About Me

My photo
This blog is the work of an educated civilian, not of an expert in the fields discussed.

Saturday, July 16, 2011

Is LWOP Better Than the Death Penalty?

An apparent case (not really knowing the details) of prosecutorial misconduct is discussed by Dahlia Lithwick. The purpose of defense attorneys and judicial oversight/review is to balance off such flaws in the system. Elected prosecutors dealing with "tough on crime" sentiments and/or those who want advancement which rarely is inhibited by going in that direction in close cases are but some reasons why we can't just rely on self-correction. It helps when the judge has a mixed background.

This led on the fray (which might be ending soon, so more links on this blog to it will be dead) to a discussion of the death penalty and how life without parole is not better.  A popular entry on this blog is my refutation of this sentiment. Without linking to it, I will post my recent sentiments on the subject, including some of the sentiments on the other side. The original thread is here and I start by responding to someone who also was against the argument made by the lede post. 
LWOP is more cruel then the death penalty? That may be so, for some people. Many others would choose life, even if they are in jail. At least LWOP is reversible though.
Right. Most, even if given the choice, are not "volunteers" who quicken their sentence. For them, it seems um paternalism to determine that its too cruel for them to keep living. The cruelty of LWOP also is partially a matter of the prisons we have. Execution is not the only solution there. And, if some can handle it, the trouble others have is tempered by the fact that they are heinous murderers. They too have rights, but some unpleasantness is part of punishment.

Finally, it seems to prove too much. What about others who have very long sentences, such as rapists or multiple felony offenders who are in prison for decades? When does this become cruel and unreasonable as well so that we need to execute them for the humanity?

I don't wish to trivialize -- for some, LWOP would seem cruel as compared to execution. But, there is no easy answers here. The system we have makes execution problematic as well. And, the problem there is that there are no backsies. LWOP has problems, but selectively executing a few people while keeping others in cages for a long period of time doesn't seem to be a great solution. That is how it always has been -- always a small somewhat arbitrary subset has been executed. This highlights the importance of life in our society (and distrust of state power), so that the state doesn't involuntarily kill people except in very narrow circumstances. Even heinous criminals. It is very unclear if the pretty arbitrary system that results is constitutional or just.

Perfect justice might allow execution, but we aren't there.

[The original person responds, some excerpts in italics.]
You are presuming things that i do not feel or think. You are close, but not enough.
To forestall confusion, what you feel or think (which is subjective) is not my immediate concern; my concern is to address a certain argument. 
My entire argument was from the perspective of society. The convict isn't my interest here.
I appreciate the clarification because when you said "cruel and unreasonable sentence imposed on criminals" and used words like "cruel" that are found in provisions that are partially concerned with the convict, I thought they had something to do with things. But, again, my game is bigger than your specific feelings or sentiments. But, I appreciate you taking the time to spell them out below.

[From past experience with this writer, though usually while I used a different name, his ability to calmly set forth his positions without personal bias and assumptions (what I "presume" / mistaking what he "feels")  was somewhat lacking.  It's hard to debate opposing views with such barriers. His reply was therefore appreciated for its basic straightforward nature.]
1. Timidity - hence my comment, by sentencing someone to jail for the entirety of their life society is condemning that convict to death, only they are doing it slowly because they are too timid to act on their ethical/moral convictions (no pun intended).
Everyone dies. The sentence doesn't do it. The sentence affects the means. The ethical/moral convictions put forth here is that executing them as compared to some other means (including having them die in prison) is wrong. Where's the timidity?
This convict is not being rehabilitated, society has given up on them - otherwise there would be no caveat "without parole". So since rehabilitation isn't the goal - then incarceration is simply to remove that person from society permanently. This is a death sentence, symbolic but no less final for the person.
Society gives up on them when they execute. And, since rehabilitation can take a long time, including after a decade or more in prison, this is particularly bad here. Finally, LWOP in actuality might not be LWOP. If the person becomes feeble, e.g., their ability to be placed outside of the prison or in some sort of hospital or halfway location changes. Some of the helpless cases in the old days now can be handled with psychiatric drugs and other methods. etc. If they were executed a few years before this method was found, they would be out of luck.

The inability to be able to rehabilitate basically is the inability to put them back into society. This doesn't mean, and often this is seen, that they have no ability to have some value or ability to exist inside the prison. We would be left with a few exceptions where people kill in prison though even there a few probably are mentally unbalanced enough that killing them would be questionable.

Like a person in other institutions, including old age homes, this is not totally "final." They are still alive. This is why so few rather die than be there. Like old age homes, the conditions often are horrible, but the ideal solution to me is not just to kill them.
2. Uncertainty - his partners with timidity, but expands on it. By imposing life without parole society is proclaiming that this person is being locked up even though they aren't entirely sure he or she is guilty.
Curiously, you use this to support the death penalty as if society is better off if the person is executed, though there is a chance (reaffirmed by experience) that some subset shouldn't be there since they are either factually or legally innocent. I'm with others in not finding this proper.
3. Cruel - while I think you have a point in that paternalism certainly enters the equation, consider what a willingness to confine another person against his/her will for the entirety of their lives is.
I believe that future societies will find our "solution" of the criminal class of putting people in little cages for years on end to be as heinous as some of the things we now deem heinous about past societies. But, this proves too much. It would call into question as I said any type of long sentence. If the issue is too small cells, again, that can be fixed in ways other than killing people. This has been shown in prisons in certain European countries.

Finally, though I'm not gung ho about it, our system does currently seem to assume that punishment includes a retribution aspect, so the fact prisoners suffer some would be acceptable up to a point. Especially since rapists and thieves suffer long time prison sentences in small cages, why society should help heinous murderers out by shortening their time is unclear.
My argument has nothing to do with false convictions, overly aggressive prosecutes, overly zealous defense attorneys, or the imperfections of our criminal justice system. It is an examination of what life without parole reflects on the society that developed it.
The other stuff, however, does complicate handing out death sentences and even taking your interesting moral position on its own, it doesn't seem to work.

Friday, July 15, 2011

Blah Blah Blah

I continue to think that -- all the strum und drang aside -- including about the 14A, some settlement will arise from this debt limit business. The Dems will act like adults and given the control of the House, the solution will include some stupid cuts of social spending.

Thursday, July 14, 2011

TV Quickies

TV, especially with "on demand" features to view shows even without DVR, has lots of choices these days, enough for most to find something they like. I caught a couple character cop shows this way, Rizzoli and Isles and Memphis Beat. Decent time wasters.

Wednesday, July 13, 2011

Sister Wives Polygamy Case

I briefly alluded to the federal lawsuit filed by the polygamous group involved in the Sister Wives reality show. Jonathan Turley linked the complaint on his blog. They are challenge an Utah law that has been the subject of some state rulings already, one that covers those who "purport" to be "married" or cohabits with another while married. This is not a mere adultery statute (which he railed against for years) or targeted at those who claim each spouse are "legally" so, attempting to obtain legal benefits (including a license; only one wife was legally married here) arising out of that. So, it is more than a simple claim of bigamy.

Upfront, one can see the problem here. If a couple "cohabits" with a third, which let's say includes a shared sexual arraignment (is that even necessary?) under the same roof, many would not deem this issue for the criminal courts. The group here does not claim civil benefits. They do not wish the state to recognize "marriage" includes polygamous unions. They wish to live together as a family and be able to label themselves "married" (as a same sex couple might without state license if a church blessed their arraignment) in a purely religious sense.

The key case they wish to build off is Lawrence v. Texas. They want to protect an "intimate association," one that does not require the state to provide a "formal recognition" but just not make their "private sexual conduct a crime." The complaint notes in some detail the historical, religious and current presence of the practice of polygamy as well as how open it was, including to governmental officials. The complaint was submitted after the family was under investigation for violating the state law prohibiting polygamy, which only did so after the family went on national television and in effect made their actions blatant. The state even set up an outreach program with polygamous families.

The complaint also notes that the state selectively enforces its laws, particularly targeting certain people in polygamous relationships. This is the normal when such morals legislation is in place -- a consistent application could not be credibly accomplished, so arbitrary rules are set up. Or, someone who is particularly troublesome, such as are too open about what they are doing. This raises freedom of speech and in this context religion concerns; like it or not, the Supreme Court upholds general applicable laws even if it burdens religious exercise. So, peyote use can be banned, even as applied to religious use. But, if only certain types of polygamous relationships are targeted in a way that raises religious biases, it is a problem.

Polygamy is sometimes raised as a slippery slope when same sex marriage or relationships are protected.* The issue here isn't the same as SSM as generally discussed, which is a matter of state recognition, not private practice. This is more akin to a case involving a lesbian couple that got married in a religious ceremony and it was used to bar one from getting a job as a prosecutor since same sex sodomy was illegal at the time. One step further here since criminal penalties are involved. The selective targeting involved here also is problematic.

