About Me

My photo
This blog is the work of an educated civilian, not of an expert in the fields discussed.

Saturday, October 16, 2021

Supreme Court Watch

Orders: After the holiday, Tuesday's Order List was rightly seen as "humdrum" and "sleepy" with nothing much happening.

But, these things rarely are totally not noteworthy. Things happen that provide insights to legal practices that maybe are more worthwhile of attention.  For instance, the Supreme Court disposed of a lawsuit against Trump's misuse of power in such and such a case and in effect erases the lower court opinion. The principle involved involves cases that are moot.  The principle is named after a 1950 case, United States v. Munsingwear. 

Trump is no longer in power, so he cannot be required to stop the alleged illegal actions. But, it is an example of him in effect running out the clock with no consequences for what was alleged to be illegal acts. It also takes the lower court case off the books, which means the legal judgment is no longer precedent for further action.  There are technical reasons for that, though maybe it is being overused (per one account I saw), but again there is a sense that something is wrong.  

Oral Arguments: We had a few oral arguments, including in a lesser abortion case and the Boston Bomber  dispute (the actual marathon this year was Monday).   The live audio seems to be going well with Justice Thomas continuing to ask questions.  Roberts' old boss, Chief Justice Rehnquist might be upset about the laxness regarding extending argument times to deal with any further questions the judges desire.  But, though it's a bit messy (if seemingly somewhat more sedate of late), it's fine. 

PCSCOTUS:  The Presidential Commission on the Supreme Court has not really obtained much love. The Supreme Court itself is getting attention, with justices ("justices") speaking out and getting pushback. Breyer continues to make me want to scream "shut up! retire you asshole!"

But, the ongoing commission in place there to examine various issues involving the institution itself rarely gets notice.  This is unfortunate.  Even if people are cynical about the purpose of the whole thing, the Commission provides a platform for discussion of important matters. 

The whole point after all is to provide guidance to the Biden Administration, the political branches in general, of the issues.  If we have a need to address them, why not use this -- including some witnesses with strong criticisms -- as an educational platform to address the issues?  

The Commission had another public meeting today.  The purpose was to discuss what was labeled by press reports as "a preliminary report," though are labeled as "discussion materials."  A few accounts have highlighted comments opposed to court expansion.  A section on court expansion does have some bothersome phrasing.  I'm inclined, however, to wait until the final report comes out.  After all, during the discussions today, multiple members questioned some of the report. Changes are likely.

Friday's (this is being written then) session ended with a notice of the next public meeting to be in about a month's time. They will release a "draft report" beforehand and the meeting will likely discuss things.  I reaffirm my support of this effort and hopefully the final report will in some fashion (cf. a civil rights report in the Truman Administration) provide some value in public debate and action on this general subject.    

[It depresses me that I saw repeated cynical "oh so this is all bs" references to what isn't even the final report -- the commissioners (I actually listened in some; one critic is from Dorf On Law, which had not a single post on the proceedings though the preliminary report did cite him) themselves pushed for changes of the text.  Latching on to a few references, which very well might be open to criticism.  Saying the report says all is fine.  etc.  

This is cheap shot mixed with ignorance. I want to underline here the point here is to air out things, not make specific recommendations as such. Those who want to reform or radically change the system can take a bit of time to understand or even engage some with the commission's work, including it hearing some witnesses that some critics agree with on various matters.]  

Coming Attractions: There was a conference today, so there should be another Order List next week.  No conference or oral arguments are scheduled next week.  No other orders were handed down this week. 

One execution was held up by Texas to further examine religious claims akin to a case the Supreme Court are due to address soon.  One is still scheduled in Alabama for next week, after being delayed because SCOTUS via a shadow docket case said the state needed to allow the person a minister at the execution. One more execution is still scheduled in Oklahoma at the end of the month.  

Books: I am involved in an ongoing book review blog (creation pending), handling largely historical themed books. I am re-reading The Enigma of Clarence Thomas (2019) to write a review entry.  The author, who wrote a book on conservatives, notes that ideologically he opposes what Thomas stands for.  But, the book tries to determine where Thomas is coming from.

I agree with the summary in the review: "The result is rigorous yet readable, frequently startling yet eminently persuasive."  To fully be secure here, you have to "deep dive" all his opinions and other writings. I did not do that, so have to rely on his analysis.  From experience, one should be a bit careful, since sometimes analysis is somewhat selective.  But, that is some level probably by necessity. 

The book comes off as basically fair -- it spends much of its time spelling out Thomas' point of view while only having a limited degree of criticism of him being selective or cherry picking.  Also, his thesis is that Thomas and the left overlap more than we might think, including their pessimistic take on the current situation.  The author has a lot of material to work with though as with any such attempts, you should take certain interpretations from a distance with a grain of salt.  But, again, it seems convincing.  

(Finishing the book, I basically hold to this, but think the 225 page [lots of end notes], can't be considered fully comprehensive. 

He argues Thomas promotes the Privileges or Immunities Clause, e.g., mostly to promote gun rights.  But, he does reference a right to marry and raise children in one of his decisions (cited in an end note, so he is aware of it to some extent) -- though the book might argue it was a passing reference. Since there are various P&I opinions out there, it might have been useful to get more of a sense of how he handled them.

One thing that really stands out for me is that his two wives and son are barely referenced. Given the tough black father archetype the book says he promotes, this seems a tad weird.  If his grandfather is his role model, what of his own son?  The black mother / white stepmother dynamic there would be interesting.  The book does flag criticism of how he doesn't respect the problems his mother and sister went through.  So, this would further clarify his position. I would say in fact this is a glaring absence. 

The book even talks about him being wary of some black student going to an Ivy league school -- like Sotomayor, he talks to school children.  Okay.  What about his own son?  A son that in fact went to a military school, which is why he was recused from U.S. v. Virginia!  

It is not like at least his [white] wife plays little role in his life.  The book's focus on Thomas as a pessimistic black existentialist --- I'm not sure if I'm using that right -- without talking about a white wife (his professional life in a white world itself is not really dwelt on that much really) seems a tad curious.  But, there are two brief references to both wives and about the same to his son.  I don't expect a complete biography here, but even for the purposes of the book, this all seems a bit weird.  Didn't a reader flag it?

Finally, for those who wish to get a sense of what conservatives think of the book, the National Review gave it guarded praise. 

Friday, October 15, 2021

Baseball Championship Series

The AL side is Red Sox v. Astros, both teams involved in cheating in recent years. But, they aren't permanently tainted or something. Okay. The Red Sox was a surprise, pushed through some troubles, managed to get thru the Wild Card, and perform impressively on both sides of the ball against Tampa. So, you know, they earned some respect. Astros had a good year (and the division isn't that weak) and plowed thru the White Sox. Fine.

Dodgers struggled thru injuries and then pushed passed the falling off a cliff Padres. The suprising Giants hung on, winning one more game. Dodgers tied it up by needing to win a wild card game (plowing past the late "can't lose" Cards) and then winning the division series 3-2. A series where the Giants won 4-0 and then won once more, a 1-0 nailbiter and only one other game (blown in the 9th) where they actually played well. You know, not impressed.

Braves was subpar, had a mid-summer run, let also rans hang on, but did enough. They also had just enough offense to beat the offense weak Brewers. They are the only team I basically am supporting (Dodgers are like the Yanks of the NL, before the Yanks started to have a harder time of it) though I don't really actively dislike the AL teams. The Braves played the Giants well. I have low expectations about this match-up.

National Character Counts Week

The White House website provides various announcements, including transcripts of press briefings, summaries of calls/meetings, and lists of nominations. There are also already a lot of presidential proclamations, including for various "days" or "weeks" etc.

The latest is an interesting one that is unlike many that took place so far. Character is cited as "the sum of qualities that defines who we are and how we treat one another" and having a special role in today's world. Quite so. The Trump years were so upsetting in part because of a basic lack of character. Character matters. This should be emphasized.

Character leads to results and affects results. It might seem to some a sort of hazy, ephemeral thing. But, that can be taken too far. People recognize the important of character. We must not ignore the importance of such traits, focusing on other things, like the latest "Democrats in Disarray" or "things are a mess" noise of the day.

