About Me

My photo
This blog is the work of an educated civilian, not of an expert in the fields discussed.

Thursday, November 04, 2021

Election Day

I continued my recent habit of being a poll worker at my local polling place. Long day -- you start at 5AM to set up, the polls close at 9PM, and then you close shop and it's over at around 10. You get two, two hour breaks. There is a lump sum payment along with a training voucher. It doesn't really work out to be much more than the current minimum net. But, like giving blood, it does make me feel good to give a bit back.

The election this year in New York was for local elections (including the usual stupid judicial race, where you pick five of six [one labeled Republican this time] people you have no idea about. We had a few competitive races (my own city council race, parts of the area somewhat conservative, was semi-competitive with the losing Republican getting over 40% last I checked). 

The "Dems in disarray" theme doesn't really apply to NYC, where the big news is maybe the Republicans will have around five people in the City Council instead of three or four (back in the day, there was one). As shown in that article, the Dems did lose some local races in other parts of the state, helped by low turnout. Dems are probably tired after 2020. You aren't going to win them all. 

There is a notice here that an "April" 2020 rule required masks at all polling places along with a suggestion for an isolated place for those without masks.  I don't recall the first part for that primary, but there were masks available by the general.  Poll workers had to wear them.  I am vaccinated but continue to wear masks on public transportation (required) and supermarkets (advised with the Delta variant rising earlier).  I wear a cloth mask (one study cited they are less useful, but we were given them in the summer of 2020 for census work) and my glasses kept on fogging.  

My area again is somewhat conservative, so there are more registered Republicans. This led to a problem because the presence of several third party mayoral candidates (Eric Adams was not on the Working Family line, but it qualified to be on the ballot; the blank slot being filled by another third party could have dealt with the confusion) aligned one candidate in the row of Republicans.  So, if you voted all the way down, you overvoted.  This happened a few times -- even when someone was told to not do it -- but they just had to re-do their ballot.  A person had the right to two voids.  The scanner rejects overvotes.  One minor way the old lever machines could have been better. 

The other basic issue was the ballot measures.  They were on the back of the ballot in English and Spanish.  Some (one count had city voters especially doing this -- around 20%) simply skipped voting for them at all. You can undervote after all.  This is where the Republicans had a good time in New York -- rather surprisingly, every single voting related (including the redistricting measure) ballot measure failed.  The no-excuse absentee voting measure did a bit better, losing 56/44 [83% reported, but doesn't look like there is enough to compensate] over 58/42.  

The redistricting measure had various components, including setting in place the number of state senators, that I even thought iffy.  But, the two voting measures seemed to me rather benign -- the state could allow same day voting and no-excuse absentee voting.  The Republicans strongly promoted voting "no" and there is recriminations the Democrats didn't do enough to promote "yes."  It didn't even do that well in New York City.  

(The clean environment and civil court measures passed easily by around 2:1 margins. I still don't know what a right to a clean environment will exactly give me. Sounds nice though. And, yes, I think we probably do have such a right in some sense as an obligation of government.) 

There was a reference in one article that the ballot measures were simply confusing.  I think that was a bit exaggerated though I can see some confusion.  For instance, a clear explanation on why there was a need for a vote on absentee ballots -- which people have now enjoyed without limits given COVID since mid-2020 -- given constitutional requirements could have been helpful.  That one at the very least should have passed, even with Republican bullshit about voter fraud. 

The polling places actually were given some ballot measure explanation booklets (and people should have received some voting guides in the mail), but there was a notice only to give them on request.  This wasn't given much thought by my fellow poll workers, from what I can tell, but in hindsight is rather outrageous.  Why not simply put them on a table for those who wish to read them?  I actually gave one to some voter who was confused and she seemed to be quite happy with it.  

This is a civics fail.  I noted earlier that I'm not a big fan of ballot measures since I think they can be confusing and that it would be better for our representatives to have the power to do these things.  I can understand giving the people the power to make big decisions regarding changes to the state constitution.  But tweaking absentee ballot rules and the like?  At the very least, if they have the power, there should be a good education campaign to help voters to make their decision.  There was not.  

===

The big news is that the Trumpy (if with a nice gloss) Republican for governor won by a few points.  He promoted the usual things, fears of critical race theory, stop the steal curious, sympathy for parents who struggled through COVID (as if a Republican would have done better), and so forth.  It was a surprise, since it looked like the incumbent would at least eke it out.  

But, after the usual drama, some pointed out that it actually matches normal off-election trends.  In fact, the early fears that the New Jersey Democratic governor would lose too had a historical pedigree.  It turned out the Dems escaped there, if close enough for a big scare.  Still, especially if the Republicans manage to control (or get a tie) in the assembly in Virginia, it's hard.  Stephen Colbert did toss in some perspective -- we survived Trump and I'm supposed to be terrified of this guy?

True enough, but it's still rather depressing that voters still can be convinced to elect people with the usual scare lines and bullshit.  We are also seeing some people wishing the winner well and all. It's a rinse/repeat affair.  You should not be able to spread lies and bullshit about basic things like race and voting, win, and at least not have to EARN some good graces. It just encourages more of the same.  Can we please stop it?  

[ETA:  The specific person and the stuff he ran on is bothersome, but if you look closer -- which headlines and excited reactions do not -- the results in Virginia are simply not shocking.  Party control fluctuated regularly in recent times.  Youngkin won by about 2%.  This might sound like hindsight bias, but people were colored by some in the moment assumptions during the race as well. 

And, this is something that I missed and I shouldn't have really, the incumbent isn't running.  There is a particular reason -- Virginia doesn't allow the incumbent to run for re-election.  There needs to be at least one person in between (Northam here).  This shows the state encourages turnover and eight years of one party controlling is how it worked since 1994 with Terry McAuliffe breaking the back and forth there in 2013 to stop the semi-expected second Republican, especially given party control in the White House.

So, historically, a TM win would be an uphill battle.  One can argue maybe given the times a "insider" type like TM was not the best bet.  But, the guy lost by two percent.  Who knows?  If the "Democrats are in trouble," is it really because of this?]

There is the usual "Dems in disarray" stuff, of course.  I am tired of that sort of thing, though clearly Democrats need to continue to fight and carefully get through a tough environment.  I do wish some recognize they are doing things with a bare majority in Congress.  Perhaps, Manchin and Sinema etc. can also see the stakes.  This can help motivate. Or, they can just use the results (selectively) to continue their path, including wanting to uphold "bipartisanship" by not ending the filibuster while Republicans show nearly no good faith at all (one Republican senator voted for one of the voting bills ... that is to DEBATE IT).  

Anyway, though it is not completely over with some lingering races, we have gotten through another election.  Next up in 2022 is the race for New York governor, two women the leading hopefuls in the Democratic primary.  One last thing -- the long time incumbent mayor "Democrat" won a write-in candidacy in Buffalo versus the Democratic Socialist.  Basically "doing a Lieberman."  An Asian woman did win as mayor of Boston, the first time a woman and woman of color (one is now acting mayor, with the mayor now in Biden's cabinet) was so elected in that city. 

Wednesday, November 03, 2021

Sports Update

Football:  After an embarrassing loss (that involved an injury to the starter) to the Pats, it seemed hopeless versus the Bengals with a back-up.  And, not the vet one they picked up for insurance.  The Jets won by three. And, that included some slip-ups like a turnover, great stop at the goal line, and then ANOTHER turnover deep in Jets territory.  Even their back-up back-up helped to complete a series (with an injury scare) though it ended with three instead of seven given a missed catch. 

The Bengals eventually went ahead and fans had reason to fear a "this close" ending, down to the Jets looking like it would quickly give the ball back around the two minute warning (two plays took nine seconds!).  A perhaps questionable roughing penalty and (after one more slip-up where a runner looked like he could have got the first down but stopped to stay in bounds) one final push did the job.  Now there is a QB controversy!

The Giants had a shot at an upset against the clearly off Kansas City, who managed a win versus Washington after making them look like a real team in the first half.  This one was more nail-biter all the way, but KC hung on with a late go ahead field goal with the Giants last shot a pretty ugly looking four and out.  