Various problems related to polygamy are raised. But, that would suggest at best that a polygamous relationship might nullify state marriage benefits. I doubt this group would consent to relinquish the one legal marriage to live in a polygamous relationship, but by my understanding, even if the four were not legally married, they would currently break the law by "purporting" to be married. A purely religious practice would be constructive polygamy. This seems problematic. After all, how many would wish to criminalize a free love commune?

Avoiding sex discrimination in monogamous marriage is still a step beyond polygamy even taking this into consideration. But, fears of slippery slopes or not, Lawrence does suggest protection of various intimate sexual relationships beyond marriage. It's somewhat artificial, but I think a line can be drawn here once a couple gets married. State marriage benefits are in place in part out of the assumption that only one couple is involved, even if adultery or threesomes might be imagined. Actually setting up shop with two or more spouses might be a hard line to draw in some fashion, but that seems to be a step above.

The law however is troublesome for the reasons offered. Putting aside the selective prosecution, the reach is dubious. The cohabitation provision is particularly so. And, overall, criminal laws against consensual adultery are problematic violations of consensual intimacy that is but a step beyond banning fornication. I'm not sure, particularly yet, this will help a man and his four sister wives, but some sort of successful as applied challenge can be imagined given this law's breadth.

---

* The other is incest, which also raises various line drawing, involving step, adopted and outside of the nuclear family (what level of cousin?) questions. I watched a miniseries recently where a woman couldn't marry her now dead husband's brother because it was illegal at the time. This was WWI era England. They waited a few decades, having some children along the way, until it was.

A fair fight?

And Also: Jonathan Turley, off a failed impeachment defense, is now challenging the criminalization of polygamy. A hard road, but as compared to benefits (the key to SSM), attacking what amounts to an adultery crime law might work, if not on this level.

Dahlia Lithwick reminds us that civil and criminal trials provide justice writ large, not always immediate justice of the sort we want for the victims, using a politically charged civil case and a tabloid criminal case as examples. I say a few words here. One thing that stands out is that the victim (alleged) does not just lose out either. If the prosecution is based on bad evidence, convicting the wrong person isn't going to help the victim.

And, even if they lose, victims often appreciate a fair shake via a proper trial process. One point of said process is to provide a mechanism where two sides (at times more) can offer conflicting arguments using a general standardized and objective system of procedures. I often desire this to be in place when the issues of the day are discussed. I can disagree with one side, but if that side is rude or provides cheap arguments, it annoys me. This is true (if a bit less) if I actually agree with the side using such techniques. However, some issues are so emotionally charged, that arguing past each other seems like the fated result.

I was watching Democracy Now! recently and they actually had two sides on to debate the question of investigating/trying Bush officials (up to the top) for torture. The very fact two sides were on is unusual on the show, which tends to put forth a consistent alternative point of view, an appreciated but still incomplete approach. Unfortunately, the "anti" side here had stock replies, oh so tiresome. Is this the "Catholic University" approach? Talk of "antiwar left" (people who supported the war in Afghanistan?), suggesting "torture" is just to hard to define and the specter of political trials once new parties come in office (so, NO one can be prosecuted in such cases? is that a serious claim?).

So hard to have common ground. I am reading a book where some of those on opposite sides are related by blood or marriage. This and other ways to have some basic bond that requires some understanding is necessary to reach some common ground here, if only on the mechanism of debate and conflict.

All Star Game

Turned on a homer, though the imbalance of arms (an injury and the "no Sunday pitcher rule" hurt) was an issue. Jeter should have came -- his "Mr. Baseball" bona fides got a hit. That 3000 hit ball guy got stuff for the joy of giving back. K-Rod trade was a good thing.

Tuesday, July 12, 2011

FNL: Season Finale

And Also: I also found the original True Grit novel; the latest film version is very loyal to it. No wonder I enjoyed both.

I borrowed the Season Five DVD. It has some deleted scenes (less than the other sets), two commentary tracks (no actors involved), a slide show of pictures and a little feature on the show ending. Not having Direct TV, it also allows me to watch the (extended length) finale a few days early.

Some of the early episodes of this season felt a bit off and lacking, but the last two packed in lots of stuff and gave a proper send-off to fans of the show. An abortion themed episode in Season Four (giving a good subplot for Becky, who was somewhat less well provided for by the screenwriters afterwards) drew me in and I basically saw five seasons in the span of a year via television (even caught a bit on syndication -- it's now going to be on ESPN), Netflix, DVDs and Hulu/IMDB.

Season Two was a letdown and after a full length S1, the others were abbreviated. But, this was quality television. It wasn't perfect -- too many come from behind last minute finishes (down to the last) and various things weren't covered (other than Buddy, apparently Eric and Tami had no real friends and even there he wasn't Tami's drinking buddy). But, with so many characters and story-lines, you aren't going to get perfection. From that opening music on, you got close enough to really enjoy the damn show. The closing montage was a proper conclusion, down to those who wanted all the characters to be going in the right direction.

It was noted that the writers didn't give much to the new characters this season, down to Buddy Jr. who showed some potential, broke his leg and just hung around some. We never heard what truly happened to the foster girl (however you spelled her name), underlining we really wasn't supposed to care for her that much. And, Ruckle, or whatever, was a pointless character too. Best was when older characters, especially Mindy, got to shine. Unless the actress wasn't available, why Devin didn't get a chance for a bit for air time is unclear. She's someone who was interesting. Oh, and it would have been nice to see Lyla again. At least Smash got a reference or two.

[Many places provided ongoing blogging on the show, including Slate, which is the source of the below quote.]
As for the Sarah Palin moment, I did not buy it at all. FNL has always been praised as the great red-state show, the one drama with values—faith, family, community—any Republican could love. But it's always been faking it as a red-state show. The real-life version of Tyra would want to be Sarah Palin, not Tami Taylor.
Why? Ever heard of a gal named Ann Richards, who would have had a word or two (neither nice) to say about Ms. Palin? FNL was a red state show that focused upon red state values without most of the b.s. The reason why people are inclined to vote Republican, even if the party itself has become something of a cesspool. But, not trying to be political. Just saying I don't really buy that. BTW, the Palin citation is one of the few times you would realize that the show takes place in the 21st Century. Even the use of cell phones (like by Vince's father) was not the norm earlier in the show; in fact, this season had various computer references, including a website exposing the criminal past of players and a YouTube deal.

I do see Tyra getting into politics -- she has the no nonsense qualities to be able to get through the hard work involved, the smarts but also enough of the Texas girl to connect with the people. She is "wonder woman" after all! We didn't get to see too much of her, but the idea that her and Tim would go their separate ways after Christmas and build separately so they might be able to come together later was a nice way to go. Eric realizing that it was Tami's time and Tami saying that her surrendering to him yet again would shame her in front of her daughter both was powerful as was the realization that Tami would still have stayed -- as with Julie having Matt ask for her hand, the Taylor women still had some old fashioned Texas in them. Still, another time, Eric? You were married in the 1990s -- things have changed, but not THAT much!

As to Vince having so much on his shoulders, true, but putting aside that Tinker is still there with him, would Jess (congrats girl!) always be there? His dad coming to the game very well might have helped them reach some sort of understanding. He is the team leader and has enough support that he is not all alone. Becky has two families -- her mom and Tim/Billy/Mindy plus Luke, who is going away, but is her future. As to Julie, it looks like she got into a local college and will start a life with Matt. We never really saw Julie as completely her own person, as an adult on her own and when she went to college to do that, she couldn't handle it. She now has Matt to try to find her path. BTW, nice to see Landry and Matt riff together one more time.

I tried watching the film, but couldn't really get into it. Really enjoyed the series. Each time this season on NBC, a voice at the end told us that there would be a new episode next week (well, when there was one). Not any more. Thanks for some quality television from the cast to the direction to the music to everything else. I guess I can watch it on Friday one more time as well on ESPN now. Time marches on.

Monday, July 11, 2011

No Bikini

Caught this cute short film with a good message after finding it free on demand. A seven-year-old ("Robin") finds it freeing after not wearing her ill fitting top at swim class, being mistaken as a boy. Lead is very good. Those interested can find it on YouTube.

Sunday Night

The Mets did decent as a hard run of games continue but those last two were pretty depressing all the same. Giving the Giants two runs Saturday annoyed me as did the sad little half-swing to end it. Drop Dead Diva was pretty good; nice to see Jennifer Tilly.

Sunday, July 10, 2011

Sanditon

As Jane Austen was dying, she started to write a novel about a health resort. The fragment is interesting, including its satiric comments about changing times. As usual, lots of the fun involving supporting characters. The apparent lead is something of an observer of events.