Wednesday, October 13, 2021

Fake News (Book)

I saw a listing of recommendations for various CIA related type books. True or False is a different sort of thing. Written by a former CIA analyst, it is an investigation (geared for teens, but adults can benefit) of fake news. Useful reference to have.

It first runs through a history from Ancient Egypt to modern times. Interesting. Mixed in here are some lessons like looking at motives of those who promote suspect information. It would have been more helpful if the lessons were highlighted (maybe with stars or something). The second half is specifically about how to sight and fight fake news.

Baseball: Meanwhile, the Red Sox (blah but okay), Astros (same/has baggage but not a big fan of the White Sox), and Braves (over Brewers; either are okay) advanced in four. The Dodgers/Giants alone will play a fifth game. Theme so far is a lot of bullpen and long running times (bullpen + commercials help). [Dodgers won in the 9th.]

Tuesday, October 12, 2021

#ByeFelicia (Jon Gruden)

Yesterday was various things. It was Columbus Day (he isn't cancelled yet? he was barely Italian) and Indigenous Persons Day and National Coming Out Day. President Biden's statements on such things matter, even if more concrete things are as well.

As to actions, now ex-coach Jon Gruden ("Chucky" ... a new Chucky t.v. series is also beginning) was found to have 2011-18 had a series of "racist, homophobic and misogynistic" (and criticism of dealing concussions) emails. Note his team now has the first openly gay player in the NFL. There was already a woman ref (which he opposed). As black sports analyst Joy Taylor noted, it showed a "lifestyle" not a "mistake."

This was found as part a still pending investigation of the Washington Football Team. 2018 (Gruden was in his fourth year of a ten year contract) is not ancient history. It also is in the middle of a key turning point in the #MeToo Era. Would a guy like him (even with a close relationship with ownership) be hired today? We have a growing understanding that we cannot just ignore things because they don't matter. Sports have more responsibility now. It was even in the past supposed to have a certain gravitas and honor. We have a ways to go.

Friday, October 08, 2021

Canadian Court Says Tai Chi Institute Is A Religious Institution

One question that has been covered in this blog is the meaning of the term "religion." I have long cited a dictionary definition:
a set of beliefs concerning the cause, nature, and purpose of the universe, especially when considered as the creation of a superhuman agency or agencies, usually involving devotional and ritual observances, and often containing a moral code governing the conduct of human affairs.

The basic understanding is that it is a set of beliefs and practices involving god or god. In a wider sense, it can be a matter of supernatural forces, such as spirits. Polytheistic religions are not just of the type from in Ancient Greece and Rome. 

The meaning of "religion" would seem to be important when applying various legal tests since "religion" in particular is involved. See, e.g., the First Amendment.  Another situation where it arises -- though related -- is when applying tax breaks and related immunities.  So, e.g., you might have to determine of the Church of Scientology is a religion or something.

An interesting Canadian lawsuit addressed such a question as applied to a Taoist Tai Chi Institute.  Taoism itself is accepted as a religion.  The question is if this specific institution warranted a religious exemption.  And, the definition of religion (with a warning not to apply it is a discriminatory way) is familiar:

As we have seen previously, the two experts in religious sciences agree that a religion is a system of beliefs and practices shared which have in common: a) a conception of the world based on supernatural in a perspective of salvation and establishing the place of the human in the cosmos, b) a moral code in the form of precepts and rules of conduct and c) a worship that integrates assemblies, ceremonies and rites of transition.

This is from the opinion (it is in French, but I used Google Translate). A few paragraphs from the article discussing it is also helpful:

The institute’s branches, now located across the country, have altars dedicated to certain deities, a moral code advocating simplicity, compassion and altruism, and celebrations marking some Chinese holidays, noted the judge, which appears to align them with the religion definition.

Members of major monotheistic faiths such as Judaism and Islam study texts like the Torah and Koran. But Taoists pursue their beliefs through bodily activity such as rituals, meditation — and tai chi, Yergeau quoted the institute’s expert — Canadian professor James Miller of China’s Duke Kunshan University — as saying.

But the cities’ expert, Prof. Frédéric Castel of the University of Quebec at Montreal, argued the institute is not a religion because it lacks a community of worshipers with shared beliefs.

But the judge said there is still a core group who follow Taoism. The institute is no less a religion because a larger number of people are only there for tai chi, he said. Most of those who visit Chartres Cathedral in France, the Blue Mosque in Istanbul or the Saihō-ji temple in Kyoto are tourists who don’t practice those religions, but that doesn’t mean the sites themselves are not religious, said Yergeau.

The summary of what a religion entails is workable though someone might have a religion without worship as spelled out there. If someone has an understanding of God, they need not also have "assemblies, ceremonies and rites of transition."  A belief can be solitary and without rites and ceremonies.  It is likely though that the person will have some sort of rite or ceremony for which the religion plays some sort of role. 

So, I don't really want to carp here -- "religion" is one of those words and  concepts that we have general ideas about without agreeing on every specific.  That sort of thing can be a tedious parlor game.  Suffice to say that the acts practiced at these institutions have enough religious connotations for them to count.  

The article notes the institution was given some other tax exemption, so the battle is somewhat symbolic.  As the judge here noted, the case law is “rather thin on the concept of religion itself” and what defines it.  Yes.  This applies in the United States too.  We generally tend to avoid defining "religion," a term experts in various fields find it hard to parse.  

At times, something seems clearly not a religion, but that happens rarely.  And, if we are honest, even then, the exceptions probably might seem that much different from some of the beliefs most would deem religious (if ridiculous). A somewhat related thing happens when trying to find "sincere" beliefs.  The term has some meaning, surely (blatant fraud should not be allowed), but it is likely best to draw lines some other way.  

(I cited in the past my state's rule that a religion has to have some sort of specific institutional aspects to be allowed to officiate marriages. Some self-ordained minister might not be enough.  There seems no real need for that line -- for instance, you can requiring a training session of state marriage law waived if you had other training -- and it requires favoring certain religions over others that is itself problematic.)

A topical example is vaccinations.  Some cite a "religious" reason not to take them.  People find this unbelievable, especially if they take other vaccines.  But, they cite possible differences, such as this vaccine was developed using fetal cells.  Maybe, they are not being consistent.  Okay.  Start down that road, you probably will go a long way.  Basically, you will demand a rational belief system. Not necessarily an oxymoron, but can be.

If we are going to have "religious" classifications,* the word needs to have some content. Fair enough.  But, the judge's words remain valid: "It is not for the court to judge the depth of the religious conviction of the members or to establish a threshold below which the label of religious institution would be refused,” he said. “To venture down this path would lead the court to interfere with intimate beliefs.”

This is from the article and the opinion probably provides a bit more nuance.  There has to be some "threshold" here.  Still, if a self-declaration is reasonably a match to our rough definition of "religion," it is best to accept it.  The dispute here again seemed symbolic (if they would have received the tax break anyway), but we often can avoid the briar patch anyway.  And, we need to remember that "religion" is not just some traditional view of Christian faith.  

Also: I found this article in a comment I made in the midst of an old debate over allowing more religious exemptions when same sex couples are involved.  It argues sexual orientation should be treated like race and sex.  The overall principle is the same -- evenhanded treatment, not favoring certain beliefs over others since "well obviously racist religious beliefs are wrong!"  

---

* These types of discussions sometimes lead to first question type arguments. On some level, that's fine, but on another re-opening everything is basically (or isn't every time) not the issue. 

The First Amendment as well as modern day human rights law recognizes a special concern for religion.  I realize the Constitution (and maybe modern human rights law) is not always right -- the U.S. Senate, at least the two senator rule, shows this -- but as a matter of practicality and basic principle, that isn't the case here. 

Religion is special to human existence and modern society.  Both prongs -- no establishment and free exercise -- is appropriate. 

Thursday, October 07, 2021

Stealing Lust

This blog does not get many visitors though a few people looked at a couple Mike Royko posts (which should please a previous regular). One thing that gets some hits is references to erotic films (this is regarding soft porn on Showtime and the like). This may get a few hits in the future too. 

The latest such film available on Showtime (sadly less quality stuff of late) is Stealing Lust, a generic title, summarized on the website: "For confident millennial Katie, three days of angry, sexy roommates, a cheating girlfriend, and a lemonade stand are no problem at all." From what I can tell, she's more of a bored millennial.  Not a very charming character. 

