About Me

My photo
This blog is the work of an educated civilian, not of an expert in the fields discussed.

Friday, August 06, 2021

SCOTUS Watch (and other stuff)


Cuomo Update: In a move opposed by my senator, the NY Assembly gave Cuomo a week to respond to the AG report.   I rather them just get on with it, but don't know if a short delay matters much as a whole.  The clock is ticking all the same -- for instance, the impeachment process requires a month delay after the impeachment itself is submitted.  One interesting wrinkle is that during a trial Cuomo would have to aside. 
There is some support in ending the practice of a general Supreme Court recess from July to September (with emergency exceptions popping up over the years). It might be better if the Court used the time to more publicly (as some justices over the years do small scale, such as overseas talks and such) to promote legal understanding and other things.

The Supreme Court is not totally off. We do have summer orders. And, individuals members deal requests to them in their lesser known role as heads of individual circuits. Sometimes, since it only pops up on case pages buried inside the website, actions like Breyer's rejecting a request in a Big V case are less apparent. It might be useful if the public was aware of such cases, repeating my support for FAQs on basic procedures.

Others are more apparent (showing up on the Orders Page), like Roberts asking for a reply. The case, per the request, involves a claim that "Puma Biotechnology defamed Dr. Fredric Eshelman by falsely accusing him of fraud and being replaced as CEO of the company he founded as a result." Roberts temporarily held up the decision below, response due by 8/11.

===

I follow Senate Periodicals on Twitter to keep a track of Senate actions. As the Senate works on the bipartisan portion of Infrastructure Week, this was noted Thursday night:

By a vote of 50-49, the Senate INVOKED Cloture on Executive Calendar #250, Eunice C. Lee to be U.S. Circuit Judge for the Second Circuit.

[She was confirmed on Saturday, 50-47.]

President Biden also announced a "sixth" round of judicial nominees, highlighting again the diversity involved.  

Eunice C. Lee is of that caliber: she is a black woman with a legal aid background, the latter notably true for multiple nominees (judges are much more likely to have prosecutor backgrounds).  Note that after filibustering Obama nominees was taken to a certain level (aggravating a back/forth in place since at least the 1990s), that was gone for executive nominees.

Nonetheless, there has to be a majority cloture vote all the same, part of the usual pace of legislative action at least in the Senate.  The party line vote (one assumes) suggests she is somehow deemed controversial and/or Republicans might just want to voice displeasure of tossing in speeding along judicial nominees in the middle of other business.  

Both really amounts to hypocrisy given how Moscow/Graveyard Mitch handled judges. But, I figure both might be involved in this case, though it is simply petty that every last Republican would go along with that shit. (Graham is out with COVID.)

===

A law professor, who also has written/testified about the "shadow docket," which is quite relevant here, discussed the complexity of the legal debate over the eviction moratorium. The question rests on the statutory reach of an old law and if there is (as a statutory matter) appropriately applied here. There might be constitutional concerns others raise, property rights or otherwise, but the immediate issue is of that nature. 

As he notes, the complexity should be remembered -- I would add that we would balance all the issues involved, including the need of a short term moratorium as the Delta variant increases the need of such a moratorium during the summer months as Congress acts.  I find this take wrong.* The short statement of one member of the Supreme Court doesn't settle everything here.  

---

* This is not surprising.  He continuously comes off as a liberal concern troll.  I think Adam Winkler's take is more appropriate.  

Will SCOTUS intervene?  Maybe. But, they shouldn't overturn the moratorium. Furthermore, even if they do, they likely won't for some period of time. This gives Democrats and others the benefit of time, which they very well should use. This is not something that should go indefinitely. But, we are in the middle of a new uptick and other things are going on.  

Finally, to me, a basic problem is the opaqueness of the shadow docket decision. Unlike LCT, net, I don't think they shined much in their decision there, including being so unclear.  The confusion that arose is far from surprising.  Maybe, if the Supreme Court as a whole was more clear, it would have helped the clarity of what Congress and Biden could do.

Tuesday, August 03, 2021

AG REPORT OF INVESTIGATION INTO ALLEGATIONS OF SEXUAL HARASSMENT BY GOVERNOR ANDREW M. CUOMO

During the beginning of the Big V, Gov. Cuomo (NY) was out there a lot and seemed like the anti-Trump. Reasonable, articulate, and so forth. This might have been somewhat exaggerated, but early on, it was fair enough. Toss in how he was a bit of a glory hound and so on. Like many pols. This includes if you flag some questionable moves. Early on, there would be some all around, but I had a higher benefit of the doubt. 

[An example of the benefit of the doubt thing is how New York City handled things in March 2020.  Hindsight tells us that the shutdown probably came at least a week too late. Some now are very critical and I understand where they are coming from.

But, given the novelty of the situation and the great burdens of a shutdown -- I'm thinking of the shutting down of a major school system is a city where that will cause a lot of complications, much more than let's say a smaller system in a place like Washington State -- I can understand the hesitance. At the time, I surely was too optimistic.]

As time passed, especially as Biden came into office, a higher test arose. And, questionable moves about nursing homes, for instance, were even more complicated by evidence of cover-ups. I also saw allegations of favoritism in Big V treatment. Plus, he kept on (to be crude but accurate) having dick waving contests* with the mayor of NYC over who was in charge. This sort of this is particularly crude given the stakes.