Finally in football news, celebrity spokesman and from I can tell pretty well liked QB, Aaron Rodgers (Brett F., his predecessor had a bit of a reputation as an ass) not only has the Big V., but now it is being reported (though the talk is that it was an open secret) he wasn't vaccinated.  He said in one news conference he was "immunized," which turns out to be some sort of code word.  Sigh.

ETA:  Rodgers is laying on the asshole some more. Colbert flagged as well that he tried to get the league to rule that he was actually "vaccinated" or whatever because of some special procedure he had performed. We saw how useful it was.  Well, that's one more ruined reputation.  

As Carlos Alazraqui (the voice actor/comedian) argued, why can't these guys just be upfront about their fears and beliefs without the b.s. about critics being "woke" or that their path is the "macho" path etc.?  So much bullshit out there. 

The Jets also, unfortunately -- this didn't bode well -- had a short week. Off his fantastic start, Mike White got injured early, leading the third stringer to have to go in.  He helped the team score 30 points, a turnover at the goal line near the end of the game away from 37.  But, the defense was horrible, giving up 45 to the Colts.

Why they gave up a pick or whatever for an emergency back-up when the guy has yet to play for two games in unclear. 

===

Baseball: Well, the big news here is that the Atlanta Braves continued their playoff dominance by beating the Astros in six.  Can you now change your name or at least stop that stupid chop?  So, every team in the NL East except one (no kewpie doll if you can guess) won the World Series in this century, though even that team got there (twice if 2000 counts).

The Braves did take advantage of the situation to get to the playoffs, but their second half was as a whole rather good.  As I have noted, their great record as a whole should not totally paper over that they still had moments of mediocrity (that helped keep the race technically alive longer than it should have been).  This suggests how dominate they was as a whole once they started to thrive, helped by good pick-ups.

It is impressive they managed all of this with three and then two (with an injury early in the World Series) starters.  Their expected fourth starter, not great anyway, was hurt during the playoffs.  But, a fill-in, basically a minor leaguer, had a great World Series start (came in with the bases loaded, got out with one run, pitched 4.2 innings as a whole in a playoffs filled with very short outings across the board).  

Bullpen games was a theme in this playoff run.  Yes, 4.2 is basically a long time these days.  The Braves bullpen did not look lights out regularly in the second half.  Repeatedly, the Braves needed late game offense to compensate.  They had some of that in the playoffs, but the bullpen was much more dominate.  A first inning grand slam looked like the road to winning the WS in five, but the Astros' offense showed up for a second time, and the Braves stopped scoring after going ahead (again) early 5-4.

I didn't watch the playoffs much, not having much interest in many of these teams, finding the FOX announcers annoying, and not wanting various teams to win (thus worrying one team might lose).  There were some good series; mixed bag probably.  Games too long.  The bullpen game concept worsens the situation.  Anyway, can Atlanta end the racist stuff?

There is some financial/labor related stuff to be agreed upon now, so some think there is a chance the 2022 season won't start on time. Then, there is the asinine "end of the DH" business. And, the Mets have a lot of issues still to worry about.  People "thanking" them for helping the Braves along. Eh.  If the Braves took less time to stop playing mediocre ball, even slightly over .500, the Mets problems may have been flagged even earlier.

Monday, November 01, 2021

SCOTUS Watch: Order Day

Today's All Saints' Day and Day of the Dead, so the original death penalty focus (with a religious twist) oral argument seemed well timed. All Saints' Day is also a "holy day of obligation" (back in the day, that meant to Catholics that they had to go to mass even if it isn't a Sunday), but not this year ... since it falls on a Monday! I don't recall the nuances there.

But, the special accelerated (some are calling it the "rocket" docket) oral arguments for the Texas abortion cases pushed things back there.  It also is the 30th anniversary of Thomas' investiture ceremony and the introduction of the new solicitor general (and previous Miss Idaho), who everyone agreed did a great job.  Well, this isn't her first rodeo.  

Texas received less kudos and the other two did as well, though the most conservative advocate (for the private plaintiffs) did not really get much attention from the Court.  Live audio allowed for live tweeting, which was fun.  Along with lower courts, the latest High School SCOTUS interview gave some love for Twitter here

And then I think also with readers, I find Twitter to be a good platform — not all the time, but a lot of the time — for covering the law, because it’s a way to easily make documents available, and to take screenshots of the paragraph in the opinion that says, “Here is why I, judge or panel of judges, am doing X.” And people really respond to that, I think they want to trust what you, the journalist, are saying, and they can say, “Okay, Zoe said, ‘Judge did X.’ I see that the judges did, in fact, say X,” and that builds trust. You’re not trying to be the voice of God here. It’s all public information that should be public, and whatever we can do to get it out there, we should do it. There’s no reason not to. So I think it’s not just how you write it, but how you present the information to people.

Live tweeting is probably the best reason to like live audio -- I'm not really sure that there is much other use for it, if SCOTUS will release an audio link as soon as later in the day (early afternoon for morning arguments).  My  continual push for video -- and it need not be immediate -- continues.

I won't go much into the tea leaves here except to say that it isn't really surprising that the justices (or whatever the Trump trio are) showed some openness to opposing the breadth of SB8.  It's open-ended and very well can also be used to hurt rights they support more. Plus, they are judges, and blocking judicial review power makes them feel bad.  

It is a problem if people as a whole think the case is pretty easy to allow for some lower court relief (a stay as the case is being heard) and they leave the law in force for months while so many people need abortions restricted by the law.  See, Justice Sotomayor's dissent when they took the case.

Likewise, it is not somehow notable that conservative judges can ask good questions.  Barrett, e.g., got some love there from people who don't like her as a whole.  Fine enough, but it really isn't too surprising.  She's a former academic and all; she has some ability to pose hypos.  Plus, along with Kavanaugh, her "thing" will be to seem more reasonable than Alito.  

====

The two oral arguments and to a lesser extent the new SG is what most people came to see, so to speak (many can't come to see, especially the public ... a local video feed for a few minutes would be an interesting idea there, comparable to the ability of some tourists to traditionally see a few minutes of the argument without waiting on long lines).  

But, yes, today was Order List day.  The length is in significant part because Sotomayor with the liberals dissenting from not granting the federal government's request to "GVR" (grant/vacate/remand) an intellectual disability capital case.  Since the defense also requested it, this refusal is a notable part of the conservative "going the extra mile" campaign to speed along executions.  The case still can be dealt with below in some other fashion, but rejection of the request still is notable. 

Sotomayor (with Kagan alone now) has a shorter "statement" -- which is her wont occasionally -- to flag a concern she has about a lower court criminal procedure case.  Going for the sweep, Sotomayor joined Gorsuch's "see he's right sometimes" dissent arguing the Court should take a case involving media access to secret national security courts.  

The "High Federalists" disagree with merely sending back to apply Fulton (the "gay adoption case") a case out of New York which rejected a lawsuit regarding not discriminating against certain types of health care.  The trio also would have take a case involving a transgender man denied gender-affirming surgery (one tweet I saw noted it was on procedural grounds a bad case to take).  

There are various procedural orders as usual.  I will note two. There is one that accepts the government's admission of error.  That would be this case and the U.S. government's brief "now acknowledges  that  a  veterinarian  who  personally  injects a drug into an animal under her direct care in the course of her professional practice, without first issuing a written or oral order, has not engaged in misbranding under the FDCA." 

The motion of "Hannah S." to take part as an amicus during the oral argument in the Mississippi abortion case was denied.  It is not too uncommon for the Supreme Court to refuse time (except if the U.S. asks) in such cases -- they basically just want the parties themselves to be involved.  But, why is the full name not used here?  Sort of a curiosity.

Turns out Hannah S. was conceived through in vitro fertilization and the attempt is to show that life begins at conception.  She's an adult now, seeking a master's degree.  Good luck, Hannah, but a frozen human embryo is not a constitutional person, and even if it was, it would be of limited relevance to an abortion case of this nature.  Finally, the in vitro process involves the destruction of many embryos.  