Not much plot though admit to have not watched the thing straight thru or anything. I think the first sex scene comes off the best. All scenes have that glossy artificial look that turns me off. Plus, they are cut to avoid hard-core material (at least sometimes, there are hard-core penetration cuts) in a way that makes them at times annoyingly choppy. The sex scenes are often more sex noises than anything else.  OTOH, using closed captioning can be amusing. And, is helpful, since you often don't catch the words.

[The sex scenes can be fairly long though a little bit goes a long way, at least given the general lack of style.]

There is a notice that I referenced before (the production company will be familiar to those who check these things out) at the beginning that says things like they are adults and so forth as well as tossing in any reference to family relationships is fictional. Seems a bit weird -- do they think the viewer will think incest is actually happening? Guess it's technically illegal. The disclaimer is general -- it doesn't mean there is necessarily any sort of "family fun" in the film that will follow. 

As to that title, again, not quite sure the point of it (some of these films have various titles).  One thing -- this is probably too creative on my part -- is that there is a Liv Tyler movie entitled Stealing Beauty.  The lead sorta looks like her.  Anyway, skipping thru the movie (you can skip forward and back ten minutes for my cable video on demand), the first woman seems the best. She has a bit of dialogue at the beginning (bitching about the millennial) and you get a nice shot of her ass.  

Those here for this material might be interested in other political, legal, and review content.  Hey, it's possible. 

ETA: Later on, I saw maybe my favorite scene in the film, a later scene that includes the main character sneaking into a house while the couple is having sex.  The scene is done well and I found it sexy.  

Five Ballot Proposal Questions

Baseball: I checked the Wild Card games online and Twitter (former Mets catcher, Anthony Recker, live tweeted the NL match-up).  Red Sox (early lead/clinched it mid-game) and Dodgers (bottom of the ninth) won.  Oh well.  I was tired of hearing about how much the Yanks struggled and they got to the playoffs anyway.

---- 

I saw a tweet about an article discussing the five ballot proposals put on the New York State ballot this election.  Since the mayoral race is non-competitive, as are the others (Bronx borough president, city council, comptroller, public advocate), this would add something to think about.  Plus, it would be a state matter, the other bunch city related. 

I'm not a big fan of ballot proposals.  They regularly are things required by the state constitution that the general voter will not know much about. For instance, one of the measures here is to raise the minimum in the New York City’s Civil Court.  Some might find this questionable but the article notes it is being promoted as a reform measure.  Okay. 

The first measure is a package of redistricting measures.  They appear okay as a whole though questionable if you should have to vote on it as a package. Plus, again, this seems like something better to be worked out by our representatives.  Ditto the two measures to make it easier to vote.  They seem fine, but why should I have to vote on them?  State constitutional barriers.

The last measure would add a state constitutional right: "Each person shall have a right to clean air and water, and a healthful environment."  Sounds like a "puppies are cute" sort of thing.  What exactly does that mean?  I'm fine with it myself as a general matter.  I think we probably have some sort of Ninth Amendment right now in some sense -- such a "positive right" would require legislative action, but so be it.  See, Justice Douglas making a passing mention in his dissent here.  

The article's pro/con that is pretty stacked (League of Conservation v. an oil lobbyist group?), but without more detail, I am not sure what it would actually mean.  Unnecessary litigation?  What sort of litigation not allowed now would be allowed if that passed?  It is so open-ended.  Perhaps, that is a reason to vote against it.  If I knew a bit more on the likely difference it would bring.  Again, I'm not a big fan of the average voter being asked to do that without more discussion.  At least candidates -- well not judicial ones -- have meet-ups, debates, and so forth.  

So yes on the redistricting (net good), yes and yes on voting, yes on the civil courts (sounds like the right people like it), and leaning yes on the last bit though more wary on that.  Sounds nice, but what does it mean?  Here is a bit more on it -- the measure received sizable support in the legislature.   A few other states have it.  But, what exactly it will do is still unclear.  

OTOH, if my complaint is that the legislature should decide, they already put it on the ballot.  My call would be to determine if it was so questionable that I should vote against.  Using that logic, probably yes across the board.

Wednesday, October 06, 2021

Tevye Stories

The People and the Books is an interesting collection about Jewish writers. I briefly comment on it here. One writer covered is the author of stories that influenced the Fiddler on the Roof. I found a free paperback copy of a collection of his writings (The Tevye Stories and Others), translated by Julius and Frances Butwin. Helpful introduction provided.

Tevyre is a bit of a fool (always with confused religious verses) but overall an appealing character in various ways. For instance, he wants to make his daughters happy, even if they have ideas not like his own. (The one thing he won't accept is a daughter marrying a non-Jew). He also has a balanced fatalistic view. But, the work is not some light affair. His life -- especially in the last story that for some reason is not included -- has a lot of suffering.

The last story's plot is alluded to in the introduction, but again, is not found here. Why? Also, he speaks more than once of seven daughters, but we only hear stories about five. The other stories are a mixture, some with a sort of "shaggy dog" flavor to them where the plot isn't quite the point. Originally in Yiddish, the translation is smooth; glossary of terms provided.

Tuesday, October 05, 2021

SCOTUS Watch

Orders: The Supreme Court disposed of a lot of cases that were examined during the "long conference."

Breyer flagged a case involving someone on death row and solitary for the last three decades to reaffirm his constitutional concerns on the matter. 

Sotomayor flagged two criminal cases, again not dissenting but noting her concerns. She did dissent in a denial involving an alleged wrongful shooting/death, raising qualified immunity questions. Qualified immunity claims arose in multiple petitions last term and it looked like maybe they might take one to significantly address the matter. No such luck. 

(Qualified immunity regards not even allowing someone to be able to try their luck because the legality of something is unclear.  One complaint is that this is applied too strictly; after all, the person is just trying and might not win.  Here, Sotomayor argued the appellate court wrongly deemed matters of fact to be settled.  

This is one of the areas certain forms of "originalism" can help the claimant since it is argued that such immunity was not traditionally deemed appropriate.  Again, I find originalism dubious and reliance on such history even for a good reason a problematic enterprise in part since things have changed over time.)  

One notable case, which the Supreme Court simply affirmed (Gorsuch/Thomas would dismiss for lack of jurisdiction, that is, the very power to hear the case), involved a claim that D.C. residents are unconstitutionally denied the right to a voting member of the House of Representatives.  Years back, Sen. Hatch (R) supported a voting D.C. representative in return for giving his state one more member. 

I have generally felt this claim was weak, but looking at the briefs, I'm somewhat less sure now.  At the very least, the clause giving Congress power to legislate over the district very well might give them the power to do so as a matter of discretion.  OTOH, the lower court case (summarily affirmed) referenced that rejected the claim is pretty convincing.

2021 Term Begins: The new term begun on the First Monday with a live audio link on the website (really two) and Kavanaugh taking part remotely.  (This is the first time that happened; before, someone could have used tapes or so on to take part while not showing up, but they didn't "phone in" like this.)  Thomas must have liked asking questions over the phone because he asked some questions.  Seemed like things were a bit sedate early on. 

I'll repeat my usual complaint that multiple members of the Court should not be there. This makes it somewhat painful even to listen to them. I realize one argument is that you have to accept reality.  But, I will not blandly do so.  Breyer should have retired and the others for various reasons should not be on the bench.  I am not ready to grant legitimacy and just treat them as justices (GKB) and move on from there.  No.  

Ernest Johnson Executed:  The Supreme Court dealt with the means of execution in the past.  Johnson argues lethal injection, given his specific condition, is cruel and unusual.  Granting this, the misguided current doctrine is that he has to show the availability of an alternative method of execution.  The liberal dissenters argue this is true, either nitrogen gas or a firing squad.  The majority rejected that this is the case. 

[It is still somewhat unclear if this is totally true -- if the only available method is literal burning at the stake, is that okay if that is the only thing available.  The conservatives simply deny that is happening in these cases.]

Johnson was found guilty of a triple murder.  So, as to the crime itself, this is more "worse of the worst"  than various other cases.  Again, that is basically the test in place -- there are many homicides, but you need special reasons to execute someone.  But, as is often the case, there are mitigating concerns.  Here the main one is intellectual disability, which the Supreme Court has held is a total bar if serious enough.   