Cuomo's power plays, which a recent report noted included attacks on my state senator (Sen. Biaggi, who is concerned both about ethics and sexual crimes), have long been a thing. He benefited from divided government and the long "three guys in a room" -- heads of the assembly and senate and the governor -- mentality of state government. The long term issues of state government is parodied in the film 1776 as being there since the beginning.

Simply put, the guy is a known asshole.  So it goes. But, again, he was able to take advantage of the situation to be governor for three terms now. This is different from being an ideal governor, especially now that we have full Democratic government.  (Sen. Biaggi knocked off the head of a swing group of independents that Cuomo used, one reason he is no fan.)  

I simply don't know how good he was, but again, he had a lot of issues. And, to be clear, various people (including Zephyr Teachout, one of his no hope challengers, better as a public interest scholar) have argued push comes to shove, he has not been a good governor even if he long came out top in power games.  The lack of an alternative, especially now that finding Republicans with any hope (Guiliani's son running isn't helping) is unlikely, might help him stay in office. Doesn't mean he is truly good at it.

One issue was/is problems with women. As in the #MeToo way.  Multiple allegations came out last year or so in this sense.  We now have a long report by the AG basically saying "I believe the women" and that he was not just an asshole.  He broke state and federal laws. The final two paragraphs are worthy of quotation:

Upon completion of our independent investigation into allegations of sexual harassment brought against Governor Andrew Cuomo and the surrounding circumstances, we have reached the conclusion that the Governor sexually harassed a number of State employees through unwelcome and unwanted touching, as well as by making numerous offensive and sexually suggestive comments. We find that such conduct was part of a pattern of behavior that extended to his interactions with others outside of State government.

We also find the Executive Chamber’s response to allegations of sexual harassment violated its internal policies and that the Executive Chamber’s response to one complainant’s allegations constituted unlawful retaliation. In addition, we conclude that the culture of fear and intimidation, the normalization of inappropriate comments and interactions, and the poor enforcement of the policies and safeguards, contributed to the sexual harassment, retaliation, and an overall hostile work environment in the Executive Chamber.

As to the federal law bit, it is discussed that federal law bars workplace sexual harassment. Which evidence shows he committed.  This all is not surprising, but it has more bit in a long report by the Attorney General.   The ball continues to be in the court of the state legislature, who in some fashion is formally investigating him.  Though top people said before that it was time for him to resign, this did not seem to be seen as exactly something that was time sensitive. 

He leaves office as of now 1/1/23.  The Lieutenant Governor is Kathy Hochul.  There is a certain familiarity to all of this.  Gov. Elliot Spitzer resigned because of a prostitution scandal. Recall he used to be in charge of prosecuting such things. The new governor, David Paterson, is basically forgotten today.  OTOH, he did fill Sen. Hillary Clinton's seat when she became Secretary of State (yeah, this happened) with Kirsten Gillibrand, a then lesser known upper state congresswoman from a reddish district. It is a reasonable bet that Gov. Spitzer would have chosen someone else.  

I have pushed for Cuomo's resignation on this blog in the past after his actions came to light.  I think this is worse than Spitzer, but he was not just some victim of Puritans. Prostitution should be legal, but that doesn't give him a pass with all that was involved, including the higher standard warranted for his position.  Resignation is separate from civil and criminal wrongdoing. 

Cuomo is worse. It can't be handwaved as a "victimless crime" (without going into the particulars of the Spitzer matter).  And, again, the sexual stuff isn't even the only thing that warrants resignation. The report might push the envelope some. A liberal leaning state like New York especially -- though it really shouldn't be partisan -- should put people to a higher test.  

I noted that Scott Stringer, also ran mayoral candidate who once seemed like a leading possibility, was rightly put to a higher test even if the allegation was long past.  Part of this is HOW he reacted -- his campaign went all out, even accusing the women of being some Yang supporter (the allegation turned to be weak), instead of -- he was supposed to be the progressive/left choice -- carefully handling the situation. 

(He did a better job when a second woman came out, if with a weaker case)

The #MeToo Generation warrants a level of care that brings within it some marginal cases. Sen. Al Franken -- the Alabama Senate race with a sexual predator issue arising there too arising around that time adding an additional complication -- was such a case.  He was rather upset about being forced to resign.  But, especially as things were even more raw, yes, he was put to a higher test, especially as a liberal senator from a state where he could be replaced with a fine choice like Senator Tina Smith.  

Cuomo is less of a marginal case.  He has long been a bully and "toxic workplace" issues have long been known.  Over time, multiple allegations, and not just about sexual harassment, of wrongdoing have arisen.  It is depressing really that he didn't have a better primary challenge last time (Cynthia Nixon is fine enough, including doing her part in various public issues, but she was not really a credible person to beat him).

I understand why Eric Adams, who will be the next NYC mayor (oh well; I wanted one of the women to win, but guess he has some potential), recently had a mutual suck-up appearance with Cuomo.  But, it was sort of depressing.  We can do better.  Let's have Gov. Hochul as a placeholder, and see if we can pick good person to run in 2022.  

The report might make this somewhat likely.  As of now, Cuomo is still out denying everything.  Suffice to say that is getting real old. 

ETA: President Biden, who previously said he would rely on the AG's report, later said he supports Cuomo resigning.   I don't know if this as any concrete effects, but there is something important about it all the same.