Saturday, July 09, 2011

The Watsons

This Austen fragment is intriguing, the lead character (Emma Watson) an interesting character, surrounded by the usual vulgarity and distasteful rich people. Her father dying etc. led her to stop writing. It has potential, particularly the low station of the Watsons.

NYM Update

I don't think any miracles will occur but this is a gritty bunch that is playing above their abilities. Nick Evans is back -- he actually got a hit this time. Overall, guarded optimism is appropriate.

GG Again Goes Off The Rails

Glenn Greenwald in various ways is a strong voice that speaks truth to power and has stuff to back it up. In other ways, he is a blowhard, who when you point out the excesses of his rhetoric calls you a Obama bootlicker. I found this repeatedly when doing so, along with commenter after commenter calling me names and ignoring the substance of my comment or pathetically taking a specific criticism to mean across the f-ing (it is really pissing me off) board that I support everything he does. Mature adults don't do this sort of thing. This is not the "reality based community."

To take an example. GG was simply appalled when Harold Koh testified in Congress during its investigation of the Libya "hostilities" (sic) that some single thing Obama said as a candidate taken on its own would be a wrongful stance of the current legal understanding on executive power to use military force. I found this amazing. It is somehow a problem when an executive official forthrightly states that something a candidate said might be too simplistic, particularly if we (as GG does too often) have a myopic focus on the bald statement alone? I pointed this out and comment after comment (including GG who misleadingly "loved" certain things I said, in his tedious attack boy mode) ignored my critique to call me names or accuse me of thinking someone I repeatedly think is flawed could do no wrong.

The latest for GG is this headline:
Reports: Obama pushing for cuts to Social Security, Medicare
Obama supporters, at least those who lean progressive or left, are supposed to be shocked at this given they voted for someone who would move in another direction. Like those clueless sorts who thought the person who wanted to expand our fight in Afghanistan is some type of peacenik, "give me a break" comes to mind here. It was rather apparent, which is why many Republicans and Republican leaning "independents" voted for the man, that he has various "third way" tendencies that would support compromises in the promotion of general principles. Like it or not, that is who you were getting in '08.

It is therefore rich for GG to frame Obama as some sort of hypocrite or fraud for being the sort of "centrist" (these days more right leaning given how far the lines have moved in the last few decades) that would push for some sort of cuts as part of a larger effort to promote an overall progressive agenda. I really don't know what is so shocking here. We are in an economic mess at the moment. When the average person has money problems, s/he sometimes cuts back general spending that involves less money for food and medical care. You know, more pasta dinners and such than meat or going to the dentist once a year instead of two.

I need to see the cuts and balance this off with the expansion of spending (or tax cuts for those who need it) in other areas, including the expansion of health care that the "Obama is no better" crowd selfishly (since it doesn't matter to them) or stupidly (since it often does) ignores. Finally, it is notable that Republicans control 1/2 of Congress and the balance of power in the Senate are Blue Dogs. I know some hate to admit this, but it is actually realistic to realize that a somewhat fiscally conservative approach will pass.

If we want a different equilibrium in this country we need to maturely address the current situation. GG and his lackeys (comments are tediously slanted) in their passionate advocacy miss the point and in the long run are counterproductive since you need to know the nature of the situation before you can change it. Their tedious smarmy over the top tone (if emotionally pleasing at times) is tiresome but ultimately this is the ultimate problem I have with their approach. Sadly, I think GG might have jumped the shark. I find him too hard to take of late.

More on Lady Susan

And Also: A shout-out to Heather Vandeven, whose talents can be seen in Life on Top et. al. This is not an euphemism -- she is truly an actress, not just a sex performer. The amount of soft porn on late nite t.v. underlines there IS a difference. Meanwhile, Femme Fatales is of the "overdramatic" variety, but has some charm.

Before reading Emma (which I did start), as noted, I listened to Austen's Lady Susan, which was only published when a relative wrote a biography and included it along with The Watsons (an unfinished work) and excerpts of Sanditon (the unfinished work she was writing when she died at 41, not too young for the time, but atypical given the long lives of her immediate family). I have yet to finish the latter two though the latter starts well. I also borrowed the Penguins Classics volume that includes all three plus commentary and notes.*

I have found the portable and compact Signet Classics paperbacks the most enjoyable and attractive (the others can have a blah textbook feel), but this was fine, helped by its brevity. I did read Lady Susan after listening to it -- it is after all only around seventy pages -- and caught a few things that I missed while listening. The commentary notes it is a worthwhile work but flawed, in part because Lady Susan is so superior dramatically than the other characters. I think this is fairly accurate, though Mrs. Vernon comes off fairly well (the thesis of sexual jealousy is credible, but given her character, CV's objections are well-founded independent of that). It has the germ of a good novel, I think, the more finished work would be one providing the richer characterizations suggested by the intro here.

Austen, of course, literally "wrote" things, since we are talking about the days before the typewriter. The epistolary novel underlines the importance of letters in that day and age, though the introduction suggests others were more literary in their personal letters than JA was. Jane Austen: A Companion, a mixed bag guide to the Austen universe (good brief bio, some tedious and at times incomplete discussions), does suggest some interesting aspects. Unfortunately, her sister destroyed some of her letters that dealt with personal matters such as the death of Cassandra Austen's intended, so we do not a complete view there. Letter writing is not as important these days, emails and so forth providing a long form alternative when one cannot simply speak to a person on the phone.

I'm not sure, however, that learning cursive is quite akin to "like being able to churn butter and knowing how to hitch a horse to a wagon," though with a report of Indiana no longer making it a requirement, many seem to think so. I might just be getting old, but really now? I took classes five years ago in which handwritten class assignments and tests were involved. Unless public schools have personal computers for each student, I'm unsure how tests are done these days. People still write notes and so forth that require that thing known as "writing," and block printing is a tedious way to go if you have a lot to write. Again, in school, this would be rather relevant. Finally, there is probably a degree of skill and grace involved that puts one in good stead. I say this as someone who has lousy handwriting and whose teacher once pointed to the charm of word processing in my case.

One more thing -- it was noted that some have a condition that makes cursive difficult. I find this unconvincing. I reckon that others might have some condition where cursive is easier in some fashion, particularly given the nature of writing it is different. There is a certain easy flow involved that -- though I might be wrong -- probably helps certain people as compared to those who have to write in block letters. Any number of things, including related to typing and reading computer screens, can be a problem for people with a given condition. It is not a reason to not teach something. And, as to time spent, how much time does it really take? Schedule the time differently; continue to teach cursive.

---

* The notes are helpful given the Austen universe has various components that the modern day reader might not fully understand, but the absence in the Signet Classics version overall was not a major defecit for me given the overall charm of the volumes (including for most an introduction and for some another essay after the book was done).

But, they are somewhat overdone here and elsewhere in the editions that I do not favor, though the introduction in this copy is a fair length. The need to note the various word edits involved is unclear. It must have killed the editor to determine Lady Susan didn't require any notes regarding "obscure points of meaning or social detail." Given a felt need to discuss "leeches" in another work here, I somewhat question this.

FNL

A busy episode that was chock full with penultimate episode plot that basically all worked (the Luke rejecting Becky bit didn't quite work); nice to see Tyra again though she and Matt look darn old for people around twenty. Tami does pissed well. Her mom even had a cameo.

Friday, July 08, 2011

Jane Austen's Bad Girl

Reginald is never easy unless we are by ourselves, and when the weather is tolerable, we pace the shrubbery for hours together. I like him on the whole very well; he is clever and has a good deal to say, but he is sometimes impertinent and troublesome. There is a sort of ridiculous delicacy about him which requires the fullest explanation of whatever he may have heard to my disadvantage, and is never satisfied till he thinks he has ascertained the beginning and end of everything. This is one sort of love, but I confess it does not particularly recommend itself to me. I infinitely prefer the tender and liberal spirit of Mainwaring, which, impressed with the deepest conviction of my merit, is satisfied that whatever I do must be right; and look with a degree of contempt on the inquisitive and doubtful fancies of that heart which seems always debating on the reasonableness of its emotions.

-- Lady Susan
Lady Susan is a short epistolary novel (the letter format common in the 18th Century) by Jane Austen, which is quite different from the six novels published by her (the last two posthumously via her brother). It is an amusing affair about a 30-something scheming recent widow to get her Fanny Price-like daughter married off while finding amusement of her own. It starts with her running away from trouble (arising from an affair she was having while keeping his sister from getting a man LS wants for her own daughter, though said daughter wants no part of it). The plot gets a bit intricate, especially given trying to keep everyone in order in the letter format (we read letters from various characters, which is interesting). I found drawing up a character family tree of sorts helpful. Austen ends things with a regular non-letter conclusion, which might have been tacked on later.

