be hard and expensive (a matter of equality though wealth discrimination is generally acceptable to the USSC except in limited cases like getting a lawyer) to get to that clinic or hospital, in a few cases the only one in the state, even once.  The plurality opinion left it open in particularly burdensome cases that a waiting period might not be acceptable.  A few lower cases took that opening while others did not, especially when the law allowed counseling to be done over the phone, which should be quite possible in the age of the Internet more so today. 

In general, it along with "informed consent" was deemed a way to ensure the woman is fully informed and had time to think about the decision in question.  This has some logic though again the application can be problematic in various respects.  Some rule for abortion providers to be required to inform the client in a comprensive way is appropriate, since they are not all on the side of angels but are there to make money providing a particular service (though many providers are comprehensive), but also they should be able to have discretion to fit the counseling to the individual patient.  Without forced ultrasounds or talk of "unborn children."  These days of detailed warning labels and stock jury charges, flexibility is at times frowned upon, but abortion is particularly (wrongly) singled out in the health area. 

As with the gun laws in question in another set of controversial cases, however, the specifics of the matter was not given as much time as might be appropriate.  The justices were not free from blame here -- Kennedy and O'Connor was annoyed at the PP lawyer for her strategy, but nothing stopped them from asking her specific questions to force her to change gears.  Counsel is often given hypos that ask them to assume things they rather not assume and she could have been asked to defend (if possible) her side under an undue burden test.  Her basic sentiment appeared to suggest that they realized that would be a loss as a whole, which might be true to some extent, but as shown by the opinions, not totally so.  After all, the plurality spoke of "truthful" consent -- what about ideological or arguably misleading materials? The state attorney was asked about the coerced speech test and O'Connor was annoyed when the lawyer brought up a case involving advertising.

Casey as a whole is a good ruling in that it upheld the right to choose an abortion and provided a defense that is more comprehensive than in place under Roe. The lower level of scrutiny is problematic but generally workable if applied correctly.  Of course, the problem with a looser standard is that it won't always be.  The "trimester" scheme of Roe was replaced, but changing medical realities made it somewhat outdated as to safety (abortion much safer even into the second trimester) and as long as it did not override health concerns, some state recognition of the embryo/fetus is present throughout the pregnancy. Under Roe, that by itself could not be the purpose of a regulation until after viability, but it could be in cases of funding.  This in reality is a more serious burden than talk of "unborn children" during any abortion, even if that is problematic on its own.  Not being able to have an abortion at all because Medicaid doesn't pay for one remains much more of an "undue burden."  And, the basic message that unborn life has value is a major concern here. Some ways it is shown is problematic, but it's acceptable to take that into consideration before viability.

Interesting listening and reading, the issues will continue on for thirty nine more years and beyond.

---

* The informed consent law here [Stevens and Blackmun split on what exactly was problematic]  is relatively mild though some of the written materials that must be provided on request might be problematic upon inspection, at times providing factual details that providers here might deem (correctly or not) untrue as well as containing various ideological content that they wish not to provide. For instance, would a wedding provider have to provide material counseling that divorce is sinful and providing a questionable parade of horribles as part of a "full disclosure" law.   The relevant section providing information on  alternatives:
(i) The department publishes printed materials which describe the unborn child and list agencies which offer alternatives to abortion and that she has a right to review the printed materials and that a copy will be provided to her free of charge if she chooses to review it.


"(ii) Medical assistance benefits may be available for prenatal care, childbirth and neonatal care, and that more detailed information on the availability of such assistance is contained in the printed materials published by the department.


"(iii) The father of the unborn child is liable to assist in the support of her child, even in instances where he has offered to pay for the abortion. In the case of rape, this information may be omitted.
As Blackmun notes, the way this is required to be provided can be an issue too, such as some sort of forced slanted film or requiring people to watch an abortion being done.  Again, the very term "unborn child" is a red flag for various people; does that specific term have to be used? 

Obama Quickies



SOTU: Didn't listen -- not big on speeches and economic stuff depresses me these days. But, the actual alternative is not a strong progressive, but tools. Meanwhile, Obama and the Democrats brought significant things for gays, health care, getting rid of Osama, etc.  (trial? be nice ... so would a NY v. NY Superbowl).  Overall, I'll take it.  Net, he did more than Clinton without being a butthead.  Meanwhile, the Supreme Court presence:  Elena Kagan,  Stephen Breyer, Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Anthony Kennedy and Chief Justice John Roberts.

Jan Brewer Gets Miffed: Gov. Brewer and Obama had a bit of an exchange. She should be appreciative since he after all basically gave her the job, she getting a promotion after Obama took on the previous governor for Homeland Security. Curiously, I never hear this mentioned.

Meanwhile, very emotional day at Congress with Rep. Giffords retiring, her friend (and glad to have her on the party's side) reading her retirement letter with great emotion.  The humanity of the situation is there either way, but it's particularly so when it truly seems she is a nice person and one of the rising political stars who could (will) do this nation a service. 

Wednesday, January 25, 2012

Dr. Pepper Ten

Who, I wonder, thought up this thing?  Hey, men, it's too fattening for women -- it's 10 calories!  An alternative to light beer, perhaps?