The report notes that it does not decide, but leaves open others to do so, criminal charges is warranted. And, I have seen reporting that at least one locality is investigating that.  After all, to the degree there was unwanted touching (as an example), that is not only a civil issue, but a criminal one.  

It was also emphasized by some of the reporting that we should focus on the enablers cited by the report.  Such third parties (and details) often are notable in these cases, even if on some level they don't seem like the "big game."  But, victims repeatedly note the problem of enablers.

---

* I have been told someone I know personally found out about this blog. Not too many people read it.  I don't just treat it as a personal diary.  But, yes, at times I'm blunt and so forth. 

Monday, August 02, 2021

Supreme Court Watch: Order Day

As I noted last time, the "Supreme Court" did not expressly say that extending an eviction moratorium would require congressional legislation. Kavanaugh is the only person who wrote an opinion. It might be a valid long term prediction, plus the Biden Administration might not want to "poke the bear" and threaten other executive action taken. But, it repeatedly being stated (including in today's White House Briefing) that the "Supreme Court" said or ruled when only Kavanaugh was involved is wrong. I wish they would stop saying it.

[OTOH, maybe it's in their interests to spin things. Still bothered me to keep on hearing it framed that way.]

And, even if SCOTUS or SCOTUSBlog does not want to put it on their calendars as such, today is a scheduled summer Order Day. As usual, it is even more boring than a usual boring order list. But, there you go. Two more scheduled.


Quarantine Life from Cholera to COVID-19

I first learned about Dr. Kari Nixon (not Kari Lynn Nixon!) on Twitter. She is a passionate John Oliver fan, wishing she could be mentioned on his show. She also had a very charming video of her excitement receiving a box of her books. Plus, she does things like talk about Victorian medical advertisements. She comes off as a fun nerd. And, very nice (she even referenced me [Joe Paulson] as a supporter on her Twitter account).

After a book listed as a more academic affair (anyway, not in any libraries I have access to), this one is subtitled "What Pandemics Teach Us About Parenting, Work, Life, and Communities from the 1700s to Today." And, like a good teacher, she lists around thirty lessons with various case studies. The Robinson Crusoe guy wrote two plague related books. Who knew?

Her nature and love for her field is shown in the acknowledgments. She quotes (without translation) a line from the poem highlighted here. Ultimately, I found a lot of interesting stuff, but started to get a bit lost with so much material being tossed out. Do have her on John Oliver and Stephen Colbert too. I bet in small doses, she is even better.


Sunday, August 01, 2021

Two More Films

Buffy the Vampire Slayer (the film) is mostly forgotten and for some having a Trump supporter (Kristy Swanson, who later popped up on t.v. movies) as the lead didn't help. The creator of the show was also involved, but was bothered that his overall (darker) vision was not followed. And, the film has issues, especially Rutger Hauer (a genre pro) having a rather lame performance. The action finale is a bit lame.

Still, the film has charms. One basic charm is that there are so many familiar faces, who popped up in later roles. One is Hilary Swank, who plays a real shallow character here. The beginning has a good teen world Clueless vibe. I thought Swanson had potential, if given less material to work with. Also, the idea of having a menstrual cramps like feeling when danger is around is an interesting idea. Runs out of steam, but enjoyable.

I also got tired of the Finnish (etc.) film Iron Sky, which has a neat idea -- the Germans somehow escaped to the dark side of the moon in 1945, and no one knew about the colony they set up. Years later, as part of a Palin-like U.S. presidential re-election gimmick, a black astronaut is captured. Setting into motion things. One amusing scene: a take-off of the famous Downfall (one actor is in this movie too) scene that has all the parodies. It doesn't go all the way though, including the last bit where the Eva Braun character reassures someone.


Creation of the Humanoids

The Leonard Maltin guide (back in the day it was TV Movies; now there is a classics volume too though the original was discontinued in 2015, with the Internet and all) gave this movie a "BOMB" rating. That is unfair. It is pretty talky (the end was like ten minutes of exposition) and not exactly high budget. But, it made some interesting philosophical points (if in 1950s sci fi science talk at times) in its "the robots are taking over!" plot.

A basic guide for me when watching these movies is my ability to watch straight thru. This is a lot harder for me these days though it helps to use the DVR (like in Spaceballs, you can watch as it is still recording) and watching bits along with other things. And, I found I could here. Plus, I thought the acting decent enough and it had some interesting touches. Plus, humor, including what amounts to makeovers via death.

The "we had a nuclear war, most of humanity die; why doesn't really matter" had a "early 1960s" feel to it. Again, it was rather talky. Almost a televised play with multiple scenes largely a way to insert monologues and commentary. Which again I found interesting. I think they probably should have shaved a few minutes off the final scene unless the whole thing was meant to be truly a historical exercise! (spoiler).


Saturday, July 31, 2021

SCOTUS Watch: Summer Odds & Ends

RIP: As noted earlier this week, Justice Sotomayor's mom (in her 90s) has died. She has a great life story, including training to become a nurse in her 40s.

Summer Orders Update: The first scheduled summer order day is next week. It is not likely to be too notable, but we are for completeness here. Also, it annoys me that a scheduled order day gets so little respect, including at SCOTUSBlog. It is as much a scheduled order day as one during the regular term!