But, SCOTUS didn't agree -- rejected with no comment from anyone (like the last one).  So, he was executed, and again it was wrong.  The only value of the whole thing is that we don't have to wait until late in the evening to see the (mostly) inevitable (perhaps with a dissent). 

Some death penalty articles can be found among the publications here. As noted, I engaged with her recently on Twitter and she is writing a book on the death penalty, a special area of expertise.  

Preview: To add one thing, the Presidential Supreme Court Commission (remember them? we had coverage of Alito et. al. giving public speeches and don't recall any reference of PSCOTUS!) will have another public meeting 10/15.  Following the links, the meeting is said to be about discussing the public report that they are supposed to put forth. 

Sunday, October 03, 2021

Sunday Sports

Football: Buffalo cruised, Giants came back and won in OT (dubious 58 yd FG attempt by Saints helped them), and Jets survived though it was far from easy for them late including deep into OT. So, good day for New York with first wins by Giants/Jets.

Baseball: Mets shut out in their last game. Another "wait til next year." Let's see what happens. Me? The key thing for me is finding a good manager, one who you can trust to act independently. As to the other moves, eh, who knows. Need a new GM too.

All the games started around 3:05 PM (EST) though they finished different times. Looked like maybe Yanks/Red Sox might lose with the Blue Jays winning. This would result in a tiebreaker scenario. Net result was no change so the wannabees were left oh so close. Yawn.

Saturday Update

The Hallmark movie was Love Strikes Twice, a pleasant (well acted/paced) fantasy about a thirty something lawyer who magically gets to do a "do over" from fifteen years ago. Earlier in day, caught a repeat of another recent one, Snowkissed, with an actress I saw before (Jen Lilley). It too was enjoyable.

(I wondered about the accent of the actress and thought she sounded like Jill Hennessy. I might not be crazy since both are Canadian, if not apparently from the same province.)

Baseball Update: The Mets found a chance to have one more mediocre "Cookie" start and lose another one run game, drawing close late and loading the bases in the ninth. The winning run ultimately was a tacked on run given up to Robert Gsellman, back from his long break.

The Padres (swept by Braves and Dodgers) managed -- if in the 10th -- to actually win a game versus the Giants.  Thus, with the Brewers losing again, there is actually a one game difference between them and the Dodgers.  I still think the Dodgers won't win again plus the Giants losing, but hey it's possible.  That would require a one game playoff.  

The Yanks (Rays) lost badly, the Red Sox won again okay (Nats), the Blue Jays won comfortably (Orioles), and after giving up three in the eighth, the Mariners scored three of their own (Angels), so won.  Winner? Ex-Met Paul Sewald, now thriving in Seattle.  Now, all the non-Yanks team are probably (well some of their fans at least) smacking themselves for not winning one more game, especially versus the Yanks, but so it goes.  

So, the Yanks and Red Sox are now tied with the Blue Jays and Seattle one back.  The Nats have shown some life versus the Red Sox, the Orioles just won a series versus them, the Angels are playing the Mariners tough (they aren't a bad team really), and you figure the Yanks can win once against the Rays.  But, well that race too is going to Game 162 and there are various ways there might need to be a possible tie breaker.  

In what might have been, the Phils lost too, so even if they won a game instead of being swept by the Braves, today could have been elimination day.  I thought a 2-1 Braves series was more likely than the sweep. Oh well. The Phils did manage to win over .500, which is of limited relief, maybe, but did any Phils fan (as compared to the Braves) really expect much more?

Ah, competitive parity. 

Saturday, October 02, 2021

FFRF's Brief in Religious Rights/Death Penalty Case

Online resources allow easy access to briefs, including friend of the court (amicus) briefs, and court opinions. Once upon a time, a college library access to slip opinions was a big deal, and I had to go to a certain library to look at lower court opinions.

Freedom From Religion Foundation has an interesting sort of brief in the upcoming case involving the right to have a minister to touch the person and vocally say prayers during an execution.  The writer of the brief was on Freethought Radio recently to talk about it along a woman who "fired God."  Let's say, like some others, it is a brief that adds something among briefs that often say basically the same thing in different ways.

[You can find the brief along with others here.]

I don't expect the Supreme Court as a whole to be overly impressed by the whole thing though it provides an interesting perspective.  As the author noted, many FFRF [there is a link on my blogroll, but the feed pops up when I put the link there, so you can just use this] members are against the death penalty.  The brief cites the usual arguments in summary argument there.  I don't think it really adds anything new there in general.  

The organization specific concern here is that the death penalty in part at least is justified by religious reasons.  This is done in a historical sense in the brief, but ironically it also argues that "almost all mainstream churches have formal opposition to this barbaric form of punishment."  And, it goes back to arguing that the death penalty violate current standards of decency.  I think it possible to provide more detail on how even today that the death penalty often is defended using religious rhetoric.   

Perhaps speaking to their audience (a conservative leaning Court with multiple judges interested in their own vision of religious liberty), a core argument is that the biggest threat to religious liberty is executing people.  The case here is about a rather trivial matter next to the end of a person's life, and their ability to practice their religion.  Yes, it is clear under current law that not allowing the person's wishes here to be fulfilled violates the law.  But, on a basic level, it is absurd to focus on that.

I think that has some force, but it might be talking past those who think the death penalty is appropriate in certain cases.  If it is appropriate, like something like killing animals for food, you then can focus on how it is important to do so appropriately.  I have seen people thinking it absurd to worry about a "trivial" matter like this while being okay with executions and wrongful detention.  You can worry about both. 

And, perhaps a viewpoint that assumes the absence of an afterlife (I don't think there is one, but I'm more focused on freethinking myself than "freedom from religion" itself) belittles some the importance of an end of life ritual.   If you believe in an afterlife, the person dying is not at the end of the line. They have a lot more time, shall we say, left.  Not that even those who belief it is the end of the line fail to recognize the importance of a finale.

The brief then argues that any execution process here needs to take into consideration those without religious beliefs.  If only religious people have "end-of-life" comfort of this nature, it is a sort of coercion to have religious beliefs.  Equal protection here would apply such accommodations to those with comparable beliefs such as the statutory application in the Seeger case involving conscientious objection.  

This overall would be necessary for a true right to "free exercise of religion" in a neutral way.  One law professor on Twitter rejected the right to have a special religious based end of life accommodation here -- why not a friend or relative?  But, the First Amendment doesn't refer to that. It refers to religion.  And, that includes a "non-religious"  (as I often said, I think the term "religion" is rather broad)  approach to the basic questions involved here.  Basically, conscience questions that all have.

The brief thus covers a lot of ground and provides an interesting perspective that might even surprise some FFRF followers.  

---

ETA: By chance, I was actually wearing my FFRF tee while writing this entry.  Also, I have a FFRF calendar.  The historical figure that is highlighted for October is Alton Lemon, an African-American humanist beyond the Lemon v. Kurtzman "Lemon Test" ruling.  

Again, I am not not really as supportive of a total "freedom from religion" as being a freethinker -- my long term theme has been to give "religion" a wide meaning -- but do support many of their efforts.  Plus, they give out free copies of their newspaper, which includes promotion of swag.  

Some of their efforts basically reflect their "freedom from" sentiments and involve opposing religious symbols in the public sphere that involved governmental endorsement in some fashion.  I think those things of some importance, but they might be focused too much on them at times. I appreciate the brief here for its broad and interesting perspective. 

Baseball Update: Game 159 (158 for Braves)

The final weekend does have a bit of uncertainty left though less so after the first games. Giants/Dodgers won again. Not seeing Giants going 0-2 and the Dodgers 2-0, which would be needed to force a one game playoff. So, thinking AL Wild Card is the key.

The Mets won by one, some of the Braves bats resting. If it mattered, the Mets had a chance to make the Braves sweat, perhaps. The possible killer, which I happened to see part of, was Seattle (Red Sox beat Nats, so needed a win to hold serve for the second wild card spot) not taking advantage of a first and third opportunity late where only a sacrifice was needed to tie. They lost the game 2-1 over the Angels. Painful. Helped Yanks too.

Rays won, but they are just prepping for the playoffs. No more must wins. And, really the Yanks just need to win one even if others win out. Home field matters financially, but not sure how much for the win. I really don't want a Yanks/Red Sox Wild Card though guess if somehow the Red Sox manage to win it, it would be a bit amusing.

