About Me

My photo
This blog is the work of an educated civilian, not of an expert in the fields discussed.

Friday, September 24, 2021

SCOTUS Watch

Orals: The vet SCOTUS reporter, now retired, who used to cover the news for SCOTUSBlog might not have liked it, but many liked the justices taking turns during oral argument. The big thing for some was that Justice Thomas (who went second) actually asked questions, which he does fairly well actually.

Now that things will be back in person, the old system (with the two minute intro, "generally" without interruption) will return. But, with a twist -- if they want to, in order of seniority, the single questioning will return when the advocate's time expired/they are done arguing. This furthers the Court's already openning for expanding argument times if the judges have more things to ask. It seems a good compromise.

Someone Is Wrong On the Internet: This expert on sentencing law and policy has a side of him that is just annoying. I simply argued that the federal executions were done in a way that violated due process by a packed Court. This -- my sentiment is because he is too busy with his talking points to actually engage with what I am saying -- confused him so much.

Thursday, September 23, 2021

Local News

Mets: With ten games left, elimination is approaching, but even now a sub-.500 team not totally being so shows the weakness of the division. The Braves finally won and the Mets lost on the same night. The Braves lost today, so the elimination number holds at 4. That is a combination of Mets losses or Braves wins. Mets can still play spoil, helping Phils.

Food Delivery Reforms: Major legislation helping delivery people, who have been especially important during the days of Big V.

A summary: "City lawmakers are acting to aid workers in the booming multi-billion dollar app-based food delivery industry, scheduling a vote for Thursday on a landmark slate of bills intended to ensure bathroom access, minimum pay and more." It passed.

Tuesday, September 21, 2021

What's Cooking

A lot of even older films can be expensive on demand (it's ridiculous though yes various films are free and you have so much other stuff to watch), but this one was reasonable ($2.99 or $3.99). It is about four ethnic families (black, Asian, Hispanic, Jewish) celebrating Thanksgiving with various problems going on that mostly work themselves out somehow.

Very good cast, though the Asian family stands out a bit less even with Joan Chen. The director is better known for her English/Indian works (including Bend It Like Beckham and Bride and Prejudice). The Sven film last weekend was the original Dracula. Bela seems less scary and more silly than some vampires and the nemesis more of an old professor type. From what I can tell, great atmosphere. Did not really watch it though saw bits of it.

Monday, September 20, 2021

Supreme Court: People's Court ... and more abortion fictions

And Also: The December calendar of oral arguments was released, as you recall with live audio, and the big one is the Mississippi abortion case.   Some from the look of it  not really notable procedural order by Kavanaugh was also released. It is not really clear why it warranted a posting on the main orders page as compared as just on the case's docket page.  [Update]
Law professor Eric Segall, a nice guy who is right about various things, keeps on saying things like this (per a recent tweet):
Good morning. In 1870 SCOTUS stunned the country by ruling Congress could not make paper money legal tender for prior debts. Huge decision. One year later with 2 new Justices the Court overruled the decision. Changing judges changed the law on a huge case 1 year later. 1870-71.

This is a reference to the Legal Tender Cases, when the Supreme Court first held paper money was unconstitutional and later changed its mind. The first was 5-3 opinion; a change in court personnel (the nominees were picked in part for their different views on the issue) later made it 5-4 the other way.  

The message is that this is a sign that the Supreme Court is not really a "court," that personnel and their values is what basically determines things.  The justices didn't change the law on a range of issues.  On a particular issue, one strongly divided and novel, they did change.  

Because humans, picked by other humans (in our system, politically), are involved.  Nominations provide a key time for the people (indirectly) to affect the path of the law.  The system encourages this.  In some other system, perhaps some nominating board or something, itself regularly appointed by political actors with different views, might be involved.   

President Lincoln in his first inaugural argued the importance of allowing the people to influence the law in this fashion in novel cases.  He was talking about the principles of Dred Scott v. Sandford, and how it was appropriate for Congress and others to push back, to try to convince the Supreme Court it was wrong.  And, one might add, put new judges on the bench that might see things differently.

In practice, this does not result in rapid changes of the law in short period of times.  It can lead to changes in some respects, especially on certain issues that are given special attention.  In this case, it could very well be argued that the two new justices corrected a serious error, one that wrongly handcuffed the discretion of Congress to make fiscal policy.  The system basically worked as it should work.

A person might say, but reading his work, I don't think this is all he is saying, that the Legal Tender Cases is a red flag on the limits of judicial review.  That it is a lesson that it should be used with strong restraint.  That's a valid concern.  But, at times, there will be a quick turnaround, the people's representatives putting on the bench new people who strongly feel that something was wrongly decided.  This should be done with care. The justices surely thought they were doing so.  It is part of the system.

The justices are still acting like a court.  And, sometimes, this will be done in ways that people like me will find very wrong.  But, the law does change. So, we have to take the bitter with the sweet, though it is quite possible the judges are bad for some other reason.  Thus, the talk of how the Trump bunch got there.  The way the system should work, including its hard complexities, only make not being able to respect the legitimacy of new members that much more troubling. 

===

Abortion Briefs: The architect of the Texas anti-abortion choice / bounty law is involved in an amicus brief in support of the Mississippi law due to be heard by the Supreme Court.  It's a doozy, including use of scare quotes for "rights," aiming for rights for gays, and arguing women can just not have sex, so why do they really need abortion rights?

We also have a "moderate" originalist argument for abortion rights -- supposedly history shows that quickening is the line and quickening basically happens around fifteen weeks.  My general understanding is that it really comes closer to twenty.  On top of that, though a quick read over doesn't suggest they cover this, even pre-quickening will -- going by history -- justify a lot of other barriers such as for minors.

The level of assurance on the history and what it offers at various points seems a bit too assured.  Also, there were a variety of laws in place in 1868, including bans pre-quickening, if "minor" in nature.  They still were in place.  Originalism by this account would suggest that states had a wide discretion to basically totally ban abortion.  

Finally, this sort of thing underlines the limits of originalism, at least some fairly strict version of it.  Quickening, to remind, is feeling fetal movement. The reason it was used is that the knowledge of the time was such that was the only way to determine the fetus was alive.  Modern science, however, provides technology to do so.  Mere movement in itself does not seem to be independently much of a line.  A brain dead fetus might move. 

The article (retweeted by Segall) is a fairly common example of trying to make firm judgments, often in a way open to criticism, regarding something that doesn't truly offer what is trying to be sold. The article might appeal as a "reasonable" approach, a compromise of sorts. I think that is a sort of fool's game here based on sand.  Not that I think it would work well either.

Sunday, September 19, 2021

Sports Update

The Thursday Night Football game was Giants at Washington. The team that was a gimmee for the current Giants QB. And, though the Giants kept on making mistakes, their reliable kicker and a missed field goal at the buzzer looked like another win. If by a hair. Oh. Another penalty. Retry. The back-up QB to injured Fitz wins the game. 0-2 (of 17)

Meanwhile, the Braves (first place in the NL East) are in midst of a four game losing streak. Unfortunately, the Mets are in the midst of a five game losing streak. This is a continuing story of late of a day by day slow water elimination march. The Braves could end the fans' misery by winning a bit more. Do the fans really want the Phils (who I bet have one more screw up left in them) to sneak into the playoffs? After all, Adam W.'s Cardinals just might!

The Jets and Pats play on Sunday [blah], a pair of rookie QBs. And, the Mets play Sunday Night (they also had the Saturday Night FOX game), so no conflict! The Giants are good enough and their division weak enough that you sorta hope there; the Jets you can enjoy more with lower expecations. [But, you want more than you got today].

Saturday, September 18, 2021

Some Books

Leaving the local supermarket, I recently saw a bin with a bunch of books outside. One was various works of Nella Larsen. I wrote about a novella that is part of the book, but could not get into the book this time. This has happened a few times with books I have read. Housekeeping was particularly hard going. Just so much color possible.

Another is a book I read some years back -- Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Cafe, which was made into a pretty good film version with various good choices for the characters. An old lady in the 1980s talks to a younger woman about life in Whistle Stop, Alabama back in the day. And, we hear tell of the lives of the characters over the years. I enjoyed reading it again; I remember much of it, but a few parts I did not.