The letter format is a bit tedious (especially later on when lengthy letters are required to fully express what happened) but the scheming (letters to a friend* providing a means to show her true thoughts) is fun. A current day revisionist attempt [Lady Vernon and Her Daughter] to explain that LS is actually a good person sounds like a ruining the fun sort of deal. The shortness of the novel, the somewhat creaky technique and the unAusten-like morals of the lead suggests why Jane Austen never had it published. It was included in a later biography by a relative. Such slightly wicked charm is left to supporting characters in her novels, but this early effort underlines Austen's abilities. One almost wishes she could have wrote a full length book with such a lead.

The novel, as with many other works in the public domain, can be found online. Project Gutenberg in fact has an audio version with different people doing each role. It is a quite good effort though again I found the longer letters hard going. It paid to have the text available to skim over stuff that I didn't quite get the first time. Austen is often re-read anyway and listening (especially while doing something) only makes a first read that much more productive.

---

* Of a similar sentiment, as shown by this excerpt:
What could I do! Facts are such horrid things! All is by this time known to De Courcy, who is now alone with Mr. Johnson. Do not accuse me; indeed, it was impossible to prevent it. Mr. Johnson has for some time suspected De Courcy of intending to marry you, and would speak with him alone as soon as he knew him to be in the house. That detestable Mrs. Mainwaring, who, for your comfort, has fretted herself thinner and uglier than ever, is still here, and they have been all closeted together. What can be done? At any rate, I hope he will plague his wife more than ever.
Some characters in her novels are bitchy, but this has some bite!

Annoying

Lite Beer is annoying in general (how macho!), which might be why there has to be so many commercials to insist that it is so great. But, "here we go" is an especially annoying slogan.

Thursday, July 07, 2011

SG's First Loss?

The effort discussed 7/4 failed, 5-4, and the person executed. No surprise. A short stay for the reasons Breyer spells out works for me, but "hypothetical legislation" is a somewhat iffy thing.

Wednesday, July 06, 2011

DOMA Attacked Again By Obama DOJ

The Obama DOJ is strengthening its efforts in opposing DOMA, supporting Karen Golinski's claim for SSM federal benefits. [Edit: It says a reasonable argument can be made for rational basis. Not sure if this means they totally concede the point. Still, fail.] More here.

Tuesday, July 05, 2011

Quickies

A somewhat saner Cuba Policy (Congress blocks a better one) -- yet another reason Obama is better than Bush. Dawn Johnsen criticizes Obama with a degree of perspective (reading GG?). More on Clinton's (D-NY) replacement, who so many deemed a lousy choice.

Monday, July 04, 2011

The Coming Revolution?




This is a review of the book The Coming Revolution Signs from America's Past That Signal Our Nation's Future By Dr. Richard Lee, which I received from Book Sneeze in return for providing a review for my blog and a major book selling website.

I chose the book because of an interest in American history and how people interpret its meaning. The book uses an expansive look at the Founding of the U.S. to provide a warning to the problems of today. The problems can be summarized as the lack of religious spirit, the lack of patriotism taught in schools, and the breakdown of the traditional family unit. It is one of those books that promotes the idea that a rightful understanding of our history can be a guide to how to live today. Of course, this results in various views of just what our history means and this is no different in that respect. Overall, on that front, I am not convinced. A selective reading can get you to the conservative place this book wants you to go, but a full-fledged one does not. What "is" is not the same as what allegedly "ought."

The perilous of the approach is suggested by one review: "I would have also liked to have seen the author show a little more non-bias in his recounting of history, which I believe will lead to most non-believers disavowing this book very early on." This from someone who (unlike I) shares its overall point of view. I guess it might be useful to understand what a true believer thinks. Acceptable on that level though if you actually want a historical account, not a moral one, I suggest you go elsewhere. 

Two stars. 


Solicitor General Starts Job On A Good Note

The Obama Administration takes the rare step of urging the Court to block temporarily a state from executing a convicted individual — in this case, a Mexican national who contends that Texas violated his rights under an international treaty, the Vienna Convention.
Item.

An ongoing issue (it's discussed here back in 2005) is the right to consular assistance for foreign nationals charged in another country that is enshrined in a treaty the U.S. signed in 1969. The Roberts Court held that to give teeth to this requires Congress to pass enabling legislation, ruling against a determination by the Bush Administration that held otherwise. Such legislation was passed to enforce an anti-torture treaty.

Such legislation is pending; it would give a foreign national the right to a court hearing to determine if non-notification "caused actual prejudice to the defendant in the process of administration of criminal justice." [I quote Justice Stevens' concurring opinion.] Stevens as well as the dissenters supported a stay in that case to give Congress time to pass legislation to no avail.

The new Solicitor General, who was involved in a lethal injection case a few years back, asked the Supreme Court to stay the execution of Humberto Leal Garcia (due to die this week) to give Congress time to pass such legislation. His case is discussed here.  Five justices are needed for a stay.  Important as that is, it unfortunately seems like as much of a long-shot as the legislation passing soon. But, knock on wood.

[Idea of post expanded upon.]

Stand up, John!

I see fireworks! I see the pagaent and
Pomp and parade
I hear the bells ringing out
I hear the cannons roar
I see Americans - all Americans
Free forever more
"Molasses to Rum" is powerful stuff too.

FNL Had a Subpar S2 too ...

I have praised the Cinemax shows Lingerie and Life On Top, but it seems like Season 2 of the latter has various new characters that aren't as interesting. The apparent conclusion of S2 of Lingerie was pretty good though. The same core staying helped.

Sunday, July 03, 2011

Bongs Hits: The Book

The "Bong Hits 4 Jesus" case was something of a "lame ass" affair. James C. Foster's book, with loads of notes and source citations, was rather pretentious. It covers the subject okay if not great; the problem was the style. Material is prime but the result is not.

Saturday, July 02, 2011

Not FULL Terms ...

Mr. Weiner, a seven-term Democrat who was once viewed as a rising star in the party, resigned on June 16 after being felled by a scandal over his lewd online behavior.
Not a bad run. Ended badly though.

FNL

I discuss the episode some here. 

Friday, July 01, 2011

Male Circumcision

Largely concur with the sentiments discussed here, particularly how it is trivial next to the female version.  OTOH, I really don't see it as a BIG autonomy issue, personally, and can name other much more harmful childhood stuff like some forms of education.

Medicinal Marijuana: Federal Policy

Obama has been disappointing on this (my thoughts on the general issue), but his policy was never great anyhow and clearly the ball is in Congress' court. Various comments of the "same boss" variety are tiresome as I note.  And, the Republicans are just worse.

Thursday, June 30, 2011

Little Known Constitutional Provision Alert

Debt ceilings are issues for both individuals and the nation these days and as Jack Balkin and others note, paying OUR debts has constitutional significance.  We went down a somewhat similar road with Social Security a few years back.  What's next, the 3A?

No Justice: Token "Looking Back" Edition

This is pretty pathetic. More so that it is more than you expected.

Mets: Ruining the Buzz Edition


 
They also clinched a series win and, at 41-39, rose to two games above .500 for the first time since April 5. This is a team that was not expected to contend, and is still not contending - but it is playing respectably, and enjoying the moment.
What does this modest success mean, and how far will it take this team? It is useful to remember that, exactly one year before Wednesday night's game, the Jerry Manuel Mets were 43-34, and that record did not even represent their peak. They finished the year 79-83, lousy enough to cost the manager and general manager their jobs.

Our point? These Mets have not proven anything yet.

See here and here.  Yeah, okay.  Still, enjoy the moment. 

Wednesday, June 29, 2011

A Bit of History ...



Who needs time machines when you have books?  Once read Mr. Justice (edited by Allison Dunham and Philip Kurland, both men), a collection of mini-biographies of justices that included a chapter by one Mr. (sic) John Paul Stevens. The edition was published before he was even a federal judge, the library copy so old that it had an old address for the Mid-Manhattan library.  The book had accounts of justices from Marshall to Rutledge (Stevens was his clerk).

I recently also re-read a book, Justice William Johnson: The First Dissenter written a bit earlier than that.  The book is a bit of a trudge at times, but overall, it is an interesting account (focused largely on his career, his family basically disappearing after they came on the scene) of a largely unknown moderate Republican voice on the Marshall Court.  He had a restrained view of judicial power, but also accepted the basic lines of Marshall's view on the Commerce Power.  So much that when a state law infringed upon it (and the treaty power), he strongly rejected it, even it was a law involving black sailors coming from his own state of South Carolina.  He also rejected what he felt was hysteria over slave uprisings in other areas, including cutting back on due process rights.  I wrote the below early in the Bush Presidency.

A bit of history ....