SCOTUS Watch: Long Conference

English history buffs might know about the "Long Parliament," but the Long Conference is just a name to something that appears to be a brainchild of Justice Blackmun (per Chief Justice Rehnquist's own book on the Supreme Court). The crew have a big backlog at the end of the summer recess and deal with a bunch of pending matters before the beginning of the term on the First Monday of October. A short order list was handed down Thursday; a larger one is likely on Monday, mainly a long list of stuff rejected.

The five cases (including a separate campaign finance appeal that is handled differently) that were taken for review are discussed by Amy Howe. A sentencing related case is discussed here.  As usual, there are various interesting cases, but nothing too "hot button."  

The most notable there is a case involving  "a Christian group after the city of Boston denied the group’s request to raise its flag – bearing a Latin cross."  Other groups got to do that, so it is likely that they will too, this crew not likely to realize the Establishment Clause problems involved.  

There is a matter of "governmental speech," which arguably can make this different from something like adding a cross to a bunch of other displays.  A flagpole has special meaning there.  And, yes, this is often framed as a free speech issue, though when you are dealing with crosses and other religious matters, it is more than that.  But, again, I'm not too optimistic.  This might be one of those "disappointments" Sotomayor talked about.  

Live Audio: The first three months of arguments  ("sessions") will have live audio, the public and certain members of the press still not allowed.  In the past, you could go to the C-SPAN website to check out live audio and later in the day the Supreme Court would have transcripts and an audio link. Now, there will be a live audio link on the Supreme Court's own website.  Slowly, the Supreme Court makes things a bit less difficult for public access. 

Charming: Prof. Segall, a nice guy who I disagree with on certain subjects, has a podcast where he talks with fellow law professor types. He recently talked with Prof. Lain, who nicely emailed a while back about a comment I wrote among her guest blogging in 2015 regarding the death penalty.   I saved other emails, but don't seem to have that one.  Too bad.  

She nicely also engaged with me on Twitter regarding the death penalty (the subject of the podcast), including citing something where Justice White during the Furman v. Georgia  negotiations suggested he supported ending the death penalty. (The comment is a bit opaque though.) The accounts I have read, especially The Brethren, if anything suggests he was more open to it coming back later on.  It's one of those things where you read familiar stuff and an interesting bit is tossed in that is new.  

(I read a few books covering the history of the death penalty, including the back/forth in the 1970s, but don't recall that tidbit.  I might be forgetting something, of course, since there is so much details in these books.  She phrased something in her summary in the podcast that I found iffy, but you know, one should be humble when dealing with experts.)

Anyway, I again appreciate how various people engage with me, not an expert, online.  Plus, in general, she seems a charming person overall.  

Kavanaugh Gets COVID: In a reminder why we wear masks even when we are vaccinated, Kavanaugh tested positive even after getting vaccinated.  The Supreme Court gets regular testing and it showed that our lying partisan rapey judge [not "justice" in my book] is positive with the Big V, if without symptoms.  On Friday, it was reported he will take part in oral arguments next week remotely

This also shows the realities of the day. People -- a few senators tested positive a few weeks back -- will get COVID.  Early on, Tom Hanks did.  It is not generally some sort of death sentence though for some people it very well is.  It is something that will have to be factored in with the right amount of care and concern.

Sotomayor Watch: I will just quote Amy Howe:

"The Supreme Court refused on Friday to block New York City’s requirement that all public-school employees be vaccinated for COVID-19. Justice Sonia Sotomayor, who handles emergency appeals from the area that includes New York, turned down a request from four of the city’s public-school employees to temporarily block the enforcement of the mandate while they litigate their challenge in the lower courts. The city planned to enforce the mandate beginning at 5 p.m. on Friday."

As she notes, Barrett weeks back also on her own refused to block a mandate regarding university students from Indiana though again one from there is less likely to be broad enough to get one in trouble.  Still, other than perhaps the issue I addressed separately, I think vaccine mandates in general will be upheld.  Not that I am assured about that in all cases.

Supreme Court Triggered: Joan Biskupic talks about the "anger" of the "justices" (not a word I would use for Barrett) though Sotomayor of the five seems from the coverage mostly to be upset at results (she began to talk about the ability of people in Texas to change the law and caught herself). Biskupic generally plays it cool, but this seems like a bit of snark on her part:

Breyer, too, has criticized journalists and politicians for identifying justices by the presidents who appointed them and their political parties. The Bill Clinton appointee also argues that the current 6-3 split at the high court does not reflect politics or ideology but rather jurisprudential methods.

She also references how Alito "tried" to make a case. Ha ha. The pessimistic note that there isn't much that is likely to happen with them having life tenure and no major changes (heck any changes will be something) seemingly on the horizon.  But, the judges seem to think the situation is troubled enough that they have to say something.  

Alito is just someone who gets triggered and Thomas has some of that too, but when so many are talking at once, it's somewhat notable.  I appreciate Sotomayor, who at times keeps it a bit more real though tosses in the usual bromides at times too.  She surely keeps it more real in her opinions, even if like some of us, we rather there not be so many dissents.

Oh well.  Something of a busy week.

Friday, October 01, 2021

Limited Religious Exemptions From Vaccine Mandate Challenged

Suit was filed this week in a Colorado federal district court challenging provisions limiting religious exemptions from the University of Colorado Medical School's vaccine mandate.

There have been various lawsuits against vaccination requirements. I will briefly talk about this one. The opening of the complaint has this:

The University of Colorado has enacted a Policy dividing its staff and students into two categories based on their religious beliefs: the “sheep,” whose religions teach the approved orthodoxy, receive exemptions to the University’s COVID vaccine mandate, while the “goats,” who hold non-approved religious beliefs, are denied exemptions and then fired or expelled.

Uh huh. Those who get vaccinated are now the "sheep" who just follow the "approved orthodoxy." It is not enough to request a religious exemption. One has to insult the majority.  This doesn't come off as neutral.

The challengers, including at least one M.D., are "devout" such and such. Yes, well, we wouldn't want to protect the religious liberty of believers who are not, right?  For instance, one Jane Doe here is a "devout Catholic."  The Catholic Church has not only decided taking a COVID vaccine is morally acceptable, but the Pope himself has spoken of a "moral duty" to do so.  The Vatican has a vaccine mandate though allows a negative COVID test.

The concern for some is that decades ago the vaccine was developed by using aborted fetal cells.  The Catholic Church is sure to denounce this in general, but balancing moral equities, accepts the use of the vaccine until there is a good alternative.  Others can try to figure out the moral balancing involved here when fetal cells developed from a long ago abortion (it is not like the abortion was done to get the cells) is forbidden in this fashion. The artificial purity when a much more direct relation with "evil" will surely be practiced given the level of indirect relationship involved here.  

[The complaint notes that there is some Catholic support for the idea that you cannot mandate vaccination.  But, vaccination is not being mandated here except to the degree that you need to be vaccinated for a specific place, a medical school.  That is a special place where more specific burdens are appropriate.]  

The Buddhist involved opposes all vaccines, noting that the creation of some involved harm to animals.  This is not the only reason for the opposition, perhaps again realizing the number of ways we are somehow involved with the harm of animals in ways a lot more direct and/or significant than the use of a vaccine developed from animal testing. 

This complete opposition is helpful since the regulation -- shades of conscientious objection rules requiring opposition to all wars -- requires a sincere religious belief that opposes acceptance of “all immunizations” and vaccines.  I am not sure the two will overlap in all ways, but that seems a reasonable rule to avoid complex decision-making that can be subjective in specifics.  For instance, I'm not really convinced that the judge here made a good enough case that the people there was not "sincere." 

So, I'm wary of "sincere religious belief" tests in general, but that is working off common principles.  The second rule stated in the post, however troubles me.  There is a requirement that the person is "a member of an organized religion whose tenets include a hierarchically promulgated, authoritative position on the moral liceity of “all immunizations” and vaccines."  That is wrongful religious discrimination.

I talked about this in the past in reference to New York's rules for marriage officiants.  Without checking the exact specifics, there is some rule for a certain organizational structure that led to problems when the Universal Life Church got involved.  Putting aside the idea that might not be a "real" religion, whatever that term means must include religious beliefs that do not meet that requirement.  Individual religious beliefs, including those who disagree with their church's stance, are protected.