Roe: Various odds and ends continue to be covered as there is a lull in Supreme Court news. One thing is the start of anti-abortion briefs, including one joined by most Republicans (three women senators and around twenty-five or so House members did not join; three Republican senator trolls joined a stronger anti-Roe brief) focused on disposing of the viability line. In practice, that would result in a free-fall for abortion rights.  People do not just want to tinker with second trimester abortions here.  

Eviction Moratorium: We also had a notice from the Biden Administration regarding a CDC eviction moratorium that is due to run out at the end of the month.  It supports a legislative expansion and a partial extension by administrative means. 

The problem (other than the complications of legislative fixes) is a shadow docket ruling from last month that turned on Kavanaugh's vote -- the quote in the notice is actually not from the "Supreme Court," but his brief opinion saying he rejected the challenge only so far as the moratorium would run out at the end of July.  

The statement notes: "the Supreme Court’s ruling stated that “clear and specific congressional authorization (via new legislation) would be necessary for the CDC to extend the moratorium past July 31.”  But, the quote is from the Kavanaugh opinion.  The basic effect is the same.

Four conservatives, without an opinion explaining why, would have put the moratorium on hold.  Four justices (including Roberts) rejected that without an opinion.  Now, I have seen some liberals/moderates suggest on statutory grounds there is a reasonable argument that the CDC's move was not authorized.  I don't know.  But, it would be nice if we actually had some sort of explanation.  Note even the old SCOTUS vet, who is still grumpy about the telephonic arguments and is kneejerker speaks of "abusing" of the shadow docket. 

Corrections: We also continue -- including in opinions related to orders -- corrections. I wonder how that sort of thing is done. Do people point it out to the chambers?  Do the justices have their clerks double check?  Are the justices bored and re-read while traveling or something?  

BTW, it's one more thing that would be useful on a FAQ page for orders and opinions.  They do have a FAQ, but it isn't comprehensive.  My push for a FAQ for orders stands -- orders have a bunch of minutiae that are lost on even regular court watchers.

Trump Tax Returns: The House might actually get the returns, years after they should have.  Dawn Johnsen, Acting Attorney General for OLC (her being blocked when nominated by Obama was something that particularly pissed me off -- I saw her as a special symbol to re-gain integrity and she was blocked for bullshit reasons)  signed an opinion authorizing it. 

The OLC opinion spent a lot of time interpreting the Supreme Court opinion (when they got around to it) worrying about the lower court not taking Trump's interests in hand enough.  A bullshit argument even if the net result was supposedly a sign the Roberts Court wasn't in the hock for Trump.  But, even granting that, DJ explains how there is a valid public purpose in the House commitee getting returns here.  I am just left with a "yeah, duh."

Friday, July 30, 2021

Mets Update

In recent memory, the Mets have went on a dive, not being able to catch up in the end. This would be a "June swoon." Last season, the weird Big V fraction of one, was a lost one, even though the Marlins getting to the postseason showed the potential.

This season, there was not really a June swoon. More of a period of mediocre play that continued into July. The Nats had a lousy time of it, this time not coming out of their hole. The Marlins are the Marlins. The Phils are the Phils (sorta a .500 team, but something of a tease). And, the Braves with injuries etc. would appreciate actually being over .500.

Net result, especially with so many injuries (e.g., deGrom has been out for a while now and it's like he is almost an forgotten man), the Mets seem pretty comfortable, even if their lead is only around four games.  Like they just lost another series to a divisional rival (Braves, 2-3), but it was like "who cares?"   The Phils struggled to come up even versus the Nats.  I simply am not worried about them.  The Braves?  They are four games back and this series underlines their problem having an extended winning streak -- the opening to put a scare was there. Gained a game.

Someone on Twitter challenged me, saying it was an opportunity to move ahead by six games or something.  I guess.  But, the competitive difference is not so much that I really expected much more anyway.  Yes, with so many games and injuries, they tossed in some AAA guy that gave the Braves a laugher.  Even there, the guy in the past wasn't THAT bad.  

I noted last season that I was not really into baseball with the Big V delaying the season and so on.  The Mets struggling to gain traction didn't help.  This time, the Mets are showing something, managing to win no matter how many people are injured.  But, the division is so middling.  It's depressing on a competitive level to see so few (other than three NL West teams) good teams.  The Cubs showed some life and now they are giving away the store.  Will the Reds show something?  Didn't look too scary when they played the Mets the first time. 

The Mets wasn't really expected to make the playoffs (shades of 2015?) yet. But, why not? They picked up old vet Rick Hill and Trevor Williams (back-ended fill-in starter material). And, with Lindor hurt, they have his pal Javier Báez as a rental. When Lindor is back, seems a bit crowded, since McNeil already gives you a pretty good second baseman.

And, if Carrasco actually is healthy (he starts today -- the Mets are also bringing back black jerseys), we still have deGrom and maybe Thor too add arms later on.  Someone starting now (a guy named Megill is the new wonder, the new Matz, but more calm) can go into the pen.  And, the pen now is rather good, no one (other than Seth Lugo, off an injury) really struggling.  Also, if Walker -- who hasn't pitched much the last few years -- needs a break (he is struggling after his All Star appearance), he can get a rest too.  So, I think the pick-ups at the trade deadline are okay. 