There were lots of young adult books in the mix and took one with charming title, Getting Revenge On Lauren Wood. It was decent enough, but yeah, a counsellor wrote the thing. Soon enough, since the person is good, she feels guilty about things. Spoiler alert, even if she grew to be upset about it, she did get revenge on the girl who betrayed her in eight grade. Too bad she wasn't allowed to enjoy it. Well, it was a learning experience.

Drone Strike Admitted to be "Tragic Mistake."

The Pentagon acknowledged on Friday that the last U.S. drone strike before American troops withdrew from Afghanistan was a tragic mistake that killed 10 civilians, including seven children, after initially saying it had been necessary to prevent an attack on troops.

One thing I have disagreed with some liberals on is the justification of drone strikes. People argue they amount to "assassination," have no restraints, and so on.  I disagree.

Assassination is the unauthorized murder of some political leader. For instance, no matter what is says on his tombstone, Jesse James was not "assassinated."  Killing of a person like Martin Luther King Jr. (civilian leader of a movement) is more appropriately an instance for that term. 

A military leader in an armed conflict is not either in most situations, particularly when they are killed during an authorized conflict (such as one arising from an authorization of military force) in a combat zone.  This also touches upon how drone strikes are part of a process, subject to a variety of rules.  Likewise, deadly force can be legitimate even without court process.

Also, American citizens can be killed without court process. The Civil War is a prime example, but a few American citizens also served in other foreign conflicts, at times being in harm's way.  

Note that though it doesn't cover all drone attacks, the authorization of force covering the Pakistan-Afghanistan region at the very least is a sort of "process" too -- it is a specific authorization.  Some American who went to live with the Taliban or something and became a leader of their military effort very well is fair game in the right situation.  

This does not mean drone strikes are generally a good idea. I don't think they never are justified.  I can imagine how the use of a drone to kill an enemy combatant that is an immediate threat and cannot be obtain by other means could be defensible.  But, like use of force generally, there is a lot of problems.  The news item highlights why.

It also highlights a problem with tough guy talk like President Biden saying that those who committed the attack on the airport or similar suspects have a price on their head.  A certain level of rhetoric pushes the sentiment that use of force for reprisal is necessary.  Closer calls become seen as more of a reasonable risk.  And, it simply is going to be the case that drones will kill innocents.  They aren't that pinpoint, even with the right data.

The article also the NYT itself studied the evidence, questioning the attack. It is unclear how much that led to the official finding, but probably can be said to have put some pressure on the Pentagon.  It seems there is a quick turnaround, the attack happening less than a month ago.  

Drone strikes were used particularly by the Obama Administration, the Bush Administration more concerned with two military invasions of Afghanistan and Iraq.  They seem like a less invasive approach, which they probably are, but they can also fool you.  The U.S. forces rightly left Afghanistan because military attacks and occupation is going to cause "tragic mistakes" too.  War does that.  Drones will do the same while looking "cleaner."  Something can be wrong without be wrong in other ways.

We now are hearing calls for some "accounting" -- was that such a concern in past drone strikes that somehow went wrong?  Do have one. Meanwhile, the children are still dead. As they many were during the invasion.

===

Meanwhile, France removed their diplomatic personnel from the U.S. for instructions (apparently never happened before -- even during the Quasi-War?)  because France thinks the U.S. really screwed them over regarding a military deal with Australia.  I guess Australia is less of a concern for them, or perhaps France-Australian diplomatic relations is less newsworthy here. 

[Guess they are mad at Australia too.]

I find it hard to care too much though it's notable enough to serve as a sort of footnote.  France comparing Biden to Trump surely won't help much to clam things down.  I don't recall the Trump Administration actually managing to do something this productive. I'm sure some of their people might be jealous of such "art of the deal" behavior.

Anyway, it is France after all. The U.S. is not their enemy or something.  And, the French need the U.S. too.  At some point, it is hard to imagine they won't relent, perhaps being paid off somehow. 

===

To toss in one more thing in the news, one of the ten Republicans who voted to impeach Trump (the second time) said he won't run for re-election. Recall that the election is next year, but these days, we probably do have something like continual elections on some level.  His act of "infamy" already got him a primary opponent. He figures he can win, if after a nasty primary, but doesn't want to be part of the current House majority any more.  The need for protection after voting for impeachment doesn't help.

The problem is widespread here.  It is a problem of the Republicans at large.  And, it helps turn off a few, probably more likely to be halfway decent in some sense (the true believer/willing to go along can still thrive), from being part of Congress.  We have heard for a few years now some noise -- at times Democrats too -- finding the situation more unpleasant. 

Many could have agreed that Trump crossed the line.  No.  They either avoided the responsibility or actively agreed with him.  This yet again goes beyond mere party politics to the heart of the matter. 

I was a strong opponent of the Bush43 Administration, repeatedly personally appalled by things they did.  I supported strong opposition, including filibustering judicial nominees (in hindsight, questionable).  But, Republicans have gone further down in my estimation. Down the sewer.

Friday, September 17, 2021

SCOTUS Watch: Members Realize They Are In Trouble

It's late Friday afternoon and there are no new orders or anything. But, by now, we know that we should not assume things will remain the same. Enough late Friday action. I'll post it though and edit if necessary.

Still, let's focus on multiple members of the Supreme Court (Barrett, who I refuse to label "Justice" given I find her appointment tainted, included) are out there defending their institution. The big news -- covered in the past -- is Justice Breyer promoting his overly positive view of judicial review, including on places like Colbert. Now, on some level, I appreciate him going out in the public to discuss his views. These people aren't just ivy tower above the fray sorts. They should engage with the public some more and appreciate some of their efforts.

The problem is with his message and failure to realize it is time to retire. One annoying moment was when Chris Wallace asked him about Garland not being given a hearing. Breyer started with some stupid joke that even he saw didn't go over well. Then, he said that was the "political" side -- as if it had nothing to do with him and the Court -- and if the people opposed it enough, they could change it. 

Not exactly realistic, and he is actively out there trying to sell that there is no reason to do so since the Court is doing its job, and strong opposition to it it a problem.  So, that's sorta bullshit, you know?  Breyer and probably others pine for a day when judicial nominations were bipartisan walks in the park.  So, Garland etc. looks bad.  But, they also don't actually want much change (though Breyer has said term limits seem okay and Colbert suggested only a "majority" opposed cameras), which will temper down any action to get any. 

The fact the members of the Court are at least somewhat worried or annoyed or something is suggested by the fact recently multiple members are out there responding. One red flag is that there is recent polling that suggests public support of the courts have significantly decreased.  Which is warranted given the Trump trio and all that is going on.  

For instance, Barrett is out there -- in a location named after Mitch McConnell -- trying to sell that they aren't all partisan hacks. As noted here, her (and others) attack on the media is bullshit.  If nothing else, you can try A LITTLE and avoid any connected to Mitch McConnell.  

But, as Mark Stern and others noted, each Trump nominee did not follow that rather simple rule.  Some have high bars of ethics, such as a judge not being involved in an ACS event, but there are basic rules of avoiding the appearance of impropriety here.  How about formal ethics rules for Supreme Court justices? I suppose would be basically self-enforcing (though disclosure rules could be included), but seems useful.

Justice Thomas joined the "we aren't all partisan hacks" brigade.  We have this simplistic appeal:

“I think the media makes it sound as though you are just always going right to your personal preference,” the justice lamented during a lecture at the University of Notre Dame. “So if they think you are anti-abortion or something personally, they think that’s the way you always will come out. They think you’re for this or for that. They think you become like a politician."
This is rather simplistic.  As is his comment that national leaders have “lost the capacity” to “not allow others to manipulate our institutions when we don’t get the outcomes that we like."  For instance, their abuse of the shadow docket, doing so selectively in ways that surely do come off as based on ideological factors, is an "outcome I don't like," but sometimes that is a problem.  The way the Trump picks were handled also would have been bad if a Democrat did that.  His framing is simplistic.

It is true that justices are not just politicians in robes.  There is some nuance here.  The truth is in the middle somewhere. Judicial nominations tend in some rough sense, all things being equal, to have some partisan ideological overlap.  And, more so in recent years.  And, judges aren't just automans here.  Moscow Mitch et. al. purposely worked out that certain types of judges got on the bench. It's a lie to pretend otherwise.  

(The honest answer is that personal beliefs factor in and that judicial interpretation will be influenced by them to some extent, especially given our judicial selection process. The judge's duty is to do the best they can. And, to avoid an appearance of impropriety.)  