(You also can have no church.  Your religious beliefs can simply be a result of your own individual understanding of what God etc. requires of you.)

I understand the desire to avoid trying to go into the weeds of idiosyncratic religious beliefs that can seem to be makeweight in nature.  But, the rule favors some religions over others and does so by the very terms of the rule. It is not a favoring in effect.  It is a clear favoring of certain types of religion and religious belief.  There is a neutral reason for it, yes, but the Constitution bars certain categories of legislative tools.

This shows the value of a blanket rule against religious based vaccine exemptions.*  Vaccines are necessary for the safety of third parties.  A neutral across the board ban will avoid trying to determine what is "organized" and "hierarchical" enough and so forth.  A person is allowed to disagree with the position of their church.  A person's faith is no less to be respected in that situation.  Yes, it's harder to test sincerity, but you are just making somewhat different problems for yourself this way.  

I suppose those who wrote this regulation had some reason to think it was an appropriate one.  We would need to see the response to the complaint and so forth.  But, I am inclined to find the second part problematic, and avoidable.  

---

* If you want to have religious exemptions, this at least is not the way to go.  A complete opposition of vaccinations very well might work, but it must include what a person's individual religious beliefs require.

Medical exemptions are separate since they are in place to protect the health of the individual.  This is the same overall concern of vaccination guidelines in general.  And, it is no absolute thing either -- if the condition will result in harm in third parties, the person can be disqualified from doing certain things. Finally, there will be hard calls, but parsing religious beliefs is specifically a problem under the First Amendment. 

Dems Governing Marches On, However Messy

We have had extended play by play focused on the struggles of the Democrats to pass an infrastructure bill (bipartisan) along with a much larger reconciliation bill that focuses on such procedural goings on that always makes the Dems being on the cusp of failure. It's very tiresome.

The Dems have to basically govern alone since the Republicans repeatedly barely let them confirming assistant members of the Cabinet these days.  The reconciliation process lets major budget matters to be passed by a simple majority.  But, then, we have to deal with Manchin and Sinema.  Manchin is fine with (as AOC notes) defense spending that is more than the combined annual price tag of the reconciliation bill.  Which is repeatedly cited not by its annual cost but the price tag of a TEN YEAR package.

Such details are hidden in the headlines that focus on "Dems in Disarray" process.  It's bullshit.  The package is the median Democratic package, the Biden plan, supported by large majorities.  But, actually getting Manchin and Sinema to go along is this whole damn process.  Anyway, perhaps, focus on what is in these bills.  At the very least, make clear we aren't talking about 2.5 trillion a year.  It's  for ten years. 

I saw a complaint that we are spending so much focus on the pay fors and not what the money is being spent for.  Yes.  Focus on that.  I am hearing various Democrats doing that.  Focus on how the money is being pay for. How the money is for investment that in the long run is profitable, and not just in ways monetary.  Focus on how Republicans and yes certain Democrats (including a few in the House on certain issues) are going against both good policy and the will of the people at large.  

The drama yesterday (as September left us) was that the progressive caucus wants the bigger reconciliation package to pass first before they will vote on the smaller bipartisan measure.  This very well appeared to be the plan agreed by each side and Biden himself.  The progressives -- who already are compromising to support a more moderate median package -- stood their ground.  NO!  We had a deal and we aren't going to let a few "moderates" force us to go along breaking it.  Plus, the whole thing is popular!  Come the f on.  So, yeah.  Thank you.  

The wider principle of filibuster reform is appropriate. Right now, the Republicans (who again used the debt ceiling for political gain, wanting the Dems to be the only grown-ups to cover stuff they already spent) on the national level repeatedly show themselves as not worthy of a shred of respect. When individual Republicans actually do something worthy of it, it is notable since it is not what their party does.  Why should they be allowed to block something by minority rule? Block even DEBATE?!

And, we can forsee limited reform, such as how reconciliation provided an opt-out. I'm tired of Dems saying how bad the Republicans are or how important voting rights are.  Fine.  Break the filibuster somehow and let the thing pass.  But, that's something at least -- the core of the matter is being dicussed, not just hand-wringing on how Dems are in disarray.

The Democrats have already done things and it is still 2021, still a fraction of a year since they got into power.  They will do more things. They must. And, I am glad the progressive caucus, with people right both on the merits and crafty on the process, is there from AOC (my rep) on. 

Thursday, September 30, 2021

Baseball Update

September ended with more races (Houston and Atlanta) over and the last Mets home game.

It was a win, thanks to more rough Marlins play (it became a laugher when the manager tried to squeeze one more inning out of a long reliever), allowing Rick Hill to finally get a win as a Met. Hill has done his job -- you could basically rely on him to give you five or so innings and giving up at a run or two. But, the team wasn't good enough until now to actually allow him to win. They lost the middle game, so 2-1 series win.

The Braves has gone on a run again, and now swept the Phils (who played just mediocre to come in second), so that final series with the Mets won't mean anything. So, more of a chance of a win or two, perhaps. Red Sox continue to struggle, lost a series to the Orioles, so tied with Seattle with three to go. Yanks about ready to take the first wild card. Giants two ahead of Dodgers, so really only the AL Wild Card race left. Rooting for Seattle.

Tuesday, September 28, 2021

SCOTUS Watch: Execution & Other Matters

Execution: Rick Rhoades is the fifth execution this year, three of them by very problematic rushed executions by the federal government in January. He is the third executed by Texas. He was sentenced for a double murder thirty years ago. Rhoades (per the article) confessed, but the long delay alone as discussed by Breyer here continues to constitutionally and as a matter of policy very problematic.

The article cites various due process claims raised. The Supreme Court was asked to stay the execution particularly to address a claim that evidence could show that the jury was tainted. The Supreme Court, to me wrongly as a matter of principle, rejected this without comment. Before the Supreme Court makes the final okay of taking a life, a brief statement explaining why the final claims are not worthy of review should be given. 

The sister is cited as unsure about capital punishment, but more secure here because he confessed.  But, putting aside the three decade delay, the system of executions are problematic, even if some lottery system will pick one or the other who particularly are less so.  Rhoades was prosecuted thirty years ago for murdering two brothers as part of a robbery.  This deserved a long prison sentence. Selecting him out for execution to me is a step too far.

===

I added another blog, a new one that will address SCOTUS, but not about decision; other matters of interest will be focused upon.  

This article argues Kavanaugh's finances is a misguided subject for left leaning opponents to focus upon. His deep pocked parents are a basic source of his money though he's part of the problem since he is not really upfront about the matter.  He gets away with it because of a loophole in disclosure rules.  I basically agree that I don't think there is a big conspiracy there, though better disclosure could help to address the controversy.  

(I also don't think there is some big conspiracy regarding Kennedy's retirement.  He retired after thirty years, at age eighty, when a Republican got into power able to replace him. His son's financial dealings years earlier involving Trump is latched on to, but the idea it was some sketchy quid pro quo to cover it up is basically silly.  There are simple reasons for Kennedy's decision, which is quite open to criticism given he enabled Trump.) 

Congress will have a hearing on the shadow docket and Prof. Steve Vladeck continues his helpful informing the public function.  The written testimony, btw, includes an explanation of how the Texas abortion is crafted in such a way to keep abortion providers continuously at risk even if a specific lawsuit is won.  To belabor something, one critic of some of the pushback to me skipped over that sort of thing, arguing all you have to do is violate the law and the matter will be decided.  

[ETA: I expanded the last paragraph.  But, more notably, Justice Alito had a speech at Notre Dame Thursday that addressed criticism of the "emergency docket."  At first, it seemed like it would not be accessible to the general public.  This led to complaints, which might have influenced the move to make it available by live audio.  His strong criticisms of the criticisms were themselves criticized.  I appreciate the open audio policy -- this sort of thing should be open to the public to consider.]

Finally, with oral arguments coming up next week, SCOTUS has announced COVID testing rules for advocates for the next three months. A positive test will require phone arguments for the person involved.  Vaccination does not appear to be required.  Limits, including mask requirements, for those who do come to arguments are also cited.  Recall the public is not allowed, but the press with full credentials are.

Addendum: I missed a press release last week referencing a ceremonial investiture ceremony for Barrett this Friday. That is in the final days of the 2020 term, the 2021 term starting next Monday.  I'm unsure why it is taking place now instead of when she was forced on the bench illegitimately last October.  