Background: The slavery question was beginning to cause major excitement, especially after the Missouri Compromise.  A planned slave uprising was recently put down, and Charleston, SC strongly dealt with those accused, using special judicial proceedings ... but note even slaves in the heart of the slave South had judicial proceedings, if with limited rights.  Supreme Court Justice William Johnson (a South Carolina slave owner) was upset, since basic rights such as being able to confront one's accusers and seeing the evidence against you were not being protected.  As the proceedings went on, he publicly used an apparent earlier miscarriage of justice involving a slave to serve as a warning.  His fellow citizens were not pleased.  Thus, his sad words to Thomas Jefferson about a year later:
"I ... begin to to feel lonely among the men of the present day. And I am sorry to tell you, particularly so in this place. This last summer has furnished but too much cause for shame and anguish.  I have lived to see what I really never believed it possible I could see, --- courts held with closed doors, and mean dying by scores who had never seen the faces nor heard the voices of their accusers.  I see that your governor has noticed the alarm of insurrection which prevailed ... the best way in the world to make them [the people] tractable is to frighten them to death; and to magnify danger is to magnify the claims of those who arrest it .... strangers are alarmed at coming near us; our slaves rendered uneasy; the confidence between us and our domestics destroyed."

"[T]he governor ... consulted the attorney general on the legality of their proceedings, and you will be astonished to hear that he gave a direct opinion in favour of it. If such be the law of this country, this shall not long be my country."
The governor was concerned abuses occurred, and made such concerns official:
"The rules which universally obtain among civilized nations, in the judicial investigation of crime, are not merely hypothetical, or simply matter of opinion, but the result of the highest intelligence, instructed and matured by experience. They are given as guides, to assist the imperfections of human reason, and to enable it to combine and compare the various circumstances and probabilities, which occur in every case. Few minds are competent without these aids, to develop intricate affections of the heart."
But the state legislature was not pleased, and tabled the move to officially accept his statements. Instead, the state moved slowly toward their extreme defense of slavery, including harsh treatment of black (negro) citizens, such as trying to block entry of black seamen.  Of course, later there was a move to declare that all former slaves could never become citizens.  Congress also passed a law allowing alleged fugitive slaves to be returned to slavery without basic constitutional rights of "persons" (including some who might actually be free and therefore "innocent") put in place. Likewise, whites were harmed, such as not being able to receive certain literature or even to free slaves when they desired to do so.

Currently, another "major excitement" has led to serious threats to basic liberties, and another disfavored group are the primary victims, though in the process everyone is hurt. This includes the distrust and fear (and concurrent ire and desire to strike back) between us and those that are being victimized.  Finally, we are again left with a choice: respect our basic constitutional liberties, in place because of their value in obtaining our true happiness, or continue on a road of oppression toward total disharmony. Remember also, that things didn't look that bleak overall in the 1820s, but that didn't mean the seeds of future horrors were not being sowed.  

Legal Tidbits

After a break, the often interesting Findlaw commentary essays are back.  Another appeals court upheld the PPACA, conservative darling Judge Sutton concurring.  His dubious "not a tax" discussion suggests problems, but this is a big win for supporters.  Inactivity, huh?

Monday, June 27, 2011

Scarecrow and Mrs. King

Watching the various episodes of S1. Well done overall, though too many killings for what amounts to light entertainment. I love Kate Jackson's voice.  I thought it was geared to the calm somewhat befuddled suburban mom here, but she sounded the same elsewhere.

Supreme Court Watch

Final rulings.

I think Citizens United was okay, but today's campaign finance ruling was much more hinky. Kagan's voice comes out in dissent. "Except in a world gone topsy-turvy, additional campaign speech and electoral competition is not a First Amendment injury." I'm tired of simplistic statements of what CU stands for, but whatever this opinion means (and it will lead to more confusion in determining what public financing laws are okay) leads me to think that the critics have some degree of truth in their scorn.  Not that I find it pleasing that each side is spitting at each other. 

It was apparent that a California law that banned the sale of certain types of violent video games being sold to minors would fail, the only question is how badly. Interesting result. Scalia led the way, Alito/Roberts rested more on vagueness, Thomas dissented on his understanding of original understanding's limited protection of minors and Breyer on his pragmatic view that this wasn't too much of a limitation on freedom of speech. The statement that free speech is "principally to protect discourse on public matters" troubles me if it has any bite, but the idea children on their own have First Amendment (and others?) interests me.

Two other rulings, one unanimous (doesn't look that notable), one split various ways with Ginsburg (according to Scotusblog) orally dissenting, suggesting it is of some importance. It concerns personal jurisdiction, which can be important given it determines who gets to go to court, but Breyer/Alito's concurrence also limited the reach of the opinion. The Supreme Court also accepted more cases (such as concerning GPS) and Scalia had a chance to show some spleen in a dissent there. Not that big of a final day, really.

The Supreme Court goes on break and I wait a few months for my annual Cato Supreme Court volume.

"Republican Controlled Senate"

Yes, the NY Senate is split 32-30, Republican. The pro-SSM vote split 29-4. So, let's have a tad bit of perspective here. The old Senate was as evenly split, the balance a handful of conservative Democrats.

Sunday, June 26, 2011

Not Cool Blogger Of the Day

Really, David, you are not really leading me to want to read your book. "Joe" responds (masochist tendencies seen in past posts too) here.

Cool Blogger of the Day: Jen McCreight

Boobquake originator and all around charming friendly atheist JM talked about dealing with a condition known as "dermatillomania." She wanted to inform regular readers where she was and also:
Mental health has a lot of stigma attached to it because people are so embarrassed to admit anything is wrong. And frankly, it's silly. We don't tease or shame people for having bronchitis or cystic fibrosis or other physical ailments. And hell, mental health is still physical - the brain is an organ, not some disembodied spiritual puppet master. If we don't mock people for being deficient in insulin, we shouldn't mock them for being deficient in serotonin.
See also, here. Right you are, Jen, and cheers for promoting good sense again. Talking about good sense, she inserts a video as well about how not to behave around women. Common sense. Often neither. That's why we need people like JM here. Right?

Saturday, June 25, 2011

Most Charming Glass Eyed Actor Dies

Oh, there's just one more thing...
Memories.

Change Is Possible

Significant and seemingly impossible social and political change happens more often than we think, and it happens more rapidly than we realize.  Even the most momentous change is always possible if one finds the right way to make it happen.
Agreed. Some things stay the same, but things do change over time.

Friday, June 24, 2011

SSM in NY? Yes

Senate approval was the final hurdle for the same-sex marriage legislation, which is strongly supported by Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo and was approved last week by the Assembly. Mr. Cuomo is expected to sign the measure soon, and the law will go into effect 30 days later, meaning that same-sex couples could begin marrying in New York by midsummer.
The world doesn't stop, does it?  

FNL

Ticking down to finale.  The long-haired one is back.  Wasn't they going to take two weeks to decide?  Good to see Becky and Tami get some air time plus Vince's mom stand up for her son.  Some nice bits.  Pleasant enough episode that is symbolic of the season.

Scarecrow and Mrs. King

Another bit of nostalgia for people of a certain age, I passed the first season on DVD in the library.  Fun show.  I actually never saw the first episode and remember wanting to when it was still on.  This would be prime USA "characters welcome" material.  New books on panel.

Thursday, June 23, 2011

Reason To Vote Democrat

Most Republican senators say they strongly oppose the [SSM] measure on religious or moral grounds.
Not to worry. Some aren't resting on breaching the First Amendment. Some rest on politics.

Supreme Court Watch



A legal blog has had a series of posts on a recent ruling that gave some rights to those subject to incarceration at civil contempt hearings, in part noting how state courts led the field after the Supreme Court interpreted requirements somewhat narrowly.

Meanwhile, today was another decision day, though a few of the hot button cases (e.g., violent video games) were left to the final week.  The cases today were somewhat less flashy, but still legally important and divisive, the 5-4 split more prevalent than last time. For instance, yet another ruling concerning Anna Nicole Smith was a 5-4 split that struck down on constitutional grounds one aspect of a bankruptcy law. A case on the  Federal Employers’ Liability Act had an interesting split where Thomas was the swing vote, (mostly) joining with the liberals.  A tort case split the Court in more predictable lines. 

Sotomayor wrote a dissent in that case.  She also concurred separately in a Confrontation Clause case (Kagan along with Thomas didn't join a portion of the main opinion, but didn't concur separately) involving lab tests.  The case was important to the extent it sent a signal as to how the new appointees would join the expansion of the rules in that area, the matter still somewhat unclear since she (but not Kagan) suggested the case today was not as open-ended as some might suggest.  Sotomayor also was the only liberal justice who joined a ruling striking down a regulation on use of drug information. Breyer wrote the dissent, suggesting more discretion should be allowed for commercial speech regulation (and, anyway, precedent doesn't require it).  It is notable that Sotomayor joined the more restrictive majority opinion on the point. 