I don't know how much change in recent years; think this article suggests a bit too much of a shift. Surely, the Warren Court did a lot.  There has been a change, including as a result of changing political winds -- there was more overlap in the past.  We could have a liberal Republican become a justice.  Something similar could be seen c. 1900 when Democrats and Republicans could put people who didn't respect racial equality and support libertarian economic stances.  

There is also the imbalance caused by the 2000 and 2016 elections.  The lower courts have been more flexible over the years.  But, the Supreme Court didn't have a Democratic appointed majority for over fifty years or a Democratic appointed Chief Justice (himself a conservative) since the Truman Administration.  That's going off the rails without the problems with the last three nominations.  

The public and some members of Congress realize something is wrong. They might talk about it somewhat simplistically.  What else is new?  Breyer, Barrett, and Thomas (and Alito in the past), however, aren't really showing themselves to be much better. Perhaps, humility is best here. 

=====

Note: I added a new website to the blogroll, Balls and Strikes, which aims to provide a progressive view of the courts.  

A major constitutional/legal dispute these days is religious liberty limits to Big V rules. Someone who is generally friendly to religious exemptions (probably too much) argues religious exemptions to vaccine mandates are problematic.  I agree, and to the extent we have had them, in recent years, there have been problems with their usage as well.

Finally, perhaps worthy of a separate entry or something, but the latest attempt to compromise on a federal voting law looks good. Manchin is for it.  Like his support of a filibustered background check years back that 90% or something of the public supported, will this actually come to anything?

Sunday, September 12, 2021

Odds and Ends

The Failed Promise: Reconstruction, Frederick Douglass, and the Impeachment of Andrew Johnson by Robert Levine was an interesting account. The beginning was the most notable with some early hints on why Andrew Johnson (Unionist and against slavery later on) seemed not a bad VP option. The book later on, though we got some interesting stuff thru the eyes of Douglas and some other black leaders, covered more familiar ground. But, overall interesting book with a Douglass speech in the appendix.

The Hallmark movie yesterday, Roadhouse Romance, was a low key affair with a basically new woman lead and a more well used male lead. The net effect was charming if a bit rough acting along the edges. Good line - country music is "three chords and the truth." The Sven movie was an Abbott and Costello monster movie that I didn't catch.

Football season began with Buffalo losing to the Steelers and the Jets losing to Carolina (where the old Jets QB went). Jets looked better in the second half. The Giants are playing Denver today, so all the "NY" teams sorta played teams they could beat though we shall see how the Giants do manage. [Not too well.]

Saturday, September 11, 2021

9/11: Twenty Years Later

As one ages, it seems that some things shouldn't really be that long ago sometimes, but it is. You watch some film or television show, for instance, and realize that it was on decades ago. Wait, is that the Winnie from Wonder Years as the lead on Hallmark movies? Is Kelly Bundy really almost fifty now? Then, various things happened, and even 2016 seems a long time ago.

9/11/01 does seem a long time ago. I was in mid-town when I first heard about it. One moment that is in my memory is a woman reporter (her sex is not too relevant, and me saying that annoyed someone, except that the voice sticks in my head, not any voice, her voice) with a cry reporting the collapse of the second tower. Passing by a church that repeatedly had funerals also. I did take the subway uptown that afternoon.

I don't think "everything changed" at the moment. Life staid basically the same for me and many others. Yes, the concept of a terrorist attacking us suddenly was real. But, one thing that helped was that it seemed something of an one-off, even though low level acts (bombing mailboxes came to mind, this was before they were altered) seemed fairly easy to do. Some were stopped. Still, we didn't suddenly become Israel or something. 

I am a live-long NYC resident so it bothered me that the attacks were used (abused) to promote some sort of misguided patriotism or that questioning Bush policies or something was seen as almost spitting on the graves of the victims.  I was in midtown; I recall seeing smoke from downtown. Midtown was largely empty of traffic even a day or two later.  When I go to the Union Square subway station, I still can see (if many sadly worn) a wall with the names of the dead.  I can easily go see the WTC site.

So much has happened since then.  The people directly affected obviously have special memories and emotional reactions.  I have limited reactions since even though I lived through it, as something of a local (did not live downtown or something), it still was "out there."  I realize it provided a moment of end of innocence for us.  But, we weren't that innocent and again it felt something of a one-off without follow-ups.  

(This might seem harsh, but compare it to mass shootings, which seem to happen again and again.  A single shooting involving little school children is a special event that you can write off somewhat.  Repeated shootings? Not so much.  Again, those directly involved, including fighting future terrorists, would feel somewhat differently.)

The end of our military presence in Afghanistan is probably well timed, though too late (like the end of World War I, ends of wars should not just be nice dates).  Some then (I was wary but not as strongly against as with Iraq II) and now question our involvement.  Seems hard to double guess when the government was harboring Bin Laden.  

Still, you go there, and it becomes open-ended.  As one person noted, killing Bi Laden provided an opening.  Obama was not Biden though -- he was less sure of himself regarding military judgment calls.  Plus, with Trump signing an agreement, Biden wasn't acting on his own either.  Made it easier.  Not easy -- had to stick to it -- but easier. 

I have no profound thoughts for 9/11 twenty years later.  Other than this entry, I have no special things to do or anything.  Local baseball teams honored it, the Mets stadium serving as a emergency center at the time, and the manager (Bobby Valentine) having an emotional connection.  The "American Pastime" has general symbolic meaning there.

It is still a memory, sort of my JFK assassination, though I think America was a bit more hard-ended by 2001. 

Friday, September 10, 2021

Odds and Ends

Supreme Court: The Order List is one page. For one case, "The motion of petitioner to dispense with printing the joint appendix is granted." Various rehearings were denied. Kagan didn't take part in one involving the U.S., probably her being involved in the case when she was solicitor general.

They will do the "long conference" to deal with a bunch of pending stuff around the end of the month. First Monday in October (beginning of the 2021 Term) is fast approaching. Oh, Breyer is continuing to promote his book and annoying liberals.

Books: I have been adding content on the Teach N Thrive website (see blog panel) for a while now. The web creator is expanding to books, but the website is not up yet. When it is, I will provide basically history book reviews, including a few covered here. 

I read or skimmed a couple books by Peter J. Hotez, a vaccine scientist.  He mentioned Paul Offit, who is in the same field, but has done more media/advocacy (including books about various scams).  I found Bad Advice: Or Why Celebrities, Politicians, and Activists Aren't Your Best Source of Health Information on a library free rack. No one wants to buy it on Ebay yet, but it's an interesting and down to earth book.  While covering the subtitle, you learn something about his life and work. 

(The practice of NYPL to provide a rack or little red kiosk for free books, including those donated or taken out of circulation, is a good idea. It's like Strand Book Store or some other store having a cheap rack, which has a lot of eh stuff but you can find some good stuff there.) 

Sports: NFL is back with a Thursday Night Football game (a Tampa game being over after 11:30 PM seems unnecessary) that was the proverbial "good" (if at times messy, including a key missed XP) game between Dallas and Tampa.  Let's say if Dallas is this good consistently, the Giants should try to find a way to sneak in as a wild card team. 

Pretty Boy won on a final drive, as required. Dallas stopped them repeatedly, one of the scores a result of a turnover, but of course, in the final eighty or so seconds, they couldn't find a way to stop them from scoring the winning field goal.  It's getting a tad old, and I'm sorry, the result is not that "great" when it is same old same old.  

Baseball is still going on.  The Yanks are in the midst of a losing streak, allowing the Blue Jays (long winning streak) to knock at the door. Problem is that is it is hard to sustain that sort of thing and hope the Yanks stay away.  Still, at the moment, the Blue Jays are only a half game away from the Wild Card with the Red Sox and Yanks basically tied up.

The Mets had two weeks of the Marlins and Nats and managed to go 9-5. The Braves had to deal with the West, so that allowed the Mets to gain a bit of ground, but struggling to even win those games (they just went 1-2 vs the Marlins) doesn't bode well for their mid-September real team run.  The Braves didn't make it easier for themselves, but managed eventually to win in the 10th (with a two out hit) to lead the Mets by five games, less so the Phils, who continue to tease.  

There are some races technically open though it might be the only real battle is for the last NL Wild Card slot, which the Reds had for a bit, but now are a bit behind the Padres.  The Padres had a major slide of their own, but I think they somehow will manage it. 