ETA: The congressional hearing referenced is on the shadow docket and SB8, the Texas anti-abortion bounty law. This is the second congressional hearing on the shadow docket and Sen. Whitehouse has also focused on other Supreme Court related subjects. 

I hope once the presidential commission is done with its work -- perhaps November -- serious effort will be placed to pass legislation. But, this sort of thing is helpful to publicly address the matter. Note too Victoria Nourse's three part discussion of her new Trump impeachment casebook and the importance of Congress in constitutional law. 

Each entry is useful and her comment in the latest that criticizes the amount of attention the courts get respecting "constitutional law" as  if only the courts do that is something I have voiced over the years. Years ago, I wrote a personal view of the Constitution -- a lot has changed over the last fifteen years there -- and my open-ended views was not just meant to apply to what the courts themselves should apply. 

Marijuana use very well can be a constitutional right (restrictions also could interfere with them) but also something legislative action should secure since it is not so clear that the courts should strike down anti-marijuana laws. The Bill of Rights, for example, is not just something for the courts to apply.  It is a statement of principle that guides us.  This was flagged when it was first put forth by James Madison and others.

It still holds true.  One lawyer on another blog was quite critical when I raised constitutional concerns regarding the handling of certain nominees or suggested the impeachment process has constitutional limitations. How silly! It's all political!  As if it is but a policy choice to badly apply constitutional text and principles here.  That is a shallow and on some level dangerous approach.  We need higher standards than that.

She's On First

We recently had what seems like the first woman ref in a NFL game as well as an openly gay player (he even had a key role in the Raiders winning the Ravens game), but no woman players yet. I know of no woman MLB umps even and if the Mets ever have a ballgirl I'm sure Keith Hernandez (a bit behind the times) would have something to say. I would not be surprised if some trans person played at some point.

There were various fictional accounts (not speaking of when women had their own league), including a [decent] short lived television series. This book is from the 1980s (she also has a true story book on women playing baseball) and one charm is that there is a lot of baseball in it. It involves a women shortstop though of course there is some dramatic non-baseball material mixed in. I like the various points of view (owner, scout, reporter, player), but we only indirectly get the sense of her fellow players. That's unfortunate.

I have a charming book about a little leaguer pitcher who pitches a knuckleball. I also read a while back another book that had a woman ballplayer, but other than a bit about a guy being shot in the knees or something so he couldn't break a record, don't much at all of it. Anyway, I re-read this one and enjoyed it once more. My copy is an older version than the link.


Viceroy's House

As noted earlier, I re-watched What's Cooking? (didn't remember most of it, so that's fine), and it turns out it was directed by the woman (British with Indian background born in British Kenya, during the final years of rule) behind Bend It Like Beckham. She also directed Bride and Prejudice, another film I watched. And, many others.

The small sample shows she tends to direct somewhat light hearted films that deal with families involving in a cultural clash of some sort. The last one is a sort of Bollywood version of Jane Austin though don't recall THAT much music/dancing. Viceroy's House (she also later was behind a historical miniseries) is something of a change of pace. It involves the final days of British rule and the partition of India. As whole, I liked it.

The reviews were somewhat mixed and the "white guilt" complaints have something of a point, especially near the end. Recall again a British Indian woman directed this. The film also tosses in a sort of conspiracy theory on the partition being pre-ordained that appears to be of somewhat dubious historical accuracy. But, we should always be wary of taking historical films at face value. The last few minutes of the film, including rather cheesy bit, also probably should have been left out. But, a lot to like.

Monday, September 27, 2021

Congress Back: Dems Struggle to Govern / Republicans Rather Not (FU)

Congress is back and the Democrats -- since the fucking Republicans refuse to govern (and somehow it is sane that they might take control in 2023, like cats would have more credible reason to do so) -- have a lot on their plate including the debt ceiling. Since they have nearly no margin of error, since again every fucking Republican refuses to govern (a few opt outs, like investigating Trump), this is very hard. The fact the people at large support chunks of what is being sought out doesn't matter. Only Dems have agency.

Let's march to the drummer of "Dems in disarray" by all the usual suspects, including those very concerned about voting integrity. Robert Kagan wrote a strong article on the stakes of our republican system in that regard. Wikipedia labels him a "neoconservative," but the piece is largely on the money, except a few noises on giving Republicans "a chance" with a still smaller voting bill. Who among that crew shows any credibility?

Saturday, September 25, 2021

Obtacle Course: The Everyday Struggle to Get An Abortion in America

This is a good book, using many personal accounts, to discuss the many obstacles put in place to obtain an abortion. As do I, the book's ideal is to treat abortion as a regular health procedure. The book also views things through a "reproductive justice" lens -- government and society has an obligation to provide and protect comprehensive reproductive autonomy to all.

Finally, the bottom line is the obstacles cause a lot of mental and physical harm, but do not block many abortions. (They must block some, and a few times we hear tell of people not able to obtain one, but the book is not inclined to estimate.)  For instance, the lack of Medicaid coverage in many states puts pressure on private methods, but seems most people* find a way somehow.  

The net result is gratuitous cruelty in the promotion (though this angle is not focused on much) of ideological goals.  And, it is applied selectively, the poor and POC particularly burdened.  Again, some unclear number of people are blocked from getting abortions while the increased burdens of those who still manage are often hidden as well.   

The book is unapologetically pro-choice, which is fine.  For instance, there is no abortion that are a bad idea  unless the person doesn't want to obtain them.  And, are there any problems in abortion care from the clinics' side?  Surely, no one is perfect.  But, this is not the book for that honest critique. 

Obstacles:

[1] Making the Decision -- most people are clear on what they want and  providers carefully screen patients.  Barriers here include: gag rules, reason bans (gender etc.), misinformation ("abortion causes breast cancer"), minor consent/notification laws, crisis pregnancy clinics, and doctors themselves not wanting to refer patients or even hiding key information like how far along.

[2] Few Clinics / getting there

[3] Money (insurance/Medicaid limits) / resulting delays

[4]  Clinic Protestors

(Not surprisingly,  they do not come off well, though the "prayers" might be mostly harmless if something of a nuisance.  I do wonder what the best usage of their time might be.  Nasty yelling can't be too useful. 

"Sidewalk counselors" are liable not to be too successful either.  But, a low key approach would seem to be the best.  For instance, say you are there if people want to talk.  Offer, kindly, an alternative.  And, even if you oppose their decisions, offer a praying hand -- after all, Jesus supports sinners.) 

[5] Biased ("unborn child") or fraudulent "informed consent" including forced ultrasounds / better to use normal informed consent pattered to the patient's needs.  

[6] Waiting periods

[7] Limits on procedure including limits on telemedicine, on types of procedure ("partial birth"), limits on medical abortions, doctor only requirements [physician assistants/nurses very good], unnecessary TRAP laws regarding clinics (admission privileges etc.), and skittish clinics/hospitals who don't do many more controversial procedures

===

It is not the focus of the book, though some cases do come up, but the Supreme Court have dealt with these issues over the years.  The original rule was that the second trimester could have rules intended to protect the women while (with a life/health exception) the state could ban post-viability abortions.  The basic first trimester rule was that an abortion might only be allowed to be performed by a physician.  

(Three liberal justices in the 1990s flagged one law that seemed to target a single physician assistant to make it harder to have an abortion.)

A mid-1970s case dealt with some more regulations.  It turns out "may not restrict the decision of the patient and her physician regarding abortion during the first stage of pregnancy" does not mean NO regulations. The case, e.g., allowed in the first trimester record keeping and consent laws specific to abortion as long as they were reasonable.  

Meanwhile, a 1980s case reminded that second trimester rules that departed from acceptable medical practice could easily be found unreasonable barriers to abortion.  Recall too that the trimester scheme in Roe was tied to current medical knowledge.  Viability is basically the same. OTOH, what was unsafe in the 1970s very well might be safe now.  Perhaps, one basic pre-viability rule makes sense.  How "clean" was the trimester scheme applied?

Casey held: "A finding of an undue burden is a shorthand for the conclusion that a state regulation has the purpose or effect of placing a substantial obstacle in the path of a woman seeking an abortion of a nonviable fetus."  This opened up more regulations, but  not sure how much different it would be on the ground. Court personnel would be key.  And, the Whole Woman's Health ruling (2016) said any burden had to have benefits.  Some pointless law with minimum burden would still be bad. 