The cases are of some interest but nothing overly exciting jumps out.  I am somewhat annoyed that in more than one case the majority wasn't able to control themselves and not include sections that a majority of the justices were able to join.  The Vermont case is a tad technical, but generally I agree with at least somewhat stricter tests for commercial speech than Breyer would seem to require.  Not sure if this case is really anything to worry about, particularly given while listening to the orals, it seemed the law was in some fashion particularly badly drawn or litigated.  And, if the specific matter in the Confrontation Clause opinion seems somewhat minor, the basic principle of consistency in criminal protections is ideal.

Anyway, even given the last few cases, this term seemed pretty unexciting this time around, the issues of the OLC and so forth more interesting at the moment. See, here and here for a taste why we should be wary about not only the result on the meaning of the WPA regarding Libya, but how they got there. 

SSM in NY?

It doesn't get much uglier than that. Tying the fate of same-sex marriage to unrelated disputes over money should offend New Yorkers on both sides of the debate.
-- Bill Hammond
Maybe so, but it shouldn't surprise them.  Politics is about horse trading and other somewhat unsavory actions, which do not suddenly disappear when really important stuff comes to the table.  Republicans as a class are no big fan of this legislation, even if some would vote for it once introduced or if given free reign.  Their base hates it or at best would not mind if it went away.  And, if it allows them some influence over something they do care about (tax cuts, apparently) or at worst to lead to some religious exemptions and such, they will do so.

The Democrats on some other issue would do the same.  The NY legislature is an equal opportunity political machine.  Has been so for a long time -- the film 1776 joked about it with some degree of truth.  And, we aren't just talking New York here.  When did the Thirteenth Amendment pass Congress? In a lame duck session and Lincoln probably helped pave the way by promising a few goodies for the lingering votes.  The Constitution itself, including slavery, was a compromise where "unrelated disputes over money" mattered.  So it goes.

Marriage is a fundamental right but has traditionally been the discretion of the states.  This includes as it underwent various changes (e.g., women having an equal status, easy divorce laws and other matters that affected the institution much more than same sex marriage* would today) over the years.  So, though ultimately a federal constitutional issue, state by state development is essential here.  Events in California suggest it is only a matter of time there.  If New York joins in, logical since it already recognizes out of state same sex marriage (though the highest court did not decide the issue), it would be a major step forward.  [See here for my comments on why "rights" is one proper way to address this issue.]

The lieutenant governor in this state does not have the power to break ties in the state senate in respect to legislation, so a tie will not cut it there.  The measure already was passed in the assembly.  The vote in the state senate is up in the air, one or two more votes needed.  This is a six or so vote improvement since last time, which is impressive.  The talk is that if voted upon, it will easily get a majority.  Problem is that Republican leadership has yet to agree to put it to a vote.  As I said, this is understandable, but that doesn't mean it lacks ugliness.  Yet again there is more than a dime's worth of difference between the parties.

A reminder of what is at stake.  Loving v. Virginia held that race was an illegitimate classification for marriage, even if interracial marriage burdened both sides. That is, each race having the "equal" right to marry only people of the same race was not enough.  The same applies if the classification is based on sex.  Some argue the problem in Loving was racism while this classification is benign.  As with selective concern for tradition (coverture? not making spousal rape illegal? the latter was true into the 1970s) , doesn't cut it.  Stereotypical sex roles, a major concern of sex discrimination case law, is not allowed either.

Some cheapen marriage by arguing that procreation justifies the [invidious] discrimination involved here.  But a ruling on marriage of prisoners underlined that marriage is important and to be protected even if every aspect of marriage is not in place in a given case.  This lesser known case warrants an extended quote:
The right to marry, like many other rights, is subject to substantial restrictions as a result of incarceration. Many important attributes of marriage remain, however, after taking into account the limitations imposed by prison life. First, inmate marriages, like others, are expressions of emotional support and public commitment. These elements  are an important and significant aspect of the marital relationship. In addition, many religions recognize marriage as having spiritual significance; for some inmates and their spouses, therefore, the commitment of marriage may be an exercise of religious faith as well as an expression of personal dedication. Third, most inmates eventually will be released by parole or commutation, and therefore most inmate marriages are formed in the expectation that they ultimately will be fully consummated. Finally, marital status often is a precondition to the receipt of government benefits (e. g., Social Security benefits), property rights (e. g., tenancy by the entirety, inheritance rights), and other, less tangible benefits (e. g., legitimation of children born out of wedlock). These incidents of marriage, like the religious and personal aspects of the marriage commitment, are unaffected by the fact of confinement or the pursuit of legitimate corrections goals.
Clearly, all married couples do not and sometimes cannot procreate, but that is but one aspect of marriage.  This excerpt suggests the breadth of marriage, which in basically every case applies to same sex couples.  This even can include legitimation of children, which can include legal recognition of the parenthood rights of two same sex people. As another lesser known case (leading Justice Powell to question its breadth given regulations of among other things "homosexuals") noted;
Although Loving arose in the context of racial discrimination, prior and subsequent decisions of this Court confirm that the right to marry is of fundamental importance for all individuals.
The right is personal.  It should not be limited based on the sex or likely sexual preference of the partner involved.  Doing so is wrong since there is no good reason - given the reasons for the state license in question - to fence out people on such grounds.  It is bad public policy and New York should act on that ground alone.  Its courts did not join with those that saw a constitutional (state and/or federal) problem, but there is one there as well.  And, as with other marriage and relationship matters, old ways or norms are not a good reason to do otherwise.  Change occurs there slowly, over time, and we are seeing yet another development here. 

It would not shock me if politics holds up the works here, things all so close.  Hopefully not.  If so, however, the true path is apparent and it is but a matter of time.  

---

* I continue to favor this term for various reasons.  It is what is at stake. The sexual orientation of your partner isn't the issue.  It also focuses on the sexual discrimination going on.  "Gay" even is arguably a problem since it often is limited to male homosexuals.  I realize that gays are obviously a big part of this whole thing, but SSM (it even is a nice acronym) is the appropriate term to use.

Wednesday, June 22, 2011

Summer

Welcome to summer, a season less ideal for adults who don't like the beach or the heat.  The exact beginning (13:16 EST) suggests the inexactitude of things (and Daylight Savings Time) since you'd think it would occur at noon, given the whole evenly divided day thing. 

Tuesday, June 21, 2011

Life on Top and Jane Austen

I have referenced this show already, perhaps partly to note a supporting character that charmed me in such films as The Devil Wears Nada (her personality, that is; her body is fine too, but it's her personality and humor that is particularly notable). My latest satellite package ("cable" no longer fully accurate) brings with it lots of channels, including some that has late night soft porn.

Most is pretty forgettable, but as with other pay channels, there are some shows and so forth of some note. Life on Top and Lingerie included. I earlier, in a brief form of this entry, referenced the first episode of the title series. I also saw the first episode (as with other shows, child, teen and adult, the episodes are replayed often) of Lingerie. More so than Co-Ed Confidential, though that has some charm, some of the characters on these shows are interesting.

Suffice to say, long form, soft porn needs more than breasts. That's said in part since that is the most evident thing, though other parts of the body (though rarely front male ... watch prison shows for that) are seen. One thing not seen is bodily fluids. This includes sweat. These people have sex at a drop of the hat, put their clothes back on (it helps, of course, that the women tend not to wear bras ... and not only because they are too small) and go about their business. The reference to a condom (even showing it) in the Life on Top premiere is as rare as a reference in the movie cited above of a character still smelling of sex.

The series premiere of Life on Top put some effort in making us care about the female characters (Lingerie has more focus on males, though the leads are women; btw, I notice many teenage Nick/Disney show lean female, while many animated shows lean male -- very few female characters, e.g., on Bugs Bunny), who also have some acting ability. It might be assumed that acting is not the point here, but for series television (and for some, even films), it does matter. The first episode even had one of the characters lead her partner in sex (that is, tell him to "go slower") while her sister had a sexy bit of foreplay in a car.  [I saw the third episode last night and it had a quite acrobatic sex scene that looked like it required some choreography to accomplished.]

These type of shows/films rarely have such context and lack something in the process. The "Bella" (and "Regina" aka Brandin Rackley) of Life on Top were also in a few soft porn films that are basically take-offs of other films. They are amusing ... when you aren't really expecting much, a bit of something means a lot. I guess it might be a matter of taste, but in this area, I like a bit more than soft porn sex with cheap music and a 50/50 shot (at least) of fake boobs. Tiresome. Might have to see what Disney/Nick re-run is on instead. Seriously, a bit of "pillow talk" and character goes a long way.

These shows have some, though watching a few episodes beyond the pilots, not enough. Still, the acting and writing is pleasant enough to be worth a look some night. It brings to mind a show from the 1990s (a "Desperate Housewife" was in the cast, long before she was that well known) called Bedtime, a cable soap opera with some explicit sex. I will now shift gears.