The Giants have a bit of breathing room versus the Dodgers, but it would not surprise if the Dodgers sneak up on them. Since a Wild Card game is a crapshoot in many cases, winning the division there is very important.  

More Baseball: A look at the paper provides some more baseball fodder. So, Mets fans are upset that they were once up for four games and eventually were down by 8.5 (now 5) in the course of August? 

How about this stat from ex-Mets reporter KA:  "On August 27, the Blue Jays were 9.5 games behind the Yankees, they are now just a half-game back (and tied in the loss column) for the second American League Wild Card spot."  Ouchie.  This was after it looked like the Yanks went on a nice run after the break and had a comfortable lead in the Wild Card race.

(But, they still have the lead, if barely. The Mets can factor in a bit with a Subway Series coming up next.) 

[Update: The Yanks played poorly in the first game, but showing how hard it is to catch up, the Blue Jays blew a chance to get a wild card slot by losing to the Orioles.  The Braves won, but the Phils lost, so the Mets are closer to being in second place.]

Meanwhile, after a National pitcher was tossed early for hitting a player, the Nats player who was hit earlier that seems to have led to targeting later basically won the game for them.  Even with the Nats having to go with long relief.  That is probably the best way to send a message.

Thursday, September 09, 2021

Texas Abortion Law: Further Developments

A good discussion of the Texas abortion law. This sort of deep dive should regularly be done to help us understand the laws involved in key cases like this. Two people known for their abortion writings (Mary Ziegler and Melissa Murray, a historian and a lawyer) helped.

We also have various op-eds. Linda Greenhouse overall sees the anti-abortion laws as basically a wrongful use of sectarian religion (concur). 

We also have two supporters. One talks about how the science is gaining on the pro-choice side. But, really, what has changed but somewhat more knowledge and fetal surgery? The same basics hold. What makes this particular law, for instance, any less wrong? Viability didn't change much. Forced pregnancy is not so much easier or anything. We know the same basics about the moral, religion, and other factors in decision-making. 

Another from a Southern Baptist (right after Roe, that religious tradition supported leaving it to the individual in many cases) viewpoint appears to try hard to be moderate.  Factoring the various hard questions given nature of the law, including the troubling legal aspects.  Noting how society in various ways helps an abortion taking place.  

But, the op-ed is clearly from a "pro-life Christian" (as that term is usually understood; all these terms can be spun in various ways) point of view.  An "unborn child" is involved (most abortions occur in the first trimester, if not so early to fit under this law, including when many would not use that term).  Each abortion is a "failure" for both the woman (not always a woman; many girls, some trans and non-binary people) and said child.

Really now?  If a woman is raped, is it really a failure to have the abortion?  The implication is that a birth could never be a failure.  But, many do not believe that.  There are various scenarios where an abortion seems to be the appropriate choice.  It need not be considered a failure. Conception sets into place a process.  Some chunk naturally are miscarried.  Is that a failure or just nature taking her (let's say) course?  

She notes that "The highest purpose of human law is the protection of human life, from its beginning to its natural end."  Again, people debate what "human life" in this fashion truly entails.  Also, how do you truly protect human life?  If fifteen year old girl -- to take an easier case -- is not ready to give birth, perhaps human life is best protected via an abortion. 

===

President Biden asked the DOJ and HHS in particular to look into the Texas law and how the Biden Administration should respond.  Today, AG Garland announced a civil suit against Texas to block the law.  For instance, would it not interfere with federal prisons being able to provide health care to its women prisoners?  

[This blog post has some helpful links and summaries.  Note how the "heartbeat" quotation usage. The journalist behind Jost on Justice wondered in a tweet about just that.  Many have noted that at the six week guidepost -- actually weeks earlier given how pregnancy is usually counted -- does not really  have a true heartbeat.  

It is more a blip that is heard on machines.  So, he argues quotations to signify a word is not really being used normally, a sort of scare quotation, would seem to be appropriate. And, I think he makes a good point. 

Maybe, even "six" weeks is appropriate.  It was noted that many men are not aware of how pregnancies are counted.  I think many people are ignorant there.  After all, we are continuously warned about the ignorance that leads to pregnancy, and not just by teens.  (Update)]

After some noises about another approach got some upset, this firm attack impressed various opponents.  They also liked the Administration going after federal workers with a vaccine mandate though the post office and the other two branches would not be included.  It's only eight months in (soon) and the Biden Administration had a lot of activity, huh?  

Anyway, there is obviously a lot of debate over the approach, with various people saying it is sound (but who knows how the Supreme Court will rule).  We will see what happens, including if the Administration will do some more things. 

===

Friday: 5CA decides and does so with a gratuitous anti-trans potshot (at least one of the panel -- though the opinion is unsigned -- is a known anti-trans judge).  Maybe we forgot, but the Supreme Court acted when the 5CA granted an administrative stay (deemed by  various law types as a dubious move) of the district court opinion.  They got around to dropping the opinion to keep it in place on take out the trash day. Coincidence?

The opinion is summarized here. One thing various people flagged was a footnote:

The district court felt moved to “note that people other than those who identify as ‘women’ may also become pregnant and seek abortion services.” Order at 2 n.2. This notion, whatever it might mean, ignores that the law applies only to “an abortion on a pregnant woman.”

One thing some people (to the disdain of this nature of some others) have noted was that "women" aren't the only people who might need an abortion. Trans and non-binary individuals also might.  If the judges here are so confused, that is what that probably means.  As to the last bit, are pregnant girls, transmen and non-binary people not covered or something?

Jackass.  We also have Ivy Tower guy (though granting it unfortunate) says "But, for better or worse, procedurally the court is correct."  One law professor / appellate litigator (far from alone) said he felt the reasoning was "thin."  And, including members of the Supreme Court, others are out there who agree with him at least to some degree.  No comments allowed though.

ITG, like the 5CA, says the way to go is for someone to violate the law.  But, that leaves people open to a lot of liabilities, which is why other ways were found to avoid needing to do that.  The summary says the 5CA will look at once potential party that the district court says has no immunity, but the court holding things in place (continuing harm to those who need abortion services) does not bode that well for that either. 

And, the wheels continue to go round and round. 

Wednesday, September 08, 2021

SCOTUS (Mexican/U.S.) Watch

Abortion: The first bit of Supreme Court news comes from the Mexican Supreme Court. In timing that seems not totally coincidental, they 10-0 struck down an anti-abortion law.  There is a Spanish language version of the opinion at its website, but have not found an English one yet.  As I understand it, an earlier opinion said abortion could be made legal, but that still left local areas to have the power to block it. 

If one translates (Google Translate) this press release, "As a majority that exceeds eight votes has been reached, the Court's reasons are binding on each and every judge in Mexico; both federal and local." I believe from Gay USA that various other hot button issues were split, so a ruling was not so universal. There are ten judges, so I guess there can only be one dissent. 

[Meanwhile, here, there will be some protests for abortion rights and other things.  Here is a good article on what to and not to look for at protests.]

SCOTUS Orals: Moving to our own Supreme Court, the first three months/sessions of oral argument will be in person, but without non-press (full time credentials) public access. They will continue live audio. No more phone stuff / one at time stuff (one assumes). 

This pleases a lot of legal types. I'm less concerned about a slight delay. If the audio was allowed in the afternoon (when the transcript drops), I would be okay. But, it helps. I would rather have video, since the public (and even some press) won't be able to access the oral arguments of the 2/3 legitimate Court. The building is closed to the public for the time being. 

Death Penalty:  John H. Ramirez accepted his fate -- execution -- but wanted a spiritual advisor to lay his hands on him and pray as Ramirez died.  Texas only would allow the advisor to be in the death chamber, something that has been a matter of dispute in various shadow docket cases in the last couple years.  It might have been useful to take a case for argument to clarify something that repeatedly split them and other judges. 

I don't know if he somehow challenged his execution in the past.  It would seem so, since the summary has him being sentenced almost fifteen years ago.  He murdered someone in gruesome fashion (over twenty stabbings), fled to Mexico, and eventually was caught.  A one-off murder like that does not to me seem like a "worse of the worst" scenario.  He is only 37.  If you accepted your fate here, one might think those who are sentenced to a term of years might be suffering more.  Subjective thing.  