You got a couple arms, will get some back, and JB is a nice bat. In 2015, they picked up Cespedes (who they should have then let go) and some bench guys.  They already have some good bench guys.  Overall, the Mets should be able to win the division (knock on wood) and no reason they cannot beat a team like the Reds/Brewers.  The rest is gravy.

And, if the Phils/Braves go on roll, the Mets still should be okay unless they go into a freefall.  This is not that likely with the mediocrity as a whole.  The pick-ups, people coming back, and not too many make-ups left will help there too.  Average play until further notice should be enough with a burst of late season energy -- also quite possible -- providing an edge. 

I would actually welcome a threat, finding the current situation a bit boring. One more thing: the on the cusp team to root for in my book are the Mariners. They very well might not quite make it, already having slumps. But, with the Twins and "Cleveland Guardians" out of it, the Mariners are aiming for at least a Wild Card. More likely than Toronto, who seems to be paying some money/prospects for hope and prestige. 

And, they might actually be able to play at home, deprived of the privilege so far because of stricter Canadian Big V rules. 

ETA: In somewhat suspicious timing -- reports are that the Mets tried to get a better starter (with Walker iffy of late, Stroman is the one safe top three guy until Carrasso -- love how he has a nickname (Cookie) as if he has been around all season -- proves himself) but the asking price was too high -- deGrom now is reportedly out to at least September.  

Again, this is not too shocking -- I saw a note that suggested he was getting along, but it's like he was totally MIA after what I thought would be like a short injury stint.  And, though he nasty for the first half, he repeatedly showed signs of being human. One reporter kept on saying "stop worrying," but it was worry-some. 

deGrom out, Walker scuffling, and they still are doing okay pitching-wise (it is not like the losses tend to be blowouts).  Shows a certain depth, especially a pen that even has "B" teamers holding people down. No "waiver moves" this time after the deadline -- rule change.  Let's see if that means something.

Wednesday, July 28, 2021

In the news ... Olympics and 1/6 Select Committee

Simon Biles: I don't watch the Olympics, but Simon Biles is so prime GOAT material (plus saw her in at least one ad) that I'm familiar with her. The big news this week is that she step aside mid-competition because of mental stress. Caring about mental well being is more acceptable these days. Good. Let's remember the human side of sports, including that humans are involved. Comes out in baseball in various ways.

1/6 Select Committee: While the #3 Republican in the House goes full "we are at war with [checks notes]," the commitee started with the two House Republicans willing to not be totally in the hock for Trump. Very emotional beginning with police officer testimony. Also, a reminder at the power of witnesses, even if "we know this, so why is this necessary?" Or, "this is all theater." Yeah, it's a bit more complicated.

Good beginning. This includes keeping two Republicans off the commitee who either might be a witness or started off from right after being picked showing his total disdain of things. Pelosi didn't use her veto power (power in place only because the independent commitee option was filibustered) to block all Republicans, even one who challenged the electors. Next steps, including who to subpoena and making sure to go big or go home, will be harder.


Monday, July 26, 2021

RIP Bob Moses

Gay USA honors various activists who have died. History is not just about snapshots, even if we often study it that way. It is for the long haul. This is seen by civil rights activist, Bob Moses (well named; RIP), who later on started the Algebra Project (news to me, but so is many things) to promote math education.

The White House honors his memory. The best way to honor his memory is to do things to advance what he fought for. On that front, this op-ed challenging Biden's "all in" sentiments on voting rights is correct. Yes, the economic program will help blacks too. But, I'm sort of tired about hearing how supportive the President is about things. There is a certain not quite all in sentiment that belies just what is at stake. People DIED for voting rights in the 1960s.

I could add this to a SCOTUS post, but I will toss it in that Justice Sotomayor's mother has died. She also is a civil rights icon in her own fashion.


Sunday, July 25, 2021

Abortion Ruling is Clearly A Religion Clause Issue

Reference is made recently at Religion Clause of a district court issued a preliminary injunction to the severe anti-abortion law in Arkansas.

This is the sort of thing Texas is trying to avoid via their "hey, it's just private parties" enforcement approach. Think antebellum states trying to get out of the fugitive slave retrieval business while also passing laws that support the slave states. How well this will work remains to be seen. The validity of the move as noted in the comments is dubious, but will it be hard to attack pre-enforcement in the courts? The comments are closed here but other law professors appear more open to the suit.

The district court opinion is really a holding action until the packed Barrett Court decide abortion cases. But, the citation on a blog focused on religious issues, without discussion of why exactly (as if it's obvious), is fitting. Abortion disputes are in a basic way about religious matters. Planned Parenthood v. Casey correctly spoke of it being a matter of conscience.


Friday, July 23, 2021

More On SCOTUS

I was upset that the Presidential SCOTUS Commission is not getting more attention, including in lieu of the same old, same old.  So, it was nice to see that Jamelle Bouie has an op-ed concerning the body and notes how it is "interesting, illuminating and worthy of your attention." For instance, it flags the testimony of Vicki Jackson (who was an amicus in the DOMA case):
"It is an unstable situation for a party supported by a minority of the population to be able to control the Senate, frequently the presidency, and the Supreme Court,” she writes, “If citizens cannot look to elections, nor to the Courts, nor to the amending process, to achieve a federal government that is in broad terms responsive to democratic views, what remains are methods that should trouble all who believe in the rule of law.”