A re-viewing of The Jane Austen Book Club took place about the same time I tried Austen's first book (if one released after she died), since it seemed to have amusing elements and was pretty short. I was somewhat disappointed with it, since it didn't seem to focus enough on the "abbey" of the title. Persuasion kind of felt the same way -- after the lengths of the other books (and I have not yet read her longest, Emma), it seemed a bit too abrupt. The satire of "abbey" was not given enough attention in my opinion and too much of it took place at Bath.

The charm of her writing is her felicity of expression, the emotional lives of some of her characters and (often in particular) the many boobs and knaves among her casts. Like in many an adventure story, the good guys often aren't what makes or breaks things. It is the flawed characters, particularly the bad guys (or girls). Austen has lots of them and they are very fun. Looking at a collection of "her other writings" (including unfinished books), notes Jane herself took underlined the point. She lists various reactions to Mansfield Park, and many don't really like Fanny Price, one person thinking her "insipid," another "could not bear" her. Edward also got a mixed reaction, such as "cold and formal."

Austen's works are a social commentary of her times and she clearly finds much to fault in society, though she shows a certain "Tory" (one biography notes she was a loyal Tory) respectability. One source noted that she felt for Fanny, a bit of a dull sort who couldn't bear a somewhat racy (involving an unwed mother) play to take place while her husband was away. The notes cited shows many at the time liked Pride and Prejudice better while some even wanted Fanny to marry some lively young cad type that underwent a change of behavior once he fell for her. She had only one true love and when the love is respectable, the Austen way is predictable.

Austen had a limited range in her novels (an unpublished early work, Lady Susan, suggested she had the potential to focus on a more flawed character) in that sense. Pride and Prejudice was not only lively but had the most independent young woman character (though published later, in an early form, it was written years before) as well as the most interesting male one. Darcy fell for Elizabeth and though we read mostly about her family, he has a special role.  His emotional center of gravity fell apart and we get more of a sense of his inner feelings than male characters in other works.  More so than an Edward in Mansfield Park.  Again, I have yet to read Emma, which might be worth noting. Unfortunately, unlike her siblings, Jane died fairly young, so we did not see if future novels would go past the Fanny/Anne quiet heroine role.

I will comment on Emma (the source material for Clueless) when timely as well as whatever biography I choose to read. It is noted that Jane Austen's writings (including letters) are online, since even ridiculous modern copyright laws don't go back to 1817. Also, Becoming Jane -- not to be taken that seriously as biography (well, at least, with a large grain of salt) -- was pleasant to look at but around 1/2 way in, I got bored.

[Update: The commentary track was done in such a plodding way that it too was tedious.  I do think the lead, who actually wrote a thesis paper on JA, was pretty good. The film as a whole didn't do it for me, though.] 

Monday, June 20, 2011

Supreme Court Watch


The end of the term is approaching, but there was some degree of unity in the cases handed down today. There were some interesting splits, generally in reasoning, that will be the focus today.

In the one case where there was a full 5-4 split, ruling on the issue if there is "a right to appointed counsel for indigent defendants facing incarceration in civil contempt proceedings" [update: or, if not, what is necessary] in certain cases. Roberts/Alito didn't join the section of Thomas' dissent [on why his ethic issues aren't the same as Fortas', see my comments here] that rests on original understanding.  They also didn't join a section that was concerned that the majority opinion's balancing test "does not account for the interests of the child and custodial parent." The majority did cite "any countervailing interest" factored in the analysis.  It isn't clear how important this matter was to the ruling and Roberts/Alito very well could have thought it unnecessary to deal with the point.

The Supreme Court unanimously held that class in a major Wal-Mart gender discrimination suit should not have been certified, though four (via Ginsburg) would have done more to leave open an alternative route.  This case has received a decent amount of press (see, e.g., Slate or Democracy Now!), but it is not really that surprising that the broad claim that tried to bring in so many people failed. As with some other rulings this term, some will find this a very troubling development, but not sure how bad it is, long term.  Devil in details.

An attempt to use the federal courts to bring broad environmental claims that the EPA would logically handle was rejected, not surprisingly.  Sotomayor recused (it was from her old circuit), the Court was split on standing, the lower court upheld by an evenly divided court.  On the merits, Alito/Thomas felt obligated to remind people they disagreed with an earlier ruling, but since each side assumed its legitimacy, they would go along with the majority.  I find such a thing a tad bit gratuitous but it is a way for justices to continue not to respect precedent they find particularly wrong in some fashion. 

Kennedy wrote an interesting Petition Clause case that unanimously (Scalia and Thomas not agreeing with all the reasoning)  rejecting the claim because a public employee was involved and the petition was not a matter of public concern.  Scalia didn't want to accept that the clause applies to petitioning the courts, noting the matter was only cited in dicta (one case written by Justice Douglas, singled out by name, which is um interesting) .  Thomas said he basically agreed with Scalia's comments but brought up some other reason to rule as the majority did, yet again figuring out some idiosyncratic reasoning ala Stevens might.

Scalia's opinion has more than one interesting bit of reasoning that comes off as assumptions.  For instance, "a pre-existing individual right" like this one "means that we must look to historical practice to determine its scope."  Is the rule different for other constitutional rights? Why?  Also, when is "core" aspects not the right question (possible hint: when you aren't writing a compromise majority opinion?)? Scalia honestly notes that various scholars have refuted his stance on petitioning courts. This only reaffirms the limits of "original understanding." He also thinks saying the clause largely deals with "personal grievances" undersells things, but as the majority notes, many petitions (e.g., against slavery) were quite "public" in scope. 

Scalia actually dissented in part. I don't think "there should be no doctrinal distinction between them unless the history or tradition of the Petition Clause justifies it" (when the text doesn't clearly compel) is the reason, but am inclined to agree that a "public concern" limit to bring claims very well might be a problem.   But, the partial opening Scalia would allow in this case is barely discussed and not really taken too seriously.  It is basically since the other side didn't bother to dispute it.  So, I don't know how much value it really provides at the end of the day.

A few big cases, including involving video games, forthcoming.

Drop Dead Diva

The premiere had some cute moments, including a nice opening musical number and "gotta love Stacey" stuff.  Kim also continues to be someone you can root for.  The law stuff is still a bit weak. Will Grayson really marry? Decent start.  This quote got me a few hits.

Sunday, June 19, 2011

Pet Peeve

The inability of some to see your point of view. It is not about disagreeing. It is about not even appearing to try to understand or respond to your arguments. Often done with an attitude or general clueless tone.  We are lost if we can't even truly discuss things.

Persuasion

This is Austen's last completed novel and is shorter than all but one of them.  Has various good Austen touches, including flawed supporting cast and some of her strongest emotional touches.  Story is not as extended as her best. Middle of the road Austen, perhaps.

Saturday, June 18, 2011

FNL

I saw that Season Five is already in the library, but will hold back until I see some more on regular t.v.  The set has various extras, including commentary, so should be good. The episode this week was okay with Matt, I mean Luke, getting the victory.  Four episodes left.

Thursday, June 16, 2011

Empathy is part of judging

The same day the Supreme Court (7-2) didn't apply the exclusionary rule to certain cases on appeal,* they ruled 5-4 to consider the age of the person when trying Miranda cases. Dahlia Lithwick used this to support "empathy" in judging. I'm not sure if it is the best example, but perhaps it is a decent one. I provided the below reply in the fray.  I have dealt with the issue of empathy in judging a few times already, but since it is repeatedly used as bludgeon in court fights, deemed "liberal" when so done, a periodic reminder seems appropriate. 

An article cited by Lithwick notes:
If anything, Obama’s comment was more neutral than Roosevelt’s. Roosevelt twice used “sympathy” which connotes identification with, or bias toward, another. “Empathy,” Obama’s misconstrued word, simply implies an understanding of, and sensitivity to, the feelings or experiences of another, not any predisposition in favor.
As Justice Blackmun once said:
There is another world "out there," the existence of which the Court, I suspect, either chooses to ignore or fears to recognize.
This is not a "liberal" or "conservative" world in any given case. The "common sense" or "grim roster of victims" (to quote Scalia and Alito in the recent California prison crowding case) the judge takes note of can be of a conservative variety. Each judge brings his or her own experiences and perspectives, which is the value of having multi-member benches as much as twelve jurors. This fact, as with Judge Walker being in a same sex relationship, doesn't make them unable to uphold their oath to evenhandedly apply the law. But, judges are not machines. They bring forth points of view. They bring with them human empathy, which is part of how they do their job.