As to his claim, moving past any procedural issues that I have little reason to opine on, the lesser request of prayer probably is the strongest. As a matter of discretion, probably would let the spiritual advisor lay his hands on the guy.  But, as a matter of mandatory requirements, somewhat hard to argue that the state has no interest in avoiding someone not a state official to touch the guy as he dies.  Always a chance of some problem there. 

Mind you, I thought Hobby Lobby supplying their employees birth control coverage could be required too.  To be fair there, prisons generally get to have stronger rules, even with a federal law in place specifically to protect state prisoners.  Again, maybe if the Supreme Court had a full argument on this question -- which came up to them at least three times -- there would be a bit more clarity on the rules in this context.  

Meanwhile, an article about various things people on death row can ask for when they are about to die.  

Supreme Court says ... at around 10 P.M. D.C. local time, an order dropped that GRANTED CERT, which is a tad surprising though given the multiple cases cited above and concern for religious liberty (Alito granted the overall claim of having a spiritual advisor was a credible one) -- not totally ad hoc -- only so much.  

[This article discusses three shadow docket cases; another later was sent back to determine if there was a good reason to deny the request.]

A special proviso was added to schedule it so it would be heard in October or November.  No dissent noted.  Anyway, good move.

Orders: There will be an Order List this Friday.  

ETA: The orders were bland, but we had more late Friday stuff, if only an extended list of questions to address in the death penalty case.  Why it dropped late is unclear, but maybe they just are used to late Friday drops.

Monday, September 06, 2021

A Phone Story

Friday was one of those tedious things. In the morning, I tried to charge my phone. For some reason, it suddenly didn't work. The battery seems to burn more these days, but it's an old phone. Charging? Never had an issue. Suddenly it won't charge?

Okay. So, I go to a local authorized retailer via the website.  This is like a twenty minute walk away, but hey, good exercise and it's a nice day.  The big store is a T-Mobile, but there is a smaller one for my phone. The person just sells phones, but checks it, and suggests the problem is where you plug in the charger. I ask where I can have it checked. 

This confuses him for some reason. His tone suggests I am asking some strange question.  Rule to the wise: try not to make other people seem like they are idiots.  He could have simply checked the website or something.  He is listed as an authorized retailer for my phone. It was not a hard or strange question for me to ask. 

I check the website again, battery bleeding low, and then call the info number. It suggests I check an online test, texting me a link. When I do it on the phone, it says I should use another device to check online. Then, why did you suggest I do it? 

I trudge home and deal with the online agent, who seems to be on a delay, and is also not helpful except for clueing me in on a cheaper rate for my phone service. Not a total loss.

I do what I should have done originally and set up an appointment at a main store, though I need to take a bus there. I dealt with them before when for some reason I was sent an expensive item that I didn't order and they handled things professionally and solved the problem. 

Guy checks the phone and the problem is the charger cord. They don't sell that separately, so need to spend almost $40 on a new allegedly "high speed" [ETA: seemed quick the first time but since then seems about the same length to charge the thing, but otherwise works fine] charger. OTOH, I will work it off in about three months with the reduction on my phone bill.

With travel time and everything (including waiting for my appointment), I was able to get back and eat lunch in the middle of the afternoon. I figured that I deserved something good and turned out to eat too much when a small breakfast-like meal would have been better.  

End scene.  Life is filled with these little annoyances.  The aim is to actually try to accomplish something in the process and you know have other things. 

Saturday, September 04, 2021

Saturday Night Update

The Sven film tonight was The War of the Colossal Beast, a sequel to another gigantic man via nuclear power film that Sven can't get rights to yet. It starts with an amusingly cheesy Mexico interlude where the thought dead beast (now with a sister) is found in Mexico.

The latter half is more boring with him in captivity and twice trying to escape (without managing to do much damage other than killing a doctor). The end has him caught in a park with a crowd outside looking on, after people were told to keep away. He appears dead this time. The sister (and some Mexican locals) overall provides the most life in this film.

Meanwhile, the Mets (vs Nats) split a doubleheader (one via a 9th inning extras win, thanks to multiple unearned runs), while the Phils (vs Marlins) and Braves (vs Rockies at home) both lost. Net, the Phils are 2.5 back and the Mets inch closer at 3.5. Lot of mediocre baseball.

Finally, Christmas in early September with the short, but well written and covering most of the bases book, Christmas: A Candid History. Some worker stuff for Labor Day.

More On the Texas Abortion Law

I tacked on comments on the last two entries, but seems useful to provide a new entry to say a bit more about the Texas abortion law and related stuff.

I have criticized this guy (did so without attribution one place [comments] and he felt it necessary to "correct" me without actually fully responding ... thin skin). Note the famous cartoon at the top of the page. The useful thing here is to use such people as a "type" to critique. I felt that way back to my teenage years about op-eds. They provide useful short discussions to play off of.

I confuse two people on that blog to some extent, but one at least has doctrinaire views on such things as freedom of speech (so much I feel darn conservative*) and "departmentalism" (which can be an unrealistic approach where each department of government gets to judge constitutionality) and so forth. He is a symbol of the ivy tower who is too full of their own theories.

[Aside. Some woman lawyer noted she thought use of "people" to reference those who have abortions seemed a bit arch or something.  But, I have seen one or more person remind us that trans and non-binary people have abortions.  Such people do not always feel "woman" tells the whole story.]

Such people regularly are not useless. They are informed individuals, who might be experts in particular things, providing details for the general reader.  And, the professor's discussion of the procedural questions on an academic level is fine on some level.  Take that link I provided to his latest comments.  Yes, the law is not totally free from judicial review.

But, that is a rather weak version of the criticism.  I'm sure you can find someone who says that, but even they probably would admit with mild prompting that they recognize that at some point the law can be subject to judicial review.  Surely, lots of people commenting readily say that. They reference the DELAY as women in Texas can't have an abortion.  

I don't think the discussion, with its talk of "hand-wringing" and so forth seriously addresses this.  AGAIN, sorry to cap lock, it is fine to discuss in detail the legality at hand.  One lawyer helpfully spelled out the issues, including reference to Ex parte Young and all that.  I saved it for my own reference.

It still is quite possible not to ivy tower-like act like it is all theoretical.  Lots of litigation has time lags, but much less has such immediate harms with these stakes. There will be people who won't be able to obtain an abortion -- "able" here is a matter of general human decision making, not pure possibility -- or at best will have to deal with more complicated, costly, dangerous, and for some, morally fraught later in the pregnancy abortions.  This is part of what the "hand wringing" is about.

The person notes that one way for the law to be addressed by the courts substantively is to have someone break it.  Now, even that, might not get you there until someone actually goes after them.  One brief I saw noted various state actors are required to enforce the law.  But, many laws are not actually enforced. Think of sodomy laws back in the day.  

Still, that came to mind for me too. The difficulty of legal liability in the short term at least is why clinics have traditionally went the route of pre-enforcement challenges.  Equity (which is in place in part to clean up the nastiness of strict legal rules) alone warrant a similar approach here, if possible.  The legal liability risks is a "substantial burden" on abortion rights. Planned Parenthood v. Casey specifically blocks that.

The professor earlier said this and it annoyed me. Again, I cite this as an example and avenue for response.  Such comments are not unique, though the specific way they are framed might be different:

Justice Sotomayor offers some judicial supremacy, calling the law "a breathtaking act of defiance--of the Constitution, of this Court's precedents, and of the rights of women seeking abortions throughout Texas." She is 1/3 right--it defies the Court's precedents. But I presume the Texas legislature believed the law was valid under its reading of the Constitution, under which women do not have a right to seek abortions. Agree or disagree with that position, but it is an interpretation of the Constitution that the Texas legislature is entitled to make, if it wants to live with the consequences of being wrong about what the Court will do.

This is wrong for various reasons though it is nice he finally opened comments. (He apparently accidentally opened it one time, a person mildly critiqued him, and he closed them again.) 

Sotomayor did not offer some "judicial supremacy" as the term should fairly be applied. The concept is that the Supreme Court has a somewhat absolute ability to determine what is "constitutional" and other bodies must follow.  The more limited view is that the ruling applies to the case at hand.  

It is unclear to me how this applies here.  She is allowed to herself opine on the constitutionality as much as some other governmental actor, isn't she?  She is responding to why the specific case should have been decided differently.  The claim is an unfair potshot. 