Her testimony did not just support (like many) term limits, but flagged specific problems (not just, as some witnesses spun, the idea this is all about one side being upset at results of cases) and the state of recent nominations:

In 2016, the Senate refused to consider President Obama’s nominee to the Court, asserting that it was doing so because he was in the last year of a two-term presidency. This was a novel claim and decried as illegitimate by many at the time. More recently, the head of the Republicans in the Senate announced thatif Republicans regained a majority in the 2022 elections, no nominees of the President--in the last two years of his first term--would be confirmed.
She is not the only person who did this either, showing this is not all above the fray type of testimony. Jackson does not support court expansion particularly, but realizes there are problems behind such talk, problems that should influence any reforms proposed. The op-ed finds chances of reform in the short time unlikely, but it worthwhile to bring this all out.

I agree. Just what will come out of this in the short term is unclear. But, for instance, calling into question (with vague details in the coverage) the FBI investigation of Kavanaugh is appropriate. There should generally been a value to openness and providing a better understanding of what happened. Likewise, it causes a shadow to be put on those involved, which helps in some fashion the possibility of change and a better path forward.  

Someone was annoyed at my use of slow old fashioned techniques etc. It is unclear what special techniques was desired.  And, I support adding people to the Supreme Court, ending the filibuster and so forth.  You can scream about that only so much.  Change is a long process and "softening them up" helps.  The witnesses also at times suggested certain reforms, such as ethics or more openness of the courts, are possible.  These things make it more possible, since they aren't so sacrosanct or "not able to be touched."

Plus, while Sen. Whitehouse et. al. does things (including getting media coverage), others can do "less politically correct" stuff too. For instance, during the Kavanaugh hearings, protesters sought out senators in elevators and the like.  The more attention given here, the more chance of this happening too.  This includes even something many deem forgettable, that is, hearings and reports.  This nuts and bolts stuff has value.

===

A former clerk of Justice Thurgood Marshall (not Kagan) has a good long discussion of him that provides various insights.  

Also, for the sake of completeness, I see yet another edited (dated 7/23) to Supreme Court opinions.  Other than a challenged citation in an opinion related to an order early in the term, I am not aware of anything really substantive in these corrections.  They appear -- though I have not looked at every last one -- to all be of a typo variety.  The latest cited the wrong place regarding a historical reference.  Often it is a matter of a typo in a citation.

Thursday, July 22, 2021

War of Independence

Patriot Battles: How the War for Independence Was Fought is an interesting approach.

The first part talks about the various aspects of fighting (armies, weapons, etc.; one thing not covered was POWs) while the second are basically case studies for various battles (with maps; the first half could have been helped with pictures too). The battles including a touch of naval though the first half does not cover the navies.

The writing style is approachable with some touches of spleen to add some bite. The few comparisons to recent times to me overall works. (An end note expands a comparison of two Georges.) I was less interested in the nuances of the battles, but they aren't so detailed (the chapters are all pretty short) to be too tedious. And, again, the maps help you get a sense of what happened. Overall, recommended, especially since I like a complete approach.

Wednesday, July 21, 2021

SCOTUS Watch: Presidential Commission

We have an order -- special briefing rules to address Big V delays were revoked. As of now, the building is scheduled to be open for next month. One person (didn't notice) pointed out that the Court calendar repeatedly said that and took it back once the month came. [And, it was marked closed by Friday.]

The second (and perhaps last) big public hearing day for the Presidential SCOTUS Commission was held on Tuesday. Again, there were some interesting witnesses, including a Canadian judge in the final panel. I listened to some of the opening panels. I think it can be criticized, but some diversity was present. I also wish there was more public reporting -- e.g., Rachel Maddow led with yet another Trump scandal that evening. Why not give this a try?

Meanwhile: There was strong strong criticism of Garland when it came out the Justice Department would not prosecute Wilbur Ross even after an inspector's report showed he lied to Congress. I was less appalled given how these things tend to go (the talk of "rich whites" was stupid -- poor blacks don't get prosecuted either). I did want to see the report. Then, it turns out new information led to a correction: the TRUMP Justice Department made the decision. Okay. Watch out for hot takes. Hot news sometimes is updated!


Saturday, July 17, 2021

Books and Film

I am writing a blog on another website about cavewomen. Looking into it, one book about the general subject that I found was The Invisible Sex: Uncovering the True Roles of Women in Prehistory. As suggested in this review, it's a mixed bag, including a lot of "filler" that is not about women particularly. The writing style also was a bit chunky or something. But, it had some interesting details. Among the stuff I found is this interesting piece.

I enjoyed Crucible of Faith: The Ancient Revolution that Made Our Modern Religious World more. This is a look at the developments in Palestine from Greek times until the early Common Era. It arose from my interest in the time period of the first Hanukkah. I would still like a book focused on that, but this as whole is a good account. A few times, going into the weeds of the beliefs is a bit tedious, but even there, it is mostly very readable.

Our new film (I will re-watch Walking on Sunshine, a fun 1980s pop hits musical), new to me, is Mama. The executive producer is behind the very good Pan's Labrinth, where a girl used fantasy to deal with WWII horrors. The fantasy was more reality here. Jessica Chastain has a very good supporting role as sort of the "new" mama. The ending is kinda dumb. 