==

Okay.  So, there will be more interesting cases this week, including the oral argument in a big gun rights case.  You can listen in via the live audio link at the SCOTUS website or at C-SPAN.  SCOTUS will later in the day provide  a transcript.  No video yet, though C-SPAN airs some of the oral arguments with photos to help you along. 

Christmas In My Heart

Stephen Colbert recently took a shot at Hallmark Channel movies being very white. And, yeah, they tend to have white leads with some person of color tossed in as a colleague or friend. Maybe, the channel started to get the memo because they seem to be starting to include some more "color" in their movies. This includes multiple biracial romances.

This one has a familiar male lead (twelve Hallmark movies!). I agree with the person there that this has a different feel than usual and "impeccably written that the discussions about race flowed naturally" also is on point ("impeccably" is a bit strong, but it has a good script). Tossing in the Judaism is a bit much! The film takes time to tell the stories of each, the romance often not being the focus. But, that's fine. Don't let this one get lost in the bunch.

The other two linked are less race conscious, but both were pretty good too (like the sweet pecan one better, but yeah, on the "lazy" part.).

Saturday, October 30, 2021

Frankenstein Meets the Spacemonster

This week's Sven movie is a ridiculous one that is pretty fun with decent pacing that makes it also painless too. "Frankenstein" here is actually a human robot that is injured by invading aliens, one who sounds just like Jon Lovitz (1960s, so not him).

The set-up is decently done, if with corny aliens, but then it gets pretty low rent with a lot of stock footage. The actual final battle is brief and covered with smoke. One of our heroes going to some stand in Puerto Rico, asking for a phone, and calling in an alien invasion to some lone soldier is prime drama. The movie sort of just sputters out.

This Is Your Mind On Plants

Michael Pollan is a well known writer on food and other matters.

This book is more limited in scope than his most well known books, basically three essays on opium, caffeine, and mescaline with a specific concern with his own personal experiences.

The first chapter covers his own personal experience growing opium in a more anti-drug era, when OxyContin would turn out to be the true menace. This was for me the best chapter.  It had something to say about opium while the reader follow along his own growing experience.  Pollan left out a section discussing how he brewed some opium tea, putting it in here since he no longer would have to worry about criminal liability.

The chapter on how caffeine revolutionized history to me seemed somewhat incomplete and I didn't quite buy it. And, regarding his own personal experience cutting out caffeine was also both incomplete and a bit unbelievable.  Pollan barely referenced decaffeinated coffee.  He notes caffeine doesn't really add to taste.  So, the ceremony and taste of coffee very well might be in place without the caffeine.  

And, his hyper response to having caffeine again seems a bit much. I'm not a big caffeine drinker, but regularly had a large cup brewed at home from espresso coffee.  I at times took a break with decaffeinated coffee or some coffee substitute.  I did not have some grave effects.  The book could have at least talked about coffee substitutes some more.

The mescaline chapter had some charms, but it also was incomplete and had a personal flavor that did not do it for me.  The discussion of Native Americans and peyote use was interesting, including his interview with various people.  But, he alluded to other sources without citation of what they had to say about Native American experiences. 

The Supreme Court cases concerning peyote (briefing covered) and ayahuasca (the drug is cited; not clear if he is even aware of the case) could have been discussed more.  One theme of the chapter is the concern of Native Americans that non-Natives usage of psychedelics was a threat.  The peyote case involved a non-Native American (though it is often forgotten about).  Also, the case opens up a chance to learn about Native American experiences, which the author says he could only so far obtain.

Pollan has written about his experience with mind altering drugs (or whatever one wants to call them) before.  His joy as an grower of plants here is about matched by his experiences taking them.  He talks about his use of opium and mescaline, the latter including some sort of ceremony with his wife and a few others.  It was some sort of spiritual experience.

He used a lot more words.  To me, admittedly I didn't experience it, it came off as somewhat pretentious.  The drugs alter your consciousness, changing your senses.  As part of a wider ceremonial practice -- the peyote ritual -- on some level I can respect what is involved here.  It is a community matter, combined with a basic connection with nature.  

Pollan's experience seems more some sort of mind bending exercise. There probably is some fascination there, but after a few paragraphs, it seems to this reader as not too fascinating.  Again, he wrote more about this elsewhere, including how the substances involved can have value for mental health and so forth.  It's an interesting thing to examine on that level. Mind altering drugs are after all the point of many antidepressants.

Anyway, mixed rating for me.  The first chapter -- good.  The second -- tiresome after a while.  The third -- ditto, though like the second, it has some interesting aspects.  The third is broken down into parts, so it is easier to read and skip over the boring. 

A final thought. The last chapter took place during the Big V (COVID).  It is somewhat a matter of my own experiences, but I continue to think there is some exaggeration regarding how isolated we all are.  We are not literal prisoners in our own homes.  People can go out and so forth.  There is more limited movement, including for chance of travel and doing certain events (especially entertainment related).  

But, the author is a well off person in his sixties, a writer with his wife.  Just how much did his life really change?  

ETA: Checking on television ... again, why can't there be more recognition regarding COVID?  Hallmark movies are somewhat understandable, since they are fantasy enterprises, but is really hard to show people wearing masks or something? 

Friday, October 29, 2021

SCOTUS Watch: Botched Execution & Other Matters

We have new SCOTUS related post at the "real blog."

There was no conference last Friday, but some action this week all the same. First, they worked out a bit more how the oral arguments will go in the Texas abortion cases (earlier they pushed back arguments scheduled that day to make room). Basically, the most notable thing, the state and private parties will have separate argument time, at least in one of the cases.

The next order seems to tee up an arbitration case to replace one that was dropped. See here for the details. The order itself merely grants a stay, but I think cert. ultimately would make sense. 

===

Oklahoma was due on Thursday to re-start their executions, having multiple executions scheduled over the next few months. The lower court held it up, there being challenges involving the lethal injection protocols. Yes, even after they spent years examining the question on their own. 

(The docket page of the Supreme Court case can provide access to briefs from both sides. One thing that is a tad ironic is the claim  with religious liberty connotations.  It just goes to show how open ended that sort of thing might be.) 

There are, as usual, various issues involved in the cases, including a claim of racism in the jury process.  The first person up for execution was waved forward by the state pardon and parole board by a 3-2 vote.  Okay. This shows that even a case where the details seem less iffy (murder in prison) has question marks.  Moving past that the crime happened over twenty years ago.  Same issues with executions so long after the crime again. 

The Supreme Court -- without any explanation on either end -- overruled the lower court, 5-3  (Gorsuch did not take part, probably being involved in the proceedings in the past).  The order itself only posted on the Order Page some time Friday afternoon.  Various reporters posted a preliminary link right away -- that happens sometimes; the posting delay was longer here. 

(The docket page for each case is an "inside baseball" thing that many will not be aware of, but it provides helpful breakdown of developments as well as briefing that helps clarify the arguments on both sides.  

SCOTUSBlog has a page for each case the Supreme Court accepts for argument as well as some that are pending.  These too are helpful resources.  For instance, when SCOTUS grants a case, I usually can insert the case name in a search engine and the SCOTUS page for it pops up.  This allows me a quick way to determine what the case is about.) 

The execution took place later that afternoon.  It did not seem to go well: "He began convulsing and vomited. Medical team wiped his face. He was still breathing. Convulsed and vomited more."  The reporter referenced compared it to the Lockett execution. Which was botched.  

The dissenting court of appeals judge and state referenced how long this is taking and so forth.  What's the argument?  "Hey, we could have messed this up years ago!"  Oklahoma authorized nitrogen gas -- the latest "this will be great!" method -- a few years back.  But, it couldn't figure out a way to formulate a way to do it.*  (I sort of figured there was some problems likely involved.)  The firing squad is available but last used in 1915.  

If the particular drugs they have available can't do the job, they should use another method of execution or punishment. There were two other executions recently without this sort of thing happening.  It is not like the state wasn't on notice the drugs could cause problems. The last two executions each had problems.  

Scalia/Thomas argued a specific intent is necessary to prove an 8th Amendment violation.  At some point, even that seems to have be met here.  Indifference of clear possible harms at some point is enough of a red flag.  The current rule assumes the state has some "right" to execute so the defendant has to show the availability of an alternative when alleging the method is illegal. This somewhat perverse rule was argued by the court below to have been met.  