We should be careful to take such judging purely on face value, as a simple application of the law, full stop. Such simplistic compulsion led judges to say that Dred Scott was merely what the Constitution demanded, human sympathy notwithstanding. Alito in dissent in the case here:
a "core virtue" of Miranda has been the clarity
Meanwhile, in a Fourth Amendment case he wrote that was released today:
When the police exhibit “deliberate,” “reckless,” or “grossly negligent” disregard for Fourth Amendment rights, the deterrent value of exclusion is strong and tends to outweigh the resulting costs. Id., at 144 . But when the police act with an objectively “reasonable good-faith belief” that their conduct is lawful,
All quite "clear" concepts, unlike taking into consideration the youth of the person interrogated! Lithwick again:
Therefore, she explains, "a reasonable child subjected to police questioning will sometimes feel pressured to submit when a reasonable adult would feel free to go" and that—empathy alert!—"such conclusions apply broadly to children as a class. And, they are self-evident to anyone who was a child once himself, including any police officer or judge."
Empathy or a reasonable approach to the question? But, "reasonable" is not a dry affair, without context or spirit. A spouse or friend who cries "be reasonable!" speaks from a certain point of view and position that the person s/he is trying to convince might simply not accept. A certain understanding that results in them being on a "different wavelength," which might explain how sometimes around here I simply do not seem to be "got" by some people (and they feel the same way, vice versa). Some understanding of another p.o.v., some ability to stand in someone else's shoes, some "empathy" is necessary to be able to even possibly reach some common ground.

It is also necessary to judge. How to properly balance the evidence and determine reasonableness which requires applying rules to people unlike yourself? You need to understand the experiences of others. You need to empathize. As Dahlia notes, each justice does it. As they should. The charade that it is somehow illegitimate was but one annoying aspect of recent Court nomination hearings.
--

* I respect the dissent, but can't get too worked up over not applying exclusionary rule guidelines not even in place (except in the ether as part of the Constitution) when the event occurred. The troubling part of the ruling really is the continued use of anti-exclusionary rule rhetoric and it is a small favor, if appreciated, that Sotomayor (but not Kagan) concurred separately.

She not only avoided the rhetoric but suggested the rule set forth is even narrower than possibly the case (see dissent). This plus (unfortunate) precedent makes the decision not that bad. The rhetoric is the true problem. And, Sotomayor's concurrence also suggests the "Obama's justices will help the burial" of the rule is a tad overplayed too.

Glenn Greenwald Tweet: Oh Shut Up

Anthony Weiner was forced from office, but George Bush & Dick Cheney - torture, illegal eavesdropping, 100,000s dead in Iraq - weren't.
Yeah, a lowly member [OTOH] of Congress is more disposable than the president and vice president in part for stuff Congress authorized (especially Iraq). Meanwhile, Bob Herbert accepts reality.

Wednesday, June 15, 2011

The "little bit pregnant" defense

Libya Edition. Yeah, don't really buy it.

Pride and Prejudice

My original review is here; I listened to the commentary track recently and enjoyed it. The movie is fairly loyal to the book though a few things are passed over largely to fit into a theatrical release.

Tuesday, June 14, 2011

Gay Rights: Good News Comes In Threes

The path to marriage equality has advanced in various areas of late. A bankruptcy ruling, a rejection of a Walker recusal claim and (best of all) a step closer to marriage equality in New York suggests sometimes good news comes in threes.

The basic sentiment of the recusal ruling is that being in a same sex relationship is no less a barrier to deciding the issue than being a woman would be when their equal rights were at stake. A judge can be trusted to do his/her job in such cases and beliefs otherwise are "unreasonable" under our system. A claim otherwise might need not be deemed "appalling" to be shown to be weak.

The basic rule put forth:
The fact that a federal judge shares a fundamental characteristic with a litigant, or shares membership in a large association such as a religion, has been categorically rejected by federal courts as a sole basis for requiring a judge to recuse her or himself.
Thus, another ruling held that "recusal was not warranted ... in an action brought by an abortion clinic against protestors of the clinic where one of the presiding panel judges belonged to the Catholic faith." Also, the claim of appearance of bias rests on "assumptions about the amorphous personal feelings of judges in regards to such intimate and shifting matters as future desire to undergo an abortion, to send a child to a particular university or to engage in family planning."

The judge in this position is in the same position as "the general public" and the alternative ignores that when deciding such questions ultimately as a legal matter, "we all have an equal stake in a case that challenges the constitutionality of a restriction on a fundamental right." The heterosexual could be as concerned if s/he thinks the law is acceptable as a way to protect marriage. I would add that some possible personal factor added only underlines the value of a diverse bench, just as sexuality shouldn't lead a person to be unable to be on a jury deciding an alleged hate crime.

To single out Walker might not rest things on sexual orientation alone but still ultimately rest "on the sole ground of Judge Walker’s same-sex relationship.” After all, there was no evidence of him planning to get married (this alone underlines why the claim was weak as applied to this case though in some theoretical case, the matter might be less easy) and a person in a different sex marriage can have concerns about the law as well. Such a de facto focus on personal characteristic has been rejected.

Some might have a kneejerk feeling that it is not totally off or bigoted to think Walker could not avoid an appearance of impropriety. But, it is hard to imagine such a rule would be truly applied evenhandedly. Any number of cases involve rights that might benefit the judge as well as the general public; did the judges in the Connecticut contraceptive cases have to lack an interest in using them? The logic of Prop 8 suggests the different sex judge (especially since the rules apply to something that involves a spouse and minor children) would be interested, since the law is "necessary" to protect their marriage or the safety of their children.

The bankruptcy ruling underlines the breadth of anti-SSM rules in place, including many federal rights that are reliant on different sex marriage. If you don't want to call it "marriage," what interest is there to deny bankruptcy protection to same sex couples, particularly if you do accept they can have "civil union" benefits. The chance that a few final votes will be found in the NY Senate (and the new governor is pressing the issue without having the weak hand of the old one) would mean a major success particularly given the likelihood California will follow in one way or the other within the next couple years.

I have a personal stake given my own state is involved. I recall the days when DADT first was an issue and Hawaii led the way on the idea of SSM. My access to the Internet wasn't the only things that changed and continue to change since then. Progress is not always in a consistent direction, but on this issue, remarkable changes have come to pass. More will follow.

Flag Day

Happy Flag Day!

Two Women

Netflix's dubbed version is a bit annoying, but it is done pretty well, though a bit of the dialogue doesn't work. As a whole, very good Sophie Loren. I was a bit surprised the rape came so late; the post-rape stuff seems a bit too brief.  Overall, powerful stuff.

"Justice"


Jesus answered, “You are right in saying I am a king. In fact, for this reason I was born, and for this I came into the world, to testify to the truth. Everyone on the side of truth listens to me.”
“What is truth?” Pilate asked
- John 18 (NIV)
There's justice in the barrel / Of a loaded gun
- Bon Jovi
What is "justice"?

Is it based on the "justice system" so that President Obama misused the term when he said OBL being killed ("shot in the head") was an act of justice? The use of rules of engagement, targeting someone who otherwise under the rules of armed conflict could be killed (not just a random "bad guy") and taking into consideration other issues (like his ability for years, if desired, to surrender to Pakistan officials, if desired) would not change this. It might be "moral" or "acceptable," though some think not, but it isn't "justice."

[I reference in this discussion arguments made in a few posts over at the Jurisprudence Slate fray.]

Wikipedia says:
Justice is the concept of moral rightness based on ethics, rationality, law, natural law, religion, fairness, or equity, along with the punishment of the breach of said ethic
Does "punishment" here only means via the court of law (here or in the hereafter)? Dictionary.com (if helpful) says this:
1. the quality of being just; righteousness, equitableness, or moral rightness: to uphold the justice of a cause. 2. rightfulness or lawfulness, as of a claim or title; justness of ground or reason: to complain with justice. 3. the moral principle determining just conduct.
Merriam Webster leads with the "the maintenance or administration" of a system that is "especially by the impartial adjustment," but this doesn't limit ourselves to the courts. When someone says "no justice, no peace," will peace only come in court? One example given:
We should strive to achieve justice for all people.
This brings to mind "social justice" as one activist promotes here. This usually doesn't just mean, though it often does partially mean, use of the "justice system," either criminal or civil. And, sometimes, the justice system, even run fine, is seen as patently unjust. The justice system, e.g., could protect slavery. Does this make the Fugitive Slave Act "justice"? And, if you seek out such "natural justice," where do you seek it out? It need not merely by the heavens as the UN Declaration of Human Rights, signed by secularists too, assumed as a given:
Whereas recognition of the inherent dignity and of the equal and inalienable rights of all members of the human family is the foundation of freedom, justice and peace in the world
Justice? This board is limited to "jurisprudence," which seems limited somewhat, but broader themes and senses of justice pop up here too. As Victoria Justice says, it is "not so easy" to determine what the word means.