ETA: I enjoyed Walking on Sunshine again, catching a bit more on a second watch.  (Much more than second, but usually listen only to the songs.)  The DVD extra is a bunch of cast interviews.  One big issue: there is no closed captioning.  This is particularly problematic for this movie, which is very good to sing along to.  When I had it available via a t.v. viewing, I could access the captions/lyrics.  

One thing that all the new platforms (which I don't personally have though I temporarily registered for Hulu last year to check out a Christmas movie involving lesbians) provide is reboots of old shows.  Sometimes, you can get a taste of them on regular television, such as a new Star Trek series.

Nickelodeon aired the premiere episode of the iCarly reboot (with the main characters, minus Sam -- the actress moved on from acting at the moment; Gibby also does not seem to be involved). "Mosby" from Suite Life directed the episode.  "Harper" is not THAT one (that's Disney).  Anyway, nice to see everyone, but the episode itself was rather blah.  It is basically set-up, so maybe the later ones are better.  It was renewed already.

Wednesday, July 14, 2021

SCOTUS Watch

The tainted 6-3 Supreme Court will start its first full term -- the ninth member railroaded in as we voted in October -- in October. The October Term argument schedule was posted with some key cases. Again, I won't shut up about this, with a fucking tainted Court.

The summer will have mostly odds and ends in respect to Supreme Court news. A good interview from the High School SCOTUS team of a top Supreme Court reporter. We are up to the final orders regarding the Online Sources Cited page. (I also saw an opinion edit dated 7/16.) A good analysis by Prof. Nourse, including about originalism fan fiction.

Another Presidential Commission on the Supreme Court public meeting next week. One appellate lawyer called them out for having basically one token woman (with one exception) on each panel. Six panels; likely another long day.


Tuesday, July 13, 2021

NYC Primary A Bit More Final

Kathyrn Garcia had a quotable line in her concession speech (Wiley also conceded) last week: "People will try to hand you a jacket that's made for someone else. You don't have to accept it. Wear one that fits you.”

Things are more final today with only basically a handful of votes left. The difference is less than one percent, if not .5, which where an automatic recount is required. There doesn't appear to be any issues. Sigh. So close.

As I noted before, maybe Eric Adams is a sort of Biden (who he met recently to talk guns and such; ETA: also a bit of a lovefest with Cuomo/ugh), and overall is okay, especially with progressives around him. I still am not too excited and maybe a third party protest/symbolic vote is in my future. There are options. No ranked choice. Meanwhile, the public advocate marries a lobbyist. Not a big deal really, I guess, but a tad depressing.


Saturday, July 10, 2021

Books and Film

Books: I'll Be There For You about the show Friends. It starts with an extended discussion of its creation, which covers ground basically found in the official coffee table book published at the show's completion. That book often talks about how the show handled 9/11.The show does not directly reference it, but they show Joey wearing NY type tee-shirts and all. Plus, it helped people have something light to watch.  Which is nice, but it is not exactly some profound statement. 

This book doesn't really have much special (except reference to a lawsuit lost by a writing assistant). It was a quick read, so perhaps it would be a good summer read.  Since reading is harder for me these days, partially since I read so much online, that is of some value.  But, the book was somewhat lacking if okay.

It also leaves out stuff like Christiana Applegate, who as a major actress and Emmy winner deserves at least a footnote. After all, she did work with "Joey" before.  And, a chapter that discusses gay issues doesn't reference how one of the writers/producers is gay himself.  His husband is referenced in passing before.  It's not like she doesn't realize he is gay or anything.  Seems like his .02 would be relevant. Sorta annoying. 

I realize you can include only so much but some things are a bit worth tossing in.  And, the late seasons are basically skipped over (the Joey likes Rachel bit is covered briefly and then Rachel likes Joey, but I think Rachel having a kid warrants more than a quick reference).  After the book provides a pretty in depth look at how the show started, the actual ten seasons are not given a complete look.  Even Matthew Perry's drug addiction is only referenced as part of what he did AFTER the show.  

Again, quick read, and the allegation of sexual harassing work environment in the writer's room was an interesting bit, but a bit lacking as  a whole.  And, pictures would again be useful, though the author's pic is good.

===

The book is from a few years ago.  No Common Ground: Confederate Monuments and the Ongoing Fight for Racial Justice is written more recently.  It provides a history behind the monuments and how they were not just memorials of the dead.  They were from the beginning clearly (including as shown by the speeches given at their dedications) there to promote the values of the Confederacy.  

Thus, there would be no "common ground" today.  The author wrote about the Daughters of the Confederacy organization in the past. So, she knows a bit about such messaging.   This one has photographs. The book is under two hundred pages, but arguably might have been a bit shorter.  Overall, it is an interesting account, including up to date battles.  

Written in Stone: Public Monuments in Changing Societies is by Sanford Levinson, who also writes over at Balkanization.  I re-read the original version, written over twenty years back.  An update was written in 2018 and he adds a blog on the subject in 2020 too.  This is when comments from outsiders were still allowed, so you can see some, both from people like myself and those who are basically Confederate sympathizers. Well, at least one such person, who lives in South Carolina.

I am not a great fan of the original.  It has enough material, including a helpful summary of options to address monuments (though as noted below, after listing, the possibility of applying them is basically "not happening really"), to be useful to some degree.  Still, re-reading it, it has issues.