Either way, this result shows the problems with it.  Some theoretical ancient cruelty akin to an actual burning at the stake should not be required to stop this from happening.  [This seems to be in theory left open in the recent Supreme Court opinions that handwaved that being present here and/or resting on other grounds, basically rejecting proof of danger being present.]

The usual responses were made on Twitter as well. Tiresomely.  It is not total hypocrisy to support execution in a few cases while opposing abortion, especially given the number of abortions.  Catholics come in all shapes and sizes.  The person executed committed a horrible crime. The 8A does not have a "horrible guy" exception.  It doesn't take a philosophy or legal degree to realize these things.  I assume many know this.

Again, if the state is allowed -- contra to the decision of the lower court, which placed a stay to allow the factual issues to be determined -- to execute someone, the Supreme Court should SAY WHY!  If they should not, the three justices who think that should SAY WHY!  I know Sotomayor is tired of representing and Breyer is tired from his happy-go-lucky book tour and all, but they still should have wrote a dissent.  

Oklahoma does not have some "right" to constantly fuck up executing people, even if executions are currently constitutional.  Well, functionally, they do.  

---

The Biden Administration might have split on who they wanted -- talk of a California judge who some might want to have Kagan-prepped to be a justice, but she didn't want the job -- but the acting solicitor general was confirmed to have the job permanently.  Years back, did Miss Idaho (really) know how far she would go?  

Solicitor General Kagan began with the re-argument of Citizens United, the big campaign case.  H/t Amy Howe (and others), we now have confirmation that the new SG will also start things off with a major case: "For petitioner: Elizabeth B. Prelogar, Solicitor General, Department of Justice, Washington, D. C." 

===

There was a Friday conference and an order was dropped granting some cases for review.  Two major issues.  To quote two reporters, "agrees to consider limiting EPA's authority to curb greenhouse gases from power plants, will hear appeals from coal-mining companies and Republican-led states" and "Red States' bid to reinstate Trump-era immigration rule known as the public charge rule."  The latter regarding their right to bring a suit to defend the rule once the U.S. stops defending it. 

I will post this now. If anything else happens -- see below; there has been enough -- I will update.  

Update:  Yeah.  They, decided to drop a late in the day bit.  The High Federalists wanted to block Maine's vaccination mandate for not being properly respectful of religious liberty.  In their view.

Barrett/Kavanaugh thinks this would be a misuse of the "emergency docket."  Prof. Shadow Docket flags they seem to be applying a "when it feels right to us" rule.  Which is iffy if honest.  The others just reject it.  

Just how much of a threat it is to religious liberty is debated.

===

A final comment.  It can overwhelm you if you are not careful, but this post alone shows the about of information at our fingertips these days. As someone is being executed, you can have a running commentary.  Before, you can access the ongoing legal battle, reading a lot of opinions about it both in briefs, court opinions, and elsewhere. And, after, you can read more, including someone like Prof. Lain on Twitter, an expert on executions, who expressed how pissed off she was.  

Just one thing.  Again, it is a bit overwhelming. Still, it's pretty amazing and useful.  Like food in a supermarket, what you do with it is up to you. And, those who report on it should be aware of the resources available, and try to help readers with links and so forth to better understand what is going on. It's a complicated thing to do right, but hey, there are people skilled at that sort of thing.  

---

* One of these days, we will have use of nitrogen gas, and it surprises me somewhat it has not happened yet.  To be clear, this is not cyanide gas.  

I think inertia is delaying this, assisted by there being so few executions in the last few years.  The federal execution by statute follow local practice, so all of them used lethal injection.  Once nitrogen is used and it seems okay, others might follow.  Lethal injection surely has enough hardships.

Like I doubt there is a shortage of nitrogen or anything.  We shall see, including if it will work without a hitch.  Its lethal nature in non-execution contexts is only so comparable. 

Thursday, October 28, 2021

Justice Department Addresses Violent Threats Against School Officials

I have written about critical race theory (the last part is by the teacher who runs the website). Some applications, including some distrust about the good faith of those in power and results that burden others, very well might warrant push back at times.  At least, a reasonable argument. But, this woman is all over the place. She has more of a shall we say "ethos."

But, she speaks for many, and many Republicans (including the person running for governor of Virginia; he is also "stop the steal" curious) are loathe to challenge them.  We saw this when Attorney General Garland was in front of the Senate and Republicans kept on harping on a legal memorandum concerned about an uptick on harassment of school officials. 

Sen. Sasse suggested the main concern was some offensive "yokels." Repeated attempts were made to suggest it would threaten mere criticism at school board meetings.  That is was an offensive invasion of local control. Some ideological / partisan takeover of the Justice Department.  They laid on it real thick, including Sen. Kennedy who was more offensive than usual (he usually does a Mr. Haney from Green Acres shtick).

The NYT article touched upon what is involved here:

But news accounts over the past year have detailed physical fights, arrests, charges of disorderly conduct and threats made against board members, faculty and administrators stemming from arguments over topics that have animated the right, such as mask mandates, gender issues and curriculum that deals with racism.

And, Sen. Cory Booker (who is so doggone earnest) also eventually [the first rounds basically covered various Democratic concerns, though one Twitter thread flagged the newbie from Georgia as usual was diligent with oversight type questions] flagged the real concerns involved. 

The press release (linked with the memo cited) explains what is involved and references how the Justice Department will ensure that threats are "communicated to the appropriate authorities."  The memorandum itself is entitled a "partnership" with local and federal authorities. It starts reaffirming "spirited debate" is protected.  Meetings are sought out to determine the proper path.  If localities do not want the federal government's help here -- there is all the same a whole Department of Education for these purposes -- they need not accept it.   

The level of offense, hysteria, and partisan attacks by Republicans regarding a serious issue is very offensive.  I speak both as a citizen who cares about these issues and someone with a sister and niece who are teachers.  I don't like to personalize things -- that seems the road to subjectivity -- but hey, I linked my CRT piece and the teacher who runs the website at one point outs me as her brother.  I commend her for her honesty.

The high dudgeon that the memorandum is proof positive that the Justice Department has been taken over by partisan forces is a tad much from the Trump Party.  But, we can move past that.  I do not know the level of uptick here, but it would not be surprising. There has been an increase of heat in recent years by those who feel left out, having the world pass them by.  It is both a bit ironic and understandable they call others "LOSERS" so often.

The bottom line is the need to safeguard basic civic institutions, including schools, voting, and the courts.  Sen. Sasse, who puts himself out as a civics minded type, especially comes off badly here.  Not that I have a high opinion of him by now, even if he voted to convict in the second impeachment trial.  And, again, it is just a legal memorandum with caveats and ultimately proposing meetings!  

One side is coming off as totally unserious here.  And, we are supposed to block basic things like voting rights to protect bipartisanship with them?  As I said in the past, that at the very least requires a level of willingness to be credible partners that is not being shown.   

ETA: This bit of hysteria was cited by Senator Cotton.  

A more general thing about Attorney General Garland.  People are upset about how the Justice Department is handling investigations of Trump and other matters.  I do not know how that will turn out yet though it is reasonable to think it will not go as far as warranted.  If you are upset, however, it probably goes to the top.  This roughly matches the wishes of President Biden.  He chose Garland advisedly.  

While discussing this, people still bring out his nomination to fill the Scalia seat.  People are still critical of the nomination.  I still find that rather misguided.  It still bothers me when people flag it.  Given the full reality of the situation, including the fact the Republican controlled Senate was not going to even provide a hearing to anyone (even someone as mild as Garland), opposing his nomination is even more asinine.  

In general, re-litigating things tends to be tiresome, especially when the same arguments are made, in the same confused way.

Wednesday, October 27, 2021

Biden / Rachel Held Evans' New Book

We stand in defense of religious freedom not only as an expression of our deepest values but also because it is a vital national security priority. The United States will continue to rally the globe to protect and promote the right of freedom of religion or belief, including through multilateral coalitions such as the International Religious Freedom or Belief Alliance.