Taking the idea that the Texas legislature can attempt to apply its own view of the Constitution for granted, why is Sotomayor not correct about the "right" view of what the Constitution means?  It is a rather extreme view to argue there is really no "right" view at all.  As if, if Texas was willing to take its chances, Sotomayor cannot say a law that discriminates against Catholics is "unconstitutional."  Again, how is that wrong?

The same thing about the "rights of women."  You might DISAGREE with her -- though it is unclear that he does -- but their rights can reasonably be said to be violated.  Since "1/3" is used, I take it that he is using those three things to determine the fraction.  

What seems to be his problem, I guess, is the "breathtaking act of defiance" part.  That is, his view is that Texas gets to try, so it isn't really that.  Confusingly phrased, if that is the point -- at least, it seems to be given his response that seems largely unresponsive. 

Even there, taking how we actually approach the law, over his possible view of how it should be approached, they are defying the law.  You might think that is a good thing. When the now (at least for the time being!) governor of California as a lower level official went against state policy and married same sex couples, based on his own constitutional views, he was "defying" on some level, but many rooted for him.  

(I saw "some level," since you very well might argue there is some right to challenge a law, hoping to be eventually upheld.  But, especially here, with someone so concerned with proper frames, there are various levels to a word like "defiance," especially when used in a singular quickly written dissenting opinion.  Using my overall policy of fair minded criticism, again, I think his reply is an unfair one.)  

So, why is she only 1/3 right again?  His other critiques basically amount to at least partial disagreements with the assumptions of the dissenters. Fine enough, but as me and many others note, this is all a matter of discretion. And, as Sotomayor noted, the district judge provided an extended argument on why at least someone (even if you don't agree with it all) has standing. 

Again, equity and prudence in general (see Roberts) warrants holding up the application of the law.  One that will harm a lot of women until the courts somehow get around to interpreting it and needing to (unless they are clowns) note it blatantly violates Planned Parenthood v. Casey.

===

One particular travesty of this law is its broad reach to those that "aid and abet" abortions. Just what this means is unclear though it seems to go further than merely applying to doctors and immediate medical staff.  

One thing litigation would have to determine is its reach. For instance, in theory, mere advocacy might apply.  At least there, I think even conservative judges would be wary about being too broad in scope.

To note a possibility, partially on the litigation extravaganza possibilities, I received an email from Lyft (the ride people) -- I signed on to them when COVID early on made mass transit seem risky -- strongly opposing it:

We want to be clear: Drivers are never responsible for monitoring where their riders go or why. Imagine being a driver and not knowing if you are breaking the law by giving someone a ride. Similarly, riders never have to justify, or even share, where they are going and why. Imagine being a pregnant woman trying to get to a healthcare appointment and not knowing if your driver will cancel on you for fear of breaking a law. Both are completely unacceptable.

This reminds me of the concern regarding tracking people via third party means (phone calls or car tracking devices) having First and Fourth Amendment implications, such as concern about privacy of personal associations.  There are many moving parts here and "aid and abet" will bring within its ambit a lot of them.  This tends to be the case in many cases. We are a united whole and must join together. 

The email notes it is setting up a driver defense fund and donating a million dollars to Planned Parenthood.  Uber says it will support the former, but the reports I have seen did not say it will donate money.  

===

President Biden and VP Harris in separate statements strongly criticized the decision and law overall.  Biden directed the HHS and DOJ in particular to look into the matter and overall promised to find a way to protect the rights of women in Texas.  It is unclear what immediately this would entail though Jen Psaki (press secretary) referenced a national abortion law, which Nancy Pelosi promised will be brought to a vote.  

(I have seen this national statutory abortion protection idea come up before, and there is always some problem, including what it should cover, anti-abortion Dems, the filibuster, and an overall lack of urgency.) 

And, Pelosi is all about only doing that when she has the votes.  A concern there is that the Supreme Court will target such a law, though we don't know yet just what it would say.  But, as Chris Hayes noted on Twitter, that is a problem we face when it comes. After all, we are a far way from the law even passing since we do have the U.S. Senate.  

I agree on some level that Dems got too complaisant about abortion rights on some level.  The writer's overall tone has a lot going for it.  But, he repeatedly is more rhetoric than realistic voice, which is fine on some level -- people have different roles -- if something that still stands out.  

For instance, this "privacy protector" idea (which a bunch of people "yes man!" him on Twitter for) seems overly cute.  As but one person noted, it isn't that easy to get around the Hyde Amendment.  The purpose of the amendment is to not allow the federal government to get involved in the abortion business.  This, which at some point will involve some sort of funds, does the opposite.  Still, think big, man, and continue to amuse us with your daily dealings with your smart aleck/cute sons. 

====

Ultimately, I don't know exactly what this law will wrought. Its breadth -- which other states now might follow with the Court letting it stand -- suggests a lot of horrors.  But, the very breadth might require them to temper the blow.  Pandora's box.  

It also might be all a holding action until the Supreme Court decides.  We shall see.   

ETA: One of the second generation, so to speak (Anna S. is now in college and doing things like writing Lawfare pieces), High School SCOTUS contributors (class of '24) wrote a very good summary of the abortion ruling, including lower court developments. 

---

* One blog was a strong denunciation against local officials letting the courts handle the question of people putting vulgar (think "Fuck Biden") signs on their front lawns.  He argued this was obviously unconstitutional, citing various Supreme Court precedents.

But, do they really?  A big vulgar sign in front of a home which children might pass daily is not the same as briefly seeing a jacket in the courthouse, sending Snapchats to your friends, sexually themed books and magazines, and a whole slew of other cases.  If "fleeting" obscenity can get you in trouble merely if said on television, why not here?  

The permanent open sign next to your home to me raises novel questions. There was some 1970s case involving a flag put up on someone's home and they decided it on vagueness grounds or something.  Just what is allowed here? Can't stop at "Fuck Biden." Since no one reads this, what about "Pelosi is  C-Word"?  Something about seeing you next Tuesday.  

Political speech, right?  Or even use of the "N" word.  It is not like a "fighting word" in that context, is it?  But, hey, it is just down outrageous for a mayor -- partially for political reasons [hey, they have the right to try, right?!] -- to toss big vulgar signs Dennis the Menace might see on his way to bother Mr. Wilson to the courts to decide.  

There was also a continual blather about limits on speech at public stadiums and so forth (think hateful speech), including not allowing student athletes to bad mouth other teams or something as a violation of sportsmanship rules.  This all was not just problematic, but GLARING on free speech grounds, as it was all so obvious.  I think not. 

Thursday, September 02, 2021

Mets Update

The Mets in recent years (started watching them in the last 1990s) have continuously been somewhat tedious. Common things were the ownership never quite getting a complete team, though one good enough to be a tease. Various players that you can root for.

Or, general managers that repeatedly seem to be bullshitting us somehow. Not great luck there this season: first one was out because of sexual harassment claims. And, now another is out for the time being because (this came out on an off day, as if the team needed news) of a DUI charge. 

And, various flawed managers, though I liked Terry Collins. On that front, Luis Rojas, an emergency manager that was held on to this season, is at best a mixed bag in my view.  He seems to be a "trainer" manager, as if there is an expectation he will grow into the job. Rojas looked good when the team hung together via various problems.  Less so, when there seems to be some need for tough love leadership. 

Also, repeatedly up/downs, never quite going all the way.

This year seemed more tedious. Lot of rain-outs. Lot of injuries. Good enough, but not that good (including key bats like Lindor), until they weren't. Braves and to a lesser degree Phils (which then slipped) hung around enough to make moves at the deadline. Mets made limited ones. And, then they had pretty bad July/August.

Being the Mets, they tease. Nats turned out to be losers and now they have a two week stretch with them and the Marlins. The Braves managed the slumping Giants, but lost each game versus the Dodgers/Yanks. 

The Mets now are five games back, with another rain-out because of yesterday's deluge. The margin is that close since the Mets have an actual winning streak going, including a "storybook" ending (per one report) where they scored five in the bottom of the ninth versus the Marlins, who missed multiple chances to have a bigger lead.  Such are the ways of scrubs, but still annoying on a competition level.

(To add to the carnival, Baez -- who has been underwhelming in various cases except for certain moments -- lost his earring scoring the winning run.  There was a big to do about trying to find it.)

The Mets fan comes in various shapes and sizes.  Some complain a lot, including how horrible the team is. Others live in the moment. This allows them to enjoy the Mets winning now, even if it is against bottom dwellers.  I'm at this point not there.  I'm tired of their season. I'm tired of their refusal to admit much is wrong as they had problems all year, especially lately.  