It has some tedious philosophizing that seems a bit too stream of consciousness.  As noted below, it reminds me of his blog style, pre-blog. It is something of an extended personal essay and it shows. This includes his white Southerner viewpoint, if one that is more liberal than some others. 

The opening is basically that, talking about monuments in Hungary.  Then, the core of the short book (one hundred and forty or so pages) about the subject of the newer book basically.  OTOH, his history is much less clear about how the monuments clearly were put in place to advance racial inequality.   The new book provides clear evidence that memorializing the death, full stop, was just not why they were put up.  Why there is "no common ground" today.  If Levinson accepts (up to a point) that as to Confederate flags, monuments to Lee etc. should follow.

He also suggests secession is legitimate -- majority rule and all (okay -- see Sandy, they had majority rule -- they lost the 1860 elections), but slavery did make it problematic.  I don't accept this -- are you saying if they strongly disagreed with the North about industrial policy (and it wasn't code word for slavery), it would have been okay for them to go?  

You actually have to show your work there.  The Union was a creation of the  nation as a whole. Chunks of the Confederacy was actually bought and created by a national entity.  A national entity on principle should be involved if it is broken apart.  The South in effect argued that there was a just cause for secession.  Maybe, a grave injustice would warrant that, though even there, it is complicated.  What about California. Does "consent of the governed" allow a region to break apart? 

But, still those monuments are not just for promotion of slavery.  What about the ordinary solider?  So, the Lee and other major figure ones can go?  He tosses in that he sees the Vietnam War about as bad as the Civil War, so a monument to soldiers there would be problematic.  Putting aside the issue of those drafted and all, maybe if the monument was as racist as the average Confederate monument.  And, the U.S. was racist too. It did not break apart from England in basic part to defend slavery; its Constitution did not as blatantly protect it either. Oh let's have him ramble a bit.  

(The blog also has this character.  I'm being a bit mean here, especially since he repeatedly complimented my comments -- when I can still make them -- but his style is an extended stream of consciousness which tosses in grumpy comments about how screwed up our Constitution is in practice and other stuff that often do not hold up to scrutiny.  But, there is so much there, it's hard to really fully answer what he is saying.) 

It has a discussion on constitutional issues, but does not raise the potential Thirteen Amendment argument that Confederate flags at least are "badges of slavery."  Then, it has various options, none of which he really thinks is likely to actually happen though if the people agreed, he would generally be okay with putting monuments in museums.  

Though apparently that would be hard to do, since the first nuclear bomb drops exhibit was controversial and stuff.  Since a significant amount has happened flag/monument-wise since 1998, the update (which I think I might have read though maybe not) has a lot to cover.  Hopefully, maybe a bit less ignorance of the depth of the history.  

===

Film: I recently re-watched Two Weeks Notice, so decided to check out some other Hugh Grant material.  I noted that the film was pleasant enough though the third act (to use a term used in the film I will get to it in a moment) was problematic.  It has a basic quality to it, but basically did not handle it smoothly. This often happens -- comfort food takes work.

The Rewrite was the film that was most immediately available. Music & Lyrics is a longer wait in the NYPL queue.  But, it turns out all three are from the same director.  Each has Hugh Grant with a familiar actress (Sandra Bullock and Drew Barrymore before).  The latest (2014) is Marisa Tomei, which the DVD box has being in The Wrestler.  Is this the film most people know her from? 

[The writer/director actually was behind even more films with Bullock and Grant that I watched.]

This one actually does not have a problematic third act.  It is not surprising really -- the one hit wonder screenwriter decides he likes teaching college writing -- but it is paced better.  The film overall is less amusing than the first one, and perhaps the second (from what I remember of it).  Still, it is charming -- I liked the story and respected the performers. Plus, it has some familiar old hands, which is a good way to make things go down smoothly.

The extras are two minor deleted scenes and a "making of" bit.

Friday, July 09, 2021

SCOTUS Watch: Clean-Up

Doing a check, multiple -- including some from a while ago in the term -- SCOTUS opinions have been edited. Online urls cited in opinions are also slowly being addressed. And, elsewhere, Charles Fried's brief testimony (another term limit supporter) was added to the Presidential SCOTUS Commission page.

There are various takes that this term was surprisingly not that conservative with various people saying "um," including myself. One correction there is here at NPR.

Interesting article on a few places that allow non-citizens to vote. I'm for that, especially for (or at least for) local issues like school elections. In the past, many places did allow non-citizens (at least those on the road to citizenship) the right to vote. And, residents are required to follow the law and even is liable for treason. So, actually do have some "tie."


Wednesday, July 07, 2021

Mayor Eric Adams: The First Vegan Mayor?

After flubbing the first unofficial count, the Board of Elections wasn't going to do it again. They didn't release the results until the early evening, after earlier tweeting to expect a more "brunch" time result. Either way, the main results were not too surprising.

Eric Adams had a small lead before the absentee ballots were counted with Kathyrn Garcia a close second. Same thing yesterday -- less than a 9K difference, without the same chance of catching up with the remaining votes. Garcia and Wiley conceded today, even if it won't be truly official for another week. Other races also seemed set.

As noted in the article, a major goal this time was a female mayor. It is open to some debate how much more liberal Garcia is than Adams. I took a quiz, though, and she was much closer to my answers. Still, maybe he will be a sort of "Biden" type. And, the comptroller and City Council will be more progressive. I'm still not very excited for the November race.