While the details (not as much as desired) of the reconciliation bill is negotiated, I saw something cited as a central promise of the Biden Campaign. Eh. Biden promised a range of things (his ultimate four issues were COVID, race, climate, and the economy/workers) and two basic things -- being decent and being basically a qualified experienced person. You know, not-Trump. Talk about some "key" promise otherwise is somewhat bullshit.

Biden's decency and empathy -- however a bit laid on thick it might seem at times -- are likely his biggest draws. And, I do think it is on a basic level real. As is his religious faith. One person flagged that he has an asshole side. I think so -- it comes out at times when he finds some critics or something being clueless or worse. That too really is appealing. 

===

Rachel Held Evans continues to publish books, so to speak, even though she died two years ago. Her death, under 40 with two young children, was very hard for many people in the religious community who saw her as a positive, but questioning Christian voice, one that also spoke with a feminist tenor. One book she was working on was a children's book:

In the book co-authored with Matthew Paul Turner, Held Evans encourages children to “think about what makes you feel safe, what makes you feel loved, and what makes you feel brave. That’s what God is like.”

I think of religion in large part a form of poetry. I think "God" is best seen as a form of metaphor, a symbolism of something that humans need to personalize. Some people ridicule that sort of thing. I think that is unfair. A person might have a confused or even cruel view of God. But, one like that is not of that nature. The article also notes:

“The God I have come to believe in is not some stern grandpa in the sky, waiting for me to slip up,” she writes. “Instead, I’ve come to see God through the things that God has done... That God is the architect of creation, the engineer of love, and the master craftsman who came up with the idea of the heart.”

This reminds me somewhat of the God of Thomas Paine, a God he argued is shown through the universe. Evans' blog and writings are worthwhile and are particularly important to her fellow Christian believers. One was a bit silly attempt to follow biblical rules. One was a creative look at the Bible through different means. I liked it the most. Two were more geared to her experiences during her faith journey. You can also find many videos of her online.

“I’m agnostic. I think God is unlikely. I don’t believe prayer heals. If it did, sick people prayed for would be healed more often than those who aren’t,” he wrote. “But if I ever believe again, it will be in the God Rachel understood. I hope for the God of “What Is God Like?”

I don't know if her husband was an agostic before her own death. I would understand if that was the reason he was pushed into that. But, since sick people always were around, I hope not. I also think prayer can help, can "heal" without going all the way. It is like a medicine that tempers the pain. I speak in general, not as someone who uses prayer. But, when someone says "pray for me" or something, is it not a request for empathy? Is that not a positive thing? Does it not help in some fashion?

Her new book is coming out soon and is scheduled to be at the NYPL eventually. When it does, I will probably write more. 

[The History focused book review page I contribute to now has a few reviews, including three by a Muslim author.]

Monday, October 25, 2021

NFL Update

The Bills have a bye, but you can see former Jets (and Giants) quarterbacks this week.

One along with his team down in Carolina had no offense (three early points; it was 5-3 for a while, but the Giants eventually scored a TD, tacked on, and won 25-3) while Geno Smith is filling in at Seattle. The Jets (beaten and then beaten some more by the Pats) will need a back-up too. Their QB will be out for a few weeks at least.

There were many uncompetitive games over the weekend, including Kansas City being beaten 27-3 (by the Titans, who have beaten the Bills, while being beaten by the Jets). The Sunday Night game (in the rain) was competitive until late. The Monday Night Game has a couple of major teams (Saints/Seattle) with iffy QBs. One more week of action this year!

Sunday, October 24, 2021

Braves v. Astros

Sports is in part an emotional thing. People find a reason to root for one side, even if objectively there is no real reason to be so passionate. In the case of the Astros (a sort of forgotten about very good team with only five less wins than the 100 win Rays, with two good divisional opponents) -- the 2021 World Series home team -- somewhat less so.

I did not pay much attention to the Astros cheating scandal, though Carlos Beltran's role did eventually affect the Mets. After their GM and manager was fired, they still managed to almost make it in the 2020 series. They also got a fine (5M? uh huh) and lost some draft picks. Their players were not penalized. They didn't have to give up their World Series trophy, aided by cheating. Yeah, it seems not enough.

The Braves only got over .500 mid-summer and still had a mediocre run in them. But, the division was worse. And, they had the luck of a weak hitting Brewers team and apparently a Dodgers team finally spent. The bullpen game strategy also seems to have helped, including overuse of Scherzer, which burnt them this series. Still, the Dodgers had second and third with no outs with the score 4-2 in the seventh. Three strike outs. Impressive.

Saturday, October 23, 2021

More On Previous Subjects (Voting/ERA)

I briefly referenced voting and the ERA. I will discuss it some more here.

Today was the beginning of early voting in New York. In the past, I was wary of the concept, perhaps largely out of sentiment.  Years back, I wrote something about saying heck with tradition, but I have some desires in that direction.  I should not be too full of myself.  Still, I think there is some value to a single special day (make it a national holiday) to vote.  But, that ignores the inconvenience involved.  So, yeah, more days is helpful.  

Early voting was one of the reforms that full Democratic control of the state brought (so it came in 2019).  I first had to walk about a half hour away to the public high school I would have went to if my parents didn't send me to a Catholic high school to avoid it.  My sister now is a teacher there, having gone there herself years back.  For the primary this year, there was a closer spot.  Now, there is a spot about five minutes away.

This year we have local races, including a new mayor.  Eric Adams won a close primary and is running against the Guardian Angels / talk show host guy who likes cats.  Curtis Sliwa is not a serious candidate really, but since the Republican candidate would be a thankless role anyway, perhaps the party can do much worse.  I'm not too gung ho for Adams, but he should do okay.  I'm glad Marjorie Velázquez will be my city council person, after she lost to a more conservative guy who resigned his assemblyman slot to get the job.  The comptroller will be a progressive who AOC likes.  

[I was thinking of voting for some third party person on the mayor line since Eric Adams has nothing to worry about and he is a bit too moderate on certain issues for me.  But, I by rote started filling in the Democratic line ovals, so voted for him. It's okay -- opposition to Biden and the Democrats warrants a reminder of the importance of supporting them. Net, he will likely be a good mayor, even if on a few issues, I will be upset.

There was also a lower court judicial election -- pick five of six, five being Democrats. Now, me, that is easy, but what if I was not a Democrat? Anyway, unlike some places, judicial elections are not really advertised much at all around here.  Other than party, and their names, there really is no way to judge if you should vote for these people. The voting guides sent to us don't even provide information.  My protest, ha, is to write in someone's name here.  You do what you can.]

There are also five ballot measures, submitted by the legislature by the constitutional process in place.  I covered this before.  I decided to vote "yes" on all of them but the first, a catchall provision involving various redistricting measures.  I decided that there was too many things to vote for at once and something like keeping the number of senators in place was not ideal anyhow.  Why not leave that open to discretion?  

As usual, I appreciate having the chance to vote, and doing my part. Thank You For Voting, the book I referenced, at one point spoke about people believing their voting "matters" is on some level a myth.  On some level, since it does matter, but it isn't unclear how much.  Still, it does matter, including on a personal level.  Voting in part is a special act that is the center of our contribution as a citizen as a whole.  I agree as a whole therefore with the book The Duty to Vote.

Section 1. Equality of rights under the law shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of sex. Section 2. The Congress shall have the power to enforce, by appropriate legislation, the provisions of this article. Section 3. This article shall take effect 2 years after the date of ratification.

I also briefly touched upon a House hearing regarding the ERA.  Earlier this year, the House (basically by party line) voted to remove the deadline originally in place for its ratification.  There is some debate, but I think it is the case that a simple majority is all that is needed to do this.  The deadline was not part of the amendment itself.  It is like the punishment vote after the supermajority vote passes in the case of impeachment.

I linked one of the various discussion threads in a blog over its ratification for which I added multiple comments. In the past, my druthers was that we really shouldn't pass the ERA.  It seems a bit redundant and why should we focus on one category of equal protection?  Voting is dealt piecemeal in the Constitution, and it leaves something to be desired.  Also, I thought as a matter of norms, it dubious to finish the process forty years later, with so much having changed since the beginning of the process. 