I'm tired of controversies such as some apparent stupid gimmick where a few players do a thumb down as a "fu" of sorts to fans that booed the team.  This specific thing was called out by Sandy Alderson, who said the players admitted they were wrong.  Uh huh.  I would have actually DID something to show them they were wrong.  Fine, skip a game, even DFA.

The odds are -- given the Mets will eventually have some real competition and the Braves have various soft teams -- that the Braves will win the division.  If the Braves somehow falter -- which is possible, since they still are a flawed team (they really needed to win ONE of those Dodgers or Yanks games, which they repeatedly ala the Mets lost by close scores) -- maybe the Phils can sneak in.  But, my lack of respect in them seemed warranted given recent struggles versus teams like the Diamondbacks.  

It's not a gimmee, again, the Mets are in the midst of some gimme games, though the Marlins' pitching can get ya, and have enough talent to go on a run if only just so Pete Alonso and company can get all excited.  The result will be more teasing -- who would be shocked if the margin goes down further than five games.  I should like that, but the team is so tiresome.

The Mets hung in first for some long because the competition was so mediocre.  If they actually manage to sneak in, it would be more of the same there.  It also would encourage ownership to do even less to improve the team.  Why bother? They are playoff bound!  But, they are flawed, from the manager on down.  

I'm just tired of them. 

Howie Rose, the veteran radio announcer, received some love being he will be out the rest of the season because of a medical procedure he has to have done.  As a bonus, he finally got his Twitter "checkmark."  Rose is a lovable sort, who for some reason got a sort of "dad beard" (one of his daughters, Alyssa, is on Twitter too and has a sports media position) this season to boot.  

Mets fans have the charm of great t.v. and radio people, if somewhat less so on the post-game shows.  

ETA: I had not keep track of the Phils before writing this and see they are  (sorta like the Mets) back to winning ways, helped by scrubs. They are closer to the Braves than the Mets.  I still don't trust them, but who knows.  

The Mets won last night against the Marlins in a low scoring (4-3) messy game.  That's what they had to do.  The Braves won by one run versus the Rockies too.  So, they remain five games back.  

.... and, the Mets won another exciting one, after blowing it in the 9th (after the blowing, the Nats had a man on third with one out & basically one shot ... I knew they wouldn't win in extras) when the Nats took a risk running on 0-2 and via collision at the plate, tied it up 2-2.  HORRIBLE at bat and ground out ended regulation.

The Nats, not being able to hold that level of pitching for TEN innings, made it easy for them by giving up four.  The Braves lost to the Rockies, who do good at home, and now we are hearing the "it's a race again" talk.  Back to .500 and four back.

I'm with those who am getting a bit tired of this.  It is who they are though more often than not the tease brings heartache.  Again, this season seems a bit more tiresome than usual though for me personally 2021 itself hasn't helped. 

SCOTUS In The Dead Of Night Acts

We had a deluge last night and I fell asleep early as the hard rain continued. It was bad -- saw reports of the subway being shut down for a time.  Waking up early in the morning, I checked my phone. (As an aside, since I am a Mets fan, the Braves lost, so the Mets did gain 2.5 games as the Braves were swept by the Dodgers, after going 2-1 vs. the Giants but 0-2 ... the losses regularly close ... vs the Yankees.)

To preview this, the Trump additions to the Supreme Court were a result of corrupt procedures that make them as a matter of sound government -- the moral guidance cited in the Declaration of Independence that still matters in this country -- are illegitimate. 

I don't say that about the rest of the majority. But, Roberts and Alito are the result of a minority POTUS, if one re-elected by the ONE case of Republicans getting a majority of the vote since 1988. The courts will not be simply a result of majority rule. But, at some point, things are so skewered that we are in trouble. It is a factor in why expanding the Supreme Court is so justified. Okay ...

At around midnight, via a brief unsigned order found in the "opinions related to orders page," the Texas abortion ban was left in place by a 5-4 vote. You can read Amy Howe's summary. To reminded, here by the lead guy SCOTUS commentator at Slate on Twitter, though Sotomayor also made reference to the basic point, this law:

Just want to reiterate that the first near-total abortion ban to take effect in the United States since Roe v. Wade allows random strangers to sue anyone who "aids and abets" an abortion—for $10,000+—including an abortion patient's friends, family, clergy, doctor, counselors.

It is a "heartbeat" law that can take effect as early as six weeks. It is the sort of law that I have said that SCOTUS rather not touch -- they rather attack abortion rights with easier lower hanging fruit like second trimester bans. But, Texas' approach provides a procedural slight of hand (rightly noted as one by the dissents, more so the liberals) to allow SCOTUS to have an excuse to let a more extreme law stay in place as clinics already are turning women away. 

And, it provides a signal to the states and conservative judges below. Or, we can talk about technical points and reference "hand-wringing" like this asshole.  The seriousness of this -- even if Roe is not totally in the ground yet -- is shown by the dissents, from Roberts (we need to hold things in place) to Breyer (this is bad and let's not let procedural tricks cover that up) to Sotomayor (fuck you) to Kagan (screw you too ... shadow docket edition).  

To underline something Breyer flags, we should not allow  procedural semantics handwave the purpose and effect (both factors flagged by Planned Parenthood v. Casey) of the law, which used just that to override abortion rights.  It's like the proverbial survival benefits being given to the person who murdered their parents.  

[Each justice had their own concerns. Michael Dorf flags how the CJ realized how Texas' approach can't be cabined to this subject, which results in an open-ended approach to attack rights.  

It is telling that the majority just ignores these dissents, including by the Chief Justice. Even if you think the case was decided correctly, why not respond to strong dissents from 4/9, including not all from your ideological opponents? To address another addendum below, this is not just "laziness." It is a choice to avoid basically doing your jobs.]

We also see the reactions on Twitter, including from one woman lawyer.

For a sane woman lawyer who lives in Texas, this is true for a variety of reasons.  First and foremost, you have the basic right over your body.  

But, it goes further than that.  It goes to the basic integrity of the law and the Supreme Court.  I'm just an amateur.  Imagine how someone who lives their life practicing (or teaching) law.  They look at what the Supreme Court did in the middle of the night.  In such a corrupt way.  How it let stand not only an anti-abortion law but one that uses a method that can cause a lot of damage in various ideological ways.  

What do you do?  Chris Hayes last night had the usual liberal voices (like Melissa Murray) and Elie Mystal for the angry guy vibe.  Such voices are valuable though there is a certain "yeah okay, I know what yo are going to say" vibe, and I wished he had a bit more diversity (not saying FOR the law or anything).  

EM was like "we need to do something big, pack the court ... I don't care about Joe Manchin. Don't talk to be about him." etc.  Charming.  He exists though.  At some point, this sort of tough guy talk is annoying.  Not saying that he is wrong on a basic level, at least regarding the need to go big. But, a 50-50 Senate and all the rest (including all it has to do vs. insurrection enabling trolls) can't be handwaved.  

One guy on a blog whose tone annoys me was the first one there who flagged the ruling.  He ends his comments on a sort of realistically forlorn note:

There must be some kind of way out of here, but I can’t see it right now.

Yes.  But, at some point, events happen, instigation happens, that forces your hand.  Direct action protests, if not 1960s level, have been in place to pressure Manchin and others to act on voting rights. The same might be at hand here.  Waiting for the presidential commission to release it's report in November has a feel of token bullshit at this point. 

One possible route, though it is seems pie in the sky since it goes against his very soul, is Justice Breyer admitting the Court is broken, announcing his retirement, and the confirmation hearing not only brings in a middle aged black woman justice, but an opening for a platform for action.  Again, I don't see that happening.  I like the idea -- unlike expansion of the Court, which is proper -- there is a shot in hell of it happening. 

So, goes the line, we have a chance?  Meanwhile, "This is bad."  I still won't say Roe v. Wade is dead.  Some federal judge still has the authority and obligation to strike down this sort of law if given the chance. Ditto state judges.  That matters.  But, a chill wind blows.  It is starting to howl.

ETA: There are various accounts that argue the result is really just a trivial procedural matter or at most a result of how procedure works. But, again, four justices (including Roberts) and many other critics really doubt that. 