Compare this to the dismissive way the Casey plurality said that clear burdens of waiting periods were not undue in that case.  Other waiting periods (including 72 hours and in states with less clinics) very well might be different, but even beyond the basic principle of second guessing women, this sort of thing surely sounds undue:

The findings of fact by the District Court indicate that because of the distances many women must travel to reach an abortion provider, the practical effect will often be a delay of much more than a day because the waiting period requires that a woman seeking an abortion make at least two visits to the doctor. The District Court also found that in many instances this will increase the exposure of women seeking abortions to "the harassment and hostility of antiabortion protestors demonstrating outside a clinic." 744 F. Supp., at 1351. As a result, the District Court found that for those women who have the fewest financial resources, those who must travel long distances, and those who have difficulty explaining their whereabouts to husbands, employers, or others, the 24-hour waiting period will be "particularly burdensome." Id., at 1352.

As to informed consent, the plurality required it to be "truthful, nonmisleading information," but allows something like "probable gestational age" of the fetus, which might not be appropriate for a given patient.  An early case, which it deemed too restrictive, more carefully limited such information requirements, including something like "the unborn child is a human life from the moment of conception."  

This the earlier opinion said was an illegitimate insertion of "one theory of life" into the "informed consent' portion.  Casey allows the state to do something like that though "the interest in potential life must be calculated to inform the woman's free choice, not hinder it."  Note previous cases allowed the selective denial of Medicaid funds to promote said interest (one brief in the upcoming Mississippi case lists the various thing the state could do to protect life but does not).  I find this to have First Amendment problems, along with the equal protection problems many flag. 

The state is not only forcing ideological messages -- not mere professional speech requirements -- but it has religious sectarian overtones. The matter has not been addressed much by the Supreme Court and the selective application of the rules is seen by the crisis pregnancy case cited below. See also, Hobby Lobby where a  minimum burden on beliefs in a public sphere was seen as problematic while pro-choice burdens are ignored. 

Justice Stevens touched upon the possible Establishment Clause in his Webster opinion and multiple religious liberty amici in the upcoming Dobbs case covered the overall issue of religious freedom issues here. Casey itself spoke of the choice to have an abortion being a matter of "conscience."  Ronald Dworkin, the now deceased liberal law professor, also argued along with euthanasia issues, religious liberty is a big issue here. A major Medicaid funding case avoided the question though the judge below addressed it in detail. 

One other area of dispute that is relevant to the book is free speech cases.  The Supreme Court upheld certain court determined injunctions that set up buffer zones or bubbles, but rejected unanimously when Massachusetts tried to set a buffer zone by law.  I am sympathetic though it is easier to see the law as unnecessary there than in a red state.  

Hill v. Colorado upheld a more limited law that makes it unlawful for any person within 100 feet of a health care facility’s entrance to “knowingly approach” within 8 feet of another person, without that person’s consent, in order to pass “a leaflet or handbill to, display a sign to, or engage in oral protest, education, or counseling with [that] person." [Cleaned up]

(The Roberts Court in the later case -- Roberts wrote the opinion though the other four conservatives at the time concurred separately -- cited Hill without suggesting it is no longer good law.)

Finally, there is the crisis clinics disclosure case that was a travesty.  Of course, abortion law is one big to be continued.  

===

* The book was published in 2020 and notes early on the relatively new (from my vantage point) practice of reminding us that everyone that has an abortion do not represent as "women." But, given most are, the book tends to still use "women," though at times "persons."

Mets: Cusp of Elimination [and More Baseball News]

The Mets might have had their final time in the sun by winning the Subway Series, though not exactly in intimidating fashion. The Yanks (who seem a bit better of late) were in the midst of a horrible run.

(The Mets, if they show life, can play spoiler versus the Braves. The Twins have versus the Blue Jays, perhaps; two losses dropped them two back in the wild card race with time running out. It also might have helped save the Yanks.)

The Mets split two high scoring games by one run though they also had a nice 10-3 win, which might also have been Megill's (the nice surprise early on) last moment as well. After a disappointing finish, resulting in a decent but surely not dominating two weeks against the Marlins/Nats, this suggested maybe they might compete against the big boys.

Nah. They won one game (with two left) versus Cards, the Phils (whose playoff chances might turn on their Braves series), Red Sox, and Brewers. The Braves continue to basically win every other day. So, the Mets elimination number is now two, when they really should be eliminated by now. The Cards show how a late run can carry you to the playoffs. The Braves (and other wild card hopefuls until the Cards went on a run) allowed the Mets to stay alive. 

The Mets really didn't have to win too many more games to be still alive at time point, even if (like back in 1999) it would have taken some help and/or sweeping the final series (here the Braves, who then could be forced to make up a Rockies game, if the game mattered).  A team 73-80 shouldn't really be in that position, but again, it shows the mediocrity of the competition.  Until their recent run, the Mets also had the Wild Card route open to them.  The Cards current fourteen game winning streak closed that off.  It also basically put the Padres and Reds out of their misery too.  

The two game elimination number figure is also rather particular.  The Braves have 81 wins and the math is that the Mets can at most get 82. Problem is that the Phils have 80 wins.  And, the Braves and Phils play each other.  So, basically the Braves must win once (Padres - 2, Mets - 3, and Rockies 1 if necessary must all be losses), and it has to be against the Phils while the Phils must win twice (they play Pirates and Marlins too) and only versus the Braves.  

The Mets must win out (Brewers - 2, Marlins - 4, Braves). The math would result in a three way  82-80 tie.  Any other combo is elimination.  Baseball around this time of year is prime for such mathematical gymnastics.  

[ETA: Before the Mets began their game, the Phils won.  The Phils and Braves now have 81 wins.  One will have 83 since they play each other for three games.  So, the Mets are eliminated.

And, after the game (a loss), the Braves won in the tenth. So, they would have been eliminated either way.]  

The basic surprise is the Cards (hovering behind the pack but not that far back) rushing forward.  It looked like Padres/Reds, but both decided to play mediocre again.  Giants/Dodgers for division remains a nailbiter. Again, the Blue Jays (after doing a Cards) must be smacking themselves losing to the Twins.  It's not a lost cause, but the long expected Red Sox/Yanks Wild Card match-up looks likely.  In rather impressive news, Seattle actually has the same record as the Blue Jays now.  Around 90 wins? Who thought?

Anyway, it's "wait to next year ..." again for the Mets. Tiresome. The Mets had a team that was probably good enough to make at least the wild card possible, but then injuries and a lot of underperforming happened. Somewhat amusing, multiple injured pitchers might be available the last week.  It will be like one last look in a television finale or something.   

ETA: Their last game against "the big boys" (the Braves come up after a four game Marlins series though how much they will count for the Braves remains to be seen) put a cherry on top of their embarrassing play. 

Another rough start from "Cookie" (mediocre after he finally got off the DL though providing some decent games), but eventually they were only down 5-4 versus the Brewers.  A couple errors, each helped by Alonso, made it 8-4, which was the final score.  With the Cards never losing going on over two weeks now, the Brewers needed each win to clinch at home (the rest of the season is on the road).  

The Mets obliged.   

The game assured an under .500 record.  The team has problems, but winning ONE game versus the non-Yankees big boys is rather pathetic.  The first of the two misplays alone (the Brewers helped them a bit by questionable baserunning, but the next error scored that run plus another anyway) led Keith Hernandez to go off on how they are a second level team.  The t.v. booth is professional and doesn't like bad baseball. 

Note without giving the Brewers three runs basically (though one was technically earned), the Mets had a decent chance of winning the game.  Maybe. They lost a lot of one run games.  But, the bullpen did their part.  Me?  I was basically screaming that Alonso had to be pulled out of the tame. Dominic Smith was available to play first.  Coming up in a big spot (two guys on), Alonso didn't do anything anyways.  

Leaving Alonso in, though both the pitchers and the manager were pissed, just is an example of how the manager has let the players be. When they were goofing off with imaginary hitting coaches and a stuffed horse, it seemed amusing.  When there was some stupid dig at fans for booing, it looked somewhat less.  But, as a whole, the manager has a role to control the team. Taking out Alonso would have sent a message.