I do think Congress has the power to determine that contemporary needs warrants removing the deadline.  The hearing had some assumptions that this was unnecessary, that the Constitution just provides for proposal and ratification.  But,  Supreme Court precedent recognizes some discretion there, discretion to recognize the understanding that the ratification process be contemporary.  [Such issues are covered some here.]

The limited nature of the 27A alone suggests we should not put too much emphasis on it.  I think they should have re-introduced it anyway.  Its mostly symbolic reach made congressional passage in the 1980s pretty easy to imagine and ultimately enough states ratified to make up for the few old ratification from yore.  

I still am wary at singling out "sex" here, though especially in the 21st Century, that has a broad reach (gender identity, sexual orientation, trans issues involved, while more debated in the 1970s).  Perhaps, the ratification would encourage additional amendments. That might be a good thing, since things such as voting warrants attention.  

But, I have changed my mind on the reach of the amendment. The amendment is not redundant.  Moving past the specific textual statement of "sex" (Prof. Nourse warned us about Scalia there) and not needing to use the equal protection component of due process to address the federal government (the latter, a bit of nicety only a few care about), the language is clearly broader.  How much is unclear.  That warrants careful review.

The thing is -- and this isn't really new -- just what it means is not really dwelt upon too much.  Yes, people are concerned -- as they were -- about its reach over such things like gay rights and abortion. 

When the 14A was ratified, people saw it generally as a way to protect civil rights (and do specific partisan leaning things in the middle sections that soon became somewhat obsolete). The specifics were not dwelt upon, even if some now say things like "obviously" it incorporated the Bill of Rights (people were not really concerned about if grand juries now were thing for each state) or something.  

Same here -- it was and is seen as a general matter of sexual equality.  But, the text is important here all the same.  What about the specifics of the text?  "Equality of rights under the law shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of sex." Here I move past a fairly obvious statement that the amendment provides more clarity for accepting a strong acceptance of sex as a "strict scrutiny" category.

Originalists might be concerned about how "on account of sex" has a broader meaning in 2021 than when it was proposed in the early 1970s. This might make them concerned about the length of the ratification process, leading to confusion on meaning.  I'm not an originalist, but that does concern me to some degree when looking at what the people think they are ratifying. Congress does serve a legitimizing function here.  

Due process now cannot be "deprived" while equal protection cannot be "denied."  The language is not the same though it is unclear how much it matters.  The federal government cannot deny equal protection (as a matter of due process).  But, "abridged" is broader. The Privileges or Immunities Clause of the 14A says "make or abridge."  It historically has had limited reach.  This is an additional barrier to full understanding.

Still, the word "abridge" suggests that limiting is blocked as well with congressional enabling legislation providing even additional protections to make sure that doesn't happen.  The word "abridge" is found in the First Amendment (speech) and we see how far that is taken these days.

And, there is this: "Equality of rights under the law."  That is another interesting phrasing. What exactly does that mean?  The 14A says states cannot deny equal protection of the laws.  Is that the same thing as "equality of rights"?  What does "under the law" add?  The hearing spoke of equal pay and such.  Prof. Nourse was part of the effort (Biden's baby) to pass the Violence Against Women Act.  U.S. v. Morrison rejected that as applied to "private" action, including public accommodations.

There seems to be a general assumption that the amendment, especially the enforcement clause, would provide broad protection and powers to enforce equality here.  If so, again, this does more than the current Constitution is generally understood to mean -- surely as applied by current doctrine.  

The amendment would under this light be a sort of "modern" protection of equality.  The language very well might warrant that.  Let us be upfront about the change all the same.  It would also make the opposition more understandable, perhaps, to those who wonder why sexual equality (even beyond hot button issues) is apparently controversial.  

I support a wider view of equality, particularly regarding the reach of the federal government in its enforcement.  Realistically, I do not see the ERA being ratification in the immediate future.  But, discussing its reach is important.  The hearing (which I did not watch all of, so maybe the textual nuances were covered more than I saw) was appreciated.

As with other constitutional matters, however, the true breadth of the question also should be covered. 

Books and TV

Books: I have been tasked to add history book reviews here.

The first set basically involves me writing segments for stuff I read already though for a few I re-read them. The latest, not published yet, involve stuff touched upon here -- Thank You For Voting (topical for the start of early voting) and Louisa On The Front Lines. The "front lines" here amount to a short stint as a nurse, so there is some more filler material, including covering the last twenty or so years of her life briefly.

Television: Tom Hanks' co-star on the 1980s dress-up show Bosom Buddies has died. Peter Scolari is not quite as successful, but had a long and successful career (including Newhart). Meanwhile, Astros won in six -- sort of expected; surprising really that the Red Sox lasted this long. We will see how the Braves do (ETA: won in 6). Yes, Mets, hire him; he's a pro.

Friday, October 22, 2021

SCOTUS Watch

FTC exclusive: Barrett’s chambers refused to allow livestreaming or any video for 9/12 McConnell Center event; newest justice feted with McConnell-hosted dinner, free hotel & flight & personalized Louisville Slugger bat, per just-received public.

Maybe, the Presidential Commission on the Supreme Court will be on notice about such things. The link provides more detail of what the Fix the Court records request obtained, including the Court's public information office ("PIO" in lingo) reminding event planners and so forth what ethical rules (voluntary as they might be for members of the Supreme Court) require. Barrett's refusal for open government should be kept in mind while she and others do not want to be considered partisan hacks.

On the partisan hack front, a look at the C-SPAN website to check the timing of the daily Biden press briefing provided this video:

Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) and U.S. Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas joined the Heritage Foundation for an even marking thirty years of service by Justice Thomas on the Supreme Court. The Senate minority leader spoke about the importance of the Judiciary, while Justice Thomas thanked all those who have helped and supported him along the way as he reflected on his time on the Supreme Court.

I wonder how Breyer feels about this and its effects on his sads on how the Court's legitimacy is more in question of late.  Quite seriously, this is horrible stuff.  You really should not have someone tossed out as the "intellectual leader" of the current Court or whatever, and place him in a blatantly partisan situation like that.  As someone said, what if Kagan had a joint appearance with Senator Majority Leader Chuck Schumer?

===

Fridays repeatedly in the last year or so have brought various special news of interest from the Supreme Court, at times later in the evening.  There is as you might recall no conference scheduled this week. But, we had big news.  The Supreme Court accepted two Texas abortion law cases, with oral arguments scheduled November 1st.  

Today being the 22nd, let's say that is very fast as the Supreme Court goes.   The speed is also a creature of their own creation. If, like four justices (including Roberts), wanted at the end of August, they simply stayed the law, there could have been a steady and deliberate legal process without such glaring speed.  It not only would be a good idea to protect abortion rights, but as a matter of good litigation discretion. 

The Firearms Policy Coalition, a pro-guns rights group, for instance, submitted a brief warning what a "keep away" law of this nature could be used for in other contexts.  It also was left to Justice Sotomayor, Breyer and Kagan perhaps (again) strategically silent, to remind that every day is a glaring undue burden on abortion rights.  

If the idea is that the Supreme Court will probably eventually hold against Texas being able to do this, it doesn't really improve the argument that they were dead wrong not to stay the law. The law being so clearly wrong even for a conservative court sympathetic to its stance on abortion only underlines it should have been stayed.  

To be clear, the two cases (though Texas was open to making it about that) were not taken to examine the substance of the law, that is, if you can block abortion where there is a "heartbeat."  The federal case concerns the power of the United States to bring its lawsuit.  The state case, looking at the question presented, is about the procedural barrier of even having the law examined until someone eventually gets sued for a bounty etc.  

We shall see what happens, but the Supreme Court is not really being "reasonable" here because (eventually) they stop this shitty law. It is especially not impressive if the idea is to provide "cover" when it gets around to watering down Planned Parenthood v. Casey.   

Some of the usual suspects might say otherwise. But, as with the Trump trio working with Moscow Mitch, their legitimacy remains quite dubious. The (eventual) removal of this issue from the "shadow docket" gets a minimum cookie in my book, at best. 