And, it is gaslighting to suggest that the Court's actions have nothing to do with their beliefs on the merits.  It is a charade to think there is merely some procedural trick that lets the state pass this law with this purpose and effect, but get away with blocking abortion services by "this is just private" dodge.  

It wouldn't work with a regular abortion law, blocked pre-enforcement for litigation purposes.  I might not know all the nuances of procedural law, but all the lawyers et. al. are not morons about that.  They know there are ways to do that.  It is a choice to let a blatantly unconstitutional law to remain in place.  

I still question if the ultimate abortion decision that they will decide next term will blatantly allow for this sort of law. But, since you need two of them to provide a "less bad for now" approach, perhaps that too is somewhat less likely.  

Also, more no comment dubious-ness -- I don't think the shadow docket is just the Supreme Court being "lazy."  Did they suddenly become lazy last year?  Also, the reference to the summer recess is bad too, as if that is the only time they used it.  That is high asinine cluenessness. 

... One more thing.  Among all the commentary, I saw more than one person note the basic conceit here -- the "private" action (bounties) is a result of state action. The bounty hunters are serving as agents of the state, in promotion of a state based anti-abortion law.

Compare this to "private" covenants, property restrictions at times based on wrongful things such as race [court enforcement was deemed "state action" but perhaps a better framing is that it is a sort of badge of slavery, the 13A not requiring state action], a result of individual contractual acts. 

Such things are not free from problems and property rights ultimately are a creation of the government.  There is still a notable difference. 

===

* As a footnote, we have the delay.  This is all guesswork and on some level is academic.  But, then, this is a footnote.

Why?  One suggestion would be that the majority are chickenshit.  Well, clearly that is part of it.

There is also the need to write dissents. Eh.  Twelve pages total. They could have, if necessary, announced the ruling and said writing was pending. This is done elsewhere with time sensitive rulings. Having us wait in the darkness for a day was not a great look.  You'd think they'd care a little.

Rick Hasen suggests on Twitter that maybe the liberals (maybe Roberts?) wanted to show that the law in action had serious effect.  Maybe. What is the point there though really?  The majority could have claimed not to know what would happen? That itself could have been used against them, given what happened.  Also, because it would be ridiculous, given what was clearly going to happen.  Maybe though.

Maybe, part of it was some attempt to talk reason into at least one of the majority.  Roberts would have special reason here to be upset. His Court is also passing him by.

Also, I saw someone note that Kagan's reference to the "shadow docket" is a first.  Directly speaking of it seems to be, doing a search on the SCOTUS website.  But, back on 9/11/19, Sotomayor flagged it as part of how the Trump Administration used it, citing an article by a leading voice.

Wednesday, September 01, 2021

Texas: So much wrong

And Also: People are correctly appalled, though there is a cynical partisan reason Biden is trying to find a longstanding powerful [if problematic] Democrat a plum, that Rahm Emmanuel was nominated for ambassador to Japan. Japan is pretty important for someone not qualified for that specific role and this alone is poisonous.  
It's September. Year is moving along. August ended with a SCOTUS Watch involving Texas' horrible abortion law. Again, let me let Amy Howe summarize:
The law bans abortions after about six weeks of pregnancy – a time when many people do not yet know they are pregnant – and allows private citizens to sue anyone who helps a patient get an abortion.
The last part was a nice bit of trickery, making it harder to bring a lawsuit to stop the enforcement of the law, which started at midnight (1AM my time) last night. A horrible 5CA panel (two Trumpies and this Judge Jones) granted a stay (which more than one lawyer type on Twitter noted was procedurally inappropriate), allegedly for a short time to get briefing.

But, the time limit for that was yesterday morning. The district judge held there was standing to sue. That is basically the ballgame, since the law is clearly unconstitutional under Casey (often simplified as "Roe v. Wade" in general speak).

A finding of an undue burden is a shorthand for the conclusion that a state regulation has the purpose or effect of placing a substantial obstacle in the path of a woman seeking an abortion of a nonviable fetus.

The law clearly does that and the procedural trickery is in my book only more proof of what is going on.  Some will insist -- of the fact (in a past blog -- no comments allowed -- he focused on the "media," but now realizes lawyers and law professors also disagree with him)  that "No court at any level can stop SB8 from taking effect tomorrow."  I'm not an expert on procedure.  But, lawyer and law professor after lawyer and law professor very well disagree that this is true.  

The assurance is rank arrogance on some level.  One person, a person with a law degree and who knows abortion law as well as this guy, called out frames of this being "Sharia law" as just more Islamic shaming.  Yes. 

And, besides, the Islamic rules on abortion is far from clear.  There appears to be a general idea that it is allowed at least for some reasons up to the fourth month of pregnancy.  Ultimately, as Casey notes, "the abortion decision may originate within the zone of conscience and belief" left to the individual, minus valid medical regulations and so forth. 

Anyway, since the law was due to come into effect last night at midnight Texas time, SCOTUS was asked to block it.  So, we had a late nite Twitter wait, akin to when we are waiting for them to decide on some execution due at midnight or something.  This is similarly a bad way to run a railroad.  Each side briefed, which was handled by early evening or so.  

One could keep track on the docket page.  And, wait.  Midnight passes on the East Coast.  After two wins (including completing an old game) for the Mets, the Braves loses late vs. the Dodgers.  1AM (EST) passes.  Final game ends  (part of this was the Diamondbacks getting  a hit late to avoid a no-hitter).  No action.  Still none in the morning.  

Not sure what they are driving at here.  Are they waiting for the 5CA to act? The expectation was basically SCOTUS would deny the request and the wait was because some liberal was writing a dissent.  (Earlier, the hope was they might hold the case, with some conservative writing a dissent.)  But, by early afternoon the next day, in the face of a law that blatantly violates a basic precedent (which should be a problem for SCOTUS conservatives just on institutional grounds), nothing.  Crickets.  

Strong response from President Biden though doesn't say how he will protect abortion rights.  But, such a statement really shouldn't go into specifics, especially until SCOTUS actually acts.  All the same, Dems in Congress are now put on notice, if they wasn't already.   And, there are multiple ways to respond to SCOTUS.

A final thing is that I was annoyed with the "Roe is gone" comments.  If some lower court has to rule on some broad abortion ban that clearly violates Casey, SCOTUS' inaction here does not allow them to say "oh well, it's de facto overruled!"  Doesn't work that way.   

On some level, I'm being too literal.  SCOTUS letting the law go into operation even for  short while is a gigantic red flag.  On the ground, just how much does Roe v. Wade supply in Texas?  Still, it is still the law of the land.  That matters.  The "all the way" framing is common, but misleads. 

====

Meanwhile, basically forgotten (the Texas Dems fled the state ... big story for a while ... then we moved on to Afghanistan ... a few came back,  I saw the reason being because of need for COVID relief law [really?], giving the Republicans the quorum necessary) Texas voting suppression bill quickly went through the legislative process and was signed into law.  

A charming final "fuck you" occurred during the conference committee process.  One house actually tossed in a good bipartisan measure to address an infamous case:

Even the final vote did not escape a parting round of confrontation after Senate Republicans, at the last minute, scuttled one of the few areas of bipartisan agreement: efforts to shield voters with felony convictions from prosecution if they did not realize they were ineligible to cast a ballot. It had been included following backlash over the arrests of two Texas voters, both of whom are Black, which intensified criticism amid a broader fight over voting restrictions that opponents say disproportionately impact people of color.

Upon opposition, the provision was removed from the final bill. The U.S. Senate will be back soon and voting rights will be back on the front burner pursuant to statements by Sen. Schumer.  It is a necessity.  

As I said, so much wrong. Again, here's my piece on critical race theory that is apparently getting some hits. (The last part about teaching it is a statement from the teacher who runs the site.) 

===

Since this really has a lot to do with SCOTUS (including the voting law, which Shelby v. Holder provided a big welcome sign for), just to toss it in ... this is a good op-ed on both why their eviction moratorium ruling was wrong and the political need to get funds to people who need it.  

The New York legislature, in an agreement between our new gov. and legislative leadership, has come back in session to address this very issue along with some other stuff (e.g., cannabis regulations).  

Meanwhile, we wait to see if the California recall will fuck up things there. That is a whole other screw-up, including how a small percentage can bring forth a recall and if a majority votes yes, there is no run-off or anything ... a tiny plurality (with a big field to split the vote) can vote the next governor in.  But, that is one more thing September will bring.