===

We have the first correction of the term. Yes, we only had two per curiams, but on Friday, an edited version (a one word typo) was dropped. 

Core Bullshit On Budget Framing

I don't watch it much, but saw a thing on Chris Hayes that pissed me off. It reminded us of how the spending packages that the Democrats are working on are so horribly covered.

We are told of trillion dollar price tags without regularly (like it is some complicated thing to say) being told it is for TEN YEARS. And, the money is less than is spent of the military. The money is going to various things. The military (Congress gave the defense department MORE than it asked for in the latest budget authorization) alone gets more.

It is bad enough that this thing is made out as merely some process story, one where the Democrats are made to look like stumbling clowns. The usual sausage making and how the Republicans simply refuse to take part in a package the public as a whole widely supports is ignored. The policy matters are ignored. But, the simple BULLSHIT framing on the money is alone so aggravating. We need to do more to constantly fight it.

Thursday, October 21, 2021

Constitution Watch

ERA: The House had two hearings of note about the same time -- Attorney General Garland and an oversight hearing on the status of the ERA. Nice to see Prof. Victoria Nourse. The Republican witness tossed in some anti-trans material. Alyssa Milano provided some celebirty presence. Some links here. Some past thoughts on the matter here.

I had mixed feelings about accepting the ratification after around forty years, but as a matter of power, Coleman v. Miller seems to give Congress the power to do so. The supporters here suggested basically the deadline could be ignored. Eh. I think it a discretionary statement of ripeness. I still not clear what exactly the text will add, but have reached a judgment it is broader than the Equal Protection Clause. "Abridge" etc.

Death Penalty: Meanwhile, after delayed by the Supreme Court holding they need to allow a minister in the death chamber, the latest challenge to Willie Smith's execution was rejected. Things were held up for Sotomayor to agree there was no procedural ground left, but that the process is still problematic. I appreciate the brief discussion, which I think is warranted for each execution. Net result: executed, but no nitrogen gas yet.

Wednesday, October 20, 2021

TV Watch

I checked out the first episode of the new Chucky series (I liked the movies as a whole; did not watch the third and thought the last a bit garbled). It starts off on an impressive footing, with good performances, writing, music, and atmosphere. It also appears that you are allowed to say "fuck" on USA Network. The series has received some kudos as well for being GBLTQ friendly. Jennifer Tilly will be back. Maybe, they can get Catherine Hicks!

All Rise, the diverse crime drama led by a black woman judge appeared to have been cancelled after a two season run on CBS. The show had some behind the scenes drama with the showrunner, but ended fairly well. It in fact will return on OWN Network, which I hopefully have. We will see how this goes, but sounds good. The range of possible networks and platforms allows salvaging such worthwhile material.

A Taste of Honey (along with another film with the young British actress in the lead) was on TCM. It is a B&W film from 1961, which has some Mike Leigh in it. In that, I mean a realistic look at the working class without bells and whistles. It's well acted with people who seem like real figures (including a sympathetic gay character), not performers. This includes flawed characters and a somewhat downbeat ending [see link] though that part is not really totally necessary for things to be realistic. The actress still is acting today.

Monday, October 18, 2021

RIP Colin Powell (Bronx Guy)

Colin Powell, in his 80s with a medical condition that made him particularly at risk, died of COVID related illness though he was vaccinated. Many kudos, including from liberals like Melissa Harris-Perry and Joy Reid along with some not suprising "f you" type responses for him helping to sell Iraq War II. Both are fair though he did repent and later support Democrats.

SCOTUS Watch: Orders etc.

In 2015, moreover, the United States rejected a request from Polish prosecutors to facilitate Abu Zubaydah’s testimony under the countries’ bilateral mutual legal-assistance treaty. Nonetheless, the government would permit Abu Zubaydah.

Coverage of the states secret case orals suggests that the government is likely to win, but (as in the past) litigation alone has some value. For instance, even conservatives like Barrett say the "t" word (torture) aloud. And, multiple judges (Breyer, Sotomayor, Gorsuch) also specifically asked about having the GITMO prisoner to testify himself (see also that article).

A letter (cited in the opening) sent to SCOTUS from the Biden Administration clarified the situation to some extent.  [The letter is linked at the article; CNN covers it without providing a link.]  The government, leaving open the right to redact for national security, is willing to let the prisoner write about his experiences using the process (explained) in place.  This all shows how even limited access to lawyers and judicial oversight can provide some checks to the system in place. 

PCSCOTUS: We continue have coverage of the draft chapters of the presidential commission's report.  SCOTUSBlog, which even as a blog specifically geared to SCOTUS has had limited coverage, has a helpful report on the proceedings on Friday.  It is fine to criticize and/or discuss the limited nature of the commission's actions etc.  But, this requires a full accounting of what they are doing.* 

(I also saw an interesting footnote that was reported earlier.  Two conservative members of the commission resigned, including notable "sane" Jack Goldsmith.  Why?  Who knows, but it is a bit weird, and notable. They so far don't want to say why, which you know, is wrong. Note the "do nothing and support status quo" theme of some coverage is a bit off given some of the critical comments referenced in that article alone.) 

Order List: There is no conference this week, so there will be a break from the weekly order lists, but today's was somewhat more notable than usual.  First, beyond the usual odds and ends of some note, the Supreme Court granted two cases involving tribal matters for full review.  They do not seem to be major cases (as if I'd know!), but we shall see.

As noted at that link and by various tweets on Legal Twitter, the Court also by two (by definition) unsigned per curiams -- without any cited dissents (so, you know, without dissent in fact), reversed two lower court cases that denied qualified immunity in abuse of force cases.  This is basically "error correction," something that they supposedly do not really want to do.  And, a few exceptions aside, it usually goes in a conservative way. 

Some comments on Twitter suggested the phrasing might be a flag to additionally restrict qualified immunity cases (e.g., "In one of its summary rulings this morning, #SCOTUS dropped a strong hint that *circuit* precedent may no longer be sufficient to provide “clearly established” law. That would be a *huge* barrier to damages suits against government officers who violate constitutional rights.").

Qualified immunity -- one of the many things that federal legislation can address if there is a will -- has been overused.  Without dealing with the weeds, the basic idea in my view is that people should generally have a broad right to at least try to show abuse occurred.  They might lose.  But, they should at least try.  And, individual actors (like a police officer) still might be protected; the ultimate issue is having some ability to get relief from the government in some fashion.   

Error correction clearly has some intent on clarifying the law though it is done in a rather opaque way.  Various justices last term flagged their concern about giving proper discretion to police and other public officials in certain emergency situations and so forth.  Such and such officer goes to a call where someone is allegedly at risk, and they have to think in the moment. Fine enough.  As applied -- clarified by cases they take for review -- the people can show their actions are acceptable.** 

Miscellaneous Orders: After I wrote this originally, SCOTUS dropped two separate orders.  One allotted order time for various cases where the Solicitor General has time.  Another granted a request by a challenger to speed along the SB8 case (this is not the U.S. case against Texas).  What this means is unclear -- various theories on Legal Twitter.

Book Review: Skimmed: Breastfeeding, Race, and Injustice uses the experience of the first black identical quintuplets to examine this subject.  I first saw it when Melissa Murray (always good for material) flagged in on Twitter.  (As I recall, someone talked about food and the law.)  And, it is appropriate to include here because there is a lot of law, including Supreme Court cases, involved in the mix.  The rest of the book tells their story. 

One thing (though the date is wrong) that is cited is an old Fifth Circuit case that says breastfeeding is an aspect of the constitutional right to privacy.  I am familiar with the case since repeatedly it is cited in string cites when some lower court opinion references privacy cases. As shown here, it has not had much influence as precedent, even as applied to the parties involved apparently.  But, the book's legal discussion includes what "might be," and on that front, it still is important.  

One interesting connection is the involvement of Susie Sharp, who became the first (white) female Chief Justice of the North Carolina Supreme Court.   I have a biography of Susie Sharp.  This book is written by a white woman, but Prof. Murray is not.  

Also, the book makes sure to make some comments about the freedom of choice, but is clearly pro-breastfeeding. In a few spots, perhaps a bit much, since many women very well would want, e.g., a doctor's office to have stuff on the wall supporting both breastfeeding and formula.   Finally, yes, it is wrong to "moo" at people who are nursing.  I apologize, however, for laughing a bit when seeing that.  It's okay to be a bit mean silently.  

A suggestion to include the book as an entry at a new book review website was turned down for the time being because of limited attention.  But, "Books in a Flash" is finally online.  I will mainly contribute "History" books for review and those interested can click the History link here, a few books already up. 

---

* Note this line from a criticism (after I wrote this entry) on relying on term limits (which alone isn't enough, besides being a long shot anyway): "Perhaps this result was to be expected from a commission ostensibly created to study Supreme Court expansion."  

If this means "along with other things," sure. As spelled out in the executive order, "reform proposals" (more than expansion being out there) should be addressed.  I'm unsure if that is quite how many take it though. It sort of implies that was the primary reason they are there.  

The linked Slate article says these things -- including the shadow docket which has had a fairly recent uptake -- been "studied to death."  As compared to let's say civil rights when Truman had that studied?  It is upset conservatives (two less now) are on a commission -- apparently you need strong (as compared to weak links like Laurence Tribe) supporters of court expansion for legitimacy, but well conservatives? Surely not. 

The fact the analysis notes the commissioners -- who are criticized as too moderate, wary of change -- pushed back shows maybe we should give them some credit.  

** One of the cases is highlighted in this blog post.

The lower court opinion does not come off as patently unreasonable.  The Supreme Court per curiam -- without full briefing or argument -- decides by examining the facts (not their job really) that the situation on the ground is different from a previous circuit case relied on by the court of appeals.

The blog post reminds us of the George Floyd case.  I'm unsure if that is fair, since this case involves a much more momentary use of force. But, what bothers me yet again here is that the case seems to turn on debatable details that the Supreme Court reached out to "error correct."  

Maybe, the lower court was wrong.  If so, it was far from glaringly so.  The case they cite has multiple similarities to the current case.  The notable difference seems to be that the guy here had a knife on his person. The court of appeals, however, note he also was just shot with a beanbag gun. And, there was reason to judge the knife was not a danger.  

These are FACTUAL questions for a jury to decide.  If the case is so clearly reasonable, that can be judged then.  Consider a call that seems to many to be pretty clear.  A replay very well might determine there is no grounds to overrule.  You still have a chance to try.  It's not for replay office to second guess an agreement among the umpires that the call was at least somewhat open to debate (if that is the rule!).  

The Supreme Court tries less than seventy cases for full argument these days.  Why the hell are they interfering with these marginal cases?  They do not only refuse to change the rules for qualified immunity.  They want to reach out and error correct the hundreds (or more) cases like this, in the process affecting many more. Without argument.  It's wrong.  

Saturday, October 16, 2021

Thoughts on Saturday Articles

Sinema: It would seem logical for Kyrsten Sinema to become an independent. Shades of Bernie Sanders, she has not been a mainstream Democrat over her career.  It was not just that she wants to be a "maverick" like her predecessor, John McCain.  It is that the state finds that sort of thing attractive (as do others), and her personality/political history was something of a good fit. 

Some cite her membership of the Green Party to show her troll type tendencies. But, I'll grant some good faith here, mixed with just a basic part of her personality. That sort of thing, the showy stuff, isn't going to disappear. That part of the op-ed is a bit silly.  And, I will grant (honestly) she has basic progressive positions on a range of issues, sometimes more so than Manchin.  She is a bother, but bothers are not just fakes.

I am even sympathetic to a degree -- more so than some -- of the passion for bipartisanship.  Fine.  The problem is that Republicans have to put up or shut up.  The mild infrastructure bill that some supported was a limited example of just that.  But, what else?  I'll accept compromising on reconciliation and voting rights if there was some real evidence of bipartisan support of a weaker package.  To do so for a bill that is supported by the median of the party and probably would get 48 votes, without ONE Republican joining in?  Come the fuck on.   

Still, though it might ruin her "independent Democrat" cred some, if she wants to act like a (pesky) gadfly, why not be honest about it?  Maybe, she can get a bit of it out of her system without doing unproductive things like not meeting with her constituents and saying what she wants.  Note that this is a red flag to people -- it is not that they just want her to be a "loyal Democrat" with every disagreement a sign she is some "traitor."  OTOH, blocking something like voting rights?  Well, that is a deal breaker.

(Voting is also one of those "must haves" where if you need to break the filibuster, okay, you break the filibuster. This is so even if you think that is not appropriate for other legislation.  It's like when at some point blocking Obama's appointments got to be too much and you had to end filibusters for executive appointments. A few now forget why it was done and are all "I don't think we should have done that."  No.  It was appropriate.) 

We already have a few independents, including the guy from Maine.  She can even say that it will encourage Republicans to join the coalition at times.  Someone like Evan McMullen (the conservative challenging Sen. Mike Lee and who ran an independence run in 2016) can on certain issues, for instance. Which might be a pipe dream short term, but hey, I'm sympathetic to the dream.  I'm less sure by this point her good faith.

Vaccine Hesitancy:  A lot of attention is give to Republican politicians (especially the governors of Texas and Florida) and media voices (such as Tucker Carlson) promoting vaccine hesitancy and blocking good Big V policies in the name of "freedom."  And, that sort of thing is a big problem.

It would not be if there lacked a fertile soil for it to grow.  There is some vaccine hesitancy and it's not just against liberals and the like. I'm sure that is part of it.  Maybe, significant part.  But, there is also some real concern over the (real) hardships of dealing with COVID.  Of the possible effects of a vaccine, one unlike some other one, we are not as used to. The bothers of masks, even if it seems trivial in most cases.  And, so on.  

The vaccine hesitancy that arose in recent years [to be clear, there are different moving parts here] has been somewhat cross-ideological. Robert Kennedy Jr., for instance, has been on the case.  The article cites some people who were hesitant and as locals in a NYC paper, logically they are not just the usual conservative suspects.  

But, and mandates played a big part here, there are ways to push them.  Such is why enabling resistance, which often will disappear when pressures are put on it, is so nefarious.  At this point, yes, we should have mandates.  They work.  And, those who focus on this sort of thing will tell you, there are things you can do to address hesitance in general.  It's very important.  

Michael Caine:  Something a bit less important.  Caine, 88, said that he has basically retired from acting.  He is promoting a movie and at least one other is in the process of being released, but he says he might be done.  Well, maybe some voice or stage work will come up.  Okay.

Well, he has been at this from the 1950s, so he had a good run. We will see.  I recall Anthony Hopkins saying something like this some time back, and he has done a lot more work since.  OTOH, recently saw something about Gene Hackman talking about The French Connection and he really has been out of acting for a while now. 

Caine is great overall, including his distinctive voice.  Seems a down to earth guy, but who knows. Haven't heard anything bad about him.  His latest sounds like it might be good; he's a grumpy old writer forced to go on a book tour, from what I can tell.  

Mets:  (Added)  These things necessary to turn the team around highlight basic concerns of mine.  Yes, you need a "veteran manager" who is not a "figurehead."  Yes, you need a winning culture, with the "toxic positivity" (no matter how lovable Alonso was) not the way to go.  Who is the new lead person for baseball operations will factor in here. 

And, yes there needs to be better hiring/vetting practices.  To give some credit, they did make some good talent selections, though their deadline moves (or lack thereof) was not among them.  The article does not reference injuries, but from various accounts, that too was a problem. Many teams had them, but the Mets seemed to have more.  And, the stringing us along with deGrom was annoying.  Fans were right to see problems there.  

The new owner spoke of a World Series win (or at least getting there) in three to five years.  I didn't expect a total win right away.  But, the team continued to have  troubling problems that felt "more of the same."  Keeping a non-veteran manager there because of the Beltran controversy in 2020 to me was but a sign of how it seemed like they were not ready to move on.  They did not have to get to the playoffs (though that would have been nice), but after a somewhat misleading good run, the team collapsed. That too seemed familiar.  Okay.  It's time to shape up.